8 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Dynamite (24 Aug)

Jon Moxley and CM Punk unify the AEW World Title, Ricky Starks spits fire, trios match pops.

Jon Moxley
AEW

Where to start with All Elite Wrestling at the moment?

The promotion has remained near the top of the professional wrestling news cycle despite WWE's recent upturn under Triple H's creative lead, albeit for reasons most would view as far from positive. Between talk of CM Punk going into business for himself on last week's Dynamite, the now-former AEW World Champion's beef with 'Hangman' Adam Page, bad blood in the women's division, rumours of contract tampering, and other situations, recent reporting paints a chaotic backstage picture in Jacksonville. AEW is quickly cultivating a wild, unruly reputation in line with wrestling history. This is how the sport has always been.

And it's how last night's Dynamite was as well.

This show was pure chaos. A wild, white-knuckle ride from start to finish, it hit the airwaves at some close to full gear and didn't relent until the clock struck 10 PM on the east coast. By the end, AEW had delivered one of its most eventful television shows ever.

It'll be debated ad nauseam, too, particularly for what happened when Jon Moxley and CM Punk unified the AEW World Championship. We'll open that can of worms later.

Let's light the fuse...


Downs...

1. Father & Gunn

Billy Gunn Colten Gunn
AEW

The most artificial feud in AEW continued last night, with Colten Gunn felling father Billy one week after Gunn Club's undercooked implosion, when Colten and Austin turned on the man who'd raised them in the blink of an eye.

That moment suffered not only as it was the product of an insubstantial build, but because Billy didn't care. His own flesh and blood had stuck a knife between his shoulder blades and he had moved on to scissoring Anthony Bowens within seconds. Those same issues bled into last night's match. How is anyone supposed to buy into a bout stretched so far beyond the realm of believability?

It was a basic contest not helped by Billy's increasing in-ring limitations and Colten's greenness (understandable, given the limitations). It closed on Colten low-blowing his dad after an Austin/Stokely Hathaway-assisted distraction, then hitting the Colt .45 for the win. Afterwards, Swerve in our Glory saved The Acclaimed (who rapped Billy to the ring) from a further beatdown.


Ups...

8. What An Upgrade

Motor City Machine guns
AEW

Sonjay Dutt grabbed a microphone after Dax Harwood vs. Jay Lethal, swerving an established All Out match. Rather than facing Dutt, Lethal, and the green Satnam Singh at the pay-per-view, FTR and Wardlow will fight Jay and the debuting Motor City Machine Guns on 4 September.

That this angle would have been more satisfying had Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin appeared in person is a valid argument. Nonetheless, this is a considerable upgrade. Singh, as fun as he has been in fleeting outings so far, has a long way to go, while Dutt is more effective in his over-the-top managerial role than between the ropes these days. On top of this, Motor City Machine Guns vs. FTR is a sought-after dream match - one that can finally happen in the aftermath of this.


7. Solving An Unfortunate Problem

Thunder Rosa Tony Schiavone
AEW

Thunder Rosa's injury isn't a work. The AEW Women's World Champion is legitimately hurt, preventing her from defending her belt, as revealed in an emotional backstage promo with Tony Schiavone. Best wishes to her as she recovers from whatever ails her.

Tony Khan's divisive solution was to announce a four-way match for an interim championship. Britt Baker, Hikaru Shida, Jamie Hayter, and Toni Storm will contest this at All Out. While such temporary belts will never be unanimously popular, the Jon Moxley/CM Punk situation and now this suggests that it will be a go-to response from Khan, whether well-received or not.

Personnel-wise, while rankings-related questions are valid (Athena and Anna Jay are both positioned higher than Hayter and Shida at the moment), AEW could scarcely have picked more appropriate wrestlers from a kayfabe perspective. Three of the combatants are involved in Rosa's current storyline and the other is the most decorated Women's Champion in company history.

Much of this unrivalled around Britt Baker vs. KiLynn King, which was a good television match with a great face/heel dynamic. Baker entered a strong heel performance opposite hometown hero King, whose support levels were brought up as a result. Their contest concluded with an inevitable Britt victory via Lockjaw. Afterwards, a glib Baker promo was cut off by Storm and Shida, who ran the heels off.


6. This Awful Man

Christian Cage
AEW

You could be forgiven for struggling to connect with Christian Cage's promo, given that it aired immediately after the shock and awe of Jon Moxley vs. CM Punk, but its content and delivery were on point despite the burnt-out viewership.

Christian Cage, the biggest sack of kayfabe trash in All Elite Wrestling, tried to paint himself as the good guy. He claimed he was extending an olive branch to Jungle Boy before last week's attack and while he admitted saying some personal things about his former ally, Cage tried to spin it as tough love. Every word that came out of his mouth was designed to paint him in a positive light despite overwhelming evidence that he is Just The Worst. It is fantastic, villainous content, proving that there are legs to this character beyond the low-hanging fruit insults, which were effective themselves.

Cage accepted Jungle Boy's All Out challenge. The match is on. Watch Christian come down to the ring with his arm still in a sling then whine about JB going after an injured man, before springing his latest despicable, hypocritical move.


5. House Of Dragons

Chris Jericho Bryan Danielson
AEW

Dynamite, in a very un-Dynamite move, opened with a multi-person in-ring promo segment last night. That AEW hasn't run such things into the ground over the course of several years makes such things tenable here, particularly when the quality is high and the segment has a purpose.

Which was the case here.

Chris Jericho wanted Daniel Garcia to apologise for putting his hands on him last week, which came when Garcia responded positively to Bryan Danielson's show of respect after their main event. A wrestler vs. sports entertainer narrative unfolded. Garcia told his stablemate that the issue's root was Jericho ruining a moment he'd been dreaming of his entire life, having just shared the ring with his childhood hero, while Chris grew increasingly agitated not only at his protege, but also the "you're a wrestler" chants coming from the crowd.

Garcia wouldn't apologise for what happened. When he tried to turn away, Jericho grabbed out at him. Cue: 'Red Death' shoving his mentor to the floor.

This was all to book Jericho vs. Danielson for All Out. Bryan attacked Jericho's false claims at being the last survivor of the Hart Dungeon ahead of 'Lionheart' vs. the 'American Dragon', with Garcia's loyalty still very much in question.

It's easy for segments like this to devolve into melodrama, though this didn't happen last night. Each wrestler played their role well, including Garcia, who was in his biggest talking spot to date. A young wrestler conned into believing he was a sports entertainer, his


4. Rasslin'

Jay Lethal Dax Harwood
AEW

The purest wrestling match on Dynamite was Dax Harwood vs. Jay Lethal, which ended up being a lot of fun.

As tight and clinical as you'd expect from these two, without sacrificing competitive spirit, a match that started with a battle for grappling parity unravelled with stinging chops to reddening chests. It was a chess battle between two razor-sharp workers that, to its benefit, never became a bombfest, though Dax's German suplexes rattled Lethal's skull and a slingshot Liger Bomb almost sealed the deal.

Lethal's attempts at softening Dax's legs up for the Figure Four played out through Dragon Screws, primarily. Harwood was still able to keep his wits about him, however, countering many of Lethal's biggest moves, including a spectacular Sharpshooter out of another Dragon Screw attempt.

Sonjay Dutt hit the apron to provide a distraction. This wasn't decisive, but Jay grabbed handfuls of tights on one of his many pin attempts to score the fall shortly afterwards.


3. Ricky Starks, Fire-Spitter

Ricky Starks
AEW

Like Christian Cage, Ricky Starks' promo suffered from the crowd being a tad burnt out following the pure chaos of Jon Moxley vs. CM Punk, though the former Team Taz delivered on every conceivable level.

This was the red-hot, fired-up Starks fans have come to expect over the past few months. Preceding even his split with Powerhouse Hobbs, Ricky has been in the form of his life on the microphone. He is coming of age as a fully-rounded television performer inside the ring and elsewhere, with this the latest example of that.

Starks' core point was that Hobbs was a background character before Ricky brought him into the spotlight. That Hobbs had the nerve to be upset at him for their inability to become World Tag Team Champions is therefore unacceptable. Now, Hobbs is a snake, and where Ricky's from, they cut the head off snakes.

The feud's next chapter will likely come at All Out, where the duo's excellent onscreen chemistry should yield a great match.


2. United Empire Topple Death Triangle In State Of The Art Headliner

Will Ospreay
AEW

AEW's ongoing Trios World Championship tournament has produced varied action thus far. Its most notable match to date, The Elite vs. La Faccion Ingobernable, was story-driven, built mostly around Kenny Omega's healing body to raise kayfabe questions over whether or not the long-absent star had returned to wrestling before he was truly ready.

Last night, we got a spotfest.

And what a spotfest it was.

This was the kind of cutting-edge, state-of-the-art, blow-you-out-of-your-seat banger this division will yield countless examples of through its lifespan. United Empire defeated Death Triangle in an adrenaline-pumping ripper of unbelievable spots performed at a fierce pace that provided a different giffable moment every other second, to the point that play-by-play is almost pointless.

Building towards showdowns between PAC and Will Ospreay was a clear priority, though the match also yielded Kip Sabian's return. The Englishman, who has been following PAC throughout his various All-Atlantic Title defences, removed himself from his cardboard box, neutralising his rival before the finish. Gone for over a year, it's nice to have him back.

Prior to this, PAC, who might not be a human being at this stage, somehow reversed Ospreay's Stormbreaker into a Poison Rana.

A post-match showdown with The Elite followed for United Empire. Kenny Omega and Ospreay have been building to a match for a long time, doing so primarily through media snipes. Expect whatever happens between them on next week's show to build anticipation for a future singles clash.


1. Shock & Awesome

CM Punk cooked
AEW

It's hard to imagine anybody feeling "meh" about what happened when CM Punk wrestled Jon Moxley.

To say the reaction has been divided wouldn't do it justice. On current evidence, you either enjoyed it to a 1/10 level or a full 10. Hated it or loved it. A Marmite match.

This is in the eye of the beholder. The idea that art (which wrestling certainly is) can be objectively good or bad is false. Quality is a feeling, not something that can be quantified through metrics, and one man's trash is another's treasure. If a viewer felt shortchanged by Jon Moxley crushing CM Punk in under four minutes where this once felt like a pay-per-view main event, that's a valid feeling. It isn't objectively wrong because no wrestling opinion is.

So, subjectively, this was incredible.

In an arena hotter than the surface of the sun, CM Punk sought to take advantage of a hot start by hitting Moxley with a high kick. He immediately collapsed to the canvas clutching his standing leg. The story that Punk's surgically-repaired foot was still badly damaged was established, leading to Moxley aggressively targeting it through holds, opening a window to blast Punk with two Death Riders and become undisputed AEW World Champion.

Breathless, shocking, and utterly exhilarating, it was a gobsmacking piece of booking on par with Brodie Lee's decimation of Cody Rhodes - and it leaves the All Out 2022 main event wide open.

The arena was all in on it, too. Enraptured in every single second, from the snug collar-and-elbow tie-up that opened things up to Punk's despondent glance back at Moxley while he was being taken away, Cleveland was hooked. Big time. Tony Khan's big booking gamble appeared to pay off for the ticket-buying public.

In delivering an outcome few would have predicted heading into one of the year's most unpredictable matches, AEW have ensured that debate on All Out's main event will remain atop the news cycle for the next week-and-a-half. Whether this was part of the plan or not almost doesn't matter. At a time when AEW's closest competition is making headlines for its creative turnaround under Paul Levesque (and Khan's own locker-room appears increasingly chaotic), All Out needed this bump.

Here we go.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.