7 WWE Acts That Peaked In NXT
Potential never realized on the main roster.
NXT: not quite the indies, not quite the main event - a half-way house for aspiring WWE Superstars on their way to the biggest stage of them all. Vinnie Mac’s third brand is meant to prep the superstars of tomorrow before they go on to bigger and better things.
Whilst many graduate to Raw and SmackDown with dreams of taking their career to the next level, there are some wrestlers who'll probably end up looking back on their runs in developmental as the apex of their WWE careers.
So, without further ado, here are seven WWE acts that peaked on NXT.
7. Titus O'Neil
It's fair to say the big man hasn't had much to brag about on the main roster. There's the 'millions of dollars' dance in a third tier tag team, and that strange seal noise he makes along with his patented pose. There's also that time he got real-life suspended for touching Vince McMahon. Memorable perhaps, but not for the right reasons.
But back in 2014, Titus had a short but successful stint in NXT. Paired with Neville and Sami Zayn, O'Neill was booked like a monster as Full Sail's finest bumped and flipped their hearts out to put him over. Sure, the NXT MVPs did most of the work, but it gave us a glimpse of what Titus could be if he was portrayed like a beast. These were easily some of his best matches and, unfortunately for him, the strongest booking he might ever receive. Since returning to the main roster he’s been relegated back to the undercard.
6. Emma
No one quite knew what to make of Emma when she showed up at Full Sail. A ditzy space cadet with a goofy dance, she was a different kind of underdog character. Emma’s oblivious schtick made her celebrate her own awkward antics as if they were triumphs, be it her silly dance, or her awkward ring entrance. She wasn’t even phased by losing all the time. It was a slow-burn, but eventually the crowd bought in to it, cheering her on and doing the Emma-dance en-masse. The fact that she really owned her lame antics kind of made them cool.
That relationship with the fans took time to develop. When Emma was called up to the main roster she was thrown out there fully formed. The Emma dance was presented as something cool, rather than knowingly absurd. (Having Michael Cole do the dance was also the kiss of death.) The Raw crowd just didn’t get it, but why should they? From their perspective, the first part of her story got skipped entirely. Things got worse when she was cast as Santino’s girlfriend. When the Italian snake charmer got injured she was cast adrift, ultimately being sent back to NXT to make the new up-and-coming women look good.
Amazingly, Emma was able to totally reinvent herself during her second run in developmental. Evil Emma eschewed everything lovable about her old persona. She was sarcastic and mean and developed a whole new look. After turning in great matches with Asuka and Bayley, another call up beckoned. But no sooner had she returned to the main roster when injury struck! Emma still has huge potential, but two false starts are tough to recover from, especially with increasingly fierce competition in the women’s division.
5. The Ascension
Dressed up like the Road Warriors and treated like jokes, I don't think anyone would be shocked if the Ascension got cut sometime soon. But on NXT this duo dominated the tag division for an amazing 364 days. Years later, that’s still the record for longest tag title reign on the brand.
After beating Neville and Bo Dallas for the belts, they squashed all manner of jabronies week-in and week-out in an unstoppable whirlwind of destruction. It's always been a question as to whether the Full Sail crowd were genuinely into their antics or just cheered along on some ironic hipster level, but it seems safe to say the Ascension will probably never equal the heights of their NXT success.
4. Tyler Breeze
It’s so obvious that it’s a wonder no one ever thought of it before: an evil Derek Zoolander! Tyler Breeze hit pay-dirt with his arrogant male model gimmick, becoming a mainstay at the top of NXT during one of its hottest periods. The pretty boy thing had been done before, but Breeze updated it for the 21st century; snapping on selfie-sticks and singing his own entrance theme (topping the charts in Europe we’re told), Breeze merged the male model with the self-obsessed celebrity of the social media age. He could be relied upon for an entertaining segment, an amusing put-down (Hideous Hideo and the Man who Maybelline Forgot are my personal favourites), and always carried his end of a good match.
As one of NXT’s most popular acts, his call-up was hotly anticipated and initially it seemed like he was set up to succeed. They paired him up with Summer Rae and gave him a grand introduction on Raw, but after a couple of weeks something changed as creative seemed to lose faith in Prince Pretty.
After trading wins with Dolph Ziggler, Breeze was split from Summer and dropped to the undercard. He now wrestled in a comedy tag team with fellow underused talent Fandango. What success Breeze had on NXT was heavily tied to his gimmick (he languished for years as the forgettable Matt Dalton), so it’s tough to see how he can ever regain the momentum needed to get back to the main event.
3. Corey Graves
WWE clearly had big plans for Graves. He was positioned in showcase matches from the get-go and engaged in a memorable blood feud with NXT favorite Adrian Neville. Fans and announcers constantly called him the new CM Punk, and with some justification. While some of that comparison may have been down to superficial similarities like his tattoos and punk rock look, Graves was charismatic, edgy, and great on the mic.
Unfortunately, one concussion too many prematurely ended his in-ring career before he could make it to Raw or SmackDown as an in-ring competitor. Graves’ future seemed uncertain for a while, but he eventually got an opportunity to don a smart jacket and try his hand in the announcing booth.
His snarky commentary mixed with a great talent for putting over the action solidified him as an essential part of NXT during one of its most exciting periods. He can now be found calling the action on Monday Night Raw.
2. Tyson Kidd
Kidd was part of a vanilla tag team on the main roster along with fellow Hart family affiliate David Hart Smith. It was clear he could go in the ring, but he was so bland it was nearly impossible to invest in his matches. It wasn’t until he was sent down to NXT that he really found his groove.
Kidd was paired up with real-life wife Natalya, with an act centered around him being jealous of her success on the main roster. Kidd would throw her in harm’s way, and generally act like a jerk to the lovable Nattie. Kidd developed a delightfully irritating catchphrase, ending his sentences with the word ‘fact!’ He also started to develop a more distinctive look and an arrogant swagger that he took with him when he returned to the main roster. It also helped that Kidd got the chance to showcase his talents in some stand-out feuds with Adrian Neville, and Sami Zayn.
His return to the main roster saw a brief flurry of success as he partnered with Cesaro to capture the tag team championships. Unfortunately, injuries cut his run short and it remains to be seen if Kidd can ever top the heights of his NXT success.
1. Bo Dallas
Dallas started out in NXT as a really forgettable baby face. He was a smiling, no-nonsense good guy who had plenty of heart. The crowd couldn’t have cared less about him.
That's why it caught nearly everybody by surprise when he suddenly hit gold as a heel, playing the Justin Bieber of professional wrestling. The grinning goon would constantly talk about his army of Bo-lievers, seemingly oblivious to the boos from the crowd. "They aren't booing, they're saying 'Boooo'!”, he would explain. “No more Bo! No more Bo!”, they would shout. But they just wanted to know more about their champion, he would attest.
As the centrepiece of NXT, he constantly won by fluke, stoking the anger of the fans until finally losing to Adrian Neville in epic fashion as part of the main event of NXT's first ever live special. Unfortunately, his graduation to the main roster put him in the hands of a writing team that didn’t seem to get the nuances of what made his character great. His act was simplified to a sort of motivational speaker, repeating his catchphrases ad-nauseum.
Ever since his big-time debut, he's been treated as an afterthought by creative and is currently something of a jobber to the stars. Many die hard Bo-lievers hope he can one day regain the dizzying heights of his NXT run. Well, I suppose anything's possible if you Bo-lieve!