8 Amazing Wrestlers That Flopped In AEW
These great wrestlers flopped hard in AEW.
All Elite Wrestling lives by the mantra of being "where the best wrestle". Since its inception in 2019, Tony Khan's promotion has prided itself on having a wealth of homegrown talent and bringing in the best talent from the independent scene and a plethora of already established names. That has worked like a charm for the most part, but not everything can work out for every superstar.
Some of AEW's most notable acquisitions haven't worked out for either party. Whether things have been doomed from the start or soured over time, been affected by outside sources, or just not fit in with the product's fanbase and ethos, AEW has seen a whole host of talent join its ranks, only to fall flat on their face.
For some of these wrestlers, they've been the victims of bad luck, whereas others have simply not performed to the best of their abilities. Whatever way you slice it, the following talented performers have not contributed to the wider AEW story to the high standards that the company would have expected over the years, being some of the organisation's biggest flops.
8. The Hardys
The Hardys heading to AEW after their middling third run in WWE made a lot of sense on paper. Matt and Jeff were both still massive household names, were still only in their 40s, and had plenty of juice left in the tank. All this, and both Matt and Jeff had good runs on the indies when AEW's EVPs were selling Bullet Club shirts by the truckload, not to mention the Hardys had done stellar work in TNA.
The Hardys in AEW should have worked a charm, but it really, really didn't.
Matt Hardy arrived in AEW in February 2021, just over a year before his brother. Sadly, none of Matt's storylines had captured what made him so beloved during his 'Broken' days, and this somehow only got worse when Jeff arrived. Jeff was booked strongly in the first Owen Hart tournament, getting through Darby Allin via DQ on the way to being beaten in the semi-finals by eventual winner, Adam Cole, but The Hardys as a team just felt flat compared to AEW's existing tag team scene.
Their only PPV appearance came in a limp victory over The Young Bucks at Double or Nothing 2022, in a match that felt a little sad compared to the incredible Ladder Match the teams had at ROH Supercard of Honor XI just five years earlier. Unfortunately, Jeff Hardy picked up a DUI charge three months into working with AEW, and things fell apart from there. It also didn't help that Jeff would regularly complain in public about appearing on Rampage, calling it "the B show", but neither he nor his brother did anything to justify A-list billing.
7. Ric Flair
Ric Flair is correctly lauded as one of the greatest wrestlers of all time, but that does not mean there's a need for him to be part of a contemporary wrestling company. Alan Shearer is one of the best footballers England has ever produced, but nobody is clamouring for him to be part of this summer's World Cup squad.
Flair's brief dalliance with AEW seemed to be largely connected with helping him promote his WOOOOO! Energy Drink, while also being a part of the final leg of Sting's farewell run. In truth, Flair was an unnecessary distraction to that story and offered nothing to subsequent matches in which he appeared. His stuttering chops and low blows to the likes of Christian Cage, Powerhouse Hobbs, and Konosuke Takeshita felt more sad than exciting.
The Young Bucks hit Ric with superkicks in Sting's excellent final match at Revolution 2024, but Flair's appearance in that spectacle felt more like paying lip service to the Nature Boy than a vital component to the match. He appeared on AEW TV as part of a tribute to Steve McMichael on Collision in May 2025, and there were rumors of him being part of last year's Blood & Guts, but this entire relationship offered nothing to the legacy of AEW or Ric Flair.
6. Adam Copeland
This may be one of the more controversial picks on this list, but Adam Copeland has never really felt like he works as part of AEW. He is a superstar, and his aura can't be questioned, but watching Copeland run from side to side during his entrance in buildings about a fifth of the size he's used to is quite symbolic as to how his vibe doesn't ever feel very AEW.
Even when bringing violent weaponry to proceedings, Copeland naming his bat with nails sticking out of it 'Spike' and talking about it like it's an actual person, feels out of place next to the genuinely shocking violence of Swerve Strickland and 'Hangman' Adam Page's feud, or The Death Riders trying to suffocate Bryan Danielson with a plastic bag.
Add to this that the former Edge's teaming with FTR didn't really click, and his main event with Jon Moxley really let the night down at the otherwise spectacular Revolution 2025, and things just don't seem to be working for Cope. He spent the last quarter of 2025 shooting the latest season of Percy Jackson and the Olympians, but it doesn't really feel like fans are clamouring for him to return to AEW anytime soon.
5. Colt Cabana
Colt Cabana became a significant name to wrestling fans largely due to his Art of Wrestling podcast being one of the first of its kind. This shouldn't detract from Colt being an incredibly charming in-ring talent, who understands wrestling fans around the world, and showed that pretty regularly as a solid comedy performer on the independent circuit.
Cabana has spent most of his AEW tenure as part of The Dark Order. Aesthetically, it feels like an odd union, but he does fit with the idea that TDO are a bunch of outsider misfits who find strength in each other. He worked well as part of Being the Elite and felt like a believable member of the group when they offered 'Hangman' Adam Page support in his quest for his first AEW World Championship, but that never translated in the ring.
Largely appearing on AEW Dark, Colt Cabana is nowadays best known as the lightning rod for the controversy that surrounded CM Punk's AEW implosion. Staying away from that mess and keeping things purely about his on-screen work, Cabana has always felt surplus to requirements as a performer in AEW.
4. Kota Ibushi
AEW spawned from a very popular period of American independent wrestling. Part of that success came from embracing Japan's incredible wrestling culture and performers, with Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks forming their reputation in NJPW, and the likes of Chris Jericho and Cody Rhodes' appearances in Japan making events like Wrestle Kingdom more global than ever before.
Among the popular performers of that era was Kota Ibushi. For whatever reason, he was not part of the early years of Tony Khan's company. Eventually though, Kota made his first appearance on AEW TV as part of 2023's Blood & Guts, forming The Golden Elite to take on the Blackpool Combat Club.
Injuries play a massive part in why Kota Ibushi would be considered a flop for AEW, but the booking and presentation of him were also a large part of the problem. AEW is occasionally guilty of thinking that everyone who watches their programming has a wealth of wrestling knowledge, and they've never really done anything to explain Ibushi's brilliance or his incredible long-term story with Kenny Omega. Kota's gut-wrenching injury against Josh Alexander on the October 8th, 2025 episode of Collision looks set to keep him on the sidelines for a prolonged period, as his AEW woes continue.
3. Miro
What is so frustrating about the inclusion of Miro in this list is that things occasionally went incredibly well for him in AEW. When Rusev left WWE, the frustration around him was largely that we could all see how much character and personality he had. Vince McMahon, however, had reduced him to being a minor league player, even though fans could all see there was greatness inside the Bulgarian.
After making the jump to AEW in September 2020, Miro again found himself in a spot that didn't suit him. His union with fellow European Kip Sabian was thankfully short-lived, before Miro entered the best phase of his career so far. As 'The Redeemer', he cut chilling promos that echoed Marlon Brando in Apocalypse Now, and he had an excellent run with the TNT Championship, including a brilliant feud with Darby Allin.
Losing that title to Sammy Guevara after four months, Miro was expected to progress into AEW's big leagues. He was entered into the World Championship Eliminator Tournament, losing in the final at Full Gear 2021 to Bryan Danielson, but from here, Miro's AEW career flatlined. He wrestled just 11 times between this defeat and his eventual release from the company in September 2023. Whether it was injuries or backstage politics, it cast a shadow over his time in AEW that meant that the bad times, again, outweighed the good.
2. Jeff Jarrett
AEW signing Jeff Jarrett in November 2022 felt like a strange decision. In its early years, Tony Khan's upstart company felt like a fresh alternative to WWE's stale, Vince McMahon-led monotony. Brimming with fresh names like Darby Allin and MJF, AEW avoided the trappings of TNA and the concept that yesteryear's superstars had value in the contemporary wrestling landscape.
Double J is the ultimate throwback and the antithesis to modern wrestling. Wielding his trademark guitar and blasting people over the head with it, Jarrett's place on the AEW roster felt completely unnecessary from the start. He formed a tag team with Jay Lethal, and the stench of TNA was hard to stomach as it felt a million miles away from everything that had succeeded for Khan up to this point.
Throwing Jeff's wife Karen into proceedings also felt dated and misguided. Things would reach a stinky crescendo during a segment with MJF that drew criticism from all quarters. On the January 15th, 2025 episode of Dynamite, the pair spat more misogyny at one another than an Andrew Tate tweet, and Jarrett was taken off TV for good by the end of that month.
1. Aja Kong
Double or Nothing 2019 was a historic PPV, as AEW set out to show the world what they represented at their first official show. One of the most notable things to come from the show was that AEW was prepared to lean into Japanese wrestling for its women's division, and one of the most exciting elements was the hiring of Aja Kong.
A Japanese superstar from the Joshi scene, Aja's stiff, hard-hitting style is the stuff of legend in her homeland, and she even had a brief WWE feud with Alundra Blayze in the mid-'90s. Unfortunately, AEW would not capitalize on Kong's appearance in a six-woman tag team match at their inaugural PPV. Ending on the losing side of her debut contest, the COVID-19 pandemic made it difficult for AEW to build on this initial plan to include Japanese women on their shows.
Most frustratingly of all, AEW teased a feud between Aja Kong and Awesome Kong at the end of Fight for the Fallen 2019, when there was an intense staredown at the end of Brandi Rhodes' victory over Allie (who had Awesome Kong in her corner); a staredown that had fans salivating over this possibility, but a staredown that was never followed up on.
Aja Kong had just two more matches for AEW, as part of the Japanese bracket of the 2021 Eliminator Tournament, before never being used again.