7 Ups And 10 Downs From WWE Fastlane 2019
Good matches, contrived outcomes, and McMahons, naturally.
Welcome to the most pointless PPV on the WWE calendar, the last PPV before WrestleMania.
You would think that WWE could figure out a way to make Fastlane more appealing and important, but let’s face it: the vast majority of the card wasn’t booked until 12 days out from the event. Even then, the card wasn’t final, as we saw, and the PPV itself turned into an attempt to cram a dozen angles into it just four weeks before WrestleMania. (Bear in mind that only three matches are confirmed for Mania as of right now, though several are strongly rumored or developing.)
Thus, Fastlane was a mess of bad-to-excellent wrestling, overbooking, post-match angles, and of course, McMahons. It certainly wasn’t boring, and it wasn’t uneventful. But it’s funny that a PPV called Fastlane had so many twists and turns to it.
We’ll have to see how things shake out this week on Raw and SmackDown, but there still are several question marks out there. We saw a lot Sunday night, but even the negatives could be overlooked or forgotten if they lead to a really solid Mania card.
For now though, we’ll critique what we saw at the uneven Fastlane. Let’s get to it…
Downs...
10. Angle City
When Elias came out for the third time of the night to perform, you knew there was going to be a payoff of some sort. There was no way the troubadour was going to get away with singing three times and not get interrupted or attacked.
But the payoff was just a rapid meshing of angles, with Lacey Evans doing her pointless strut, Randy Orton hitting an RKO on Elias, and AJ Styles hitting a Phenomenal Forearm on Orton (they’ve had an ongoing issue). It was just a goofy way to advance the Styles/Orton feud and get Evans on TV once again doing nothing.
This wasn’t offensive by any stretch, but it felt like something that belonged on Raw or SmackDown, not a PPV.
9. Changing On The Fly
Typically when you see an advertisement for an upcoming wrestling show, it says, “Card subject to change.” That’s an easy way to avoid breaking an ironclad promise for certain matches.
But Fastlane was chock-full of changes. First off, the card itself only came together in the last two weeks, with only a couple matches announced by the time the penultimate Raw aired. Then, Sunday night, a match between Rey Mysterio and Andrade was turned into a fatal four-way for the United States Championship. A WWE Championship match was made a triple threat, and a 2-on-1 handicap match was added to the card.
That’s a lot of stuff to be moved around on an eight-match card as the show is beginning, especially when the card really didn’t come together until a week out. Is that poor booking, or an effort by the writers to keep fans on their toes?
Either way, it’s not a great look when it happens multiple times.
8. Painful Commentary
This writer has given a lot of room for Renee Young to grow on commentary, but good lord she was terrible on Sunday night.
Young’s “oooh!” reactions to nearly every hard-hitting move became overbearing during Fastlane, as once you noticed how often she was doing it, you couldn’t unhear it. Throw in some mindless banter – her gushing when Lacey Evans came out and praising The Shield without listening to Corey Graves, for example – and you had a really bad night for Renee.
She’s had much better nights, but Sunday was definitely something that should be improved upon. Young is talented and has shown she can be really good on commentary at times, but she’s got to get past some of these miscues.
7. How The Mighty Have Fallen
Looking at the thrown-together tag team of Rusev and Shinsuke Nakamura, you can’t help but reach back to last year.
One year ago, Shinsuke was coming off winning the Royal Rumble and heading to WrestleMania 34 to challenge AJ Styles for the WWE Championship. Rusev was continuing to grow in popularity as the “Rusev Day” chants grew louder and he would get a shot at the United States Championship.
Flash-forward to Sunday night, and they were on the Fastlane kickoff show losing to the New Day in a competitive match that ultimately meant nothing. A thrown-together tag team of two guys who one year ago looked to be on the upswing as singles competitors are now losing a tag match on the pre-show.
There’s a moral of the story here, but it’s probably something along the lines of meeting Vince McMahon’s notions of “getting over” or face a de-push.
6. Setting Up For Failure
KofiMania will not be deterred, but that also means that anything or anyone in its path will get trampled.
So when Vince McMahon played bait-and-switch with Kofi Kingston and made a triple threat match for the WWE Championship – but didn’t include Kofi – whomever came out was going to be jeered.
That poor shmuck? Mustafa Ali.
Ali was booed throughout the match, as fans constantly chanted for Kofi, even during Mustafa’s comebacks against Daniel Bryan. It looked like he might win over the fans as they rallied behind him after kicking out of a pinfall, but the crowd immediately turned back to chanting for Kingston.
This should have surprised no one, as everyone remembers the reaction whenever Daniel Bryan was screwed over in 2014. Ali had a tough hill to climb, and it really didn’t do him a lot of favors. He should be more than fine, but it still felt bad seeing him come out and have to endure the “We want Kofi!” chants because of who he wasn’t.
5. Bowling Shoe Ugly
Jim Ross’ favorite phrase to describe terrible wrestling matches certainly applies to the SmackDown Women’s Championship bout at Fastlane.
Mandy Rose quite simply is not ready for a match like this in a spot like this, and it showed Sunday night. Asuka never really was in danger, and even though she controlled a good portion of the match, even she couldn’t hold it all together. Things fell apart when Rose powered out of an octopus and nearly dropped Asuka like a sack of potatoes.
Worse, the ending featured Mandy basically slipping on a banana peel – well, it was the ring apron – directly leading to her defeat. So the dominant champ Asuka needed a fluke to defeat Mandy Rose. Just let that sink in.
4. Contrived And Overbooked
We already covered just how ridiculous the McMahon involvement and last-minute changes to the matches were, but the overbooking of the matches themselves was just nuts.
Consider that four of the 10 matches that took place involved post-match shenanigans. The first two of the PPV featured a heel turn breaking up a tag team, and then another tag team teasing a breakup in the very next match. The other two tag team matches also had post-match beatdowns by the (a) losing team.
Throw in the two matches that were changed and the one that was added, and a women’s match that ended in a contrived DQ and you have a really weak PPV. Sure, several of the matches were fine, but the booking was just really overdone, almost to hide some inadequacy.
3. Dominant And Unbeatable?
WWE loves to book itself into a corner when it comes to monster heels. Sometimes they reach a peak, but can never climb any higher, which results in them constantly bumping their heads against the ceiling.
Case in point, Nia Jax and Tamina. WWE wants them to be recognized as nearly unbeatable, dominant heels who run roughshod over the women’s division, but they lost in the Elimination Chamber last month, Jax lost a singles match to Bayley a couple weeks ago, and the duo lost to Bayley and Sasha Banks on Sunday night when Bayley rolled Nia up with a rana (in a lackluster match).
But hey, don’t worry, Jax and Tamina returned to their dominant ways afterward by taking out the WWE Women’s Tag Team Champs and then beating up guest commentator Beth Phoenix and then Natalya. Because why not? They’re dominant and unbeatable!
Except all those times when they lose.
Let’s note, however, that Phoenix getting back in the ring at WrestleMania 35 would be pretty cool, so maybe we’ll see that.
2. McMahons Heel It Up
Remember way back in December when the McMahons walked out to open Raw and admitted that the ratings were in the toilet because fans had grown tired of a stale product and seeing authority figures rob fans of matches they wanted to see?
Yeah, neither do the McMahons.
It’s funny, because this column will compliment the after-effects later, but right now, the McMahons being front-and-center to heel things up is just ridiculous. Vince, who was all but written off as an on-screen character, has showed up to slap AJ Styles and screw over Becky Lynch and Kofi Kingston. Shane went from being an on-screen commissioner to tag team champion to heel who attacked The Miz in his hometown.
And yeah, the purpose here is to get those wrestlers over, but “more McMahons” is always WWE’s solution to these issues. Rather than actually writing smart storylines, they always fall back on using a McMahon or two to drive the point home.
Even after that big speech in December talking about getting out of the way and starting a new era, it’s looking like just more of the same from McMahon World.
1. Becky Stumbles Into Mania
Of all the stupid, backhanded ways to get Becky Lynch to WrestleMania…
Look, it’s understandable that WWE didn’t necessarily want Lynch to beat Charlotte Flair clean to earn her trip to Mania for the Raw Women’s Championship, especially when she was dealing with a bum knee, but that’s the writer’s fault for booking themselves into a corner. And then they had Ronda Rousey serve as the obvious “out” for them, walking into the ring and striking Becky once to force a DQ, because Lynch is in Rousey’s head.
But seriously, what an absolutely stupid way this entire Becky storyline had unraveled.
The Man is the anti-hero who has to scrap and claw her way past the chosen ones of management (sound familiar?). She wins the Royal Rumble, gets injured and refuses to see a doctor. She finally does, is reinstated and her title match is on… until Vince McMahon screws her over and strips her of her title shot. Becky is suspended but keeps attacking Rousey and Flair until her suspension is lifted and she competes at Fastlane, where Ronda bails the wounded Lynch out by causing a DQ.
It’s an insanely convoluted storyline that has a bunch of added twists and turns for the sake of having them. Instead of The Man heading into Mania with momentum from having fought her way into the main event, she has Rousey to thank for her title shot because she goaded Ronda into it.
Ridiculous all the way around. Thank God this will most likely be an awesome match regardless, but the angle surrounding it will hopefully be tossed on the ash heap of history… and maybe the writers responsible will be too.
Ups...
7. Usos Retain
There really was only one acceptable outcome to the SmackDown Tag Team Championship match at Fastlane.
While Miz winning the tag titles in his hometown would have been a storybook ending, having he and his 49-year-old executive-turned-part-time-wrestler partner win the titles back over the Usos would have been just ridiculous. The match itself, while pretty decent, was more competitive than it should have been, but that’s a minor trifle.
The Usos probably aren’t the tag team to carry the titles long-term – if anything, they could use a change of scenery – but at least they’re in a position to hopefully put over the next big team on SmackDown, while the next chapter of Miz & Shane McMahon doesn’t need tag titles to progress.
6. NXT Stars Shine In Loss
Sometimes, new blood can help infuse a wrestling product with new energy.
While that hasn’t been the case overall, we did see a glimpse of that in the Raw Tag Team Championship triple threat match at Fastlane. The Revival and Chad Gable & Bobby Roode could have had a perfectly serviceable tag title bout, but the addition of Ricochet & Aleister Black definitely infused it with some octane.
One sequence toward the latter half of the match was too fast to call, but it ended with a Dash Wilder splash breaking up a German suplex pin, only to fall victim to a Shooting Star Press from Ricochet.
In the end, Dash and Scott Dawson left with their titles, but Ricochet and Black served notice afterward that they are serious and not to be treated lightly. Kudos for WWE continuing to let those two shine in their embryonic main roster moments.
5. Well, That Was Different
When Miz and Shane McMahon formed a tag team late last year, conventional wisdom would say that eventually, Miz would turn on his partner and reveal his true colors.
But instead, we got the opposite Sunday night.
Miz and Shane came up short again at Fastlane, with Miz taking the pinfall loss to the Usos. Afterward, he and Shane left the ring together and commiserated with Miz’s father, only for McMahon to blast his partner from behind and then pummel him outside the ring. Shane then grabbed Miz’s father and yelled at him before returning to attack the Awesome One some more.
Oh, and did we mention that all of this happened in Miz’s hometown of Cleveland?
After years of Miz being a pure heel, he actually generated real sympathy from the hometown faithful. For the first time in forever, Shane has turned heel, while Miz is playing babyface. Whether that carries beyond Cleveland remains to be seen, but at least they tried something different.
4. Joe Goes Over Strong
It took WWE long enough to make Samoa Joe a champion, but thankfully, they’ve also managed to book him as a no-nonsense champ.
Even as a heel, Joe clearly fears no one, signing a petition to grant R-Truth a United States Championship rematch. He then defended the title in a fatal four-way match at Fastlane, defeating Rey Mysterio by making him pass out to the Coquina Clutch. Joe hung tough with all three of his opponents and won cleanly – he didn’t even have to steal a pin or attack a wounded Rey that someone else had stunned.
It was good to see Joe win a pretty good match where everyone was clicking. It would have been better to just have booked this match from the get-go rather than do the kickoff show angle and change a singles match between Rey and Andrade at the last minute. But still, bravo.
3. Keeping Kofi Down
While the use of the Evil Vince McMahon is worthy of criticism, the positive here is that Kofi Kingston is quickly becoming the 2019 version of 2014 Daniel Bryan, where fans are nearly rapid in their support of a babyface for a world title shot.
Kingston was summoned to McMahon’s office about the WWE Championship match, only to find out it was being made into a triple threat, and Kofi’s match was next. What happened next was classic bait-and-switch, as Kingston wasn’t booked in the title match, but a handicap match against The Bar, which he lost.
Then the triple threat went down with Mustafa Ali getting the third slot, and fans chanted, “We want Kofi!” throughout the match, clearly showing that they were firmly behind the 11-year veteran.
Hopefully, all of this is building to a happy ending at WrestleMania 35, because if not, we might see fans lose their marbles.
2. Shield, Reigns, Ride Again
Sunday night was an emotional one for Roman Reigns, as he returned to action for the first time in several months after battling leukemia. To be able to beat back cancer and wrestle at a high level so quickly – if at all – is incredible.
The return was made even more emotional because of Dean Ambrose’s pending departure, which meant that this really was the last chance to have The Shield together on PPV in a match. So we got a six-man tag match where Reigns, Ambrose and Seth Rollins hit all their trademark spots en route to a victory over Drew McIntyre, Bobby Lashley and Baron Corbin.
All that said, the match itself was more of a greatest hits album than anything different or special. It was a farewell performance, not a reunion tour. It was perfectly enjoyable and fun, but consider: four weeks out from WrestleMania, your Royal Rumble match winner was playing second fiddle in a six-man tag match instead of prepping for Brock Lesnar.
So while this was fun and entertaining, it ultimately was just a farewell rather than a new beginning for the Shield, a distraction for one night before we go in a different direction. It does dampen things just a bit.
1. WWE Championship Match Delivers
If you were to turn the volume down during the WWE Championship match, you witnessed one hell of a bout between Daniel Bryan, Kevin Owens and Mustafa Ali.
But if you listened to the crowd throughout, they were way invested in someone else: Kofi Kingston. The New Day member had been screwed out of the match by Vince McMahon, and fans were insistent that he be added, even after it started.
Still, Bryan, KO and Ali worked their a**es off to deliver a high-energy, frenetic, hard-hitting match that featured some ridiculous offense from Ali and cool counters and spots from all three. The ending, with Bryan nailing a running knee on a diving Ali, was just insane.
Again, if you blocked out the crowd and just watched the match itself, it was a really, really good contest, totally worth checking out.