7 Worst WWE Turns Of 2017

Turning into a flat, generic, lifeless big man overnight? You can't teach that...

Sami Zayn Hell In A Cell

Showing compassion, worry and forgiveness for a friend in equal measures, the facial expressions worn by one Sami Zayn at Hell In A Cell hammered home his heel turn. Everything about the alignment switch was realistic. There was a motive (saving an old friend from certain doom), there was history between those involved and, best of all, there was expert execution.

If only every heel or babyface turn could be so good, but perhaps that itself is unrealistic. WWE's creative team seemed to run out of material for some this year, and that's when they reached for the heel/baby turn card like a child who can't choose which toy to play with. Talent can't take all the blame, you know.

The frustration comes when realising that those writers can weave superb and natural stories. Take Sheamus and Cesaro callously turning heel on The Hardy Boyz at Payback as one example, or the organic babyface rise Braun Strowman experienced this year as another.

Enjoy them, because (much like Sami's brilliance in October) they're in the minority...

7. Charlotte Flair

Charlotte entrance
WWE.com

Beginning the year as Raw's seductively cold 'Ice Queen', Charlotte Flair was stripped of that majestic heel aura when she was traded to SmackDown as part of the Superstar Shakeup in April. In place of the sneering villainess fans had come to know and enjoy, she was tasked with becoming a cheery figure. It's still a struggle for her.

The core problem with Charlotte's turn was that it didn't come for any good reason. All of sudden, fans were expected to embrace her as a nice person despite her stellar work as the arrogant focal point of Raw's female ranks. Overnight, Flair was buddying up with Becky Lynch again and smiling at children. Where was the motive?

This is a major issue in WWE's turn policy. Real people don't just change like that, and there needed to be more of a story to justify Charlotte's sudden buoyancy. The only reason she's so low on this list is because she remains one of the best in-ring workers WWE have on their books. If only her turn had been as meticulous as her matches.


6. TJ Perkins

Neville Perkins
WWE.com

Retro video-game loving geek TJ Perkins suddenly became akin to a Disney princess when Neville (a man who pulled off one of the best turns in recent memory) coerced his innocent little soul into doing his evil bidding. Neville's switch from babyface to heel reignited his career, but TJ's own turn to the dark side oddly left him feeling less important than he had been previously.

Perkins was the winner of WWE's Cruiserweight Classic and the first to hold the rebranded Cruiserweight Title in 2016. The hopeful end to that year couldn't prepare TJ for a horrendous 2017. This year, he has achieved precisely nothing of note other than turning heel for the sake of it and consequently appearing like he doesn't have a brain of his own.

When Neville's manipulation storyline with Perkins was dropped without warning in June, the man hand-picked to launch a new Cruiser division was left with nothing to do. As a heel, he has been ineffective. WWE have yet to make clear why they even bothered, and an explanation doesn't seem forthcoming as we race towards 2018.


5. Dana Brooke

Dana Brooke
WWE.com

Being Charlotte Flair's bitch, purely there to fight the heel's battles and fetch her coffee, was a limited role - but at least Dana Brooke was in a high-profile spot on TV with a top female worker. WWE's plan should have been to transition Brooke out of that spot as a babyface. With such a fantastic heel as Flair, that'd be simple, right?

Wrong. Oh so very wrong. Raw's writers didn't find it straightforward anyway, and they've flip-flopped poor Dana between heel and babyface several times in 2017 since splitting her from Charlotte. Once she tired of Flair's constant browbeating and attacked her, Dana should have had a period of stability as a face.

She didn't.

Without any attempts to explain why, she has been both face and heel depending which one suits WWE that week. Dana is cannon fodder in Raw's women's division, and has even worked as a braggart heel (albeit one with nothing to brag about) against Asuka. Right now, an alliance with Titus O'Neil has her playing baby again.

We'll see how long that lasts.


4. The Usos

The Usos
WWE.com

During the Charlotte entry, it was said that people in real life don't simply change their attitudes without good reason. According to WWE's creative team though, beating the unholy heck out of rivals inside Hell In A Cell will turn vicious street punks into happy-go-lucky smilers who favour a jovial outlook on life.

We're looking at you, Usos.

Post-HIAC win over The New Day, Jimmy and Jey started to concentrate less on maiming opponents and more on ripping them over the live mic before matches. It's no coincidence that they have subsequently become less cool on SmackDown than they were as arrogant brothers who believed themselves better than the rest of Tuesday night's tag division.

Think about it: the bad guys beat their irritating rivals in a dangerous battleground, only to admit that New Day's performance earned their respect. That's fine. What's not fine is using that as an unrealistic excuse for an alignment change, just so The Usos sell more t-shirts and can crack lame jokes.


3. Goldust

Goldust R Truth
WWE.com

Old-school wrestling fans were likely the only ones who appreciated WWE pressing the soft reset button on Goldust and returning the character to his Hollywood roots earlier this year. Meanwhile, younger fans must have been wondering why they were being encouraged to boo a guy who had been dancing like a fool with R-Truth just weeks earlier.

Beating up Truth and turning his back on the 'Golden Truth' tag team didn't really work for Goldust. There was no payoff to the angle, other than an interminable run of pre-taped promos, during which the face-painted weirdo repeated the same things over and over again. Worse, WWE have occasionally used Goldust as a babyface on house shows and ignored his turn.

At the special Starrcade live event, Goldust also shed his usual outfit in favour of becoming the 'Natural' Dustin Rhodes again. There's no consistency here. It's almost like WWE are saying, 'boo him for beating up Truth, but cheer him again when Truth is off TV or when we have a babyface spot to fill'.


2. Big Cass

big cass enzo
WWE.com

Uniqueness is important in pro wrestling.

If that seems like an obvious statement, then consider how badly WWE botched Big Cass becoming a monster heel in 2017. When Raw's writers wanted Cass to squash Enzo Amore and become an immediate threat as a big man, they failed to realise that Braun Strowman was already in that spot.

Sure, Braun was well on the way to becoming a fan favourite by that point, but the lazy nature of Cass turning on Enzo was there for all to see. Lifeless promos? Check. Ridding himself of a gimmick that had connected with fans? Check. Wearing dull black trunks? Check. Generic entrance music? Check. It's like the writers wanted the turn to fail.

Using the Big Show as foil for Cass seemed logical, and yet matches between the pair lacked the intensity Strowman's did against the veteran giant. Even before he went down with a torn ACL in August, Cass was struggling to convince anyone he deserved to be booed, let alone taken seriously as a potential future headliner.


1. Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggler Kalisto
WWE.com

If a freshly-turned heel is cheered wildly for ruthlessly battering two babyfaces with a steel chair, then the switch has failed. Dolph Ziggler was treated like a hero (and even thanked) by the live crowd when he smashed both Kalisto and Apollo Crews on the January 3 edition of SmackDown. That's what happens when fans don't care about the good guys.

People seemed to enjoy Dolph's fire. It didn't help that his turn was only a few months removed from an emotional, career-saving Intercontinental Title win against The Miz at No Mercy in October, 2016. Fans were happily cheering Ziggler's impassioned pleas to save his career, and now they were expected to boo him for taking out his frustrations?

Forget it. The whole exercise made Dolph less of a star than he had appeared as a fired up babyface who would do anything to save his job. That's the opposite of what WWE should have been going for, and it left him swimming against the tide from the off in 2017.

Recent US Title win or not, he's still treading water as a heel.

Which WWE turns did you think were bogus in 2017? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!


In this post: 
Big Cass
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.