8 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Dynasty (Results & Review)

Will Ospreay Vs. Bryan Danielson - an easy ***** - highlights yet another seminal All Elite PPV.

Dynasty Kazuchika Okada
AEW

Dynasty looked great on paper, but it was difficult to engage with the build on an emotional level. The event didn't feel enormous.

After a superb start to 2024, suddenly, AEW reverted to 2023 mode.

Samoa Joe Vs. Swerve Strickland wasn't a particularly gripping story. Joe deemed Swerve unworthy of being a champion. Swerve - rather too often - responded that it was his destiny. They half-tried, with a blood angle and some pull-aparts, to create a sense of hatred - but the lack of true contrast between the characters could not summon the big fight feel. Swerve is over, and to a strong extent, but he still doesn't feel undeniable. Swerve and Joe are two bad dudes; the fans just happen to like them both. AEW didn't establish a true need within the audience for one to prevail over the other.

After a promising start, Bryan Danielson Vs. Will Ospreay wasn't built all that well, either. The idea of Ospreay threatening to damage Bryan's brain in a kill-or-be-killed war was gripping, but beyond that, they each wrestled some good matches to prove that the PPV match would be good. Isn't that what the establishing premise and match graphic was for? Where was the sense that this momentous occasion simply couldn't come soon enough?

This should have felt as big as Danielson Vs. Omega. Sadly, it didn't - until the opening bell.

A dearth of ideas undermined the build, but it shouldn't go unmentioned that the expectations and standards might be unreasonably high. The Young Bucks Vs. FTR suffered from this. Sometimes, nothing less than seminal is demanded. Is that fair?

And was Dynasty as good as AEW, with those bleak attendances, needed it to be...?


Downs...

1. Chris Jericho Wrestled

Dynasty Chris Jericho HOOK
AEW

Chris Jericho is beyond a joke in April 2024, but that didn't prevent the fans from laughing at him.

For the entire seventeen-minute (!) duration of his win over HOOK, fans pelted him with abuse. They told him to go away. If he actually went away and toured with Fozzy, he'd still be unpopular: the fans also told him, loudly, that Fozzy sucks. The St. Louis crowd also told him to retire several times.

The thing is, move-for-move, this might have worked had Jericho wrestled it as 'Le Champion' when he was over. This was a theoretically cathartic match, at least for 10 or so minutes. Jericho took a truly wild sideways bump neck-first through a table. On the night, though, it would not have mattered if he turned in the performance of his life. The fans are profoundly sick of his woefully over-exposed character.

The match played out as another SummerSlam 2014 retread. Between a 2021 match with Wardlow and his first encounter with HOOK a few weeks back, this is the third time Jericho thought this was a fresh, cool idea. Deeper in the match, Jericho aimed to escalate his "sadistic" offence. It was an impossible task. He has zero aura even when he's smashing HOOK face-first with a baseball bat shot, and the realisation that he wasn't losing spoiled the schadenfreude atmosphere five full minutes before it was put out of its misery.

What's really damning here is that Jericho's very presence brings into harsher focus the differences between AEW in 2024 and WWE in 2024. The fans in AEW hijack unwanted, awful stuff that they don't want to see now. That used to be WWE's problem. What a bleak paradigm shift.

A dreadful scene.


Ups...

8. Nothing Match, Nice Moment

Dynasty Willow Nightingale Julia Hart
AEW

If you missed Dynasty, you could simply read the recap of Julia Hart Vs. Willow Nightingale and not miss much from the experience.

It was a short formality of a match lacking in tension, drama, great action. Hart deserves credit for gutting through the match, which, to its credit, was a lively enough version of nothing much at all. It wasn't boring; it was lean, didn't allow the audience to drift off, and delivered an enormously popular result efficiently. It kept the fans guessing; few people will ever remember the decent sequence in which Willow hit a spinebuster but was trapped in a Hartless attempt after missing a missile dropkick, but on the night, the fans were into it. The match was faced with a stiff challenge. Everybody was happy with it in the building. It succeeded. Willow is your new TBS Champion after beating Hart with the Doctor bomb.

In the post-match, Mercedes Moné attempted to steal Willow's spotlight by dancing in her face just as the celebrations started. At this point, it's difficult to determine whether AEW is leaning into the idea that Moné is presenting herself as a natural heel, or if the Moné/Jennifer Pepperman collaboration is that oblivious. In any event, the reaction in Las Vegas will be molten one way or the other.

Whatever works...


7. The Old Thunder Rosa Resurfaces

Dynasty Thunder Rosa Toni Storm
AEW

On a night that both women really needed, Timeless Toni Storm Vs. Thunder Rosa rocked.

Storm has constantly battled (fair) accusations that the gimmick brings down her stellar in-ring. Rosa, meanwhile, has failed to reach the standard she set - for the entire women's division - in 2021. This however was great: a two birds, one stone triumph.

Rosa impressed early by launching a stunning tornillo into both Storm and Luther. Back in the ring (and on the apron), Storm and Rosa traded stiff shots and huge bombs. The fans were receptive to the snug physicality and the tone of real enmity. Rumours persist that genuine dislike exists between the two women. Storm might as well have admitted it a couple of years ago. They struck the sweet spot by laying everything in without a hint of awkwardness. They didn't try to make one another look bad; they instead beat the piss out of one another in a match that may have been as cathartic for them as it was for the audience.

The real backstory was explored when Rosa, attempting to strike Storm with a Fire Thunder Driver, crumpled in agony. Storm never did seem to believe that Rosa had a legitimate issue with her spine two years ago, but certainly tried to give her one with a backstabber and scary release German.

The bumps were taken at increasingly sick angles as the match escalated. Storm won a lip-purser of a shoot-out with a neat meta edge when Deonna Purrazzo's attempts to equalise the interference of Luther and Mariah May only served to distract Rosa. A low blow and Storm Zero sealed it.


6. Little Heat, No Problem

Dynasty Kyle O'Reilly Roderick Strong
AEW

Roderick Strong Vs. Kyle O'Reilly was the "for the sickos" portion of Dynasty.

A wince-inducing unvarnished scrap, it wasn't helped by the fact that the key angle unfolded on, of all shows, Battle of the Belts. The Roddy turn might as well have happened on Honor Club.

Fan investment was low, the atmosphere flat. This would have been infinitely better had a degree of the build transpired on Dynamite. On this evidence, much as it performs well in the slot, Collision isn't sufficient in and of itself as a storyline driver. This would have died had Kyle and Roddy not kicked lumps off one another and dragged half of the building into caring - and would have soared to sleeper hit heights had more fans cared about Kyle's quest for revenge. As it happens, this was one of the most well-worked examples of "solid" you'll ever see.

Fierce, gorgeous technique forced the crowd to care towards the finish. Strong destroyed Kyle with multiple vile backbreakers; one launched into the top turnbuckle was pleasingly gross in particular. In several excellent moments, exploring the idea that the relationship between the two men is borderline symbiotic, Strong and Roddy countered one another's moves the very second one was attempted. They have deep knowledge of even a glimpse of the set-up. The oscillating momentum was very well done; those who liked it loved the dynamic, unpredictable action.

The finish was weird. Wardlow arrived at ringside and didn't interfere, but the commentary team insisted that his presence was enough to distract O'Reilly, who lost suddenly when he took End of Heartache.

If you still care about the Undisputed Kingdom, Adam Cole can walk now. That was genuinely nice to see and was meant to be important but, again, few people cared.


5. Trios Match Rocks

Dynasty Adam Copeland
AEW

While shaving two to three minutes from the run-time would have helped, five years deep into AEW's lifespan, it's probably foolish to expect a less is more approach. Adam Copeland, Eddie Kingston and Mark Briscoe Vs. House of Black was still an excellent trios match.

It flowed beautifully. The House of Black are untouchable as the best trios unit in the game. They put so much thought into their layouts, and the result is that they always scan as a formidable, invincible unit working in perfect synergy with one another. As an example, in a blinding sequence, Buddy Matthews sent Briscoe flying off the apron with a crisp pump knee. In one smooth motion, Mark landed on top of Brody King, who smashed him into the barricade with a revolting death valley driver. Then, when the babyfaces made their comeback, they looked awesome as a result.

Really, the House of Black should have reigned with the Trios titles for well over a year. They're such a great team, in the true sense of the word, that anybody gets over when they merely threaten to unsettle them. They'd have been perfect in the gatekeeper role, the making of, for example, Top Flight and Action Andretti - but alas.

Just before the finish, though, the sensation of Movez threatened to become a bit numbing - but just as the attention started to drift, Malakai Black misted Copeland for the win ahead of a presumed TNT title match.


4. Swerve Is The Man...For Now

Dynasty Swerve Strickland Samoa Joe
AEW

Samoa Joe Vs, Swerve Strickland was a really strange one to gauge.

Ultimately, the big takeaway is that it was a resounding and impressive success. Swerve was super over in that building, and the heat of the match ranged from respectable to hot throughout, which was some feat: the St. Louis crowd had just witnessed an all-time classic followed by one of the most deranged ladder matches of all-time. It stood no chance; that it succeeded, and was a very worthy main event, underscored that Swerve, who was not as hot as he was after Full Gear last year, might actually be the man.

The succinct take on the match is that it executed a bad core idea very well, if that makes any sense at all. It could have been better. It might not crack the top 100 matches in company history (if even that). Still, it was all about the big moment, and the fans didn't tune out until they got it.

Elements of the match were fantastic. Swerve sensing Joe's nope spot and outsmarting him was a cool idea. The match peaked when Swerve took an appalling pasting fighting from underneath. The best sequence unfolded rather too early; Swerve, after connecting with a highlight reel Fosbury flop, took a nasty power slam on exposed concrete. Beyond that, Swerve actually took a great deal of the match, targeting Joe's arm, which flattened the atmosphere somewhat. There was little sense that he had to prevail against the ultimate threat to complete his destiny. This structure also made Joe's NXT Face after the failed Muscle Buster that bit more glaring. It shouldn't have come as that much of a shock. Swerve had his number throughout.

In the end - after more than one contrived set-up - Swerve finished Joe with the Swerve Stomp. They might have actually botched the first attempt; it looked as though Swerve was meant to drive Joe to the mat from the top turnbuckle but over-shot. Still, what a recovery: Swerve quickly sent him down with a powerbomb before making history.

The fans adored the finish, but it was impossible to watch Dynasty and not think Will Ospreay is the true Ace of the promotion. If Swerve can continue the trend, and follow whatever Ospreay does, the next few months will be incredible.


3. A Towering Achievement

Dynasty FTR Young Bucks
AEW

At Dynasty, the Young Bucks and FTR achieved something virtually impossible: they followed up the Match of the Year and performed CPR on the most dead crowd you'll ever not hear.

They followed the best main event on any show you'll ever be blessed to watch, only, it wasn't the main event: Bryan Danielson Vs. Will Ospreay went on third to last. FTR and the Bucks had no right to wake that crowd back up, and for at least half of the run-time, they didn't. Even when Dax Harwood's forehead exploded and he pissed blood all over the canvas, the fans didn't respond with a gasp of distress. That crowd was on such a comedown that the natural law of pro wrestling - that blood always elicits a reaction - wasn't enacted.

FTR and the Bucks responded by going progressively more batsh*t crazy with a wild, utterly terrifying spree of major set-pieces. That's not to say there was zero connective tissue between those insane stunts. In one great moment, Nicholas Jackson crotched Cash Wheeler on a suspended ladder before both Bucks blasted his prone head with the EVP Trigger.

It's also worth noting that both teams built on their previous encounters; in one of the best spots of the match, Nicholas flexed his better grasp of the high-flying art by blasting Cash through a table with the 450 splash where Cash has struggled to execute the move through desperation across the series. Cash was a total animal throughout. In one of several heart-pounding, legitimately scary moments, he speared Matthew off the apron and through a table. Matthew's head connected with the barricade so hard that he had no means of protecting himself. The bumps in this demented war were so committed that the fans devised a new chant.

Usually, such a detached, performative chant is annoying. Earnest, incomprehensible noises are far better. But the chant of "Please be careful", on this night at least, really underscored and elevated the effort shown in that plasma-stained ring.

At the finish, a masked "fan" entered the ring and tossed Dax off a ladder when FTR were inches away from victory. It was revealed to be Jack Perry, whose smug facial expression was sublime. It was a predictable finish, but in the throes of ultra-violent drama, everybody had forgotten was nailed on to happen.

The Bucks are the new AEW Tag Team champions. AEW should run this back as Escalera de la Muerte at a later date: as unbelievably impressive as this match was, both teams deserve a shot at a fifth match in front of a less clinically deceased set of fans.


2. Kazuchika Okada Is The Best Heel In Wrestling

Dynasty Kazuchika Okada
AEW

Kazuchika Okada defeated PAC in a wonderful opener. It was a truly excellent slow-burn wrestling match, one so great that it was surely impossible not to appreciate. It was simultaneously immune to criticism without ever safely, cynically ticking boxes to craft a "great" match.

In a content-forward, trope-y landscape, this was remarkably self-assured pro wrestling. They took their sweet time building it, but the pacing was majestic - and crucial to the specific story being told.

PAC is one of the most game bumpers in wrestling history, and between several neck-jamming moments, he sold brilliantly. The fans were with him during every methodical step and gasped with awe during the few moments in which he was able to unleash his spectacular high-flying repertoire.

Okada was on bravura form as a heel, creating his first truly iconic in-ring moment in AEW by feigning to do the Rainmaker pose and flipping off the crowd as the camera zoomed back in. He wrestled as the most cocky, confident man alive - which informed the incredible drama down the stretch. Again and again, measuring the comeback brilliantly so that the fans never once forgot just how much punishment he'd endured, PAC caught Okada in flash pin attempts. And, since nobody is as good as the 2.99 kick-out as Okada, every near-fall was breathless, nerve-shredding.

At the finish, Okada got the knees up to counter the Black Arrow. PAC was a level beyond special here, selling the impact as if he'd suffered a stinger and a chipped tooth.

A deadly-looking Rainmaker - which is recovering its old one-and-done power all over again - secured Okada the win, and his first AEW classic.


1. Match Of The Year

Dynasty Will Ospreay Bryan Danielson
AEW

Honestly, Will Ospreay Vs. Bryan Danielson was almost too good for its own good early.

They worked possibly the greatest introductory counter sequence leading to a stalemate stand-off ever. The intent, the rhythm, the promise of how good it would be when it finally got going: it was an indescribable high. Everybody in the crowd lost their minds. It was perhaps the ultimate "strap in, this is a guaranteed five star match" moment in wrestling history. It was almost too effective; the next few minutes were merely excellent slow-build wrestling in comparison.

In an absolutely incredible sequence and storytelling feat, Danielson rocked Ospreay with La Mistica to transition into the LeBell lock. This was so goddamn great. Firstly, it looked majestic, underscoring that even Ospreay might not have the athletic advantage thought assured before the match began. Secondly, the spot drew on the idea that Ospreay mentioned in a promo cut early in their feud. Ospreay accused Danielson of cosplaying as the internationally-honed superstar that he actually is. Bryan, by unleashing a move he'd used before but never truly mastered enough to add it to his arsenal permanently, wrestled with a self-conscious streak. Ospreay was the better man; in a superb story beat, it was clear before the finish.

One of the greatest thrills of any art form is experiencing an idea so incredible and yet so fitting and simple that you can't believe nobody had thought of it previously.

In a capital D capital R Dream Match, the idea is to create inseparable parity between each wrestler. This idea has never been applied more intelligently than with the Busaiku knee Vs. Hidden Blade duel. They each had a weapon as deadly as the other; the only way to win was to not flinch. This single sequence, which only worked as well as it did as a consequence of the fantastic storytelling throughout, could not have been more effective in underscoring the lofty premise. This truly was a meeting between the two best wrestlers alive.

The closing stretch was phenomenal. The drama was outrageous; the execution preposterously, unfairly good, Danielson countered the Oscutter with the Busaiku and could not have caught him more perfectly if he'd hit it another 100,000 times. Then again, they probably could have reached that impossible level of physical timing again. That's how great they were.

At the finish, as threatened, Ospreay blitzed Danielson with the Tiger Driver '91. There's a wonderful, Burning Hammer-esque precedent that Will has achieved with the move; by doing the disgusting, full-tilt version first, he can do the safer variation forever and it will still feel like some unspeakable transgression. Despite the attempts of Doc Sampson to intervene, Will smashed Bryan with the Hidden Blade to win it. Bryan's expert selling was distressing.

If this match gets bettered, Omega Vs. Okada IV might actually be in trouble. It was among the closest achievements to it.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!