8 Match Star Ratings For WWE Backlash 2020
The new measure of success in WWE: "Whoa, that actually wasn't a complete joke!"
WWE built up Backlash amid turmoil and desperation.
Executive Director Paul Heyman was given the boot the week before a show that didn't involve any of the youth movement he was keen to push last year. There was a noticeable late Ruthless Aggression/early PG Era quality to its line-up, damning Heyman's noble failures and consigning them to the halcyon days of late 2019 when RAW changed its opening segment every third week.
Aleister Black might not get out of that darkened room without Heyman lobbying for him. Vince might conflate him with Gangrel and just banish him to Main Event, and when he's there, languishing, his career-uh dead-uh, somebody on r/SquaredCircle will still call him the next Undertaker.
The lack of trust in Heyman explained the ancient-feeling line-up, and the desperation informed the Greatest Wrestling Match Ever tagline. Ratings are down. There's no end in sight. Wrestling has this strange way of totally losing its audience for a while, or even forever. WWE should know this; they've lost half of the f*ckers since 2015. And so WWE, as if trying to impress a crush, told a fantastic lie in panic, which they then had to back up. I smell a sitcom!
And it was far more of a sitcom than the f*cking comedy match.
8. KICKOFF: Apollo Crews Vs. Andrade - United States Championship Match
At one point in his main roster career, Apollo Crews (Apollo) had a longer name than Andrade (Andrade 'Cien' Almas).
In March of this year, Apollo was getting decimated by Sheamus in one minute and 10 seconds. In April, he was taking Aleister Black to his limit in 27 minute TV epics. He is now the United States Champion in June.
The WWE midcard is a very disposable business, a shrugs-whatever byproduct of Vince McMahon's whims that, for the pedants and cynics, is difficult to take seriously. You can't map the arc of an Apollo Crews, unless you want to depress yourself. This isn't the start of something for him. With Paul Heyman gone, his lack of charisma will see Vince McMahon tire of the push. It's this sense of inevitability that permeates the Kickoff match and its ruthless pointlessness. This is as much a title match as it is a Main Event offering in three months.
A rematch of a rematch of a rematch of a rematch - they've shared the same ring six times since April 27 - the wrestling was really good. Apollo played along with the rope holding thing, countered Andrade's stomp, and launched him headfirst into the turnbuckle with a release overhead throw. That was well thought-through. That played effectively on the idea that these two men have developed a keen understanding of one another's games.
That was perceived as disposable content.
Star Rating: ★★★
7. Triple Threat Women's Tag Team Championship Match
This was a disappointment, narratively, but it over-delivered in terms of action.
There was lots of narrative ground to explore, given that two of the teams involved are on the cusp of a split. There was little in the way of miscommunications, outright errors, stern blind tag-ins - anything that might advance, even subtly, the wider tensions involving the IIconics and Bayley and Sasha Banks. Instead, the plot threads were mostly abandoned - there's always some exposition-heavy TV to burn through - and the three teams instead worked a furious sprint that while choppy and not exhilarating was enjoyable for more than its atypical novelty of a layout.
Bayley's trash talk started to grate after a while, but the match didn't outstay its welcome at just under nine minutes, which was smartly judged; it didn't unnecessarily over-expose Peyton Royce, who looked impressive in a more serious role.
But isn't this the company that makes movies?
Instead, this was a wonky but admirable banger simulation that, and this trope is very damaging, framed its winners (and ostensible Champions) as total chancers.
Star Rating: ★★★
6. Sheamus Vs. Jeff Hardy
It's harsh that Sheamus will be remembered for unlocking every achievement when the competition was at its weakest - his body of work betrays the nominally impressive lack of accolades - because he is really, really good at this at a midcard level.
In the early going, in an attempt to subdue Hardy to the mat, he was so subtly nasty with his movements. Grinding Hardy's ears with his fists in the grapple, pulling at his hair, he does the little things so well and so in character. You'd hate a shift wrestling Sheamus. He makes it look like an unpleasant ordeal, where so many other wrestlers go through the motions of the moments that most barely pay no attention to. Hardy registered everything very well with his distinct, superb selling ability, and it's a shame, because all anybody will ever remember is the piss.
This wasn't a banger or anything, but it was convincing, well-worked midcard fare, the excitement around which was further diminished by the haunting, mundane familiarity. These men have played close versions of these characters for so many years that, twinned with the venue, it felt much like the twilight years of a downsized band still stubbornly pumping out 6.5/10 studio albums.
The finish was really well done for a dumb idea. There can never be a happy ending.
Star Rating: ★★★¼
5. Asuka Vs. Nia Jax - RAW Women's Championship Match
Asuka knows how to work Nia Jax and extract something remotely worthy from her. This was trending in that direction before the f*cking finish, which, f*ck off. It's so typical of WWE's contemptuous booking approach that it barely warrants analysis.
"The Fed went carny again, vita sic est."
Here's what happened, and it's the sort of booking that euthanises fan investment: the programme was diminished on TV to such an extent that, when Nia Jax ran mandatory interference to promote this match on RAW, it felt like a surprise. Not through deft plotting, but because Charlotte Flair was positioned as the top contender before Nia Jax had the chance to lose.
And she didn't even lose, because nobody ever loses or wins. The feud WWE stopped caring about went to a count-out - one that made both Champion and challenger look particularly dumb because it's not as if they couldn't hear over the sound of around 17 performative robots in Edge t-shirts - and will continue. And, if they go in a Triple Threat direction, tough t*tties: they already did that match on RAW.
The match was boring when Nia Jax went through her slow and personality-devoid heat spot, and heated up when Asuka's explosive and convincing takedowns informed her comeback. The great work of a talented performer was weighed down by an over-pushed opponent and rancid booking.
Vita sic est.
Star Rating: ★★¾
4. Braun Strowman Vs. The Miz & John Morrison - Universal Title Match
This was a World Title programme.
Comedy isn't verboten in serious programmes, but Christ. That Universal Title doesn't feel remotely big-time around the waist of that passé lug, and this match wasn't even funny. So it accomplished nothing unless, of course, damaging the aura of two wrestlers at once counts. On the plus side, the Tag Team Titles also don't really feel prestigious, so it's not as if this buries the Miz and John Morrison. They simply move plots in the same wacky, slime-covered graveyard.
That's a facetious assessment of a match hardly worth critical thought, but John Morrison, he of criminal patter, does at least have the odd funny bone in him because his slapstick selling was theoretically amusing, in that the target audience of small children may not question why it is that they still watch this. But since WWE's declining viewership is principally made up of 55 year-olds, that's hardly ideal, and if the aim is to attract a new generation of young fans, maybe don't have Randy Orton threatened to "f*cking kill" that "motherf*cker" Edge.
Over-pushing an act that didn't get over to a level beyond cult affection a decade ago also isn't a good idea to attract new fans.
Star Rating: ★★¼
3. Drew McIntyre Vs. Bobby Lashley - WWE Championship Match
Much as in the main event, this rocked when it rid itself of the systemic WWE shackles, or they weren't so overbearing.
This for a time threatened to settle into your regulation WWE babyface powers through incredibly basic offence structure after Lashley had attacked McIntyre with the Full Nelson before the bell, the real drama generated by which was undermined the longer the heat went.
Why undersell the finish in the first act?
But after a very scary botch, in which McIntyre landed right on his head on the outside, this thing started to f*ck with brutal and brisk power move exchanges fought with a bruising, sweat-spraying intensity, the posturing macho rhythms of which were just lovely.
We were then gifted a rare and incredibly welcome glimpse of Bobby Lashley: wrestler who is skilled at MMA and as such was was fan-cast into a Brock Lesnar match. The submission exchanges amplified the drama, as did MVP's constant jaw-jacking on the outside.
He created a sense of peril and personality to the match as part of this promising new act, but the finish was ruined by the old - and very wearying - Lashley act. Nobody has given a single sh*t about the Lana and Lashley business since the wedding exhausted any and all perverse fascination with it, and now, nearly six months later, the last fumes of the story are deciding the finishes of pay-per-view World Title matches.
Star Rating: ★★★½
2. Street Profits Vs. Viking Raiders
What were the jokes, and where were they?
The wrestling promotion unilaterally booked by a 74 year-old man who thinks gurgling crap noises are hilarious can't do comedy wrestling because the comedy wrestling matches aren't funny, and there is no wrestling in them.
The wrestlers walk and brawl into comedic scenarios that aren't funny and make no sense. The absurdity isn't the premise because it's too aggressively zany and plain f*cking thick to develop qualities of irony or fun. They basically did a load of naff prop comedy that riffed on the skits that built towards this latest catastrophe of a "cinematic" match. Honestly, the most insulting this is that they think this is a riot. They used the same gags and even the same footage. They ran a celebratory clip show, essentially, of a sitcom no network would ever pick up because it is so sh*t.
Somewhere in the creative process, the 74 year-old white man and or the 57 year-old white man, both of whom have lived in a demented carny bubble no-selling reality for three quarters of a century between them, decided that Akira Tozawa, being Japanese, should play a ninja. Why? We know the answer. But why? Does he want the Tag Tag Team Titles? Is a heel now?
Was it all Ivar's dream? This was implied throughout. Maybe he's a big racist?
In terms of crafting something - a comedic short film, in this case - WWE proved, with its total inability to tell jokes beyond crude slapstick gags and callbacks so hollow they doubled the meaning of "Easter egg", that they might just "offer" up the worst television show. Then. Now. Forever.
In the end, a trash monster with a protruding tentacle frightened people in the Performance Center carpark. Did they rehire Matt Wichlinski?
See? That's a joke. It's not hard.
Star Rating: F*cking sh*t
1. Edge Vs. Randy Orton
It wasn't the Greatest Wrestling Match Ever.
But ultimately, Edge and Randy Orton had to work a match promoted as the Greatest Wrestling Match Ever and it wasn't remotely laughable, even with the hideous crowd noise. That's outrageous, really.
This was a true joy to watch unfold. A stunningly crafted epic, everything that was whispered pejoratively in the build-up as ironic euphemisms - "Two old pros working smart..." - actually materialised wonderfully across a match that built beautifully to the finish. Worked with animosity, emotion and clinically sumptuous pro wrestling - Jesus Christ, has Edge's way with a reversal been missed - the story, drawing on their respective journeys to put this over as the pinnacle, was so exceptionally told that it restored tropes to beats. There's a major disconnect between Orton's perception amongst fans and peers, but he proved himself selectively brilliant here. His body language in particular was so quietly, convincingly sinister.
But of course, the Fed sucks sh*t, and they pumped in patently fake and incredibly distracting crowd noise. You dumb f*cks couldn't get away with this sh*t on SmackDown, and now we're meant to buy arena atmospherics in a virtually empty gym?
The work was mostly faultless, though the self-conscious quality of the presentation did rub off on the performers with the use of the Pedigree/Rock Bottom trade-off.
There's something in Edge and Randy Orton working a tremendous, quintessentially 'WWE' match, proving there is still an inherent and timeless appeal somewhere in that company's core, and WWE conspiring to undermine it with the weird, dumb sh*t that has come to redefine them. It's as if they actively undermine that which can't not be objectively great. On wildly opposing ends of the spectrum, everybody outdid themselves here.
Undermine, not ruin; this should be remembered for Edge and Orton's towering achievement.
Star Rating: ★★★★¼