7 WWE Stars Who Can Never Be Babyface Again

No turning back.

WWE.com

WWE like to flip characters between babyface and heel often.

It makes sense sometimes. Most company stars appear on programming 52 weeks of the year, and they're hardly the most layered of personalities that maintain permanent freshness with the audience. By the second or third month of their run as a good guy or bad, the vibrancy begins to fade and wrestlers start to show themselves as one dimensional gimmicks who bore the pants off everyone.

In other words, they and the writers run out of new material and decide to press the panic button, change their alignment and start again as if nothing happened. Take someone like Big Show as a great example; the big man has witnessed more turns than the average roundabout, and fans definitely greet every latter day switch with yawns.

Now he's a legendary part-timer, Show should never turn again. The same general rule could be used for these guys, although they're camping out on the other side of the fence. Everyone on this list currently works as a heel, and they've got their own reasons for why they can't become credible goodies again.

There's no turning back...


7. Lana

Bobby Lashley Lana
WWE.com

Who the hell is gonna' cheer for a vain, self-obsessed, manipulative bitch like Lana ever again? Rusev's storyline ex has found her calling as an outspoken annoyance who thinks the world revolves around her, and she shouldn't ever try to be anything else.

Overblown self-centredness and babyface mojo don't go hand-in-hand.

Lana is way too deep into the heel weeds to make a 180 degree switch and suddenly start pretending she's everyone's friend. Her 2015 turn and alliance with Dolph Ziggler was such a disaster that WWE shouldn't try to make her likeable anyway; in fact, they should do the opposite. Lana thrives when she's flaunting her good looks as some sort of superiority mask over the rest of the human population.

She's turned on the lovable Rusev, used Bobby Lashley, strung Liv Morgan along (though WWE's writers have done a poor job exploring that plot point) and generally acted like a bratty child. There's nothing redeemable about her character.


6. Shinsuke Nakamura

Shinsuke Nakamura Cesaro Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Wrestling fans who lived through it should shudder when thinking back to Shinsuke Nakamura's 2017 babyface run. Despite being an excellent in-ring talent who could (and still can) work with all shapes and sizes, Shinsuke's lack of promo skills let him down badly.

Like it or not, fans just couldn't relate to his broken English and laid back personality outside the ropes.

Since turning heel in 2018, Nakamura has settled into WWE life a bit better. He comes across as artistic and aloof rather than personable and relatable, and that suits his heelish persona. If WWE don't realise that things improved after he ball-shotted AJ Styles and hooked up with Sami Zayn later, then God help them. Nobody needs a rerun of that feud with Jinder Mahal.

It was awful stuff, and didn't help Naka ingratiate himself to the fans one bit. He's much better of playing heel until he inevitably leaves the company and returns to Japan for one last blast around the New Japan horn.


5. Finn Bálor

Finn Bálor NXT
WWE

Smiling.

That's literally all cheeky Irish chappy Finn Bálor did on Monday nights when he was on Raw. For those who had watched his marvellous work in Japan as part of the Bullet Club or admired his kinship with fans during his first NXT stint, this absolutely sucked. He smiled, and smiled, and smiled, and sh*tting smiled.

Since moving back to NXT, Bálor has found his place in the WWE system again. His heel turn was necessary, clawed back some of the edge he'd lost as a grinning weirdo on Mondays and helped him sharpen his ring work too. The brand jump should be considered a rescue mission Finn needed to salvage his character.

It's difficult to see anything beyond mediocrity for him as a babyface in WWE if they decide to turn him back to playing goody-gum-drops in a leather jacket any time soon. The naturally charming Bálor will only grin like he's happy to be there, and that's a poor substitute for his maniacal smirks on NXT when warring with guys like Johnny Gargano.


4. Bayley

Bayley Sasha Banks
WWE.com

It sounds weird right now, but Sasha Banks has another chance to play babyface in WWE if the writers weave some reality into the mix. Before turning, Banks can express remorse for how she acted last summer and point to the fact that she thought being controversial was the way to progress her career.

Bayley, meanwhile, is stuck.

Sasha's 'Legit Boss' character was always a bit of a bitch. Bayley wasn't. She was the 'girl next door', and the kind of pro wrassler who loved entertaining your kids or encouraging adults to shed their inhibitions and just have fun. Bayley was the female John Cena in some respects, but not anymore.

She turned her back on everything she previously stood for, and there's no going back. The side pony is gone, the wacky waving inflatable tube men have been punctured and the former hugger is a much more serious performer overall. It'd be totally stupid if she abandoned recent fan bashing and returned to acting 12 years old.

Her heel turn was a hard enough change without hitting rewind.


3. Charlotte Flair

Rhea Ripley Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

By her own admission, Charlotte Flair is much stronger as a heel. She's said as much in interviews, even noting that her silver spoon upbringing makes it hard for people to relate with her lifestyle. That shows a degree of self-awareness, and WWE should start displaying the same awareness for her character.

As Flair said, playing wrestling's female role model doesn't suit the way she's presented. Lavish robes, charlatan smiles and an upturned nose towards anyone and everything are all key parts of her act, and they don't lend themselves to being babyface. It's weird then that WWE sporadically try to force her down fans throats as good-natured when she's anything but on screen.

It needs to stop.

Charlotte is heel by default now she's rubbishing Rhea Ripley as NXT Women's Champion, and that's where she should stay. She's so much better off as a heel; fans might cheer her from time to time, like they did her father Ric, but that doesn't mean Flair's mannerisms have to change.


2. Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins AOP
WWE.com

It might not be an accident that Seth Rollins' current 'Monday Night Messiah' gimmick shares a lot in common with CM Punk's old 'Straight Edge Saviour' guise. WWE might be sneakily setting something up there, but even if they're not one thing rings true: Seth cannot repeat the second half of 2019 ever a-bloody-gain.

That nightmare destroyed his babyface run, shattered his relationship with the fans and almost negatively impacted Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' for good. It also succeeded in turning Rollins from likeable wrestling workhorse into whinging git champion who cut scaredy-cat promos so unbelievable they could've come from old Goosebumps episodes.

This new heel persona born out of that misery is working for him.

Like any good zealot, he has backup to do the dirty work for him. By surrounding himself with the likes of AOP and Buddy Murphy, Seth has raised their respective profiles as well as his own. He's thriving as a ranting, disconnected and delusional WWE Donald Trump, and (much like Bayley) spat on his old bond with the audience.


1. Randy Orton

Randy Orton Edge
WWE.com

Edge's trembling, intense performance on the 27 January Raw has single-handedly ensured that Randy Orton can never be a genuine babyface in WWE again.

By attacking such a beloved figure, one who had returned from the sidelines after nine long years, Randy returned to his maliciously cold and calculating 'Legend Killer' days. He put bits of that gimmick into the nearest blender with elements of his angry, intermittently-violent 2009 character and served up the tastiest bits of both.

The whole package was sensational, and has since been heightened by Orton's refusal to explain his actions on the 3 February Raw. Now, he's heading for a massive showdown with Edge at WrestleMania 36, and can't put this particular genie back in the lamp afterwards. Mr. RKO is heel for good, or at least he should be.

Should WWE pen forgiveness post-WrestleMania from Edge, penance and regret from Orton himself or (worse) pretend the biggest angle in years never occurred, it'll be a slap in the face to every fan who sobbed their way through it. Edge's performance, and Randy's evil, was too damn good for that.

Do you agree that these WWE stars should never play babyface again? For more content, check out 10 Potential WWE Super ShowDown 2020 Opponents For Goldberg and 10 Wrestling Matches Neither Wrestler Could Afford To Lose!


Watch Next


In this post: 
Randy Orton
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.