8 Ups And 6 Downs From Last Night's WWE Raw (Oct 8)
Heel turns, big returns, un-retirements. No run-of-the-mill episode.
Well, you can’t say that Raw wasn’t eventful Monday night.
WWE jammed a ton of stuff into three hours on Raw, and it actually could qualify as too much, with the writers forcing two heel turns and three teams teasing dissension. That’s an awful lot outside Vince Russo’s heyday.
In addition to all of that, we got a Paul Heyman promo, a Nia Jax appearance (and loss), Hall-of-Famers, and the return of a masked Latino superstar (no, not that one).
Oh, and we saw one of the greatest wrestlers of all-time announce he will come out of retirement… to work a tag match.
And those are just the high points of Raw.
Part of this is likely necessitated by WWE having two PPVs in the next four weeks, one an all-female event by choice (Evolution) and the other an all-male PPV by host country fiat (Crown Jewel). With storylines needed for matches to fill both cards, you end up with an eventful program.
So you’d be forgiven if you missed some stuff Monday night. But WWE shouldn’t get a pass for cramming too much into the program and recycling too many tropes.
With that said, let’s find out what won over the fans and what drew a “boring” chant. Let’s get to it…
Downs...
6. Bowling Shoe Mode
Jim Ross used to have a phrase to describe a disaster of a match: bowling shoe ugly. It was obvious when JR said this that the match was just horrendous.
We got a match that fit the bill Monday night, with Ronda Rousey and the Bella Twins facing the Riott Squad. Brie in particular looked bad, barely making it over for a snapmare and a hiptoss from Sarah Logan. (It was so bad, it was reminiscent of Tough Enough with the trainers yelling at the contestants and threatening to throw them out of the competition.)
The match itself didn’t have any real flow either, just meandered along. Even the end was herky-jerky, with Rousey having to wait to apply the armbar until the rest of the Riott Squad could try to run in and the Bellas could make the saves.
In the end, the bout was a vehicle for the post-match angle, but still, it wasn’t a good-looking match.
5. Jax Loses Via Countout
WWE is in a somewhat tough spot with Nia Jax.
They clearly want to keep her on camera while she’s in the running for a People’s Choice award, but she’s not in the title picture. They want her to remain dominant, but since she’s not in a title picture, they don’t want her plowing through opponents, especially other wrestlers they want to keep strong.
So pitting Ember Moon against Jax presented a problem Monday night. The solution: have Moon win via countout by beating the count after Nia plowed into the ring apron lightboard. Ember got the win, but Jax still looked strong in the brief match.
However, Jax also looked foolish, unable to competently wrestle her opponent and falling victim to her own carelessness. WWE would have done better to have the two wrestle a tag match against jobbers or do a handicapped match.
But this felt like a waste of time.
4. Selective Editing
Heels have long used footage they want you to see to make their points during in-ring segments. However, that is often predicated on one thing: the babyfaces (or at least the announcers) will point out the inconsistencies.
That didn’t happen Monday night when Triple H and Shawn Michaels showed footage from Super Show-Down of Hunter’s match against The Undertaker. The footage left out much of HBK’s constant interference, dumbing it down to one interjection and one superkick. It left out the numerous attempts to interfere (although it was no-DQ, so it was allowed) and other interjections.
And then they cut right to the Brothers of Destruction breaking up a kumbaya moment to attack HBK and HHH (the dastardly villains!). Now, while this isn’t a horrible crime, the fact that it was just treated as gospel when anyone could watch the PPV and see that HBK was all but asking to be attacked leaves this as a negative.
Maybe Taker will come out to correct the record next week, but it just felt a little wrong to overlook the facts of what happened 48 hours earlier.
3. Another Heel Turn?
When they formed as a duo several weeks back, this column wondered if we’d soon see Bobby Roode turn on Chad Gable. With Gable blind-tagging into the matches late and stealing/securing the win, it seemed to be setting the table for that outcome.
We saw this happen again Monday night, with Gable tagging in as Roode was closing in on a win against The Ascension. Gable nailed a German suplex with a bridge for the pin, and Roode immediately looked perturbed. He appeared ready to confront Gable, only for the Authors of Pain to interrupt things.
The problem here is that we had already seen two acts turn heel: Bobby Lashley and the Bella Twins. Seeing a third potentially go from fan favorite to villain was just too much, even if the confrontation was stopped. (Hell, we also got a brief tease of Nia Jax turning on Ember Moon before she hugged her.)
Some agent booking the show has got to see this and say something. And so now we’ll probably get that meltdown in the next week or so, meaning three acts will have changed sides in a very short span. That’s a lot.
2. More Shades Of Gray?
As if booking two heel turns and teasing tag team dissension on the undercard wasn’t bad enough, the Raw main event featured even more group turmoil.
Braun Strowman lectured his tag team partners before their six-man tag match, and screamed at them during the bout, creating a staredown with Drew McIntyre briefly. They managed to stay on the same page and won, with Dean Ambrose taking the fall. Ambrose, who has been teased as turning on The Shield, then walked off alone to close Raw, leaving us wondering whether he was ditching his brothers.
So let that sink in: Bobby Lashley turns heel (with Kevin Owens presumably turning face); the Bella Twins turn heel; Bobby Roode is about to confront Chad Gable; Braun berates his partners; and Ambrose walks out on his teammates.
All in one show. Again, who is supposed to be paying attention to all of this stuff? Some of it might have been simmering for a while, but this is Vince Russo territory for simultaneous turmoil.
1. Going Back On Your Word
A lot is going to be made of Shawn Michaels coming out of retirement after 8-1/2 years, and it’s going to be a mixed bag, so let’s line both sides up in this column.
First, the negative…
In an era where nearly everyone pulls the “never say never” routine, Michaels’ retirement felt special, unique. He was almost dignified by his refusal of a quick payday. And then it was flushed away over a post-match beatdown, not some long, drawn-out angle to coax him back into action.
Worse, HBK’s return will come not in a high-profile singles match at a major PPV where tens of thousands of diehard WWE fans can celebrate, but in a tag match at a glorified house show in Saudi Arabia.
The reasoning for the match – a loss of respect because of a post-match beatdown – felt forced. And while that shouldn’t really count against this (after all, a perfect reason is impossible to find), there had to be a better way.
Lastly, there’s always the very real possibility that Michaels can’t live up to expectations. After 8-plus years, he’s bound to have some serious ring-rust. And if he can’t at least do a passable job, he runs the risk of damaging his pristine in-ring image.
All of this is working against Michaels. Oh, and it’s yet another D-Generation X reunion…
Ups...
8. Graves Speaks Truth To Power
Corey Graves is this writer’s spirit animal – at least in one instance.
During a Mixed-Match Challenge rematch between Finn Balor & Bayley versus Jinder Mahal & Alicia Fox, Graves commented on the team names, Team B ‘n’ B and Team Mahalicia: “Why does every team name begin with the word ‘team’?”
This was a very noticeable thing when the tag division got a few new pairings in 2012-13, with Team Hell No and Team Rhodes Scholars being two of the more prominent duos. There was no reason to call them “Team…” anything. The Rhodes Scholars or even Hell No would have worked fine.
The “Team” thing was dumb then, and it’s dumb now. Thanks to Corey Graves for calling it out.
7. Hall-Of-Fame Tag Team
“Card subject to change” is a disclaimer that is on just about every wrestling event, often too small to notice. But it can have a huge impact on the event.
Case in point, Evolution is three weeks away, and WWE took two of its matches and changed them, merging them into one. Trish Stratus was slated to face Alexa Bliss, while Lita was scheduled to wrestle Mickie James. But Monday night, Bliss and James suggested teaming up, so Stratus brought out her tag partner (and best friend) Lita.
In reality, this probably makes sense, as Trish and Lita haven’t wrestled real singles matches in 12 years. Putting both of them in singles bouts on PPV might not be the best move, so having them team up might allow them to hide any weak spots. (This is also an argument in favor of Shawn Michaels returning in a tag match after 8 years.)
The match should be an enjoyable mix of nostalgia and storyline, with Bliss being almost a perfect snot-nosed heel who doesn’t respect the Hall-of-Famers. We’ll just have to see how the match itself holds up.
6. Conquistador Conquers
The moment you saw the gold costume, you just had to know something was afoot.
The Conquistador made his return to WWE Monday night, and thankfully, WWE did not play it too seriously. Michael Cole immediately wondered whether it was Jose Luis Rivera or Jose Estrada (who portrayed the original Los Conquistadores tag team in the late 80s), while Corey Graves asked whether it could be Edge & Christian or the Hardy Boyz (who each took a turn as the golden duo in the early 2000s).
So it was only natural that the Conquistador won the battle royal and then unmasked as Kurt Angle, sending the Olympic gold medalist to the WWE World Cup at Crown Jewel.
Kudos for using the Conquistador gimmick sparingly and not taking it seriously, which made the outcome obvious but still enjoyable without being insulting.
5. Another Classic Heel Move
As “constable,” Baron Corbin was almost unbearable parroting Stephanie McMahon’s opinions to babyface GM Kurt Angle.
But as a heel GM, Corbin has found his stride, doing little things to really solidify his standing as a villain who will take advantage of his position to advance his career. Monday, Baron tried just that by assembling a group of no-names to face in a battle royal. He proclaimed that by putting together this match, he was being a benevolent GM, which made it even better.
Of course, Corbin overcame most of his opponents, but he failed to check one of the wrestler’s credentials before the match.
Still, this worked, and Corbin got his comeuppance after trying to overstep his bounds as an authority figure.
4. AOP Continues Path Of Destruction
It’s pretty clear that WWE is pulling the trigger on the Authors of Pain as a dominant tag team in the near future.
The duo has been on an upward trajectory ever since teaming with Baron Corbin against The Shield a few weeks back, running over established tag teams in muggings after matches. They took out The Ascension and Bobby Roode & Chad Gable Monday night, pretty much elevating themselves over the lower tier of tag teams without having to beat them.
Although the champs are heels (Dolph Ziggler & Drew McIntyre), it seems likely that AOP will be in a position to challenge for the titles in the coming months, either through transitional champs or even a heel/heel dynamic.
Either way, it was good to see that AOP is still being treated like a destructive force rather than WWE taking its foot off the pedal.
3. Bellas Show True Colors
This should not be construed as justifying the return of the Bella Twins, but if they’re going to be back, then this is better.
After having to listen to Renee Young try to sell the Bella Twins as trailblazers in the women’s evolution, we finally got to see Nikki and Brie ditch any pretense of being smiling babyfaces, turning heel by attacking Ronda Rousey post-match. The Raw Women’s Champion thought she had allies, but instead she had a target on her back, with Nikki presumably set for a title match at Evolution.
The Bellas are lousy babyfaces on their own. (Brie is good alongside her husband, however.) But they’re natural heels, mocking their opponents and double-teaming them.
Maybe they’ll demand respect for being trailblazers and get booed for it, and the announcers can stop trying to plug them as saviors of the women’s division.
2. A Much-Needed Double-Turn
When Lio Rush was introduced as Bobby Lashley’s hype man, things felt a little… off. Rush is an obnoxious heel on 205 Live (not that the majority of Raw viewers also watch the cruiserweights, but still), so it didn’t line up.
So when Rush had the mic during Lashley’s match against Kevin Owens on Raw, it became clear what the ultimate objective was. Lashley, who has been mired in go-nowhere feuds and a babyface purgatory on Raw, broke out of it Monday night. Lio taunted KO and tried to lead the Chicago crowd in a “Lashley” chant, which went nowhere.
Rush distracted Owens when KO rallied, leading to a Lashley victory. Then, with KO down and hurt, Lashley returned to wrap the Prize Fighter’s leg around the post a few times, just to really sink it in.
Just like that, Lashley is a heel, and Owens (presumably) is a babyface, which also makes sense given how much fans want to cheer him. Smart.
1. Return Of The Heartbreak Kid
So while Shawn Michaels coming out of retirement has some serious concerns, there are some positives to consider…
Michaels is long overdue to cash in on his marketability. There’s only so much for him to do as a mouthpiece or by making periodic appearances. It’s his work between the ropes that really draws people in, so he’s been leaving money on the table for years.
So many others have come back after seemingly retiring for good, so why not? Truth is, even if HBK isn’t even 75% of the old Michaels, it still will be better than half the roster. And by returning in a tag match with Triple H, Undertaker and Kane, the old guys can hide each other’s weak spots and exist within their own universe, away from other wrestlers who would easily be overshadowed.
In addition, fans have clamored for this for years, so now you’re finally getting it, so stop complaining.