8 Ups & 6 Downs From The Undertaker's WWE Career
The Deadman's WWE legacy is legendary, but not without flaw...
With matches at WrestleMania 34, the Greatest Royal Rumble, and Super Show-Down all in the bag and Crown Jewel's Brothers Of Destruction vs. DX battle on the horizon (2 November), 2018 has been a surprisingly busy year for The Undertaker, who hasn't worked this many bouts since 2015.
Pretty impressive, for a 53-year-old giant whose prime is now long behind him.
'Taker has been wrestling since 1984, with 28 of his 34 active years coming in WWE, for whom he has become one of the most beloved performers of all time. The impact he has had on the business cannot be overstated, and his place in history is more secure than Fort Knox. Still, while 'The Deadman' has been granted sacred cow status by many a fan, his lengthy WWE career hasn't been without its troughs, as we're about to find out.
His vast résumé means fitting everything Undertaker has done throughout his run into this list would be impossible. With that in mind, we've largely stuck to bigger picture topics, though we'd be remiss not to mention a handful of historically great (and terrible) storylines.
Let's dive into the madness and magic of WWE's most iconic gimmick.
Downs...
6. Monster Hunter
It took The Undertaker a long, long time to get good between the ropes. He was always a decent athlete for his size, but his early years were full of slow, cumbersome matches, and while his WrestleMania streak would eventually become legendary, it, too, is full of absolute dross.
Things were particularly bad in the mid-'90s, when Vince McMahon effectively used 'The Deadman' to kill off any failing monster character whose career was cratering. It started with Kamala in '92, and continued throughout the years, with the Underfaker (SummerSlam '94), Mabel (In Your House 5: Season's Beatings), and King Kong Bundy (WrestleMania XI) among the worst offenders. None of these feuds were any good, and any rub the up-and-coming 'Phenom' received from going over was negligible.
This 'Monster Of The Week' run doesn't quite represent 'Taker at his absolute worst, but it was a turgid, torturous period nonetheless. Later years would see him engage in horrific stories with plodders like Vladimir Kozlov, The Great Khali, and Heidenreich, but none were as brutal as this guy...
5. Giant Bloody Gonzalez
Of all the inept monster heels Undertaker faced during his WWE come-up, this 7'7" goober was the absolute worst.
Fairly remembered as one of the least effective giants in company history, Giant Gonzalez stumbled into WWE in January 1993, eliminating 'Taker in that year's Royal Rumble. A decent rub in theory, but the big fella was dead on arrival. An embarrassing bodysuit airbrushed with muscles and hair made it impossible to take him seriously, and he was calamitous from bell-to-bell, with physical stature his only positive attribute.
Him and Undertaker met at WrestleMania IX, working an embarrassing, graceless seven-minute mess that concluded when Gonzalez was disqualified for attacking 'The Deadman' with chloroform. This wasn't the end of it, though. Lord knows what Vince McMahon saw in that bout to make him think it warranted a rematch, but he put it together for SummerSlam '93, and the two unseasoned brutes somehow conspired to create a clash worse than their 'Mania catastrophe.
There are a handful of other Undertaker feuds bad enough to warrant their own 'Down.' As the most egregious of all, Gonzalez gets the nod. It was a nadir, not only for 'The Phenom,' but the New Generation era as a whole, and those responsible must never be forgiven.
4. Every WrestleMania Match Since The Streak Ended
The decision to end The Undertaker's WrestleMania streak by Brock Lesnar's hand remains divisive. Without diving too deeply, it at least accelerated 'The Beast Incarnate's' surge 'Special Attraction' status, placing him on a level above everyone else in the company. Still, you'll find few fans who'll argue that the bout itself didn't stink, and the past-it 'Taker hasn't worked a compelling 'Mania bout since.
The Bray Wyatt clash was a nothing match between a veteran and his supposed heir, the loss coming at great personal cost to the latter. WrestleMania 32 was the worst kind of Shane McMahon stunt show, with the ageing billionaire unbelievably presented as his opponent's equal, and his "hardest man alive" shtick at its most repugnant. Undertaker's performance against Roman Reigns the following year was just plain sad. Finally, this writer took a perverse sense of enjoyment from 'Taker vs. Cena, but the three-minute squash wasn't what most wanted, and 'The Deadman' still contrived to botch a big boot.
That such an important part of 'Taker's legacy (WrestleMania) has been tarnished by four years of sh*t is a massive shame, and a black mark against the performer himself. If only he'd retired after Lesnar...
3. Biker 'Taker
The Undertaker's biker era wasn't without merit. It helped pull the character and WWE towards a more realistic era, and yielded memorable bouts with the likes of Jeff Hardy and Triple H. Nonetheless, it was a huge net negative that regularly presented 'The American Badass' at his most unwatchable, with the ailing, out-of-shape hells angel labouring through a mid-career crisis.
It even started with a botch, as a music/video miscue left his Judgment Day 2000 a mistimed mess. The laziest period of 'Taker's career followed. Meeting the surging Kurt Angle at that year's Fully Loaded pay-per-view, Undertaker uncorked a brutal five-minute burial during which he barely broke a sweat, arrogantly breaking his own late-match pinfall to compound the burial. This is far from the only example of his apathy, and the storytelling wasn't strong enough to compensate, with dull-as-piss feuds with DDP, Maven, and others failing to hit the mark.
Though he deserves credit for swimming up the 'American Badass'' river of s**t and somehow coming out clean at the end, this absurdly over-romanticised run would've sunk a less adaptable worker.
2. The False Retirement
If WrestleMania XXX wasn't the right place for The Undertaker's retirement, then 33 definitely was. His bout with Roman Reigns was an abomination. Fans knew the golden boy was going over the legend, and their investment was in the pits before the bell had even rung. From there, we got 23 minutes of sloppy, uncoordinated brawling, with the 52-year-old 'Deadman' appearing more mortal than ever before, stumbling around the squared circle, and generally looking like a danger to himself and his opponent. Reigns worked hard, but he couldn't salvage it.
The post-match was a stark contrast, with 'Taker removing his gloves, folding his coat, and leaving them and his trademark hat in a neat little pile in the middle of the ring. He broke character to embrace Michelle McCool, then began his ceremonial march up the ramp. With Reigns long gone, the arena turned a mournful purple, and though 'Taker's departure was wordless, the message was clear: "this is the end."
But it wasn't. WWE went back on what felt like an incredible moment (and a fitting farewell) by dragging Undertaker's carcass back to life months later, and the charade continues. As it stands, 'Mania 33 might be the last time this guy ever gives us the chills.
1. The Undertaker Of Today
And so we arrive at the present day, and the absolute worst version of The Undertaker to ever exist.
In his current form, the legendary 'Deadman' pisses gasoline on his burning legacy, serving up nothing but overly nostalgic botch-fests for the dwindling portion of the audience still able to suspend their disbelief for his dilapidated act. A once magnetic character looked genuinely lost in his weird Raw 25 promo. WrestleMania 34 was too short to be a complete disaster, but 'Taker's Greatest Royal Rumble clash with Rusev was an ugly watch that served only to appease WWE's Saudi Arabian paymasters.
Super Show-Down was even worse. At WrestleMania 34, Triple H concocted a genius match layout that made a complete rookie (Ronda Rousey) genuinely look like 'The Baddest Woman On The Planet,' and presented his non-wrestler wife as the best sh*t-heel in the game. In Melbourne, him and 'Taker drowned in their own slop.
Crown Jewel should yield a better bout, as it carries the intrigue of Shawn Michaels' return, and Kane (though he's a coffin-dodger himself) is significantly less beaten-up than his kayfabe brother. Still, this Undertaker looks embarrassing. Unable to hit anything close to his old standards, he is crushing his own goodwill, and it'll only get worse the longer he sticks around.
Ups...
8. An Awesome Debut
Though it took 'Taker years to grow into his skin as a performer, his debut is one of the most memorable in WWE history, with his grand Survivor Series 1990 arrival a perfect jump-off for a remarkably successful career.
Undertaker was unveiled as the Million Dollar Team's mystery partner against Bret Hart, Dusty Rhodes, Koko B. Ware, and Jim Neidhart, and his impact was immediate. Decked out in black and grey, and standing at close to seven feet tall, 'The Deadman' gave off an otherworldly vibe from the very first glimpse. He was unlike anything the fans had ever seen before, and he made a difference between the ropes within the first two minutes, quickly pinning Koko with a Tombstone Piledriver, though he was later disqualified for going after Rhodes (who he'd already put away). Presented as a near-invincible force from day one, WWE made 'Taker look like the biggest beast in the company that night.
Was his debut as impactful as Kane's seven years later? Not quite, but it still deserves to be mentioned among the best ever.
7. Unparalleled Longevity
As rough as the past few years have been, The Undertaker's unparalleled longevity as an active WWE in-ring competitor is cause for celebration. He has been under Vince McMahon's employ for 28 years. That's insane, and while his period has brought a rollercoaster of highs and lows, nobody else has ever been able to maintain such a level of prominence for so long.
Much of 'Taker's longevity comes from his adaptability, with 'The Phenom' switching gimmicks and personas several times throughout his aeon of employment. They haven't all been hits (see: Badass, American), but at the very least, each prolonged his lifespan as a main eventer, and later, the biggest special attraction this company has ever seen.
No wrestler should ever be considered above criticism - even 'Taker, despite his dedication, sacrifices, and undeniable excellence at the absolute height of his powers. Thus, it's important to temper this point by mentioning the understandable argument that he should perhaps have called it a day by now. Even if he had, though, he'd still be remembered as an icon of longevity, and it's hard to imagine another wrestler ever managing such a stint after he's gone.
6. Making Spooky Bullsh*t WORK
'Taker's positive attributes are legion.
A level of athleticism that allowed him to move around the ring with a poise belying this massive frame. That aura of intimidation. Intensity. A near-unparalleled knack of crafting epic, big theatre spectacles that play out like Hollywood Blockbusters. A steadfast attitude towards protecting the business an its integrity.
Greater than all of these is his ability to take some of the dumbest, most contrived sh*t to ever make it out of a WWE creative meeting and somehow make them work. This guy's gimmick was a literal zombie for a while. A zombie! Yet not once did general consensus shift from "yeah, I can buy into this" to "this is far too ridiculous," despite the odd moment of excessive daftness.
The Undertaker character would've died in the hands of a lesser performer. Mark Calaway took a concept that should've been pure, unadulterated WrestleCrap fodder and made it work for 30 years, making him comfortably the most effective vehicle for supernatural concepts in wrestling history.
5. Genuine Innovation
Although he isn't necessarily known for innovating anything when it comes to the pure bell-to-bell, The Undertaker has been a genuine game-changer in this company, pushing the entertainment side of this pseudo-sport forward in a number of big ways.
He was among the first wrestlers to successfully incorporate supernatural elements into his character. It speaks volumes of his success that almost everyone who has tried to replicate these things feels like a tribute act, with the 'Next Undertaker' tag a millstone round the neck of any unfortunate sap to be lumbered with it. Still, a gimmick like Kane can't exist without 'Taker, and some of Bray Wyatt's best work came from 'The Deadman's' creepy wheelhouse.
Shawn Michaels might be 'Mr. WrestleMania,' but it could be argued that 'Taker is just as big a defining figure in the event's history, having starred in countless historically great matches at 'The Show Of Shows.' Then come the match stipulations. Would Hell In A Cell be half as fearful, imposing, and legendary if not for Undertaker's wars with Michaels, Mick Foley, and Triple H? Would more obtuse concepts like the Casket and Buried Alive gimmicks have even come into existence?
Nuggets like this ensure Undertaker's legacy will continue long after he has retired.
4. The Batista & Edge Feuds
While The Undertaker has undoubtedly grabbed the shovel to bury more than his fair share of opponents over the years, he has been a giving foe for many others. Brock Lesnar may never have scraped transcendent status if not for WrestleMania XXX, and 'Taker put over Kane huge in his early days, but some of his most satisfying work came in the mid-to-late '00s, when he was paired with hungry, talented borderline main-eventers ready to hit the next level.
His tanglings with Edge produced some of the best singles bouts of either man's career, starting with an awesome scrap at WrestleMania 24. They saved the best 'til last, though, going to war in a perfect PG-rated Hell In A Cell bout that showed the stipulation could still be compelling in a family-friendly setting, closing SummerSlam 2008 in memorable fashion.
Before that was Undertaker's equally successful rivalry with Batista, who proved an unlikely source of excellent in-ring chemistry for 'The Deadman.' Their clashes were simple, but effective: two big, tough bastards dropping bombs on each other, escalating in intensity with every new meeting. The result was 2007's best WWE feud, and an almighty rub for 'The Animal,' who came out smelling like roses.
3. The Ministry Of Darkness
Going back and viewing some of the Attitude Era's wackier content through a modern lens is difficult and unadvisable. Nostalgia is a powerful drug, but wrestling's evolution means much of the game-changing period's television now feels like empty calories, which is partly why that styling of programming can never come back.
This is certainly true of the Ministry of Darkness, but this writer is willing to bet a hefty sum that The Undertaker and his band of weird demonic goths scared the living sh*t out of you as a kid.
'Taker and his cult were awesome. A perfect fit for their place in time, their stuff would look like hokey bullsh*t if it were going down on Raw or SmackDown right now, but it worked. They were a genuinely distressing force in wrestling's edgiest period, and while the wheels fell off with the Higher Power reveal, most forget that the build to that moment was fantastic, generating huge amounts of intrigue around The Undertaker and his unholy army.
The Ministry had legs beyond the Higher Power and their Corporation merger, leading into 'Taker's hiatus and subsequent rebirth as the 'American Badass.' It's a shame they were pulled apart so early, but their daft, over-the-top shtick created some wild pantomime moments.
2. That First Kane Feud
WWE have never built a wrestler's introduction as effectively as Kane's in 1997.
The storytelling leading up to his Badd Blood: In Your House arrival was immense, with Paul Bearer telling tales of The Undertaker's long lost half-brother returning for revenge, having almost burned to death in the fire that killed their parents. We were drip-fed new details every week. Initially teased as Undertaker's "biggest secret," we eventually learned Kane's origins. This was a source of torment for 'Taker, who was shamed as the man behind the fire, and now, the burned sibling was coming for blood.
An explosive pay-per-view arrival saw Kane arrive by Bearer's side, tearing the Hell In A Cell door away as 'Taker wrestled Shawn Michaels. He planted him with a Tombstone Piledriver, and thus began one of the Attitude Era's most important programmes, immediately establishing 'The Big Red Machine' as a major force, and giving Undertaker a rival (and eventual partner) he'd be tied to for the remainder of his career.
Subsequent Kane vs. Undertaker feuds didn't hit the same heights (particularly their historically bad 2010 run against each other), but how could they? The duo set an impossibly high bar back in 1997.
1. The 'Dream Match' Era
The most depressing thing about The Undertaker's current run is that the one before it (when he transformed into the biggest special attraction WWE has ever seen) was incredible, and in our view, the most compelling period of his career.
'Taker's unbelievable 'Dream Match' run began with Batista at WrestleMania 23. An age-defying series of classics followed, with the Edge HIAC clash delivering big the following year, then Undertaker's two transcendent bouts with Shawn Michaels at 25 and 26. Separating one from the either requires splitting hairs. For many, those matches remain the peak of WWE's dramatic main event style, and any differences in quality are negligible.
Two certified bangers against Triple H followed, then, finally, the last truly outstanding match of Undertaker's career - versus CM Punk at WrestleMania XXIX. He has worked several decent-go-good clashes since then, but never anything on the same level.
Undertaker was already a surefire Hall Of Fame inductee before all this, but these are the bouts that made his streak legendary. Every year, without fail, you could rely on the big man to deliver at WrestleMania, and while age was always going to catch up with him, the period's end will always be lamentable.