8 Times WWE's Triple H Was A DISASTER-TIER Booker

The absolute WORST of Triple H's WWE booking.

WWE Saturday Night's Main Event John Cena Triple H
WWE

After the disastrous final few years of Vince McMahon's outdated booking found WWE out of touch with their audience and the average pro wrestling fan, Paul Levesque taking over as the head of creative saw the company's fortunes turn around massively. Well, at least in the short term. Since that initial honeymoon period, people have felt more critical of Triple H, and his booking has been shown to have some major failings.

As a community with wildly differing tastes and desires, it is an unenviable job to keep the majority of wrestling fans happy in the modern age. Even bearing that in mind, though, there have been some bizarre and disappointing moments in WWE in recent times that have had fans sharpening their knives for Hunter and his questionable decision-making.

After coming off the back of a particularly divisive 2025, the following booking decisions are tough to defend, even for the most ardent fans of WWE and Levesque. Triple H has the pencil in the world's biggest wrestling promotion, and there can be no hiding place when things go badly, with these being his worst booking decisions to date.

8. Bringing Back Brock Lesnar

WWE Wrestlepalooza 2025 Brock Lesnar John Cena
WWE

Brock Lesnar's return at SummerSlam 2025 was one of the most shocking moments of the year. It takes a lot to unite wrestling's polarized global fanbase, but this decision was met with universal disapproval. Not only is Lesnar named multiple times in Janel Grant's ongoing lawsuit against Vince McMahon and WWE, but it's also a fact that Brock's work in WWE has been lacking for what seems like an eternity.

Formerly one of the biggest box office draws in wrestling, Brock Lesnar hasn't had a great feud or match in years. The decision to bring him back was bad, but Triple H's creative for Brock in 2025 did enormous further harm to his already wavering reputation. Lesnar destroyed John Cena at WrestlePalooza, presumably to have a more sports-based superstar looking strong on the company's first ESPN broadcast.

This only succeeded in pissing off WWE's fanbase. If the idea is to have Lesnar look strong to elevate up-and-coming talent in 2026, defeating an aging John Cena did not achieve that. It's hard to imagine anything Brock Lesnar-related pleasing WWE fans moving forward, and this whole debacle feels misguided at best, and legitimately damages the idea that this is a new WWE in the post-Vince McMahon era, at worst.


7. John Cena's Retirement Run

WWE Saturday Night's Main Event John Cena Triple H
WWE

The Rock justifiably deserves the majority of people's disdain for his role in derailing the final year of John Cena's WWE career. Putting that to one side, the creative for every part of Cena's final run felt like it was being booked at the last minute. For a man being lauded by the company as the GOAT, it was nowhere near the standard Triple H's creative team had set themselves during a superb 2024.

Things started well enough. Cena's last dance in the Royal Rumble ended in noble failure, but then came his heel run. The heel turn at Elimination Chamber was executed superbly, and even the first few promos Cena cut as a heel made sense. However, everything that came from WrestleMania 41 onwards was not befitting of John Cena's legacy.

Cena bounced from opponent to opponent as a directionless and unconvincing heel after The Rock's no-show at 'Mania 42, and his face turn on the eve of SummerSlam felt more like an apology for these wasted months rather than a moment for the ages. With only limited dates left on his schedule, each feud felt like cramming something in, as opposed to telling a story that will last the test of time. His final moment tapping out to Gunther has as many supporters as it does detractors, but our final year of John Cena was a total mess from a creative standpoint, whichever way you look at it.


6. Bayley

Bayley 2025
WWE

The booking of the women's division has been one of the more refreshing things during these early years of Triple H's creative. It has taken a while to get there, but as we enter 2026, the motivations of the women's roster are now largely the same as the men's. Their feuds revolve around the quest for glory and titles, and not fighting over the affections of men or superficial reasons.

While most women can be happy with their creative in Triple H's years, Bayley has been noticeably left out of the shuffle. Her volatile union with Lyra Valkyria feels forced and unnatural, and the vignettes that had Bayley hearing conflicting voices in her head were a muddled mess that were dropped as fast as they were created.

Bayley is a performer with a rich history who has expressed frustration at not being given enough to do in the recent past. She is being wasted in a creative situation that has done nothing for her in the last year. This is a future Hall of Famer who was as big a part of elevating WWE's women's division as any of the performers she rose through the ranks with, and it's to the detriment of the women's roster that she is being wasted so egregiously. Even if Bayley's World Championship days are behind her, she still has the ability to tell great stories in whatever feud she's part of. 


5. The Rock's 2025

WWE Raw The Rock
WWE

We can have a massive amount of sympathy with Triple H on this one. In 2024, Hunter's boss decided he would supersede a year's worth of storytelling between Cody Rhodes and The Bloodline to put himself in the main event of WrestleMania 40. It was a colossal use of stroke and ego that fans revolted against immediately. Triple H was able to correct the course of this storytelling to create one of the best endings in WrestleMania history and give The Rock a new lease of life as the deplorable Final Boss.

All of this good work was flushed down the toilet on the January 6th, 2025 debut of Raw on Netflix. The Rock came out to give a smug and self-serving address in which his entire Final Boss persona was dropped for a schmoozing, political address about WWE joining the Netflix family. What should have been a quote on a press release was allowed to play out on-screen to the dismay of everyone, and was followed up by an equally loathsome appearance at NXT's New Year's Evil.

These creative misfires were then compounded by The Rock's no-show at WrestleMania 41. We will never know why Triple H and The Rock couldn't come to terms on how to pay off Dwayne's involvement in John Cena's heel turn, but ignoring it entirely was rotten. It was a reputation-damaging mess for The Rock (largely of his own doing), who followed up his great 2024 with a disastrous 2025. 


4. The Women's United States Championship

Giulia WWE Women's United States Title
WWE.com

The public outcry for women's midcard titles was finally heard during Triple H's era. The level of talent on the WWE women's roster calls for more than just one singles title for each brand, and the Intercontinental Championship is now highly coveted thanks to the superb work of Becky Lynch (and it's not just us saying that, etc.).

However, the United States Championship has been a far more underwhelming proposition. Chelsea Green was a popular first winner of the title, and her run with the belt was satisfying and fun, as Chelsea really ran with the USA theme, and it felt as though the championship would be able to kick on from there. What has happened since, though, has been a lack of emphasis on the belt and a considerable drop in the prestige of that title.

Winners are seemingly picked at random, with feuds not being fully developed around the championship. Green and Michin had a great thing going during that first run, but Zelena Vega and Giulia have suffered from winning the belt under shock circumstances and having nothing of substance to build upon. It's early days for the Women's United States Championship, but it is in urgent need of more care and attention from Triple H and his booking team.


3. Jey Uso's Main Event Run

Jey Uso World Heavyweight Champion
WWE

It feels very IWC to wade into Jey Uso, but it's understandable as to why Triple H went so big on Jey in 2025. He had incredible moments all the way through The Bloodline's best years, and he and Bron Breakker enjoyed a great feud over the Intercontinental Championship in 2024. There's a vocal part of wrestling's fandom that opposed Jey winning last year's men's Royal Rumble, but in terms of merch sales, audience reaction, and emotional investment from fans, Jey had earned his shot at the main event scene.

Unfortunately, it quickly became apparent that this push wasn't working, and it felt like Jey heard those loud dissenting voices too loudly, as his confidence was shot on the road to WrestleMania 41. There was a nervousness in his promos and matches that hadn't previously existed, and his World Heavyweight Championship victory over Gunther at Mania' 41 felt like persisting with a plan, instead of making the right call.

Uso's title reign lasted just two months before returning the championship to Gunther on the June 9th episode of Monday Night Raw. As the year ran on, Jey was put back into tag matches for major PLEs at Money in the Bank, SummerSlam, and Wrestlepalooza, and ended the year back reuniting The Usos with his brother. Through a mix of uninteresting stories and underwhelming performances, Jey Uso is in a much worse position now than he was before his failed main event push. 


2. The Wyatt Sicks

The Wyatt Sicks
WWE.com

The Wyatt Sicks's debut felt like a shocking attack on WWE itself. Taking out the entire 'Gorilla Position' in disturbing fashion after weeks of cryptic vignettes and clues, they were a hotly anticipated commodity with a lot of goodwill behind them. What has since transpired is a hokey and uninspiring act that has decimated a SmackDown tag division that was previously on a roll.

The Wyatt Sicks have done nothing to make themselves compelling to WWE's audience. The characters are dull, their matches have little investment from fans, and their booking has never felt like it's had much thought put into it. What reason have people had to care about Uncle Howdy? What do his minions have to say for themselves? Where is the creativity involved around this group?

Worst of all, Motor City Machine Guns, Street Profits, DIY, Pretty Deadly, and The Bloodline had WWE's blue brand tag division in great shape. That has been completely derailed since The Wyatt Sicks have held the WWE Tag Team Championships, with next to no effort being put into this group or their title reign. After such a big build-up to their arrival, Triple H and his creative team have done literally nothing to warrant The Wyatt Sicks having a championship reign that has had no heat or momentum whatsoever.


1. Flip-Flopping R-Truth

WWE Raw R-Truth Ron Killings
WWE

R-Truth being let go by WWE is one of the biggest surprise moments in recent years. Beloved by all and on the comedic run of a lifetime as a great addition to The Judgement Day and then successfully reviving Awesome Truth with The Miz, Truth's firing was a massive misjudgment of his popularity with fans by TKO. The subsequent outrage meant they had to quickly walk that decision back, and he was rehired within weeks.

What has since followed has been a creative disaster. R-Truth returned and delivered an impassioned and intimidating promo, cutting his dreads off on the announcer's desk, and announcing to the world that he was back as Ron Killings. This felt fresh and was set to give him a new lease of life as a menacing heel, but shortly after, WWE returned him to his goofy R-Truth persona because he decided he loved John Cena. Sure.

This creative flip-flopping killed over a year's worth of momentum and reduced a popular midcard talent to something far less relevant. R-Truth's legacy and popularity with fans are set in stone forever, but the muddled mess of his booking has deflated his worth in a big way. 


Contributor

Terry Bezer hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.