8 Things Lucha Underground Did Better Than WWE

The Temple has closed for the time being - here's hoping WWE was taking notes.

Pentagon Jr Lucha Underground
El Rey Network

Lucha Underground is dead, long live Lucha Underground.

So the eulogies may be somewhat premature, but Lucha Underground as we know and love it is gone. The final episode of the show was an absolute barn-burner, with Prince Puma becoming the first two-time Lucha Underground Champion in history before having the title stolen away from him Pentagon Dark. The show ended with Dario Cueto seemingly murdered.

The three seasons of Lucha Underground were utterly unlike anything else the professional wrestling world has seen before. The show was a drama, a grindhouse flick shot in a outer-LA warehouse with death, crime and intrigue a plenty. It was a pro wrestling show at heart though, and the in-ring action was always the main attraction.

Years from now, how will Lucha Underground be remembered? I wager that the positives will outweigh the negatives, and it will become increasingly clear that Lucha Underground did many things far better than WWE. Comparing the two is difficult, but the biggest pro wrestling promotion on the planet would be wise to cast a keen eye at the tapes of The Temple.


8. Booking Babyfaces

The Mack Lucha Underground
El Rey Network

This isn’t to say that Lucha Underground was perfect when it came to its portrayal of heels and babyfaces. After all, the most popular character from the entire show was a skeleton ninja who spent the first season breaking arms for fun, and also beat the ever-loving tar out of women throughout the series. There were missteps, without doubt.

But when compared to modern day WWE, Lucha Underground was light years ahead when it came to booking babyface characters. Modern day WWE has a huge dearth of major good guys, as the ‘shades of grey’ mentality has overtaken the desire for a huge superstar babyface. The biggest promotion on the planet also sabotages its own babyfaces for fear of someone outgrowing the company.

In an underground fighting league that was inherently bad, a number of pure individuals managed to get over despite performing in front of a ‘bad is cool’ sort of crowd. The Mack, Son of Havoc, and Sexy Star all experienced success whilst fighting the good fight on the show. Lucha Underground consistently showed that it was able to make pure babyface stars.


7. Consequences And Continuity

King Cuerno Lucha Underground
Lucha Underground

When something major happened in Lucha Underground, you knew full well that the following episode wouldn’t whitewash it. Mil Muertes, the unbeatable dominant force that ploughed a path of destruction through season one, had his arm broken by Pentagon Jr. at the beginning of season two. Did he no-sell the injury the next week? Absolutely not. Instead, we were treated to the sight of the monstrous Lucha Underground Champion sat on his throne in The Temple, complete with his arm in a sling.

King Cuerno lost a Death Match to Muertes at Ultima Lucha Dos, and he wasn’t seen for an entire season. When wrestlers lost it mattered, just like wins matter. There was continuity in Lucha Underground, that most basic necessity for any episodic television show. In WWE, weeks pass by and no one seems truly affected by anything that is happening on the weekly television show.

Wrestling fans frequently lament the lack of consequences in WWE, the lack of continuity. When the biggest wrestling promotion on the planet references something in its past, fans throw up their arms to congratulate Vince McMahon and co. This shouldn’t be a celebratory thing - this should be the norm.


6. Passionate Announcing

Matt Striker Vampiro Lucha
El Rey Network

Lucha Underground received plenty of criticism throughout its three seasons, and the announce team bore the brunt of it. Matt Striker and Vampiro were as hit and miss as a commentary duo could possibly be, and most of that was because of the former. Striker could be every bit as fantastic as he could be embarrassing.

Whether they were making frustrating calls or telling the story perfectly, the one thing you can’t accuse Striker and Vampiro of lacking is passion. The two were 100% into what was happening on the show at all times. The emotion of the stories always came through in their announcing - both men sounded like genuine fans of the product.

Compare that to the robotic performances WWE fans from Michael Cole week after week, or the confused dementia of Booker T. WWE’s announcers sound like they have been previously programmed to spout buzzwords and catchphrases, as opposed to fans of the product they get to describe every week.


5. Spectacle

Angelico Dive
Lucha Underground

When it was confirmed that Shane McMahon was to do battle against Kevin Owens inside Hell in a Cell, certain sections of the WWE Universe rolled their eyes. It was inevitable that Shane-O Mac was going to jump or fall from the top of the cell. WWE thought it was creating a moment, but moments cannot be forced.

The same goes with the two separate murders of Braun Strowman in 2017. WWE has thrown away any goodwill it may have had, and these high drama bouts of movie-style entertainment come across as cheesy and lame. WWE likes to believe it is creating spectacles, but the reality is it is embarrassing itself.

Compare this with the major jaw-dropping spots from the three seasons of Lucha Underground. Granted, it is naive to expect WWE to allow something as violent as Killshot and Dante Fox’s match that was accurately billed as a Hell of War match, but that isn’t the point. Some of Lucha Underground’s most memorable spots were based on the athleticism of its performers, like Angelico’s daredevil leaps from the top of Dario’s office.

Lucha Underground frequently created moments that made the believers in the temple, wrestling fans who had seen everything before, jump out of their seats and put their hands to their mouths. Lucha Undeground created a spectacle, by accentuating the strengths of its performers and giving them the freedom to do what they do best - put on a show.


4. Using The Entire Roster

Marty The Moth Martinez
Lucha Underground

Lucha Underground had a star-filled roster, a collection of talent that top to bottom was as good as any other in the world. Despite only having an hour of television to play with, the promotion created stories and characters for almost all of the performers in the show. This was clear at Ultima Lucha Tres; 34 performers in the four part extravaganza, and all 34 were given moments to shine. Nobody was forgotten.

WWE is the greatest example of too many cooks spoiling a broth. The biggest professional wrestling promotion on the planet produces at least eight hours of original in-ring content every single week, a mass of shows that are constructed by a huge team of writers. These writers have the most talented roster in company history to work with.

Despite this, WWE only seems capable of focusing on a small number of top stars at any time. There is absolutely no excuse - WWE should be able to create a roster of well-rounded characters who are always active and are involved on a weekly basis. Lucha Underground utilised its entire roster to create a show from top to bottom, whilst WWE gets lost somewhere in the upper side of the middle.


3. Gimmick Matches

El Rey Network

WWE’s transition into a PG product has neutered the gimmick matches that the company now builds many pay-per-views around. It isn’t all about blood either - the promotion’s neurotic fear that kids will copy the moves has created an entirely watered down product. Hell in a Cell, Elimination Chamber and the rest are now irrelevant because of this.

Lucha Underground managed to breathe new life into previously tired gimmick matches. The promotion took the casket match and made it genuinely must-see. It wouldn’t be a stretch to say that the overwhelming majority of casket matches in history have been forgettable, as The Undertaker vs. Token Huge Heel was always a bore. Lucha Underground took this tired trope and created incredible drama through it.

Mil Muertes vs. Fenix was the first match of this type on the show, and it stands up as one of the five best matches in the entire history of Lucha Underground. The promotion did the same for ladder matches, battle royals and general weapons-based brawls, taking the plunder dial and turning it up to 11.


2. Authority Figures

Dario Cueto
El Rey Network

The authority figure trope is an extremely tired one in modern professional wrestling. Stone Cold Steve Austin’s weekly battle to deal with an evil boss created the greatest feud in pro wrestling history, but that was 20 years ago. No one wants to see the boss as the biggest heel on the roster anymore. There is more than enough in-ring talent for heel GMs to be a thing of the past.

Dario Cueto was no ordinary authority figure however. Make no mistake about it, El Jefe ran the show, but his decisions were always made with the show in mind. Dario Cueto didn’t put obstacles in front of his wrestlers to make himself look better - he did it to make money and because of an almost insatiable blood lust.

Dario Cueto could well be the greatest authority figure in professional wrestling history. Look at it this way - if Lucha Underground was to return for a season four, the conveyor belt of talent that is the independent scene means there will be no shortage of performers to fill the spots left behind by the stars of the three seasons. Dario Cueto is irreplaceable - without him there can’t be a Lucha Underground.

It helps that the Cueto character was portrayed by a classically trained actor. Luis Fernandez-Gil wasn’t the owner of the promotion or an ageing wrestling looking to stay relevant. He was an actor hired to play a part, and he played it to a tee.


1. Wrestling As An Art Form

johnny mundo prince puma
WWE.com

Wrestling is art, and do not forget that. On the surface it is utterly ridiculous, but underneath the pageantry and preposterousness lies a carefully constructed narrative and an understanding of what it takes to move people. Pro wrestling is emotional, intense, affecting and far more real than it has any right to be.

In many ways, WWE has lost sight of this. When Vince McMahon’s promotion describes itself as sports entertainment, it isn’t just spouting a buzzword. WWE is no longer a professional wrestling company, and it hasn’t been for a long time. The heart of wrestling is what attracts most fans to it, but the company is following a different line.

Wrestling is where story meets athleticism, where the combination of conflict, combat, and creativity blend to create something memorable and magical. Lucha Underground was the first major promotion in a long time to portray wrestling as a true art form in this respect.

When Vampiro revealed himself as Pentagon Jr.’s master during Ultima Lucha, it didn’t just resonate because he’d just been chokeslammed through fire. It was the perfect storm of everything that makes professional wrestling beautiful.

Lucha Underground wasn’t perfect, far from it. A lot of bad things happened in The Temple, with Pentagon’s distasteful one-sided destruction of three women at the top of that list. But when Lucha Underground was great it was really great, the various things that make professional wrestling special amalgamating to produce a show that will be missed. Now, someone needs to make a British version of it, pronto…


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.