8 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE Royal Rumble 2024 (Results & Review)
Cody Rhodes and Bayley triumph; WWE comebacks rock the Rumble; Roman Reigns' time as champ = over!
Saturday's Royal Rumble card wasn't some over-bloated popcorn fart of a show that promised much but delivered little. Twin Rumble matches soared despite unavoidable sags for 10-15 minutes in each, and one of the undercard title bouts thrilled with a smart finish that teased more. Spoiler: It wasn't the four-way for Roman Reigns' Undisputed gold.
That's become a nagging itch Triple H will surely scratch once and for all come WrestleMania XL. 'The Game' has to, because all-too-familiar tropes bogged down the only World Title scrap on WWE's latest bumper PLE, and it laid bare why some have been tut-tutting about The Bloodline story for a while now.
The end is nigh. It must be.
That's not meant to be as negative as it sounds - Roman's title demise can still deliver greatness before The Rock finishes his 'Tribal Chief' story arc off once and for all. Besides, one need only glance at the 'Ups' and 'Downs' counts to see that this was a top notch evening from Hunter and crew.
Here's all the good and bad from WWE's first bold step in 2024.
Downs...
2. Zero Crowd Reaction = Warning Shot
First, the 'Downs'.
WWE must've spotted the almost deafening silence for some of the women (in particular) at the Rumble. Candice LeRae, Indi Hartwell, Katana Chance, Kayden Carter, Xia Li and several others got pretty much zero response from the live crowd during their entrances. In fairness, people haven't been given a reason to care about them.
This was admittedly less of an issue in the men's match, but that might have something to do with creative penning non-title stories for the dudes. If nothing else, that should be a warning shot to Trips that he needs to step up his game (ahem) on the women's division side. These workers deserve better than they're getting.
Fans shouldn't be sitting on their hands at any point during Rumble matches. Sure, a few entries here or there bring things down before incredible peaks have fans bristling with glee again, but...yeah, yeah that apathy was a little too obvious on Saturday night for some of the female pack.
1. Pre-Show Worries Ring True
Some may be shocked to see this here, but stick with it.
Concerns were expressed pre-Rumble about the four-way for that Undisputed Title. In execution, Roman Reigns, Randy Orton, AJ Styles and LA Knight tried their able best, but their match was formulaic and the finish featured tropes some hardcores have come to know and loathe since Roman's Bloodline domination began.
Solo Sikoa/The Bloodline in general saving Reigns has become an overused panic button for creative. Admittedly, all of that annoyance will wash away in an instant if Cody Rhodes beats Roman come WrestleMania XL, but still - it's fair to say that many fans are sick and tired of seeing the same old from these matches.
It's also fair to say that the Rumble's four-way offering wasn't as high profile a title defence as WWE wants to pretend it was. The occasion didn't feel grand or threatening enough to rank it amongst Roman's best, and it certainly didn't fit on a top tier PLE like Royal Rumble.
Some will disagree, which is fine, but the chap writing this piece was left unsatisfied.
Ups...
8. Starting With The Women
Kicking off the show with the women's Rumble was the correct call. Why? No offence intended, but it was the lesser of two titular specials this year. The men's version boasted a 'who will win?!' stand off between Cody Rhodes and CM Punk; the 30-woman epic didn't quite have as much juice to it.
It's still a Rumble and people were there to see it though.
Spacing both Rumbles out is wise, and that's exactly what WWE did in Florida. Running them back-to-back would've outright killed one of them (likely the women's one for aforementioned reasons), so there was a clear level of energy in the building when Samantha Irvin announced what was up first.
One can only imagine what kind of apathetic response Natalya would've received had she been out first for a women's match that fell after Cody's victory, Here's hoping the promotion can drum up some more interest across the board for the ladies next year.
If not, then it'll get the opening slot again.
7. The Lack Of Legends
Look, this 80s baby loves a legendary cameo as much as the next nostalgia-hungry fan, but it was notable that WWE kept the old-school minimal on Saturday. They didn't burn through loads of Rumble entries by ringing up names from the past like Torrie Wilson, Michelle McCool, Molly Holly, The Hurricane or folks like that.
The women's match put a keen focus on an emerging generation. For every worker that blatantly wasn't over (see the 'Downs' for more moaning about that), there was a palpable excitement surrounding everyone from Jade Cargill and Tiffany Stratton to Roxanne Perez and even TNA's Jordynne Grace.
Andrade's comeback in the men's bout worked a treat too, but he's hardly coming in to be a main eventer. It remains to be seen whether or not Triple H will even book him better than Tony Khan did. Being brutally honest about it, that won't be a challenging task, but he'll be midcard for now.
The lack of Hogan, McCool etc was appreciated.
6. That US Title Finish
This...this was excellent.
Special mention goes to the referee for his performance right at the tail end of the United States Title bout. He was busy counting, but spotted brass knuckles on Kevin Owens' hand. That caused a DQ for the babyface, and heartbreak for those who hoped to see the detestable Logan Paul get some comeuppance.
LP's title reign marches on, and it was all really, really good stuff. The finish proved to be an expert piece of booking savvy that sets up a gimmicked rematch between both guys. Look out for that at 'Mania. There, Owens will presumably blast Paul in the face with the knuckles again (legally this time) and take the prize home.
As usual, Logan showed he's a natural in this game. Kev needs a pat on the back for being the best possible babyface foil for Paul's easy-to-boo antics though - Owens looked crestfallen when the ref effectively stopped him from giving LP a taste of his own medicine.
Amazing scenes.
5. CM Punk Eliminating Drew McIntyre
Hold onto your hats, because WWE might've just booked a contingency plan should injury prevent Seth Rollins from appearing as planned at WrestleMania. CM Punk eliminated a shocked Drew McIntyre from the men's Rumble, and the cameras paused to take in both Drew's anguish and Punk's sneaky delight/relief.
Plan B has a foundation. Will it be hatched? Who knows? That decision will rest with Rollins' doctors. They'll be the ones who ultimately decide whether or not Seth is capable of defending his World Heavyweight Title vs. Punk in Philly. If not, then Punk vs. McIntyre is one heck of a backup.
That'd be sheer fire.
Drew now has further motivation to mow down Punk, and CM can understandably point to the unfairness of McIntyre whining about his fate. After all, he was ousted from the Rumble fair and square in Tropicana Field. What are you complaining about, Drew?!
Superb background planning.
4. Cody Rhodes Goes Back-To-Back
Even those sporting 'Best In The World' t-shirts in the stands should applaud the bravery of having Cody Rhodes win his second Royal Rumble in successive years. CM Punk would've been the easy play call from Triple H - it'd be akin to John Harbaugh telling Lamar Jackson to pick up some yards on a 3rd and 2.
Instead, Hunter kept everyone guessing by running something else and having Punk come up short when bets had flooded in touting his surefire success. No matter, 'cause WWE can use Elimination Chamber to correct Punk's road to 'Mania. Meanwhile, they've positioned Cody to "finish the story".
That was achieved whilst dual World Champs like Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins watched on from respective sky boxes in the building. Their interest only heightened the drama and made the men's Rumble must-win for both favourites. What a story the writers told here, eh?!
More is coming. Can't wait.
3. Naomi & TNA’s Spotlight
TNA figurehead Scott D'Amore must be going to bed with a grin that'd need surgically removed after Saturday's Rumble shenanigans. He, like the entire wrestling world, watched his product take centre stage on one of WWE's grandest PLEs. Yes, TNA/IMPACT has shared screen time on WWE's dime before, but nothing like this.
Naomi's comeback was welcome, and Michael Cole putting over her accomplishments in TNA was one of the least WWE-ish commentary calls of all time. That just didn't happen before. In fact, Cole would've been instructed to ignore anything Trinity achieved outside the sports entertainment juggernaut's walls.
This was even bigger than the plaudits Mickie James received before when she stormed the Rumble as Knockouts Champ. It's really cool to see WWE interplaying with other leagues, especially because you know they won't go overboard with it and dilute their own product like AEW and Tony Khan tends to do.
Naomi is back, but WWE thanked TNA for taking care of her.
2. Jade Cargill’s Debut Performance
"That Bitch" looked great out there during her in-ring bow at the Rumble.
The fact Jade Cargill was even involved that close to the finish for one of WWE's most famous matches is a very positive sign. Plus, eliminating Nia Jax (who was made to look like an unstoppable monster you'd need summons and co-op help to take down in Elden Ring) turned Jade into a killer overnight for those who didn't know much about her going in.
Overall, this was a super-smart use of Cargill. WWE kept her workload relatively simple, but made sure to tease coming showdowns with everyone from Jax and Bianca Belair to Becky Lynch and Bayley. There was a lot to like about the way agents formatted Jade's intro as an active member of the main roster.
Now, within the span of just one showing, she looks ready-made to take the fight to anyone in that women's locker room. Screw patience, 'cause Jade is ready and willing to show what she's capable of come WrestleMania. Stick her on the undercard, please. Title match or not.
1. Bayley Gets Her Flowers
It's easy to forget that Bayley helped carry WWE through the pandemic with serious panache. She, alongside Sasha Banks, kept TV ticking along and really started to come into her own as a character. Sadly, once that period ended, it looked like Bayley might never get the credit she'd earned.
The waiting game has paid dividends.
Triple H handed Bayley her flowers in Florida, and he let her work over an hour in the women's Rumble to hammer home the point. Surely, Bayley vs. IYO SKY is on the booking sheets for April's WrestleMania weekender. That makes way more sense than the teased Bayley vs. Rhea Ripley scrap.
Bayley has had to watch as ex-NXT peers like Becky Lynch, Asuka and Charlotte Flair won Rumbles. Then, she sat patiently as Ronda Rousey and rising star Bianca Belair won the match. 2024 is finally her year, and man has she ever worked for it.
This was a wonderful moment.
What did you think of the 2024 Royal Rumble? For more WWE, check out WWE 2K24: EVERY Major Change 2K Just Announced and 5 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Jan 26 - Results & Review)!