8 Title Reigns WWE Booked In The WORST Way Possible
Those WWE title reigns that were booked horrendously.
A title reign in WWE, or any wrestling company, is supposed to be a symbol of excellence. Usually earned by talent who've shown greatness and a connection with the audience, it is recognition that a superstar is a cornerstone of the promotion on which things should be built around presently or in the future. Only, this isn't always the case.
Occasionally, poor booking from WWE creative can turn a blessing into a curse when it comes to putting a championship on a talent. Something that should take a performer to the next level actually halts their momentum due to terrible match-making or stale storylines. What should be the coronation of their years of hard work quickly turns into a nightmare, as a talent is given terrible creative that does nothing to enhance them or the belt they wear around their waist.
Whether it's that the office doesn't believe in the performer they've made champion or, in some cases, that champion doesn't even get the opportunity to properly defend their title, the following are just a handful of WWE title reigns that sank without a trace due to awful booking.
8. Kofi Kingston - WWE Champion (2019)
No matter how much revisionist history some people try to bring to WWE, the last decade of watching WWE under Vince McMahon's creative decision-making was miserable. Being swerved and goaded by his insane booking is precisely why Kofi Kingston's march towards winning the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 35 was so enjoyable. Because genuine, fan-led, feel-good stories and bona fide WrestleMania Moments like the ones fans got to enjoy during the megalomaniacal billionaire's pomp had become so thin on the ground.
As Xavier Woods and Big E celebrated Kofi's victory over Daniel Bryan in the ring, with tears in their eyes, Kingston winning the biggest prize in WWE, it actually felt like the dawn of something special. It was a zeitgeist-defining moment for both fans and performers that felt like a changing of the guard. We should have all known better, as Kingston was given an infuriating title run that ended in the most galling way possible.
A litany of terrible booking decisions plagued Kofi Kingston during his title reign, including an inconclusive double count-out at SummerSlam with Randy Orton and having to defend his title against Dolph Ziggler four times in five weeks. This paled in comparison to Brock Lesnar squashing Kofi in 7 seconds to win the WWE Title on the season premiere episode of SmackDown on October 4th, 2019, in what remains one of the most enraging title changes in WWE history.
7. Rey Mysterio - World Heavyweight Champion (2006)
Rey Mysterio is one of the most respected and well-loved pro wrestlers of all time. After years of being impressive against literally anyone he shared a ring with, 2006 was a banner year for Rey. The sight of him flipping Randy Orton over the top rope to win that year's Royal Rumble is a classic moment in one of the most positively received Rumble wins in memory.
With fans still reeling from the death of Eddie Guerrero months earlier, Rey would go on to win a triple threat against Kurt Angle and Randy Orton at WrestleMania 22 for the World Heavyweight Championship in an emotional moment that unified fans everywhere. What followed was the worst kind of cliched booking imaginable, though.
It will have come to your attention that Rey Mysterio is quite short for a WWE superstar, and Vince McMahon's WWE was largely known for being the land of the giants. As such, Mysterio was stereotypically booked as a short man overcoming the odds in feuds with JBL and Mark Henry. This largely involved Rey being lawndarted and slammed around, only to pull out victories that made him, as champion, feel like the underdog time and time again. This lasted for just under four months before Mysterio dropped the title to King Booker at The Great American Bash.
6. Finn Balor & JD McDonagh - World Tag Team Champions (2024)
Finn Balor and JD McDonagh formed a great partnership to help continue The Judgment Day's reign of relevance. The Irishmen earned their respect over time, with McDonagh in particular gaining recognition for his resolute toughness in recent years. You would think that the pair's 175-day WWE Tag Team Championship reign would have a great deal to do with this outpouring of acclaim, but a closer look reveals that is not the case.
In a title run that lasted over half a year, the pair defended their titles twice. It is a scandalous set of circumstances and makes a mockery of WWE's tag team division. That this reign is Finn Balor's longest run with a championship in the decade he has spent on the main roster should be a source of embarrassment for how the legendary showman has been treated in those years.
After the Judgment Day duo won the belts from Awesome Truth on the 24th June, 2024 episode of Monday Night Raw, the belts were not defended for nearly three months. It then took a further two months for a second defence of the titles, before the pair dropped the gold to The War Raiders in mid-December. Worst of all, the World Tag Team Championships were essentially reduced to being nothing more than a prop to make The Judgment Day look strong for half a calendar year.
5. Nikki A.S.H. - Raw Women's Champion (2021)
Professional wrestling is occasionally a very daft place, and Nikki Cross's run as Nikki A.S.H. is the kind of character that curled the toes of fans everywhere. While The Hurricane was a figure of fun, never really threatening anybody and providing comic relief during the latter days of the Attitude Era and into Ruthless Aggression, the bumbling superhero antics of Nikki A.S.H made it to the top of the women's division in 2021.
In a Money in the Bank Ladder Match featuring Asuka, Alexa Bliss, Liv Morgan, Naomi, Natalya, Tamini, and Zelina Vega, it was Nikki A.S.H. who walked away with the briefcase in a booking decision that baffled fans everywhere. It took just 24 hours before Nikki cashed in her contract, defeating Charlotte Flair for the Raw Women's Championship in 13 seconds after Flair had gone through two gruelling title defences against Rhea Ripley in that short timeframe.
Nikki's title reign lasted 33 days, during which she managed to lose to both Charlotte and Ripley in non-title matches before dropping the championship to Flair in a triple threat at SummerSlam 2021 that also featured Rhea. The Scot's title run made literally no sense, and that only served to take the Money in the Bank briefcase out of play for the women's division for the year for no reason whatsoever.
4. Seth Rollins - Universal Champion (2019)
Seth Rollins had a tough job to stand out from the beginning of his WWE Universal Championship run at WrestleMania 35. Dethroning Brock Lesnar in one of The Beast's customary short matches happened on the same night that KofiMania ran wild at MetLife Stadium in New Jersey, and so Rollins began his babyface title run in the shadow of someone else. It personified his upcoming championship reign, in which he never really had a chance to be viewed as the company's top guy.
This had less to do with Seth's unquestionable talent, and owed more to the crazy booking he suffered while holding the Universal Title in 2019. For example, five of his first six weeks as Universal Champion had him involved in tag team matches, and things would only get more bonkers from there.
Rollins was then thrown into a feud with Baron Corbin and Lacey Evans that never felt main event-worthy. Becky Lynch was put into this rivalry for yet more tag-team matches, which then culminated in Brock Lesnar winning back the Universal Title by cashing in his Money in the Bank briefcase at the end of Rollins & Lynch vs. Corbin & Evans at that year's Extreme Rules PLE.
To this day, this remains the least satisfying run with a World Championship that Seth Rollins has had.
3. Duane Gill - Light Heavyweight Champion (1998 - 2000)
Most wrestlers who hold their championship for an elongated stretch of time are celebrated to the heavens by WWE. Think of Roman Reigns's reign of terror with the WWE Championship, or CM Punk's 434-day stint at the top of the mountain. One name that won't be trumpeted for their 448-day run with the WWE Light Heavyweight Championship is Duane Gill, the man known to most of the wrestling world as Gillberg.
During the November 23rd, 1998 episode of Raw, Christian was enjoying his 30th day with the Light Heavyweight Championship. Accompanied by The Brood, what was supposed to be a routine title defence against Duane Gill quickly turned into a nightmare for Christian. Too Cold Scorpio hit the ring to frog splash the future Captain Charisma with the referee distracted, before pulling Gill on top of the champion for the title change.
Gill only defended the belt three times during his lengthy reign, as the Light Heavyweight Championship was essentially forgotten about altogether. Duane had a short run as the parody character Gillberg before eventually dropping the gold to red-haired high-flyer Essa Rios. Gill didn't return to a WWE ring for seven years, next appearing in Raw's 15th Anniversary Battle Royal as, you guessed it, Gillberg.
2. Jinder Mahal - WWE Champion (2017)
Jinder Mahal had one of the most unexpected WWE Championship reigns of all time.
Usually, the ascent to a WWE Title win has a slow build or at least some signs that bigger things are on the horizon for a superstar, but Jinder hadn't even won a midcard title before being slingshotted to the top of WWE at Backlash 2017.
On the WrestleMania 33 kick-off show, Jinder was a faceless entrant in the Andre the Giant Battle Royal that was won by Mojo Rawley. He followed this up with losses to Finn Balor, Sami Zayn, and Rawley in consecutive TV appearances, before inexplicably winning a Six-Pack Challenge to become #1 contender for Randy Orton's WWE Championship at Backlash.
Mahal would unbelievably beat 'The Viper' before holding that title for nearly six months. Formulaic interferences from The Singh Brothers would see Jinder get the better of Shinsuke Nakamura and Orton in maddening fashion. This whole farce was cynically put in place as WWE moved into the lucrative Indian market, with Jinder Mahal being on the receiving end of merciless fan discontent. His run as WWE Champion was eventually ended by AJ Styles during a November 2017 edition of SmackDown, but Jinder's entire run made a mockery of the biggest prize in the company.
1. John Cena - Intercontinental Championship (2025)
John Cena's final year will be discussed among fans for the rest of time. After shocking the world by announcing at Money in the Bank 2024 that he'd be embarking on a farewell tour the following year, speculation ran rampant about what would happen in John's final year. Most people spoke up about the possibility of him winning a record-breaking 17th World Championship, but few would have expected him to spend any time worrying about the Intercontinental Title.
After years of discussion about whether or not the IC Title means as much as it once did, Gunther writing his name into the record books as the longest-reigning Intercontinental Champion of all time brought meaning back to the belt across 2023 and into 2024. Bron Breakker and Jey Uso had a memorable feud for the belt in 2024, as that prize was once again being used to bring prestige to the next generation of WWE main eventers.
Dominik Mysterio winning the Intercontinental Title was one of the few highlights of WrestleMania 41 for that exact reason. Dirty Dom's feuds with Penta and AJ Styles established him as a solid IC Champion, until John Cena's retirement tour brought Mysterio's reign to an end. Big Match John's three-week Intercontinental Championship run made no sense outside of adding 'Grand Slam Champion' to the icon's resumé. Worst of all, after years of hard work to restore its prestige, it made the Intercontinental Title feel like a meaningless trinket once again.