8 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Collision (June 17)

AEW Collision is off to an extremely strong start.

AEW Collision CM Punk
AEW

The wait is over, the time has come, and we can all rejoice - or boo wildly - at the return of CM Punk and the launch of AEW Collision.

A third weekly show for All Elite Wrestling, Collision was rumoured to usher in a roster split or, in simpler terms, give Tony Khan somewhere to dump his misfit toys and problem children. While those stories of a hard brand split now seem unfounded, there will very much be stars who solely feature on Collision as others spend the bulk of their time on Dynamite and Rampage.

With plentiful questions of what Collision would look and sound like, which wrestlers would be featured, what rivalries might start up, and what exactly would Crazy Phil say with a live microphone in hand, this debut episode of AEW's new Saturday show certainly delivered an entertaining, engaging two hours of pro wrestling television.

So, let's get to those Ups and those Downs for a premiere that's hopefully a fine example of what's to come from AEW each and every Saturday.

Saturday night's alright for fighting, indeed...


Downs...

3. We Need To Talk About Wardlow...

AEW Collision Christian Cage Luchasaurus Wardlow
AEW

A year ago, it seemed destined that Wardlow would be the one to topple MJF for the AEW World Championship as and when the Salt of the Earth inevitably won the promotion's top prize.

Now? Not so much so.

To say the booking of Wardlow across these past 12 months has been odd, would be a monumental understatement. The War Dog has gone from can't-miss main event prospect, to an utter afterthought. Sure, he's had three reigns as the TNT Champion since this time last year, but the powerhouse is treading water right now.

This is no fault of the talent himself, but where does Wardlow find himself moving forward? Does he get revenge on Christian Cage and Luchasaurus, and claim back the TNT Title? That could once again place him in the same sort of rut he's been in. Does Wardlow move on to something or someone else? Possibly, but it's hard right now to take him seriously as going after someone higher up the food chain, with him positioned like a nobody in recent months.

Tony Khan needs to decide just how much potential he thinks Wardlow has, and where he views the former Pinnacle man in a year or more's time. If Wardlow really is seen as a future top tier player, there needs to be significant adjustments made to his presentation right now.


2. Backwards Booking

AEW Collision Skye Blue Ruby Soho Toni Storm Willow Nightingale
AEW

Skye Blue and Willow Nightingale vs. Toni Storm and Ruby Soho was a fun match, with hometown hero Blue picking up the win, but it all just felt a little backwards.

It was only on this past Wednesday's AEW Dynamite that Skye lost against AEW Women's Champion Toni Storm. So, to have Blue be the one to get the win here - even if Soho ate the pin - was a little odd.

Logic would suggest this means Skye will now get another crack at Storm's Women's Title, but surely this would've worked better if the Collision match happened before last Wednesday's match - as in, Skye Blue gets the tag team win, which in turn sets her up to unsuccessfully challenge Storm on last week's Dynamite.

Instead, we now have a situation that's undone what took place on Wednesday.

Make it make sense, please.


1. What Next?

AEW Collision CM Punk
AEW

While Collision's premiere was an extremely strong show, one noticeable element was that absolutely nothing has been lined up for the next Collision offering.

It's becoming somewhat of a running joke, but AEW programming will so often feature an exacerbated Excalibur running through countless announcements where it pertains to the next Dynamite, Rampage, or PPV. The point being, AEW has made a fantastic habit of letting its audience know what matches and segments they can see on upcoming programming.

For this coming week, we know what's set for AEW Dynamite and AEW Rampage, but not a single thing has been announced for AEW Collision. Where's the hook for next week's Collision? Where's that tentpole match or promo that's going to have us counting the days until next Saturday?

Of course, not every segment of every show needs to be advertised ahead of time. Still, this just felt very out of tune to AEW's usual approach.


Ups...

8. The Presentation

AEW Collision
AEW

Many were pondering what exactly AEW Collision would look and feel like. And on that front, AEW has done a great job with the overall identity of its new Saturday night show.

Visually, Collision does very much feel like a familiar AEW show, but it has enough uniqueness to make it not merely be a Dynamite or Rampage clone. The red ropes and the logo-emblazed ring apron work well, and the most impressive element of the entire setup is the fantastic stage design, with a giant screen either side of where the wrestlers emerge from as they make their way to the ring.

Away from the look of Collision, there was a sense of intrigue to see how the commentary team would line up. With it announced over the weekend that Jim Ross, Kevin Kelly and Nigel McGuinness would be on the call, that trio was largely just a double-act in reality.

Handling most of the heavy lifting, Kelly and McGuinness - who of course are no strangers to one another due to their time in ROH - were fantastic. For JR, he was extremely hoarse when he joined the announce table for the show's main event, and Ross himself has since tweeted how he's going to step away "to heal" - with Collision coming shortly after Jim had a fall at the end of last week.

Speaking of "announce table", it was also great to see the commentary booth at ringside, rather than be up by the stage. A small change, but a welcome one that likewise helps to make AEW Collision feel different to other AEW programming.

Yes, there was the odd flub - Kevin Kelly butchering Andrade El Idolo's name several times, ring announcer Dasha Gonzalez announcing Buddy Murphy instead of Buddy Matthews - but AEW Collision has a brilliant overall vibe to it.


7. Captain Charisma Steals The Show

AEW Collision Luchasaurus Christian Cage
AEW

While there are plentiful questions surrounding AEW's handling of Wardlow, the War Dog's loss of the TNT Title at least gave Christian Cage the perfect opportunity to yuck it up for the cameras.

Cage proudly parading around with the TNT Championship over his head was phenomenal, with the Canadian showing off that prize as if he were a doting father showcasing his newborn baby.

From here on out, we've got the prospect of Christian wearing the TNT Title on a weekly basis, passing the championship off as his own. Similarly, you could even go as far as to have Luchasaurus outright hand the belt over to his mentor, with Cage being formally crowned the TNT Champion.

Regardless of which was AEW opts to go with this, Christian Cage will absolutely kill it. When it comes to maximising their minutes - particularly as a chicken sh*t heel - few do it as well as the seven-time World Champion.


6. Andrade And Buddy Go To War

AEW Collision Andrade El Idolo Buddy Matthews
AEW

Andrade El Idolo is a terrifically talented pro wrestler. Buddy Matthews is a terrifically talented pro wrestler. Here on AEW Collision's premiere, those two terrifically talented pro wresters put on a terrific pro wrestling match.

Matthews has long been one of the most underrated workers in the business, and he once again showcased just how good he really is. For Andrade, this marked his first AEW contest in nine months, and this outing served as the perfect reminder of the former La Sombra's skillset.

This was an absolute war, with snug shots aplenty, a frenetic pace when called for, and a nice splash of psychology in terms of both men kayfabe feeling the strains of injuries of the past. On top of that, there were also a couple of nice nods to Andrade and Buddy's respective partners - Charlotte Flair and Rhea Ripley - including El Idolo getting the submission victory with Charlotte's Figure Eight.

Should AEW opt to run this match back at any point, anticipation will certainly be high. Similarly, that same sense of anticipation surrounds the prospect of Andrade and his La Faccion Ingobernable pals stepping up to face House of Black. And then there's the mouth-watering possibility of an Andrade El Idolo vs. Malakai Black match - with Black the one to dethrone Andrade as the NXT Champion at TakeOver: New Orleans back in 2018.


5. Some Movement On The Owen

AEW Collision Ricky Starks
AEW

While this year's Owen Hart Cup was announced back in April, we'd not heard any further details on the tournament bar that the finals would be taking place in Calgary on 15 July.

Now though, we've finally have the first couple of competitors confirmed for this year's Owen.

As shown on AEW Collision, Ricky Starks and Powerhouse Hobbs have announced themselves for the Owen Hart Cup. With the tournament finals less than a month away, one has to imagine that these two announcements will be followed shortly by the reveal of which other wrestlers will be partaking in this year's edition of a tourney that AEW and Martha Hart launched last year.

Of course, Adam Cole and Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. were the winners of the inaugural Owen tournaments.


4. Exactly What It Needed To Be

AEW Collision Miro Tony Nese
AEW

Tony Nese is a phenomenal worker who very much lives to up his Premier Athlete moniker when afforded the opportunity. Unfortunately for Nese, though, the bigger priority on AEW Collision was re-establishing Miro as a dominant brute.

Miro's return was everything it needed to be. Ruthless, clinical, and furious, the Redeemer's first match since September 2022 was a three-minute run-through of the Bulgarian Brute's greatest hits.

Should you have forgotten what Miro is all about, this was a perfect reminder. And man, how we've all missed that absolutely banging entrance theme of the former TNT Champion.

A few more wins like this will be the ideal way to welcome Miro fully back into the fold, before then placing the 37-year-old into a meaningful feud with whichever dope wants to take on God's Champion.


3. Just Okay

AEW Collision The Acclaimed Daddy Ass Billy Gunn
AEW

To give the Acclaimed's Collision segment a 'down' would feel a little harsh, so this segment just about classifies as an 'up'. A borderline up, but an up nonetheless.

The general gist of this appearance was for the Acclaimed to wish Daddy Ass a happy Father's Day, and to make us aware that AEW now stands for Acclaimed Every Wednesday and Acclaimed Every Weekend. While this served the purpose of making fans aware that Anthony Bowens, Max Caster and Billy Gunn will be recurring figures on AEW Collision each Saturday, it was still very much filler.

Still, this segment didn't particularly overstay its welcome. Plus, Chicago's United Center was all about the scissoring action here. Safe to say, the Acclaimed and Daddy Ass are still over like rover.


2. One Bill Phil

AEW Collision CM Punk
AEW

Oh, Crazy Phil, how we've missed you...

The CM Punk we saw on AEW Collision, was the exact CM Punk we needed to see. This was the Second City Saint with a clear chip on his shoulder, with biting comments to be made, and with the attitude that nobody actually beat him for the AEW World Title he was stripped of shortly after Brawl Out.

Making it clear that he was done trying to be nice, this was a Punk who was brimming with intensity and passion, and who of course had his traditional one-liners that get the internet buzzing.

If you want an apology from the Straight-Edge Superstar, he's sorry that the only people softer than you are your favourite wrestlers. To Warner Bros. Discovery CEO David Zaslav, Punk is known as One Bill Phil, as he's the genuine deal in a business full of Counterfeit Bucks.

Obviously it helped that this return took place in Chicago, with 90% of the United Center cheering on CM Punk's every word, but this opening promo was a brilliant way to usher in CM Punk's return, and likewise it certainly started the debut episode of AEW Collision off with a bang.


1. A Phenomenal Main Event

AEW Collision Samoa Joe CM Punk
AEW/Scott Lesh

Much like CM Punk's opening promo, the AEW Collision main event was exactly what it needed to be.

This match-up only used Punk sparingly, with Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler taking up the bulk of the bout for the babyface trio. This match did give us enough CM Punk to more than whet the appetite, though, and it was indeed the Chicagoan who scored the win, pinning Juice Robinson after a GTS and the Big Rig.

Bullet Club Gold's Jay White and Juice were fantastic in their roles; White being the slick, smooth heel technician, Robinson as the crazed lunatic who was always going to eat the pin. And then, well then there's Samoa Joe.

In terms of whetting the appetite, long-time rivals CM Punk and Samoa Joe standing toe-to-toe was a sight many had thought we'd never see again. For the United Center, they absolutely - and rightly so - lost their sh*t at the tease of Punk and Joe slugging it out, and likewise lost their sh*t even more when that finally happened.

The way that Joe chopped the soul out of CM Punk as he talked trash to his old rival? That was brutally beautiful. That said, Joe was magnificent with all three of the babyfaces who he found himself going up against here. The aura, the posture, the jaw-jacking, and the facials... this was Samoa Joe at his most, well, Samoa Joe.

A phenomenal TV main event, a magical way to close out the inaugural AEW Collision, and now we're all left to ponder when and where we'll get CM Punk vs. Samoa Joe.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.