8 Biggest Problems Facing NXT Right Now

Are there problems on the horizon for WWE's golden child?

nxt uk tour
WWE.com

As the smoke clears and the dust settles on another WrestleMania, the landscape of World Wrestling Entertainment is a fairly unsettled one. Despite the questions that the big show may have brought us, one thing is for sure; it is all steam ahead for NXT. The latest TakeOver special event was arguably the best yet, and it seems that the momentum truly is with the yellow brand.

The quality of NXT and its position as the most consistent brand of professional wrestling under the WWE umbrella is no secret. In many ways, NXT is the acceptable face of WWE wrestling, a throwback to a simpler time where what happened in the ring was the focus and treated as though it matters.

If there is the one thing I've learnt from two decades of watching WWE-produced wrestling, it is that nothing great can last forever. Heck, nothing great ever lasts as long as NXT's run of quality has. There are bumps in the future for NXT, this cannot be ignored. What are they? Well, that is for me to identify.

Up to this point, NXT has been well-protected and well put together, enough to believe that all of these potential bumps can be avoided. But of course, this is the crazy world of professional wrestling, where bumps are mandatory...


8. Navigating The Full Sail Crowd

Once NXT transformed from a bizarre wrestling-themed game show into developmental TV for World Wrestling Entertainment, it found itself a true home at Full Sail University in Florida. Initially, this protected environment led to the crowd being one of the hottest in wrestling, something of a PGTV version of the Pro Wrestling Guerilla crowds in Reseda, California.

Somewhere along the road, the enthusiasm provided by these loyal fans morphed into the most eye-rolling of distractions, one of the most glaring examples of a big problem for WWE in this most different of ages. Where the wrestling once dictated the crowd, the reverse is now true.

A lot of crowds in the modern age seem to be in it for themselves. Now, as paying customers and free-thinking individuals they are free to do as they choose, but professional wrestling is an art that requires the audience to play their role. Engaging in competitions to get the smartest chant on TV benefits nobody, and always detracts from the action itself.

The Full Sail crowd (or at least a vocal portion of them) have overvalued their role in NXT in 2016, and how NXT deals with this will be important going forward.


7. A Relatively Light Women's Division

alexa bliss carmella.jpg
WWE.com

One of the true positives to happen in World Wrestling Entertainment in the last year or so has been the improved positioning and presentation of its female competitors. The Divas Division is no more, and the god-awful butterfly belt has followed it to the wayside.

All of this started in NXT, originally with Paige and Emma before the Four Horsewomen (Charlotte, Sasha Banks, Bayley and Becky Lynch) took it to the next level. Three of those four went up to the main roster, leaving Bayley behind. Bayley's run as champion was a lot of fun, but now that Asuka has the belt one expects the former champion to join her Horsewomen counterparts in a rejuvenated main roster divison.

Asuka is the right choice as champion, but who is there to challenge her? Outside of the champ, it all looks a little weak. You've got Nia Jaxx, Alexa Bliss, Carmella, Dana Brooke, Peyton Royce and Billie Kay. Of those, arguably only Jaxx stands out as a credible challenge for the woman previously known as Kana.

Where does NXT go from here? The rebuilding and marshalling of the women's division through this period of transition will be tricky to say the least.


6. Dealing With Main Roster Jealousy

dolph ziggler.jpg
WWE.com

On numerous occasions last year, there were rumours of jealousy and bitterness emanating from the main roster in the direction of NXT. As the yellow brand gathered pace and momentum, many at the top of the table started to grumble, and the resentment filtered out.

It is entirely understandable. Look at the two big events from this past weekend; if you take the pay and grandeur out of it, TakeOver: Dallas seemed like a much more enjoyable show to work than WrestleMania. Give Dolph Ziggler the choice between being a bit-part player in a ladder spot fest or a 15+ showcase against Shinsuke Nakamura, which is he taking?

It is clear that in NXT a lot of the restraints forced upon WWE talent are loosened. Movesets are expanded, the stories make more sense and the talent is treated with immense respect. Why wouldn't one prefer this working environment?

As such, how NXT deals with the grumbles coming its way from the main roster is very important. The whole point of the show is to prepare people for the big time after all, and creating a boundary to them up there before they even arrive is detrimental to say the least.


5. Too Many Big Fish In A Small Pond

WWE.com

In the last 18 months or so, NXT has become the place to be in professional wrestling. Whereas once those who had made their name on the independent scene weren't likely to create blips on the WWE radar, now those who make their name elsewhere are almost inevitably on their way to Full Sail.

What this has led to is a quite wonderful problem, although that is still a problem. NXT has a truly impressive roster, the likes of which anyone who had ever played a booking simulator could only have dreamt of. Just take a look at some of these names; Finn Balor, Samoa Joe, Shinsuke Nakamura, Bayley, Hideo Itami, Austin Aries, Asuka, Johnny Gargano and more. It's wildly impressive.

To this point, NXT has only one hour of weekly programming. Now, a number of NXT standouts will eventually make their way up to the main roster, but this is no longer the desirable prospect it once was. NXT creative is now faced with the unenviable task of fitting all of these fantastic talents into just an hour of TV, and doing them all justice in the process.


4. The Apathy Of Taped Pro Wrestling

austin aries
WWE.com

Hey, remember a decade or so when WWE still had the brand split? Half of the roster was on RAW, the other half on SmackDown. Which of those two shows do you remember being the better? It was the blue one wasn't it, the one with the wrestling. It was also a taped show, and over the years a mixture of a weaker roster and the apathy that taped professional wrestling brings turned SmackDown into RAW-lite.

It is an unfortunate illness in the modern world of professional wrestling that man fans (especially new ones) are more interested in the result as opposed to the action. The internet is full of spoilers, articles out of spoilers are created, and the feeling is that if you've read the spoilers there isn't much point in seeing the show.

NXT is still a taped show, and the first signs of this apathy crept in during the road to Dallas. A huge batch of episodes were taped at the beginning of the year, in which Austin Aries and Shinsuke Nakamura were introduced to the show and the TakeOver: Dallas card was set.

For those of us who sat through the taped shows all the way up to the event, the lethargy of the entire situation was apparent towards the final episodes. When the final one finished, a sigh of relief escaped, acknowledging that this trying period was over.

Maintaining an invigorating taped television show in the internet age is a difficult task, to say the least.


3. Rebuilding The Tag Team Division

american alpha the revival.jpg
WWE.com

One of NXT's strengths has been the clear focus and attention it has paid to wrestling outside of men's singles action. Both the women's and tag team divisions have gotten the spotlight during its tenure, and both are in transition periods right now.

American Alpha won the tag titles from The Revival at TakeOver: Dallas, and I'd say there hasn't been a more deserving team to hold the straps since their inception. On the RAW after WrestleMania, Enzo & Big Cass made their RAW debuts, with The Vaudevillains following suit on this week's SmackDown.

With Zack Ryder getting a little more spotlight on the main roster, the NXT tag team division is looking a little thin. Gable & Jordan will take on The Revival again for sure, but outside of those two teams it seems that Blake & Murphy are all that remains.

How NXT rebuilds its tag division will be a clear indicator of the brand's future. It is no easy task, but a smooth transition from the wildly over teams it had to the future of the division will give faith those worrying about similar problems in the future.


2. Dealing With Being Developmental

finn balor nxt champion.jpg
WWE.com

It may not feel like it, but the harsh truth is that no matter how far it surpasses WWE main roster shows in terms of quality, NXT is essentially a developmental brand. It provides the stars of the future a chance to get some experience on TV and to work in a pressured environment, and when they are deemed ready to the main roster they go.

The arrival of a number of indy stand-outs over the last year or so has changed this landscape on the surface, but the base purpose of NXT remains the same. Thus, the mining of the independent scene leaves NXT in something of a pickle. Whilst the quality of the show has improved immensely, that purpose is being muddied.

Look at the first NXT special, NXT Arrival. The card featured seven matches, including a barnstorming main event between Neville and Bo Dallas. On that event, a number of WWE-developed performers (Dallas, The Ascension, Tyler Breeze) got excellent showcases and continued their development towards being ready for the main roster.

Fast-forward to TakeOver: Dallas, and the entire feel is different. It may have been an incredible show, but it also forgot the entire purpose of NXT. Including the two dark matches it featured seven bouts, and all but one of those was won by a former indy standout (that being American Alpha).

Balor, Nakamura, Joe et al will move up the main roster soon enough. The problem will be replacing them, as spots that originally would have been for those who aren't quite ready have been filled by the biggest show. NXT has stopped developing.


1. The Pressure Of Following Perfection

sami zayn nakamura.jpg
WWE.com

Okay, so perfection may be a strong word, but TakeOver: Dallas was one hell of a show. American Alpha picked up the tag titles in as good a tag match as you'll find all year, Asuka put Bayley's dream to sleep, Shinsuke Nakamura and Sami Zayn had a true MOTYC and Finn Balor continued his dominance at the top. From the opening bell to the last, it was a hell of a show.

Maintaining such a high level of quality is difficult, nigh on impossible even. Somehow, NXT has managed to keep improving their TakeOver specials every time, helped no little by much-anticipated debuts. Dallas had Nakamura, Respect had Asuka, Brooklyn had Apollo Crews and Jushin Liger etc etc.

The specials were also helped by a truly inspiring generational roster, with the first wave of top outside stars coming in to face a generation of performance centre graduates who had received plenty of TV time before the likes of Balor, Nakamura and Aries turned up.

If NXT is unable to continue this incredible run with the next special, the cracks may indeed begin to appear in the brand. Questions about its longevity will arise. As mentioned in earlier points, NXT is a developmental brand, but if you give your audience Shinsuke Nakamura vs. Sami Zayn one week they won't accept Bronson Matthews vs. King Constantine the next.

There are a number of potential bumps in the road ahead for NXT. How it deals with them may give a good idea into how WWE will deal with its own future. Either way, it'll be a fascinating watch.


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.