7 Wrestling Cage Matches That Did Nothing For The Winner
They may have survived their surroundings but that's about it....
On the June 27 edition of Smackdown Live, current WWE champion Jinder Mahal announced that he would be defending his title against Randy Orton in a punjabi prison match, to the excitement of very few, if any dedicated WWE fans who've had to live through the past two editions of this cage match.
A creation of The Great Khali -- who didn't even participate in the original match due to elevated liver enzymes -- the punjabi prison debuted at The Great American Bash 2006. The following year, Khali finally stepped into his own playground in a losing effort to Batista at No Mercy, a 14-minute contest that did nothing for either competitor.
With the bamboo-style cage match returning after a decades hiatus, it seems only fit to look back at some other cage matches where, despite claiming victory, the winner didn't come out smelling like a rose.
7. Bobby Lashley - Extreme Elimination Chamber (December To Dismember '06)
This match, as well as this entire pay-per-view was doomed almost from the start due to poor booking. It stands as the worst bought PPV in WWE history, with just 52,000 buys and for just reasoning.
The story goes, in the main event, Paul Heyman had booked CM Punk winning the ECW Title in the chamber match, but Vince said no, he wanted Lashley. Heyman succumbed, but wanted it to at least come down to Punk and Lashley. Vince said no, as it had to be Lashley dominating.
In the end, Punk was eliminated first and Lashley won, to the disdain of Heyman as well as the fans, in what was a sluggish, sloppy display that also featured Test, The Big Show, Hardcore Holly and... oh right.... Rob Van Dam.
6. Dean Ambrose - Ambrose Asylum Match, Extreme Rules '16
This match had all the makings of being something special. You had "the lunatic fringe" taking on one of WWE's best workers in Chris Jericho, with multiple dangerous weapons surrounding a steel cage.
Unfortunately, "Ambrose's' playground wasn't utilized fully by its creator. For example, when given the option, he opted for a mop instead of a barbed wire board. If Ambrose really wanted to live up to his nickname, he should've tried to incorporate far more weaponry and inflict as much pain on his opponent as he could.
The match itself was fine, but much more was expected based on the surroundings. It didn't help that the two combatants also had to follow a tremendous fatal-4-way intercontinental title match....
5. Scott Steiner - Asylum Match (WCW Monday Nitro 05/22/2000)
Created by Steiner, this was an earlier version of TNA's steel asylum just without the hole on top. The cage was lowered inside the ring rather than around it and the effect was basically a tiny, circle shaped cage that really didn't offer much in terms of mobility. The only way to win was to make your opponent quit.
Scott was set to face off against his brother Rick in the inaugural asylum match, however interference from Tank Abbott (aka "Tankberg") rendered the fight null and void after the latter opened the cage up with pliers.
It was a concept with a few logistical errors which sadly did nothing for any of the three people involved in its inception.
4. X-Division Wrestlers - Steel Asylum (TNA IMPACT 1/04/2010)
This one is a bit different, as it was ruled a no contest. Essentially, a half-dozen or so x-division competitors were placed in a circular cage and the one who climbed through the top of the open hole was named the victor.
There were a few fundamental problems with this match, the main one being that despite the athleticism of the competitors, it is incredibly hard to keep your balance while scaling upside down on the top of a cage. On top of that, it's very difficult to keep the camera rolling on the action because there's so much going on at once.
The biggest issue with this particular match however, was the finish. It was supposed to be no DQ style affair, however Homicide beat down the rest of the competition with a baton, robbing the fans of what could have been an entertaining finish while also contradicting the rules of what quantifies a no DQ style match.
On the positive side, Jeff Hardy made his TNA debut, so there's one solid takeaway.
3. Mega Powers - Doomsday Cage Match (WCW Uncensored '96)
There was simply too many things going on in this match to begin with. There were too many competitors (10 in total) and far too many layers to the cage -- three tiers which multiple cages interlocked.
At no point during the match do the commentators or Michael Buffer explain how to win the match, which simply added to the bewilderment of what is supposed to be going on.
Lex Luger and Ric Flair didn't do themselves any favours, as Luger botched the finish, while Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage looked bad in victory, as Savage went ahead and pinned a man who had already been eliminated. Just brutal.
2. Sting, Steiner Brothers & El Gigante - Chamber Of Horrors (Halloween Havoc '91)
This match involved a steel cage style setup, where the only way to win was to strap one of your opponents into a secondary inner cage that had an electric chair. You then had to pull the switch which was located to the right of the inner cage, which would subsequently electrocute whoever was sitting inside the chair.
With participants such as Sting, the Steiner Brothers, Vader and Scott Hall all included, this match had star power for sure. Unfortunately, there was a bit too much going on at once and the ending was botched severely. Abdullah the Butcher had Rick Steiner set up in the chair, but at the last minute, Steiner was able to turn the tables and put Abdullah in the seat.
Somehow, Cactus Jack mistook Abdullah for Steiner and pulled the switch. It was confusion all around and far from a resounding finish.
1. Al Snow - Kennel From Hell (Unforgiven '99)
The build-up for this match was rather grotesque to begin with, with Snow accidentally eating his beloved pet dog Pepper, courtesy of The Big Boss Man. Granted, this was the attitude era, so if the feud was going to make sense anywhere, it was going to be here.
Anyhow, Snow's anger led him to creating the Kennel From Hell match, which involved two cages, with "killer" rottweilers situated between the cages. The winner was the man who could escape the outer cage first.
These dogs turned out to be the opposite of deadly, and were urinating and even attempting to mate during the match. The two combatants put on a decent hardcore match, however the fans were too distracted and disturbed by what was going between the cages to have any sense of care about who won the match, which was Snow in this case.