8 MMA Fighters Who Failed In Pro Wrestling
Not everyone can be like Matt Riddle...
With both forms sharing a history dating back to the days of catch-as-catch-can, it's no surprise that there has been a storied tradition of intersections between the worlds of professional wrestling and mixed martial arts.
In Japan, where the puroresu style comes much closer to emulating a legitimate combat sport, crossovers between wrestling and MMA have historically been extremely common. This was perhaps best exemplified when the legendary Kazushi Sakuraba is said to have remarked: "In fact, pro wrestling is strong" after winning the UFC Japan tournament with his experience as a shoot-style grappler behind him.
In more recent years fighters such as Ronda Rousey, Shayna Baszler, and Matt Riddle have proven that the air of legitimacy that surrounds a professional fighter can prove to be highly beneficial for those wishing to take their talents into the squared circle.
However, not every transition from the Octagon to the ring has proved to be a successful one. Many combat sports athletes have found out that although they are conditioned to deal with the physical nature of professional wrestling, the other, equally important, facets of the craft weren't quite as easy to get to grips with.
8. Dan Severn
One of the most well-travelled combatants in modern sporting history, Dan Severn has been kicking ass and taking names in both MMA and pro wrestling for decades, racking up more than 100 professional fights in the process and holding wins over the likes of Ken Shamrock, Oleg Taktarov, and Forrest Griffin.
Despite the fact that his legendary MMA career is perhaps the first of Severn's professions to appear on his resume, the fifth-degree blackbelt in Judo also enjoyed a successful spell in pro wrestling, becoming the only man to hold major MMA and pro wrestling titles simultaneously when he captured the NWA Heavyweight Championship in 1995.
It's worth noting that his featuring on this list is not meant to be an indictment of his skills in the ring, but while Severn's time as a pro wrestler certainly wasn't anywhere near as unsuccessful as some of his contemporaries on this list, his WWE run between 1997 and 1999 left a lot to be desired, to say the least.
Severn's amateur pedigree and rugged look would've been perfect for the territories of the 1980s but stuck out like a sore thumb when he arrived in the onset of the Attitude Era.
It is possible that Severn's run in the WWE was hampered further by him touching a nerve with comments suggesting that his fellow performers' physiques may have been, shall we say, chemically enhanced.
7. Rampage Jackson
Of all the fighters on this list, none seemed quite as destined to be a star of the squared circle as Rampage Jackson.
The former UFC Light Heavyweight Champion is one of the most charismatic fighters in the history of MMA, with his talents behind the microphone helping him land the role of B.A. Baracus in the 2010 A-Team movie. In his fighting prime Rampage also had a penchant for putting on spectacular performances in competition, including a powerbomb knockout of Ricardo Arona that Kevin Nash would've been proud of.
After first dipping his toe in the world of pro wrestling serving as a guest host of Raw in 2010 with his A-Team castmates, Rampage would sign with TNA in 2013 and later be revealed as a member of the Main Event Mafia. Jackson would make his sole in-ring appearance in September of the same year, taking part in a five on five tag-team match, before he and Tito Ortiz were removed from TNA programming to prepare for their scheduled Bellator pay-per-view bout.
Rampage would later trash the way that TNA operated as a business, likely slamming the door shut on a wrestling career that could have been so much more than it was.
6. King Mo
When Muhammed "King Mo" Lawal first stepped through the doors at Ohio Valley Wrestling, he had all the potential to be a superstar in the squared circle. Having just graduated college, Mo was rated as one of the best amateur wrestlers in the country with his size, skill, and athleticism proving too much for his contemporaries on the mat en route to becoming an NCAA Division 1 All American.
However, rather than following in the footsteps of Brock Lesnar, Mo would leave OVW after just a week, and ultimately turn down WWE's contract offer, instead opting to pursue a career in MMA.
Despite establishing himself as one of the best fighters in the world outside of the UFC, Mo still harboured aspirations of becoming a pro wrestler and signed with TNA in 2012. Unfortunately for those hoping for another Lesnar or Bobby Lashley, Lawal prioritised MMA throughout his career in the IMPACT Zone leading to him failing to fulfil his massive potential as a sports entertainer.
5. Daniel Puder
Possibly the most infamous of all the fighters to try their hand in Vince McMahon's travelling circus, Daniel Puder featured as a contestant on the 2004 Million Dollar Tough Enough and in the space of just twelve weeks managed to make himself one of the most despised people among the senior figures of the WWE locker room.
Puder's infamy stems from a shoot segment with Kurt Angle, where the Olympic champion challenged the WWE hopefuls to real amateur wrestling matches in front of the television cameras on SmackDown. When Puder got his chance, he utilised his knowledge of submission manoeuvres to lock the unsuspecting Angle in a kimura, forcing a WWE referee to quickly intervene in order to save face.
As you can imagine, trying to get the better of one of the company's most established talents did little to endear Puder to his colleagues, and while he would eventually go on to win Tough Enough, his stint in WWE would be short-lived. A final pay-per-view appearance came at the 2005 Royal Rumble where Chris Benoit, Hardcore Holly and Eddie Guerrero took turns chopping the rookie, clearly a form of reprisal for his bad attitude.
Puder would continue his pro wrestling career after his WWE release, with brief stints in both ROH and NJPW.
4. Tito Ortiz
Tito Ortiz is one of the undisputed legends of mixed martial arts. The Huntington Beach Bad Boy was one of the first fighters in the west to realise the importance of cultivating a persona to help build interest in fights, and his feud with UFC president Dana White is the closest MMA has come to replicating the rivalry between Steve Austin and Vince McMahon.
However, one thing that Ortiz has proven repeatedly throughout his career is that he's not exactly a wordsmith. Sure, he got the better of Ken Shamrock verbally, but that was likely more to do with Shamrock's frustrations over Ortiz's successes in their fights rather than any particularly stinging barbs.
With that being said, it's not surprising that Tito's forays into professional wrestling haven't exactly been unqualified successes. The former UFC Light Heavyweight Champion first appeared in TNA in 2005, but would enjoy a longer run with the company in 2013 as a member of Aces & Eights embarking on a feud with Rampage Jackson that served to promote their bout in Bellator that ultimately did not take place.
3. Tank Abbott
Though he may not have been the most polished fighter ever to step inside the Octagon, Tank Abbott made up for his technical deficiencies with an ungodly amount of power and ability to take a punch.
Abbott's rugged bar-brawler aesthetic was perfect for the way the UFC was marketing itself during the mid-'90s, and Tank proved to be one of the earliest stars of the burgeoning sport, even appearing on in the Friends episode, The One with the Ultimate Fighting Champion.
The former UFC title challenger would ultimately make his first of several retirements from fighting in 1998 after being knocked out by Pedro Rizzo, but his time in the spotlight was far from over.
Despite Abbott having zero pro wrestling experience, Vince Russo was looking to replicate the crossover success Ken Shamrock had enjoyed in the WWE, and believed that Tank's shootfighting background and unique look would legitimise him him as a potential opponent for Goldberg.
Tank's stint in WCW actually started pretty well as he embarked on a streak of KO victories, but his success would be short-lived as he became lost in the creative shuffle while continuing to pick up his over half a million dollars a year salary.
2. Frank Trigg
In his MMA career, Frank Trigg is remembered fondly by fans as a heavy handed wrestler who came up short in a pair of classic bouts with Matt Hughes with the UFC Welterweight Championship on the line. Trigg faced some of the best fighters the sport had to offer during his fourteen years as a professional before hanging up his gloves in 2011.
Trigg's career in the squared circle was decidedly less remarkable.
Brought into TNA in 2008 by Vince Russo, presumably with the theory that the former UFC stalwart's shoot fighting experience would lend credibility to his matches, Trigg was immediately aligned with Kurt Angle and inserted into his feud with AJ Styles.
At No Surrender in the same year, Trigg faced off against AJ in an "MMA" style match that has since been derided as one of the worst of the Phenomenal One's illustrious career. To be fair to Trigg, he was completely candid about the struggles in the ring, later recounting in an interview with Bleacher Report:
"I sucked. I was no good. I couldn’t work with someone else. I’m used to working against someone else.”
You can't fault the guy for his honesty.
1. Cain Velasquez
While it may be a little premature to label Cain Velasquez's brief foray into professional wrestling a failure, few would've expected the former UFC Heavyweight Champion's run in the WWE to be over after just one competitive TV outing.
After all, Velasquez is still considered one of the greatest heavyweights in the history of MMA, having pummeled Brock Lesnar to capture the UFC belt, and defended it against some of the biggest names in the sport before injuries curtailed his career.
Rather surprisingly for someone who was struggling to compete biyearly in MMA due to an accumulation of injuries, in 2018 Cain announced he would be making the switch to pro wrestling, and signed with Mexican promotion AAA the following year.
Despite still carrying the injuries that plagued his MMA career, Velasquez looked every bit the pro wrestling prospect when he made his debut as a luchador, demonstrating the athleticism that had made him an unstoppable force in the Octagon.
Velasquez would go on to sign a bumper contract with the WWE, though he would be jobbed out in one-sided fashion to old-foe Lesnar in his only TV appearance, before being released earlier this week.