8 Ups And 11 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 33

Plenty of good matches, but plenty of skippable moments in 7-hour PPV.

Undertaker WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

The Showcase of the Immortals has come and gone, and it left a few truly memorable moments, though the biggest ones might not be the ones that the WWE owners want them to be.

We saw the Undertaker possibly hang up his boots for good this time, losing at WrestleMania for only the second time in his illustrious career, marking him at 23-2. We saw Roman Reigns, who conquered Taker, receive huge boos despite being positioned as the big guy for the company. We saw 13 matches get crammed into a whopping seven-hour program that felt like it would never end.

And we saw the return of Matt and Jeff Hardy, as the brothers entered the Raw Tag Team Championship tag team triple threat ladder match and fig right in, instantly becoming one of the biggest fan favorites in WWE. And then they won the tag titles at the absolute right time.

We saw five titles change hands Sunday night, including both world titles, the tag titles, the United States title and the SmackDown Women’s Championship. That’s quite the busy Mania. Throw in a game ShaneMcMahon and an equally up-to-the-task Seth Rollins and you have an event that is worth watching for the big moments, but not something you should without blocking plenty of time.

So let’s find out what made the cut and what got cut...


DOWNS…

11. Crash Test McMahon

Shane McMahon WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

At SummerSlam last year, AJ Styles had a match of the year candidate against John Cena, defeating the legendary performer in an instant classic. He went on to become WWE World Champion and carried SmackDown for several months.

Sunday night, he fought a 47-year-old executive who was wrestling just his third match since 2009… and he was so evenly matched that he nearly lost a few times.

Yes, wrestling is predetermined, and yes, Shane McMahon is an impressive athlete (though JBL’s cries that he’s built like a linebacker was laughable), but come on. You have to give negative points for Shane taking AJ to the limit like that, kicking out of the Styles Clash and whatnot.

It’s not a huge negative – Shane did have a pretty decent garbage brawl with AJ and impressed as usual – but when it becomes McMahonaMania, it deserves a “down,” even a mild one.


10. Gratification Too Soon

Bayley WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

So let’s make sure we have this straight: The fatal four-way elimination match for the Raw Women’s Championship boiled down to Charlotte Flair and defending champ Bayley, with the Huggable One retaining, right?

Not commenting on the match itself, but what in the blue hell was the point of having Charlotte lose the title at Fastlane then? She had an unbeaten PPV streak going and was the champ. Instead of beating Bayley at Fastlane and then losing to her at Mania (exactly like she did Sunday), they blew what could have been an awesome moment.

So instead of that WrestleMania moment that WWE so cherishes, we got Bayley dropping a Macho Man elbow to defend her title in a good but not great title match. Talk about missing the boat.


9. Not Ready For Primetime

WWE.com

One year ago, Baron Corbin won the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal in his debut match at WrestleMania.

On Sunday, he battled Dean Ambrose for the WWE Intercontinental Championship during the Mania kickoff show. And boy, it has to be said, Corbin’s in-ring career might have already peaked. Ambrose and Corbin had a sloppy, bowling-shoe-ugly match (thanks JR!) with a dull brawl and botched moves. The crowd, hot for the Cruiserweight Championship match an hour earlier, seemingly dozed off for parts of the match.

We know that Ambrose is perfectly capable of having good-to-great matches, so you’ve got to lump the fault at Corbin’s feet. Thankfully, Ambrose successfully defended his IC title, meaning that Corbin not only left Mania empty-handed, but he underperformed and left a stinker at the biggest show of the year. That’s not a good recipe for future success.


8. Mixed Tag A Mixed Bag

WrestleMania 33 John Cena Nikki Bella
WWE.com

One of the best parts of SmackDown since the roster split has been the ascension of the Miz as an upper-midcard heel. So naturally, he and wife Maryse got to play second fiddle to a Total Bellas angle at WrestleMania.

The feud between the two couples wasn’t entirely bad (though it originally looked to be Dean Ambrose and Renee Young who were gearing up for the rivalry), with Miz and Maryse doing a brutal takedown of John Cena and Nikki Bella’s relationship. And Cena and Nikki used some colorful language to show their anger.

The match itself was absolutely nothing special, with Miz getting cheered like crazy as he slow-walked through a pedestrian match with Cena. Of course, the end saw Cena and Bella hit their finishers for a double pin. And then… Cena proposed to Nikki in the middle of the ring. Obviously, she said “yes.”

Cute moment, but it was a super-clichéd moment as well.


7. Battle Royal A Sideshow

WrestleMania 33 Gronk
WWE.com

Boy, WWE sure loves its crossovers, doesn’t it?

It’s no secret ever since the first WrestleMania that WWE tends to go back to the well of celebrities in that elusive search for mainstream appeal. The company went to the well during the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, having Mojo Rawley’s good friend (in real life) and NFL superstar Rob Gronkowski jump into the ring and take out Jinder Mahal toward the end of the contest, then celebrated with Mojo after he won.

Turning the battle royal into a sideshow in its fourth year just further devalued the event, from a potential breakout moment to an opportunity to get mentioned on social media and on ESPN. On one hand, you can’t blame WWE for trying to get some ink, but on the other, Gronk isn’t Ronda Rousey. It isn’t like this will be talked about after Monday.


6. Why Bother Showing Up?

Braun Strowman Big Show WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

Sami Zayn. Big Show. Braun Strowman. Dolph Ziggler. Luke Harper. American Alpha. SmackDown Tag Team Champions the Usos.

Following up on the previous point, all of these wrestlers got to trot down the ramp and lay on the ropes for 10-15 minutes before getting tossed to set up an NFL player getting into the ring and taking out Jinder Mahal.

In the lead-up to Mania, Zayn had to win a career-threatening match just to enter the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal. Strowman versus Show was hyped to be a big showdown. Harper had just broken out and broken free from the Wyatt Family. American Alpha were the former tag champs, and the Usos are the current champs.

All of them essentially were cannon fodder to be tossed in the lead-up to Rob Gronkowski bowling over Mahal and then celebrating with Mojo Rawley. This writer isn’t opposed to WWE trying to get mainstream appeal, but looking at the list of wrestlers who essentially were bit players as a result that’s enough to make this a negative.


5. Women Die In Death Slot

Natalya Naomi Carmella WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

Ugh. Just ugh.

The SmackDown Women’s Championship match would have been better off being held during the kickoff show rather than being shoehorned into the main PPV. As it turned out, the six-pack challenge was given about one minute per participant, and it ended with Naomi in her hometown winning the title she was forced to vacate earlier this year due to injury.

Beyond that, at least we can say there were no restholds in the match. And James Ellsworth got a Bexploder suplex for his troubles. Beyond that, it was a speedy mess to get in everyone’s 30 seconds of moves, pinfalls and breakups.

But hey, they all got to make their entrances and have a match. Soooo… yay?


4. Another ‘Epic’ Triple H Match

Tripel H Stephanie McMahon Wrestlemania 33
WWE.com

You have to wonder if the knee injury to Seth Rollins was part of the storyline simply to slow him down to Triple H’s speed. Because the unsanctioned match between the two really was a one-man show.

Rollins wrestling on one leg still carried the match, flinging himself around the ring with suicide dives, a crossbody off the ringpost to the floor, a frogsplash and a superplex into a Falcon Arrow. The Architect also took a beating from The Game, with Triple H methodically (that’s a polite way to put it) attacking Rollins’ knee and trading Pedigree attempts about 20 times.

It wasn’t a bad match, but it was long. On a show that already was long. Knowing they were running so far into the night already, maybe they should have trimmed about 5-10 minutes off this bout. But then again, it’s a Triple H WrestleMania match, which means we have to go for the most epic contest possible which means 25 minutes at least.


3. Anticlimactic Afterthought

Bray Wyatt Randy orton
WWE.com

How much does it suck to be Randy Orton at times? You win the Royal Rumble and then win the WWE World Championship at WrestleMania, and it’s barely a blip on the radar.

Orton’s 13th world title win was met with quiet applause, especially compared to the thunderous ovation Brock Lesnar received when he won the Universal Championship in the following match. The contest itself was a sham of sorts, with more focus going to a trick that saw maggots, worms and cockroaches being projected from above onto the ring mat like a screen. It was portrayed as “mindgames” from Bray Wyatt, but all it did was make fans go “ick.”

After several minutes of pedestrian action, Orton hit an RKO “from outta nowhere” to become a smiling babyface champion again. Yay.

Seriously, this could have been on the kickoff show.


2. Ultimate Thrill Ride Goes Off The Rails

WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

For the first half of the PPV, WrestleMania was looking like it was going to be a pretty damn good affair. The Cruiserweight Championship and United States Championship matches were entertaining, and opening bout and Raw women’s title match were both good.

But after the Hardys returned and shocked the world, the wheels fell off Mania pretty quickly. When you’re looking at the clock and realizing that there have been more than four hours of wrestling and you still have two world title matches, a women’s title bout and an Undertaker match to go, you know things aren’t right.

If the last few matches really delivered memorable (in a good way) moments, then a lot could be forgiven, but instead, we got completely forgettable WWE World Championship and SmackDown Women’s Championship matches, an abridged WWE Universal Championship contest and an underachieving bout between Taker and Roman Reigns.

The “ultimate thrill ride” became a yawner by the end, part due to the length, part due to the content. It’s a shame they couldn’t carry the momentum from the first half to the second.


1. Lather, Rinse, Repeat If Necessary

WrestleMania ROman Reigns Undertaker
WWE.com

Four spears. Four Superman punches. A bunch of chair shots. A drive-by dropkick. And a Samoan Drop. That might have been the entire arsenal of offense that Roman Reigns used during his third consecutive main event WrestleMania match, this one against the Undertaker.

Reigns closed out what had started out as a really good Mania with a wounded duck of a match, a slow, plodding affair that didn’t make Taker look like an old gunslinger. It made him look like a shell of his former self. And Roman was the jerky “hero” who took his spot.

If it wasn’t for the end and the postscript, there’s no way this should have closed out WrestleMania. It was a troll job of every fan who’s booed Roman consistently for the past two years, as he’s shown zero character development since then, but we’re supposed to love him now that he’s defeated the Phenom. Plus, it simply wasn’t a good match.

Sorry if you disagree, but it objectively wasn’t a good match, and it was the wrong dynamic. If you have a guy you view as your babyface of the future who gets booed more than cheered, having him beat an all-time legend into retirement isn’t going to make that situation better. Period.


UPS…

8. Stephanie Takes One For The Team

Triple H Stephanie McMahon Seth Rollins WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

One of the biggest complaints among diehard wrestling fans is that Stephanie McMahon is one of the worst villains out there because she never gets her comeuppance.

Sunday, she sort of did.

Stephanie accompanied her husband Triple H to the ring for his match against Seth Rollins. Like any good wife/valet, she interfered on her husband’s behalf a couple times, but the last attempt proved fatal. She found herself on the apron and almost got knocked off by a charging Triple H, only for him to slam on the brakes and turn around into a superkick. His momentum knocked him into Steph, which sent her flying off the apron and through a table.

The fans loved it, and Triple H was so distraught that he turned around into a Pedigree for the loss. Now, some will say that’s proof that Stephanie does get hers every now and again but this was basically her husband falling into her, not someone putting her in her place for her mouthing off or being a horrible boss.

Big difference, and not enough to wipe the slate clean. But she took a big bump for the match, and for that, she deserves credit.


7. A Garbagy Brawl

WrestleMania Shane McMahon Aj Styles
WWE.com

While you have to give down marks for 47-year-old executive Shane McMahon hanging with one of the best wrestlers in the world, his opening bout with AJ Styles was an entertaining mess.

Styles held the match together, wrestling himself at a couple points to make Shane look even better, but McMahon did his usual admirable job serving as an insane crash test dummy. C’mon, a shooting star press? Are you kidding? Still, the match had the kind of back-and-forth that drew the fans in and got a huge reaction, especially with Styles winning.

In the end, negative points for Shane as a serious competitor, but kudos for putting together an entertaining enough bout, with the right man winning. The match did its job in getting fans into the moment.


6. Raw Women Put In Work

WrestleMania 33 Raw Women
WWE.com

It seemed as if the Raw Women’s Championship match was a bit rushed, but the four women did a nice job putting together a good title match.

Nia Jax naturally had a huge target on her back as the biggest threat, and she was taken down and out by all three other women with a triple powerbomb and a dogpile. She didn’t really get a chance to shine, but Nia at least was portrayed as a serious threat who could only be stopped by all three women.

Sasha Banks had a nice mini-match with Charlotte Flair, but she wasn’t the story Sunday night, so she bowed out next. The portion between Bayley and Charlotte felt a bit truncated, but it was otherwise OK, with Bayley overcoming Charlotte’s attacks to her knee to drop the Big Elbow for the win.

If this match had been given a few more minutes to breathe, it could have been really, really good, but as it was, it was perfectly acceptable.


5. Cruiserweights Kick Off The Night Right

WrestleMania 33 Neville Austin Aries
WWE.com

Throughout the build to WrestleMania, this column has repeatedly stated that if Neville and Austin Aries got some time for their match, they’d have the crowd won over.

Sure enough, the Cruiserweight Championship match got enough time for A-Double and the King of the Cruiserweights to shine. Neville and Aries kept it to the ground for parts of the match, but they picked up the pace a few times with some awesome exchanges, most notably toward the end, starting with Neville’s snap German suplex and a series of reversals and counters leading to Aries’ super-hurricanrana and 450 splash.

In the end, Neville did what all good heel champions do – cheat – and gouged Austin’s damaged eye socket to escape the Last Chancery, hit the Red Arrow, and left with his title. For the first Cruiserweight Championship match at Mania in more than a decade, this was a pretty good showing.


4. Best Friends, Better Enemies

Chris Jericho Kevin Owens WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

The United States Championship match between Chris Jericho and Kevin Owens was exactly what you would have expected: a barn-burner of a good match.

Jericho and Owens’ hatred could be felt through the screen as they laid into each other, and the fact that the two were a tandem for so long showed as they countered in succession a KO frogsplash, a Lionsault and an Owens swanton bomb. Owens used the Walls of Jericho to try to get a submission. Both men kicked out of each other’s finishers – with KO getting one finger on the rope to break up a pinfall after a Codebreaker.

Despite Jericho deserving revenge for being attacked at the Festival of Friendship, it made perfect sense for KO to win the United States Championship at WrestleMania. Owens is the star on the rise, while Y2J – despite the old school countdown intro – is in the twilight of his career.

Still, the two of them had one hell of a match Sunday night.


3. Dominance Done Right

WrestleMania 33 Brock Lesnar Goldberg
WWE.com

The first time Brock Lesnar and Goldberg met at a PPV (WrestleMania XX), their 15-minute match was met with thunderous boos (because both were leaving WWE). The second time was at Survivor Series, and their 86-second affair was met with shock.

Sunday’s encounter lasted considerably longer than Survivor Series, but it didn’t overstay its welcome, with Brock exorcising his demons and finally defeating Goldberg and becoming the new WWE Universal Champion. To do so, he had to overcome four spears and a Jackhammer, but Lesnar also delivered 10 German suplexes and a decisive F-5 for the win. He also had a nifty leapfrog to avoid a fifth spear.

The match itself was never going to a four-star affair, but by keeping it simple and just delivering knockout punches for five minutes, we got a big fight feel and a memorable bout that crowned a new part-time wrestler as Raw champion.


2. Farewell To Taker(?)

Undertaker WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

If this truly is the end of Undertaker’s long and legendary career, then it’s a sad moment for multiple reasons, but rather than lament how things could have been done better, we should praise the Phenom for his sacrifices and efforts throughout the years.

Taker symbolically hung ‘em up after losing to Roman Reigns Sunday night, which ran his WrestleMania record to a still-mindboggling 23-2. There literally has never been anyone before like him, and there damn sure won’t be anyone like him in the future. The Deadman certainly had some downs in his career, but he was a top performer for longer than almost anyone in WWE.

His career will be remembered for its longevity and staying power, but also for how he managed to reinvent or retweak his character to stay relevant well past the point that anyone thought possible. Taker had classic matches with numerous wrestlers and made WrestleMania his own personal playground.

Time will tell if this retirement is for real or if he’ll turn up in a ring again, but for now, thank you Taker.


1. Broken, But Back On Top

WrestleMania 33 Matt Hardy
WWE.com

The Royal Rumble wishes it could pull off a shocker like this.

Just as the Raw Tag Team Championship triple threat ladder match was about to begin, New Day walked out and announced that a fourth team was joining the fray. Many fans simply assumed that the WrestleMania hosts – who also are the longest reigning tag champs in WWE history – were talking about themselves.

But instead, Broken Matt and Jeff Hardy returned to WWE to enter the match. They would go on to not only surprise everyone, but complete the shocker by winning the tag titles, sending the crowd into a frenzy.

To their credit, Matt and Jeff looked right at home, and the other three teams held up their ends of the match, delivering a truly memorable moment that will be hard to top in years to come.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.