7 WWE Good Guys The Fans Hated
Roman Reigns is not the first WWE babyface to get booed.
WWE fan reactions are a hot topic among wrestling fans with the suggestion that WWE’s blue-eyed superhero Roman Reigns should be turned to the dark side because of the loud booing he encounters on every trip to the squared circle.
Over the years WWE, under Vince McMahon, has encountered numerous occurrences where the crowd didn’t react as planned and some hand-picked favourites have found themselves on the wrong end of a live crowd’s ire.
Whether it be a rabid Madison Square Garden or a fanbase disillusioned with repeated main event pushes for the same worker with limited skills, there have been plenty of occasions where the WWE Universe has rebelled against Vince McMahon’s wishes. Who can forget WrestleMania XXX when McMahon planned to put his newly minted unified world championship on the broad shoulders of Batista. A plan the fans hated from the first moment it was teased and instead sided with Daniel Bryan. A man Vince himself had written off as a talented midcarder with a look that didn’t suit the main event scene.
This list looks at seven times that Vince McMahon’s chosen babyface hero was not met with rapturous applause in WWE arenas.
7. Roman Reigns
If you watch WWE with any regularity it can’t have escaped your attention that Roman Reigns is not the most widely liked and accepted WWE Superstar of his generation. Roman Reigns doesn’t need to be widely liked though because the one man that matters likes him. That man is Vincent Kennedy McMahon.
At some point Vince looked at Roman and decided the 6’3” tall Samoan grappler was going to be the face of his company. At no point did the WWE’s audience look at Roman Reigns the same way. A former professional footballer in the CFL and member of the world famous Anoa’i family, Reigns had a head start on a lot of wannabe professional wrestlers. Already experienced in front of live crowds and trained by his father, WWE Hall of Famer Sika, he was halfway to being a star before signing for WWE.
Roman made his WWE debut in 2010, as part of then developmental territory Florida Championship Wrestling, the precursor to NXT. When he was called up in 2012 it was as part of the Shield with fellow developmental talents Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins, two wrestlers who had fought their way through the Indies and spent years working on their in-ring style.
The feeling was that they could hide the inexperienced Reigns within their ranks until he was ready to break out. The spot was originally, according to CM Punk, for Chris Hero. Punk had pitched Hero, Ambrose and Rollins as a three-man group but WWE wanted Roman in there. They saw big things in him and Reigns was always going to be the big star of the team. While Roman has progressed as an in-ring performer there’s a nagging suggestion that he’s been over-pushed.
“We do have our finger on the pulse of the marketplace, if for no other reason than having all these live events and listening to our audience all the time.” – Vince McMahon
If Vince McMahon is listening to his audience, he’s choosing to ignore their responses. This is nothing new. Vince McMahon has a history of being entirely convinced he’s right and pushing ahead regardless of how audiences have responded. To understand where this mentality comes from with have to start our journey with Hulk Hogan.
6. Hulk Hogan
When Vince McMahon purchased the World Wrestling Federation from his father, Vincent J. McMahon, his first decision was to bring in Hulk Hogan and base the company around him. It was the correct decision. Hogan was charismatic, one of the best promos in wrestling during a time when the business was changing and had a great connection to the audiences.
The AWA and owner Verne Gagne had failed to take advantage of this opportunity and constantly stopped Hogan from ascending to the throne in that promotion, often booking him to win title matches but not win the championship itself. Vince knew what he had with Hogan and Hulkamania became a legitimate crossover success in the 1980s.
Hulk Hogan is arguably the biggest star wrestling has ever seen. Ask a non-wrestling fan to name a wrestler and almost inevitably Hogan is the name on their lips. That’s how big he was in the 1980s. He transcended professional wrestling and became an iconic figure around the world.
The McMahon’s based their company around long, significant babyface title reigns. The likes of Bruno Sammartino, Pedro Morales and Bob Backlund had enjoyed multiple years as WWF Heavyweight Champion. Vince Jr. believed in this mentality and had Hogan as his champion for four years and the company did great business during that time. The Rock N’ Wrestling Era is one of the most successful in WWF/E history and Hogan was the biggest draw.
During his run as champion shows where the Hulkster appeared routinely outdrew shows without him and by a significant margin. There is no doubt that Vince struck while the iron was hot and did sensational business as a result. However this approach working as it did has had the knock-on effect that every big star WWE wants to get over gets booked the same way as Hogan, regardless of whether that’s the right thing to do.
When the time came for Hogan to drop the title, in early 1988, his star continued to shine brightly. While Randy Savage ruled as champion, Hogan was still drawing big numbers on the B show while Macho Man headlined the A show. As a result WWE cash flow was sky high. The clash between the duo at WrestleMania V in 1989, was the highest drawing wrestling PPV, ever, to that point with 650,000 buys.
Hogan’s second run with the belt was fairly successful but when he passed the torch to the Ultimate Warrior at WrestleMania VI the signs were appearing that the WWF’s fanbase was starting to tire of Hogan. Changing champions was the right thing to do and if Vince had left it at that Hogan would remembered fondly as a great champion who drew huge money and didn’t overstay his welcome. Not only that he did the right thing and went out on his back.
However Warrior didn’t do the numbers that Vince was expecting and he went back to his more reliable toy; Hulkamania. At WrestleMania VII, a year after Hogan passed the torch, he was back on top of the business as WWF Champion and business was not good. WrestleMania VII was supposed to be the WWF’s biggest pay per view event, ever. They aimed to shatter their attendance record, the massive WrestleMania III crowd of 93,173, and ended up moving to a much smaller venue because of a “bomb threat”.
The idea being that Sgt. Slaughter’s Iraqi sympathiser gimmick had so many people legitimately riled up that something bad might happen in a big open arena. The reality of the situation is that in 1991 Hulk Hogan wasn’t the draw he once was. Although house show attendances will testify differently, which is part of the reason why Vince persisted with Hogan, WrestleMania VII flopped. The attempt at 100,000 people in attendance came in a paltry 16,158.
The rot had set in but instead of listening to the critics, who openly blasted McMahon’s xenophobic attitude to foreigners, Vince persisted on his path. The only thing that stopped Hulkamania ruling the roost for much longer was the business exposing steroid scandal, which almost saw McMahon sent to prison for his part in distributing anabolic steroids to his grapplers. If that didn’t happen, McMahon would never have switched gears like he did, when he did.
The proof being Wrestlemania IX, two years later, when McMahon once again put the title on Hogan. 1993, two years after the time was right to ring changes. Hogan even headlined the WrestleMania in between, against another of Vince’s hand-picked giants; Sid Justice. Vince was simply unable to see the writing on the wall until it was too late.
McMahon may have created a dynasty with his sterling run-on booking and monster heels in the 1980s but as soon as the 90s rolled around he looked out of touch with modern society. The fans were quite happy to tell him he was wrong, loudly cheering when Sid dumped Hogan out of the 1992 Royal Rumble. They were bored with saying their prayers and eating their vitamins and wanted someone new, anyone different to take that top spot in the promotion. What was Vince’s solution to losing his tall patriotic blonde American?
5. Lex Luger
Luger had been acquired by Titan Sports in 1992, coming straight from the main event scene in WCW. McMahon knew Lex, as WCW Heavyweight Champion when he left, wouldn’t be able to compete for him as a wrestler due to a no-compete clause. That didn’t stop McMahon, who wanted Luger to be the face of his newest venture; the World Bodybuilding Federation.
Luger’s scheduled appearance, at the WBF Championship in 1992, was cancelled after Lex crashed his motorcycle, badly injuring his arm. The WBF lasted about two years before Vince gave up. The shows are hilariously camp; McMahon commentating on two hours of oiled-up musclemen posing while yelling his support. At least one person enjoyed the WBF.
By the time Luger was fit to compete the WBF had folded, Vince using their TV slot to shill his supplements under the ICOPRO banner, and Lex’s no-compete clause had expired. To begin with McMahon utilised Luger as a narcissistic heel who vainly stared into mirrors. The gimmick wasn’t a particularly good idea and Luger was terribly wooden in the role but at least Lex was given something different to play with. When Hulk Hogan left, McMahon switched gears on Luger. No sooner had the Hulkster headed out of the exit, Lex was turned face and became an All-American hero, body-slamming evil foreigner Yokozuna on the USS Intrepid on American Independence Day 1993.
After that turn Luger was carted around the United States on a tour bus dubbed the “Lex Express”, culminating in a championship match at Summerslam ’93. Here is where things got a bit bizarre as the crowd didn’t turn on Lex first but rather Vince McMahon decided to wait until WrestleMania to put the title on Lex. Luger’s failure to capture the belt at the right time, when he had all the momentum, cooled him off. By the time the Royal Rumble came around McMahon’s grand plan was in ruins. The fans had become indifferent toward Luger and instead were rooting for Bret Hart. An everyman Canadian grappler who’d captured the hearts of the audience with his gutsy performances and strong in-ring abilities.
The ending of the 1994 Royal Rumble saw Luger and Hart declared co-winners. The crowd’s reaction is what was most interesting. Both on that event and on future WWF shows the crowd favoured Hart. If you watch the pause between the finish of the Rumble match and the announcement of who won the crowd are chanting “Bret”. It changed McMahon’s mind and it was Bret who was anointed WWF Champion at WrestleMania X while Luger came up short in his title match. From there Lex was supposed to feud with Mr Perfect, who’d had a hand in his ‘Mania failure disqualifying Luger as a guest referee. However Perfect was injured and Luger was left in limbo. A victim of Vince McMahon’s obsession with recreating the Hogan character.
Luger hopped back over to WCW in 1995, appearing on the first Nitro and firing a big opening shot in the Monday Night War. The WWF’s audience had told Vince McMahon they didn’t want to see Luger as champion and, for once, McMahon listened and changed his plans. The following year he’d go back to behaving normally.
4. Diesel
Kevin Nash had been toiling away in WCW, working an assortment of awful gimmicks including Oz and Vinnie Vegas. WCW had no idea what to do with him. Shawn Michaels did. He saw Nash on TV and decided he’d make a good bodyguard. Both onscreen and in the clubs after the show. Generally HBK was not well liked and felt he needed someone to watch his back. McMahon went along with it as Shawn had his ear at the time. When Nash arrived it didn’t take long for McMahon to see money in the big man. He ticked all of Vince’s boxes. He was tall, billed at seven feet, he was charismatic and he had ring presence.
It wasn’t long before Diesel became McMahon’s flavour of the month. He surpassed Shawn on the pecking order and in the 1994 Royal Rumble eliminated seven men. By the end of the year he was WWF World Heavyweight Champion. It was a meteoric rise but Big Daddy Cool didn’t always click with the fanbase as champion. A prime example is WrestleMania XI, a show where Diesel was the headline act, defending his title against Shawn Michaels. The challenger was perhaps a little over exuberant in his selling during the match, resulting in the crowd favouring the underdog. Shawn was just trying to have the best match he could be ended up garnering sympathy and reminding the crowd how much fun Michaels was to watch.
It almost cut the legs off Diesel’s run and resulted in Vince putting him in against more big men so he could generate sympathy of his own. Nash ended up wrestling the likes of Sid and Mabel in dire matches until he run ended. Meanwhile Michaels was shifted face right after ‘Mania. When Diesel’s title run ended he switched tweener by pointing out he wasn’t a bad guy, or a good guy, he was just Diesel and if you liked him that was cool. This is exactly the same approach that Vince has tried to take with Roman Reigns. The Diesel tweener run didn’t last long and Diesel was turned fully heel to feud with Undertaker and Shawn Michaels on his way out of the door.
Diesel and Reigns have a lot of similarities. They’re both tall and have limited move sets and they both look exactly like Vince McMahon sees his top guy as. The problem they both face is wrestling in a promotion where the undercard talent is often more exciting and more in line with what the fans think of as a star. In Diesel’s time it was the likes of Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels. In Roman’s time it’s Kevin Owens, Cesaro, AJ Styles and more. The competition for places on the roster has never been more fierce and the options people have are numerous.
3. Shawn Michaels
This is a very different example. Shawn is everything that most of Vince’s hand-picked main eventers are not. For starters he’s short (6’1”, short for the WWF). Secondly he was turned face after a surge of fan support during an extremely effective heel run in 1995. Michaels was beloved in general due to his work rate and bump-heavy ring style. He was viewed by the increasingly large number of fans that were smart to the business as a saviour for the WWF’s main event scene. This was ably demonstrated at WrestleMania X when a ladder match against Razor Ramon stole the show.
Where it went wrong for Shawn was outside the ring. The fans generally took a dislike to Shawn, as a babyface, during 1996 when he was at the apex of his career. In the ring Michaels was having one great match after another with a variety of opponents. Including an Ironman match with Bret Hart at WrestleMania XII, a surprisingly outstanding match with Diesel a month later and during the summer a wonderful contest with Mick Foley under his Mankind persona.
Michaels, often abusing drugs and alcohol, developed a habit of being a prima donna and the more clued in wrestling fans were aware of this. An example of Shawn’s petulance was during a match against the British Bulldog at In Your House: Beware of Dog. During the contest he was told the match would be finishing early due to time constraints, finishing in seventeen minutes instead of the planned thirty. Shawn had a hissy fit in the ring, threw in a ridiculous bump for no reason and argued with the referee while in a chinlock.
To make matters worse, and further stain his reputation, when it came time to work against the WWF’s biggest, baddest heel Vader, Michaels chewed the big man out for being too stiff with his punches. Vader was known for his realistic style, garnered during vicious matches in Japan, including one where Stan Hansen punched his eye out of the socket. Michaels wasn’t keen to have that kind of match and a long feud was curtailed to a single match that Shawn won.
Flash forward a few months to Survivor Series and the time came for Shawn to drop the belt to someone he preferred to lose to, Sycho Sid. The match took place in the hallowed Madison Square Garden and the New York fans let Shawn know that they were none too happy with his behaviour as champion. Normally Michaels was being cheered during matches but in New York that wasn’t the case. He was booed loudly before the match even started and as the contest continued matters only got worse.
Sid was cheered for beating up the companies top face and the typical McMahon reaction was to blame wacky New Yorkers for not reacting as they should. Vince is a known control freak, who dislikes sneezing as it’s not something he can control, and having an audience blow up on his top babyface was not something he expected. He persisted with the Michaels babyface experiment well into 1997 until turning him heel during a feud with the Undertaker. The difference between Michaels and some of the other guys on this list is that he was quite happy at the prospect of being turned heel.
2. Rocky Maivia
1996 was a year that Vince McMahon started to learn something about crowd reactions and it was the very beginning of the Attitude Era. With the sparks flying that would light the Attitude fire, Vince chose to debut a third generation star in Rocky Maivia at the 1996 Survivor Series. The same crowd that took a collective dump on Shawn Michaels. It was a risky move, although Vince would never have seen it that way. Maivia was heavily cheered in his debut match and indeed victory but that wouldn’t remain the case.
Rocky was a green, inexperienced grappler when he first debuted and it took him a while to get good at the in-ring aspects of professional wrestling. It would have been wise to have him build a reputation slowly. McMahon isn’t known for his patience and Rocky won the Intercontinental Championship in February 1997, just three months after his debut. He was well received up to this point but something about the push rubbed the fans up the wrong way. Maivia was being forced down their throats as a “blue chipper”. He was squeaky clean and a typical blue-eyed babyface hero of old. The fans slowly but surely turned on him.
The difference between the Attitude Era and all other eras of the WWF/E related to McMahon’s changes of booking. When the likes of Maivia had been booed in the past he’d book them to look even better to make sure the crowd reacted accordingly. With more live television than ever in 1997, the opportunities were no longer there to freshen up Rocky’s crowd reactions. He was booed heavily and received unflattering chants of “Die, Rocky, Die” and “Rocky sucks”.
A knee injury derailed Rocky’s run and when he came back it was as a heel. In 1998 The Rock became one of the hottest properties in wrestling, won the WWF World Heavyweight Championship and was one of the most popular wrestlers on the roster.
The Attitude Era gets praised for a lot of reasons and some of them unfairly. The actual in-ring product from those three-four years isn’t anywhere near as good as it is now. From a booking perspective however there are lessons to be learned. One of the biggest is that if you want your top guy to get over as a babyface, it’s a good idea to give him a big heel run first.
Roman had that in the Shield but not in singles. He certainly has the charisma and in-ring presence required to have such a run and it feels like a no-brainer that he’s not been turned, like the Rock was. I’m sure the Rock wouldn’t stand for a character that defiantly carries on regardless of reaction, as was evidenced when he supported Reigns at the Royal Rumble in 2015. The look on his face said it all.
1. John Cena
If there’s a poster boy for Vince McMahon’s block-headed stubbornness it would be John Cena. To put Cena’s ridiculously long babyface run into perspective it dates back to the tail end of 2003. That’s thirteen years as a fan favourite and the term barely applies to Big Match John. He has been roundly booed by most of the males in the WWE’s audience since winning the WWE World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania XXI.
Eleven years of mixed reactions and Vince McMahon has steadfastly refused to turn his golden child into a bad guy. Even in an era like the 1980s, a massive star like Hulk Hogan outstayed his welcome as a face quicker than that. You could argue that Hogan had crowd support for the entire of his babyface run, which was over a decade, but when he did turn heel in 1996 to form the New World Order, it freshened him up in totally unexpected ways.
Cena’s mixed reaction is very clear every time he makes his way to the ring. The crowd happily chant “John Cena sucks” along with his theme music and there’s a very clear divide between the men in the audience and the kids. Which is why Cena has remained a babyface for as long as he has. WWE’s market isn’t what it used to be during more successful periods. At the moment they are catering to their core audience, which is kids.
Kids who buy WWE merchandise and cheer on the traditional crowd favourites like Cena and Roman Reigns. The reactions for these gentlemen on the house show circuit, which is mostly made up of families with children at the forefront, is drastically different than in front of a hardcore wrestling crowd at a TV taping or a PPV.
It’s hard to say why Cena became such a hated figure. There are reasons for it happening that are shared with other names on this list. There’s a feeling among some fans that Cena didn’t deserve to become champion when he did. That his in-ring skill didn’t match the placement of him at the top of the card. Perhaps WWE were partially to blame by selecting certain wrestlers to compete against him. In the early part of Cena’s run on top he was routinely defending against better wrestlers like Christian, Kurt Angle and Shawn Michaels.
All fan favourites regardless of their official alignment. The original theory behind Cena working against these men was for him to improve and grow into his role as the companies top dog. It didn’t really play out that way.
Cena is not an isolated incident and since the late 1990s a lot of McMahon’s chosen babyfaces have not received the kind of reactions he was hoping for. Usually people drawing heat were turned heel though. Including Batista when he was brought back in 2014. He was positioned as the top babyface despite being away from wrestling for three years, something that traditionally annoys wrestling fans. Listen to the reactions during Brock Lesnar vs. Goldberg when both men were leaving wrestling at WrestleMania XX. Massive anger was levelled at both guys for their decisions. Even the Rock got heat for leaving and going Hollywood to the point where they had to turn him heel and make him behave like an entitled actor.
While Cena has been an isolated case in terms of his longevity as a hated babyface what happens if Vince McMahon is serious about persisting with Reigns? What if McMahon wants to build his company around Roman going forward? The one thing that stands against Roman is the declining television ratings, and the associated advertising dollars that come along with that. If the ratings continue to sink, is it going to be considered the fault of Reigns?
It’s really no fault of his own that Vince McMahon wants to push him so hard but the modern era is one where there is so much choice that persistently giving the fans the same guy, when they clearly don’t want him in that position, is eventually going to turn more eyes away from the product.
Vince McMahon’s stubbornness has long been one of his best traits. If he wasn’t determined to smash the territories and go global then wrestling may have fizzled out all together in the 1990s. Different entertainment mediums could have scooped up the wrestling fans and there would be nothing left but small time regional promotions without television.
If McMahon hadn’t been so determined to get crossover appeal and compete against those outside of wrestling we wouldn’t have WrestleMania. We wouldn’t have the Network. We wouldn’t have NXT. Other promotions have built their own companies to match WWE’s ambition. With no WWE, would there be a New Japan World? With no WWE, would British promotions like PROGRESS and Revolution Pro Wrestling be available On Demand? Would anything we love as wrestling fans really be around in 2016 without Vince McMahon? It’s impossible to tell. One thing is for sure; as long as Vince McMahon is alive he’ll run WWE and he’ll push whoever he chooses, damn it.