7 Ups & 8 Downs From WWE Raw: In Your Face (Sep 14)

Solid work undone by wretched storytelling - and the worst stable in wrestling.

Keith Lee RETRIBUTION
WWE.com

Last night's WWE Raw was weird. Very weird.

A more Jekyll and Hyde professional wrestling show won't go down in 2020, as WWE's red brand veered from genuinely great to borderline unwatchable, often from segment to segment. Devisied by WhatCulture's Michael Hamflett, the phrase "trust the workers, not the process" was made for shows like this, where wrestlers earnestly worked their hides off despite the indigestible tripe fed to them from the writers' room, which served up some of the Empty Arena Era's worst content last night.

This show was branded "In Your Face" in the build-up. This was seemingly a product of Drew McIntyre and Randy Orton booting each other in the mush repeatedly in recent weeks, as the only in-your-face thing about last night's Raw was the staggering gulf between effort and creativity.

With Dolph Ziggler and MVP on commentary, not the absent Samoa Joe, the night was ravaged by RETRIBUTION. Orton vs. McIntyre got a new stipulation, Keith Lee faced the WWE Champion in the main event, a new force ran riot in Raw Underground, and Mickie James wrestled for Asuka's Women's Title - perhaps for the final time.

Let's go...


Downs...

8. Have A Break, Change The Channel

Liv Morgan Kit Kat
WWE

Product placement! Cool.

Things like last night's Kit Kat commercial never go over well, making Raw feel more like a television show that's vaguely about wrestling rather than a wrestling television show, and this one sucked. "R-Truth talking to a chocolate bar" was the extent of its humour. Truth threatened to eat it, or whatever, then Liv Morgan showed up, snapped the Kit Kat, took one for herself, and buggered off, leaving Truth babbling.

Unfunny nonsense, and a waste of airtime beyond whatever amount Nestlé paid WWE to produce this. It doesn't bear criticism beyond this meagre word count, though.


7. Vulgar Display Of Power

Ruby Riott Lanan
WWE.com

This week's build towards The Riott Squad vs. Nia Jax and Shayna Baszler consisted of Liv Morgan and Ruby Riott bashing Lana and Natalya up in a two-minute squash match, then engaging in a tame staredown with the Women's Tag Team Champions after they flattened the felled wrestlers.

There was nothing to this. Baszler and Jax said little of note as guest commentators and beating up a couple of goons who had already lost doid little to present them as a united threat, which was clearly the goal here. The Riott Squad's chemistry vs. the heels' bickering is the story. Sure, Nia put Lana through a table with a Samoan Drop and stood tall with the 'Queen of Spades' at the end, but what does this prove, particularly with The Riott Squad watching on, not even thinking about intervening?

Nothing.


6. 10 Minutes Of Nothing

Drew McIntyre Keith Lee
WWE.com

Your mileage may vary with this week's Raw opener, though this writer found it to be a dull piece of table-setting that accomplished little that wasn't put over in Keith Lee and Drew McIntyre's interactions later in the show.

McIntyre vs. Randy Orton is now an ambulance match after the duo took turns in sending each other to the hospital. Fair enough, though you can count the number of genuinely great bouts this stipulation has ever thrown up in WWE on one hand, despite the duo's awesome match at SummerSlam. The WWE Champion then took a page out of Randy's book, devolving to low comedy for a weak Photoshop dig at everyone he has Claymored recently, before Adam Pearce walked out, flexed his authority, and said Lee defeating McIntyre and Orton not making it to Clash of Champions would make Keith vs. Drew the new main event. Cue: Lee's crappy theme music and a tense handshake.

Drew's promo was fine, though the stipulation and other Clash implications could have been announced in a tweet and the Lee/McIntyre stuff was covered more effectively elsewhere. Thus, this was a waste of everybody's time. Total filler.


5. A Great Story, Sabotaged

Kevin Owens Aleister Black
WWE.com

This part of the show was infuriating, and perhaps the night's best example of rubbish writing ruining good wrestling.

Kevin Owens and Aleister Black were working a neat story-based clash. The bout was appropriately hard-hitting and brisk, with the duo laying into each other at a level matching their feud's heat. Black was particularly intense as he worked Owens' knee over, pulling some excellent selling out of the former 'Prizefighter,' who hobbled around as if his leg was about to fall off. A desperation Superkick appeared to hurt KO as much as Black. Prior to that, the limp stopped him from getting over the top rope for a dive, and his knee collapsed beneath his weight immediately after the Superkick too. Great stuff all-round.

And then RETRIBUTION screwed with the lights, Black got confused, and Owens hit a quickfire Stunner for the win. Cool.

Situations in which a distraction finish doesn't make the victim look like a total dumb*ss are rare. This wasn't one of them. Black went from laser-focused limb destroyer to hapless goober within a matter of seconds, his great work with Owens undone by the worst stable in wrestling. More on them later...


4. Drizzling Splits

Seth Rollins Murphy
WWE.com

How many split angles can a show run simultaneously before saying "that's enough"? Either the writing team aren't working together on this or they just don't care anymore.

The repetition would be forgivable if the storylines were popping, but they aren't. The Zelina Vega/Andrade/Angel Garza thing has been protracted for far too long and ultimately means nothing because the stable were booked as losers from day one, making it impossible to invest in their split. Seth Rollins and Murphy, meanwhile, feels wholly unnecessary, particularly with the crooked cult leader pulling his following in only to knock him down twice in the same night, leaving him without allies.

Vega splitting from her team will do Andrade more harm than Garza, who is the better talker of the two, though the inevitable singles match should bang. Rollins' whole appeal as 'The Monday Night Messiah' is pulling people in with his poison, though. He should abuse his followers, but what is he without an army? Nothing.

And again, the exact same storyline - twice on the same show.


3. Send In The Clowns

RETRIBUTION WWE
WWE.com

This week's RETRIBUTION promo wasn't as excruciatingly awful as the previous one, when it seemed like they'd been pulling angsty lines from their teenage LiveJournal pages, though it was still mostly nonsense.

The masked mob interrupted The Hurt Business' celebrations following Cedric Alexander's loss to Ricochet. Spouting off clichéd guff about WWE's lies, betrayal, and greed, with the male speaker sounding like a comedian's Braun Strowman impersonation, they told the roster to enjoy their last days in oblivion (?!) - because they're gonna gut your reality. Grrrr!

With material ripped straight from a bad nu metal album's lyric sheet, these guys sound impossibly lame. It's tough to take them as a threat to WWE's corporate status quo when they willingly comply with corporate edicts telling them to stay on Raw, use the company's garbled version of the English language, and only repeat talking points that a thousand worked shoots haven't covered already. Also, guys: we can see who you are through those balaclavas. The jig is up.

At least they aren't talking about locusts anymore.


2. Asuka vs. James Underwhelms

Asuka Mickie James
WWE.com

This should have been great. It wasn't, and it's as much on the workers as anyone else, sadly.

Micke James cut a solid promo before facing Asuka, saying she was fuelled by knowing this could be her last shot at the Raw Women's Championship, heaping furthering hype on a solid short-term program. Things went south when they hit the ring. Asuka is one of the best in the world and James can still go, though they struggled to work through the gearbox here. A one-paced, sluggish bout was marred by a handful of timing issues and other sloppy moments, particularly when they exchanged pinfalls. Zero drama was generated as they couldn't break out of the early period, turning a potentially excellent bout to "meh."

And then came the finish.

This thing was a shambles. Mickie rolled the 'Empress' through on an Asuka Lock, going for a pinfall, when the referee inexplicably called for the bell. Michael Cole said that he thought James had tapped out, though it was clear nobody had a clue what was going on. Dolph Ziggler was as confused as anyone else on commentary, uttering only a confused "what?", and the ref spent a while explaining the balls-up to James, who was out of the equation immediately after.

Before Zelina Vega emerged as Asuka's next challenger (hey, at least it's fresh), the bout was ruled a referee's decision, with Mickie seemingly unable to compete. She wasn't, though. The bout was called as she executed an offensive move.


1. Goldfish Booking

RETRIBUTION WWE
WWE

Goldfish Booking is when WWE take you, the viewer, for somebody without an attention span, calling on you to dumb yourself down, lower your standards, and make massive logic leaps when watching Raw or SmackDown. They dismiss your intelligence to the point that they routinely do away with important plot points in the hope that you'll forget about them, like a goldfish. Here, it was on full display.

Keith Lee and Drew McIntyre worked a solid big boy battle. They brought the heat from their backstage segments to the ring and beefed the tenderloin off each other, looking like they were en route to a good Raw main event. Very meaty, very macho, and very satisfying... until RETRIBUTION happened. Again!

About 12 mask-clad goobers hit the ring and started laying into Lee and McIntyre. The Hurt Business ran out to join the fight and it was death by a thousand camera cuts as Kevin Dunn went nuts on production, delivering a headache-inducing viewing experience. Lee and McIntyre then hit tandem dives over the top rope to wipe everyone out for the close.

Problems? This had 'em.

1. Mia Yim was attacking her onscreen boyfriend, mere weeks after teaming with him to face Candice LeRae and Johnny Gargano. Disregard John Pollock's doubtlessly accurate report on Yim being part of RETRIBUTION here. That doesn't matter, as the NXT wrestler was clearly behind one of the masks in the earlier promos - which should have been apparent to anyone with a working set of eyes. You, the viewer, saw this. There's your first logic leap.

2. Dominik Dijakovic was part of this as well. Remember when Lee saved his apparent "best friend in the business" from Karrion Kross a short while ago? Logic leap number two.

3. The Hurt Business as valiant babyface saviour hero guys, on the very same show they ganged up on Apollo Crews and Ricochet, having just indoctrinated Cedric Alexander. Nonsense! And logic leap number three.

4. RETRIBUTION falling in their first major show-closing brawl since becoming Raw-exclusive. Not necessarily a logic leap, but a sh*tty look regardless.

This whole deal was an omnishambles. Fans shouldn't have to disconnect their brains to make sense of what they're consuming and WWE should have more regard for said fans.


Ups...

7. Erik Goes Night Night

Erik WWE
WWE.com

Bobby Lashley smashed Viking Raider Erik in just two minutes last night, overcoming a short comeback to put him away with a modified Full Nelson submission after a Spinebuster and Dominator, calling it The Hurt Lock.

This was a good bit of business. Ivar is shelved and scheduled to go under the knife today, having hurt himself on a dive last week. This leaves Erik without obvious direction, so why not have him get blasted by Lashley, making Bobby look great in the process, before going away for a little while? As both a write-out for Erik and way to enhance the United States Champion, this worked.

A singles run for Erik wouldn't go amiss, particularly if he starts wrecking dudes in Raw Underground, though he could probably use a break. He's got nothing going on right now.


6. Kevin Owens Is Great

Kevin Owens
WWE

A special shout-out to Kevin Owens and his hard work last night, as he continues to thrive in a restrictive Sports Entertainment universe.

KO entered an excellent defensive performance against Aleister Black, selling his skin off for his rival, further establishing himself as one of the company's better in-ring storytellers. He was money on the microphone, too. Owens met with Sarah Schreiber ahead of the bout, saying he didn't know why Aleister was angry with him, speculating that it might be because Hot Topic wouldn't honour his coupon for a t-shirt of "some band that screams nonsense." He promised to beat the Dutchman back into his dark little hiding spot and remind him what happens when you pick a fight with KO, adding that he wasn't worried about how he was going to do these things - because he's Kevin Owens.

This strong, bullish promo was counter-balanced by the vulnerability shown by Owens in the ring, showcasing his character's full range. A good night for him, despite the booking.


5. Street Profits Play It Smart

Cesaro Montez Ford
WWE.com

The Street Profits vs. Cesaro/Shinsuke Nakamura is built on a paper-thin premise, though the two teams over-delivered in a tough spot last night, with their tag bout cannibalised by a commercial break.

The tandems compensated for this with a high-effort performance. Having cut a weird promo about smashing his cortado on the floor, Cesaro was in excellent form. He started hot with a running uppercut and looked to be at his best throughout, going livewire on Angelo Dawkins and Montez Ford, popping a building full of half-muted Zoom calls. Great stuff from him, though the finish was well-played as well.

The Street Profits looked like smart, switched-on babyfaces when Dawkins slapped a blind tag while Ford was being Suplerplexed off the top rope. This meant Angelo could hit the top rope and nail the Cash Out splash for a fair, legal victory, outdoing the heels through genuine ingenuity.

You genuinely love to see it.


4. Finally, Braun Is A Beast Again

Dabba-Kato Braun Strowman
WWE.com

Braun Strowman has struggled to project genuine menace in 2020.

It should be impossible to write such a sentence about such a big beefy boy, though 'The Monster Among Men' rarely feels like a danger or a threat these days. Part of this is likely down to him being tethered to Bray Wyatt's sh*te for the past few months. The wacky, cartoonish hokum he is pulling on SmackDown makes him look like a goofy caricature, not a real 'Monster,' and he doesn't suit it at all. Tangling with his former Wyatt Family ally has yielded some of wrestling's worst content this year and done Strowman no good whatsoever.

It was therefore refreshing to see Strowman looking so goddamn strong in Raw Underground last night, appearing like a badass for the first time in a long time.

Braun ruled the ropeless ring last night. After grunting his way into the building, Strowman trucked Dolph Ziggler and Riddick Moss, beat both up individually, then took them down together. He looked great here. Portraying him as a massive, brutish fighter with inhuman strength is a lot more effective than anything else WWE has done with him lately and while there's no way of telling if next week's fight with Dabba-Kato will deliver, biffing Ziggler and Moss across multiple segments was a good way to build to it.

This was comfortably the best Underground night to date, and a real step forward for Braun. Let's just keep him here instead of having him roll around in swamps.


3. The Ballad Of Drew & Keith

Drew McIntyre Keith Lee
WWE.com

Credit to WWE for making the Keith Lee/Drew McIntyre dynamic significantly more interesting last night. "Mutual respect" was a logical starting point for two babyfaces who know each other well, though having them at each other's throats after needling promos is more engaging and exciting.

Lee's interview with Charly Caruso saw him promise to do whatever he must to become WWE Champion, friendship or no friendship. McIntyre responded to this by saying he could have chosen to attack Randy Orton at any point last week but waited until Keith had been RKO'd, implying that he didn't think Lee was capable of beating 'The Viper' for a second time. Lee confronted this, McIntyre accused his opponent of twisting his words, and a brawl broke out over two segments, ending, ultimately, with Adam Pearce threatening to call the match off unless they quit it.

An effective way to dollop heat on the duo, Lee and McIntyre's issues were carried into the ring later on. Last night's developments make it feel like we're heading towards a Triple Threat. A fine proposition, particularly with this new dynamic, which lifts Lee's chances of winning considerably.


2. Dominik Mysterio, Again

Seth Rollins Dominik Mysterio
WWE

Last night's cage match was very WWE. Laden with tropes and energy-sapping escape spots, it brought little to the table you haven't already seen and a harsher critic would find fault with a lot of it, from the glut of needless cage-climbing moments to the spot where Dominik Mysterio clearly had Seth Rollins beaten but chose to hit a Frog Splash rather than scale the structure and take the win.

Those complaints exist. They have merit. Raising them is fine, though the wrestlers transcended them with two excellent performances far beyond the material, delivering a match on pair with everything else they have done throughout this feud.

Rollins once again proved himself an excellent feeder, controlling the performance while laying the groundwork for Dominik's flippy lucha spots. Mysterio's fundamentals aren't there yet (of course they aren't - this was his sixth match) but professional wrestling has always been about highlighting the positives and hiding the negatives. This match was that to a tee: Dominik was once again allowed to show off his flashy stuff in spirited fightbacks and never looked exposed, demonstrating his, Rollins', and perhaps Rey's respective wrestling IQs, if the lucha legend played a part in piecing this together.

Seth won after hitting two Curb Stomps in a row, seemingly ending the rivalry. Both him and Dominik should be immensely proud of their efforts since first colliding at SummerSlam.


1. Buying In

Cedric Alexander
WWE.com

Weird saviour moment aside, The Hurt Business continued to be the best thing on Raw last night, beginning with the promo that formally welcomed Cedric Alexander into the group.

Put over by MVP, Alexander said this was his job, nobody knows what it feels like to be beaten up by The Hurt Business every week, and said he wasn't even able to play with his family after the shellackings they'd administered to him. He had been indoctrinated. Alexander has now fully bought into MVP's poison, and Apollo Crews and Ricochet emerged to point this out. They weren't looking for an apology or an explanation, though: just to beat The Hurt Business up, baby.

The resulting match between Cedric and Ricochet offered just a glimpse of what they could to together, so short was the runtime, but it was lots of fun. They're two of the most exciting wrestlers in the company. Sometimes, it really is as simple as letting the wrestlers wrestle, and they worked a fast-flowing bout that concluded with a Michinoku Driver and Lumbar Check-assisted win for Alexander.

Good, logical stuff here, and nothing over-complicated either. The rest of the show should have taken this as an example.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.