8 Storylines Lucha Underground Needs To Resolve In Season 4

Murder, mayhem, & masks. Plus a few unnecessary chair shots to the head. Lucha Underground is back!

Lucha Underground Season 4 Confirmed
El Rey Network

This week Lucha Underground returns from a long hiatus. We don't know how the budgetary changes or cast shakeup will affect the show's production values or quality going forward, but what we do know is that it will continue to be balls-to-the-wall lunacy in all the best and worst ways. After all, that's pretty much been their bread and butter since day one.

It's a pretty safe bet that the major storylines and cliffhangers from the end of Season 3 will be resolved. The magic gauntlet, Dario's murder(?) and the desperate phone call to his father, Vampiro's new master, and the continued development of the Reptile and White Rabbit tribes are likely to be plot points going forward. But in the revamped Season 4, will old storylines and dead weight drop away to facilitate a fresh start?

Over the course of the last three seasons, a lot of storyline threads have been woven into the show's tapestry, and some of them are fraying badly. Long-term viewers deserve to see both progression and closure after three years of investment in the show, even as Lucha Underground reshapes and redefines itself.

And hopefully, LU will do right by the fans and resolve these storylines as Season 4 develops.

8. Sexy Star And The Spiders

Sexy Star Rosemary
AAA

*minor spoiler alert, if you care about Sexy Star storylines*

After her short run with the Lucha Underground championship, Sexy Star was tormented with spiders. Tucked in her locker, delivered to her in gift boxes... these monstrous arachnids were seemingly everywhere. After dispatching her long-time nemesis Taya at Ultima Lucha Tres, a vignette revealed that Sexy Star had not, in fact, vanquished whoever was sending her these spiders.

Although many viewers are less invested in Sexy Star as a babyface heroine after her attack on Rosemary at Triplemania XXV (along with her disastrous PR campaign that followed), it would be a waste if this storyline wasn't resolved. And given that the current Wikipedia listing of LU's roster features a character called Black Widow, it's likely this storyline will continue in Season 4.


7. Jeremiah Crane And Catrina

Jeremiah Crane Cannonball Killshot Lucha Underground
LuchaUnderground.com

Introduced in Season 3 as Ivelisse's new boyfriend, Jeremiah Crane quickly revealed his obsession with Catrina, the teleporting mystical valet of Mil Muertes. Insinuating himself back into Catrina's life however he could -- be it by battling Mil, involving himself in the quest for the magic gauntlet, or even attacking Ivelisse after her long-awaited match with Catrina -- Crane's obsession made for interesting viewing.

But perhaps the most intriguing part was when he retrieved something from the ceiling of the Temple, revealing to the audience (and Dario) that he was much older than he appeared. How far back does the connection between Crane and Catrina go? Since he doesn't have half of the amulet shared by Catrina and the Police Chief, how does he avoid looking his age? And to what lengths will the Lucha Death Machine go to remain in Catrina's presence?


6. Catrina And The Police Chief

lucha underground catrina
El Rey Network

And speaking of that mysterious amulet, one half is held by Catrina, suspending her in time. The other half is held by the Police Chief who is hellbent on bringing Dario Cueto to justice. That police storyline (finally) started moving forward in Season 3, as Cage's murder of LA City Councilman Delgado brought the gauntlet to the Chief's attention. Catrina promised to deliver it to her, but failed when King Cuerno returned at Ultima Lucha Tres and stole it for himself.

The unexpected familial connection between Catrina and the Chief made Lucha Underground's timeline even more confusing. Is the Chief also suspended in time? Why is she obsessed with bringing down Dario? And now that Cuerno has the gauntlet, will there be a reckoning between the Chief and Catrina? (Why didn't Catrina just teleport away with it when she had the chance?)


5. Cortez Castro

Matanza Rebreak Cortez Castro Arm
LuchaUnderground.com

Speaking of the cops, why exactly is undercover cop Cortez Castro still alive? Dario murdered Mr. Cisco (knowing full well that he was wearing a wire at the time and that Cortez was listening in), and then dirty cop and lollipop aficionado Joey Ryan ratted out Castro's second attempt to infiltrate the Temple as masked wrestler Veneno.

Castro would get his revenge on Joey Ryan, and even earn an Aztec medallion for it, but that doesn't explain why Dario let him live, or why he allows Castro into the Temple knowing his agenda.

One can only surmise that somehow, Cortez and Dario will end up working together to bring down Agent Winter after his attempt on Dario's life. But still, his continued access to the Temple is a huge question mark.


4. Black Lotus Vs. El Dragon Azteca Jr.

Black Lotus Vs Dragon Azteca Jr
Lucha Underground

Another major storyline surrounding Dario Cueto is the escalating war between Black Lotus and El Dragon Azteca Jr.

Black Lotus murdered the original El Dragon Azteca after Dario convinced her that Azteca was responsible for her parents' deaths. El Dragon Azteca Jr. took up Azteca's mask and mission, coming to the Temple, only to be surprised that Lotus was working as a bodyguard for Dario. Eventually, their one-on-one match was interrupted by Pentagon Jr., who broke Lotus' and Azteca Jr.'s arms.

By the time Ultima Lucha Tres arrived, Azteca Jr. was battling Matanza for the brutal assault of his mentor, Rey Misterio Jr., when Lotus suddenly intervened, attacking Azteca Jr. and helping cost him the match. She then bafflingly turned on Dario, calling him a liar over and over, before she too was dispatched by the monster Matanza.

Why did she attack Azteca Jr. if she knew Dario lied about Azteca not killing her parents? That's what's implied by Lotus calling Dario a liar, anyway, and yet, Azteca Jr. is the one that suffers.

Given that this storyline dates all the way back to Season 1, it desperately needs resolving soon.


3. The Destiny Of El Dragon Azteca Jr.

Prince Puma Dragon Azteca Jack Evans DDT
LuchaUnderground.com

El Dragon Azteca Jr.'s reason for being in the Temple has become a bit muddled since his introduction in Season 2. First, he wanted to avenge El Dragon Azteca's death. Then, Rey Misterio Jr. spoke about his destiny to bring the seven ancient Aztec tribes together to prevent something terrible from occurring. Then, he went to war with Matanza and Dario in honor of his mentor, Rey.

They've never returned to that second, and most intriguing, idea: Azteca uniting the seven tribes. How was he supposed to do that? Do we even know what tribe he represents? You'd think it would be the Reptile Tribe, given his dragon facade, but his heroic temperament seems to imply he'd be Prince Puma's stand-in for the Jaguar Tribe.

Nonetheless, given how much they talk about the tribes in the show, they should return to this idea. His rivalries with Lotus and Matanza have to end at some point, and this would provide plenty of narrative thrust for the character going forward.


2. The Aztec Tribes

drago lucha underground
Lucha Underground

When it comes to the tribes, Azteca Jr. is just the tip of the iceberg. The various Aztec tribes got a lot of airtime this season.

The Reptile Tribe not only recruited Drago, but captured the Trios Championship, only to lose it later on (costing the popular Luchasaurus his head). The Rabbit Tribe ended up in the Gift of the Gods match and mistook Mascarita Sagrada for their white rabbit savior.

But at no point did we understand why it's important that we know about any of these tribes. Does anyone else represent Puma's Jaguar Tribe, since Puma is now gone? Are the Moths an actual tribe, or just an invention of the demented Marty and Mariposa?

At some point, the Tribes need to represent more than wrestling factions. They should have backstories, goals, and motivations. Otherwise, it's just a lot of wasted ranting from Vampiro on commentary.


1. The Gods

Matanza Cueto Champion Lucha Underground
Lucha Underground

Dario (and Vampiro) spend A LOT of time talking about the Gods. Dario's limo-riding boss appears to be one, while Matanza is supposedly inhabited by another. Vampiro's new master might be a third one. After several resurrections, it's possible Mil Muertes is a fourth, a god of death.

We've seen gifts from them like Cage's gauntlet. Heck, there's even a title in the promotion named The Gift of the Gods Championship, tied somehow into the seven ancient Aztec tribes.

But for all this talk about the Gods and their powers and the war that's coming, they don't seem to do a whole lot. It's like the Undertaker's Higher Power was invoked and referenced for three years instead of a few weeks, and still no Vince McMahon reveal.

While that's a good example of what not to do, it also represents what could happen if LU waits too long for the Gods to make their impact; instead of making a splash, they could stumble in like the Shockmaster and leave the audience laughing instead of enthralled.


Contributor

Author, puzzle guy, and lifelong consumer of pop culture. I'm a nerd for wrestling, Star Wars, literature, trivia, and all sorts of other things. Feel free to mock and/or praise me and my scribblings at @glennmandirect on Twitter.