8 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE Extreme Rules 2017

A top star is buried in epic fashion amid good wrestling, poor direction.

samoa joe extreme rules
WWE.com

For a PPV branded as possibly altering the landscape of WWE forever, it sure felt like just another Sunday night.

Extreme Rules provided some pretty good in-ring action and offered a nice escape, but it also signaled the possible death knell for one of the former top stars from NXT. It gave a spotlight to a new addition to the roster so he could sing, and then do nothing else. It billed itself as “extreme” with one match carrying a stipulation that if the rules were broken, the champion would lose his title.

This isn’t to say that Extreme Rules was a bad event, but the positive mostly fall in WWE’s strongest suit these days: the wrestlers on the roster are capable of delivering good-to-great matches any given night. So if you give them time, they will most likely turn in solid performances and entertain.

Without a doubt, the biggest kick in the gut was watching WWE’s best can’t-miss star who appeals to a different demographic, Bayley, get squashed in about five minutes. A female wrestler whose character in NXT was tailor-made to draw in young girls as fans has been mishandled on Raw from the start, and Sunday night, she was beaten to a pulp and buried. If this were the territory days, you’d think she was packing up and heading off elsewhere.

With that said, let’s find out what walloped the competition and what got battered with a kendo stick. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

6. Elias ‘Sings’… And That’s All

Brand-specific PPVs often are running short on matches, so they bulk up the runtime by having various segments, whether backstage interviews or skits.

Bringing Elias Samson out to serenade the Baltimore crowd with a song about how dirty and depressing their city is was a good way to get cheap heat, but really? That’s all WWE could bring to the table? Why wouldn’t you use that opportunity to have some local jobber out there to lose to Samson in a squash? It would’ve added all of three minutes to the PPV and given fans more of a reason to dislike the Drifter (is he still called that, or has his nickname drifted away?).

Stuff like that is frustrating, because the song was a good way to rile fans up, but then having him maul some no-name opponent would’ve served more of a purpose. On its own, the song just fell flat.


5. One More For The Bad Guys

miz maryse
WWE.com

Six matches, five won by the heels.

Go ahead and check the results. Miz, Alexa Bliss, Cesaro & Sheamus, Neville and Samoa Joe all emerged victorious in title matches or #1 contender matches, making this a PPV that really should be considered a downer (emotionally) overall. Seriously, unless you’re a huge Sasha Banks or Rich Swann fan, this was a bad night for babyfaces and fans of them.

And true, heels should win matches. There have been legit complaints before that WWE has had weak villains. But someone clearly didn’t look at the overall picture before booking these matches for Sunday night. Sure, we got two new champions, but when looking at the overall picture of Raw right now, the babyfaces got it handed to them at Extreme Rules.

A lot of seasoned fans watch for good wrestling, but ultimately, you want angles in which (at least occasionally) the babyface triumphs. And while that won’t happen all the time, you wouldn’t expect a PPV to surface where the heels all win. It’s not a cardinal sin, but it’s a damn odd and deflating thing.


4. The Odd Couple, And Not In A Good Way

apollo crews titus
WWE.com

Can someone explain, is Apollo Crews’ character turning heel, confused, or stupid?

One of the three has to be true, because there’s no other good reason for him to be paired up with Titus O’Neil. For months, Titus has been playing the same character: a low-rent, heel agent who can’t attract or retain clients. So why would Apollo, ostensibly a babyface, enlist with Titus? (See the above three possibilities.)

Since their pairing, Titus has berated a friend of Apollo’s (Kalisto), encouraged him to cheat in matches, and barked so many orders that it’s cost him a match. And then Sunday, O’Neil got up on the apron and provided another distraction, allowing Kalisto to hit Salida del Sol for the win. So again, which of the three reasons explains why Apollo remains with Titus?


3. Extreeeeme?

bayley marks
WWE.com

It’s the one night of the year when WWE gets extreme… except Money in the Bank, Hell in a Cell and Tables, Ladders & Chairs.

Seriously, these themed PPVs are misleading as hell at times and do themselves a disservice. Case in point, Sunday’s event that featured six matches, with only three carrying an “extreme” stipulation: women’s kendo stick match, tag team cage match, and a fatal five-way match (no DQ or countouts). Compare that to 2011’s Extreme Rules PPV, which had a last man standing match, tag team strap match, falls count anywhere match, loser leaves WWE match, ladder match, lumberjack match and triple threat steel cage match.

The TLC PPV each year features more “extreme rules” matches. Hell, one of this year’s bout was an Intercontinental Championship contest where the champ would lose his title if he was disqualified. The champ had to extremely obey the rules!

It’s as if WWE realized the title of the PPV a couple weeks ago and half-heartedly tossed stipulations onto a few matches and called it a day.


2. Systemic Problems

roman reigns finn balor
WWE.com

OK, let’s put aside the fact there are more ups than downs here. We can all acknowledge that Raw has an abundance of talented wrestlers who are capable of putting together solid in-ring action, which can make for an enjoyable evening.

However, it is absolutely undeniable that Raw is hemorrhaging viewers these days, and WWE overall has seen viewership drop dramatically in recent years. It has become embarrassingly bad, and no amount of excuses – Monday Night Football, hockey and basketball playoffs, people using DVRs or cutting the cord – can absolve the company.

There are problems here, too many to be noted or expounded upon in one item (it would be better suited for a separate article), but it has to be acknowledged at some point. WWE has to start doing something different to break the cycle. (No, the answer isn’t, “Push Roman Reigns harder.”) And while Extreme Rules wasn’t a bad show at all, it wasn’t the answer (or even the beginning of an answer) to that problem.

Samoa Joe winning a #1 contender’s match is a pleasant surprise, but you know what would be a dramatic change? Having him choke out Brock Lesnar next month and become the dominant heel champion. That’s just one idea/example. Give people compelling reasons to fight. Let them cut their own promos. Change things up soon, because while things aren’t 1995 WWE or 2000 WCW bad, it’s definitely, empirically not a high point right now.


1. Bayley’s Fall From Grace

bayley WWE
WWE.com

Can we all acknowledge and agree that WWE has no idea how to book Bayley as a character?

Bayley’s NXT run was a wonderful story arc of a fangirl overcoming her own inhibitions to become champion. Her run in WWE has been an awkward series of stumbles and missteps, with the Huggable One getting too much too soon, then regressing, then progressing, and now Sunday night, regressing again in what amounted to an extended squash match.

The naiveté that should define Bayley surfaced in recent weeks as an inability to “get extreme” to win her Raw Women’s Championship back from Alexa Bliss. On its own, that isn’t a terrible angle, but it’s just a continuation of making Bayley look incompetent after building her up as the face of the women’s division, knocking off Charlotte and retaining and WrestleMania.

It’s backwards booking that feels like WWE either is acknowledging they screwed up initially with Bayley and is trying to reset, or they are just completely lost with her. Either way, Sunday’s defeat basically took all the wind out of Bayley’s sails as a top-flight women’s division competitor, for now at least.


Ups...

8. At Least It Was Short

Bayley Bliss
WWE.com

We’ve already picked apart the Raw Women’s Championship match for what it represented in the de-evolution of Bayley, but let’s give credit for what it got right.

The match itself was mercifully short. Even more importantly, the women pulled the kendo stick down from the pole very early in the match, so we didn’t get 20 slow climbs to the top with the opponent stopping them at the last second. That would have been brutal.

And once Alexa Bliss got her hands on the kendo stick, she proceeded to waffle Bayley with it repeatedly, and save for a Bayley-to-Belly, it was all Bliss. The women’s champ beat Bayley soundly and pinned her in short order, rather than the match dragging out. It amounted to an extended squash, but if that’s what we were going to get, at least it didn’t go 10 minutes.


7. Swann Breaks Hometown Curse

rich swann sasha banks
WWE.com

We’ve referenced this multiple times before, but there’s a strange unwritten rule in WWE where wrestlers lose their matches in their hometowns.

We saw Bayley lose her Raw Women’s Championship last month in San Jose. Both Charlotte Flair and Sasha Banks lost the same title to each other in each other’s hometowns. And last week, AJ Styles lost to Dolph Ziggler in Atlanta, which is an hour away from his hometown of Gainesville, GA.

That’s why it was a pleasant surprise to see Rich Swann get the win in a mixed tag match with a Phoenix Splash on Noam Dar at Extreme Rules. Swann is a great hand to have on the roster with a tremendous personal story. There’s no indication of whether that factored into the decision, or if it just was in the cards, but it seems like wrestlers lose in their hometowns so often that this was completely out of the norm – in a good way.


6. Cruiserweights Bring The Goods

neville austin aries
WWE.com

It won’t be called a storied rivalry for the ages, but Neville and Austin Aries have now had a trio of good PPV matches for the WWE Cruiserweight Championship.

Sunday’s bout was a hard-hitting affair that saw both men attack different body parts throughout the contest, alternating between knees, arms and necks. There wasn’t a ton of flipping or dives, but the high-risk moves that were used worked nicely in concert with a series of submission moves. In the end, it was a Red Arrow to the back and an immediate Rings of Saturn that allowed Neville to retain.

It’s pretty safe to say that Neville’s career is looking better than it has at any point since he was called up to the main roster, and here’s hoping that his next feud (this has to be the end of this rivalry, right?) is just as good.


5. Commentary On-Point

neville austin aries
WWE.com

One of the regular negatives that pop up in these columns that readers groan about is inane or outright stupid commentary. Personally, poor announcing detracts greatly from the ability to enjoy a PPV or episode of Raw. It’s a vital part of the program, and it should be graded as such.

On the other side, really good commentary should be acknowledged, and Sunday’s announcing was pretty good by recent WWE standards. Michael Cole, Corey Graves and Booker T all did their homework and turned in solid work during Extreme Rules. Booker, often the one to go off the rails the most, was on-point with his analysis, while Graves was his usual awesome self, firing off a He-Man reference at one point.

Michael Cole provided a little history and context, even noting how the only other time a title changed hands on a DQ was Christian’s win over Randy Orton six years ago when he goaded Orton into a low blow by spitting on him. He was good enough that we can overlook calling Miz’s Busaiku Knee Kick (formerly Daniel Bryan’s finisher) a “running dropkick.”

Hey, and Booker T actually corrected Cole immediately afterward, so kudos there too.


4. Crews, Kalisto Air It Out

kalisto apollo crews
WWE.com

The feud between Kalisto and Apollo Crews (and Titus O’Neil) has been less than stellar during its weekly “development” on Raw: short, nothing matches, bad acting and a lack of logic.

But one thing that was always hanging in the background was the possibility that we’d get a good match out of it between the two. And we got a pretty decent bout out of them during the Extreme Rules kickoff show. Crews and Kalisto fired off a series of fast-paced, high-impact moves that got the Baltimore crowd rocking.

Kalisto’s Satellite DDT had fans out of their seats, and Crews catching a springboard attempt and turning it into a Samoan Drop were highlights during the match, which reminded fans just what both are capable of. It’s a shame that we won’t likely get more of this and instead will be “treated” to more “acting” between Titus and Apollo.


3. Tag Title Match Makes Right Call

sheamus cesaro
WWE.com

When Matt and Jeff Hardy returned to WWE at WrestleMania XXXIII, it was a legit shock and a great moment that fans won’t forget any time soon. And as much as they didn’t need them, the Hardys winning the Raw Tag Team Championships was a perfectly fine deal.

But two months later, the Hardys have shown that they’re far more than a nostalgia act and are capable of getting it done in the ring. So it made perfect sense for them to drop the tag titles to Cesaro & Sheamus Sunday night, and they did so in a match where they still looked strong and lost in a photo finish to escape from a steel cage.

The bout featured a lot of climbing and fighting on the top of the cage, but it ultimately came down to a race between Cesaro & Sheamus climbing over the top and Matt dragging his brother Jeff to and through the door. With the titles off their waists, the Hardys will likely find a new feud, possibly with a returning Revival, which could be outstanding.


2. Familiarity Breeds Excellence

the miz dean ambrose
WWE.com

WWE fans have seen Miz square off with Dean Ambrose a lot during the past year. Between their feud on SmackDown and now on Raw, they’ve battled physically and verbally over the Intercontinental Championship for six months now.

And while an easy argument can be made that these two should be forced to separate and find new dance partners, it was easy to see Sunday night what that familiarity could do for their match. Their IC title bout, which opened Extreme Rules, had a lot of solid action, with the underlying story that Ambrose couldn’t get disqualified or he’d lose his title. That provided a nice backdrop for the action, which was also bolstered by a raucous crowd.

When the stipulation was added to the match, you knew it could go one of two ways: either it would be groan-inducing, or it would work really well. And having Miz get desperate enough at the end to have Maryse slap him to try to draw a DQ was a great bit. John Cone played his part perfectly, threatening to DQ Ambrose multiple times, which got the fans to lose their minds at the thought of Dean losing the IC title like that.

While many might be tired of this rivalry, the match itself was a good one and a solid opener.


1. Fever-Pitch Ending

samoa joe roman reigns
WWE.com

When you put five top wrestlers into a match, you would hope you get something like what we got in the Extreme Rules main event: a solid bout that barely took a breath during the closing moments.

Fans can break down and criticize various aspects of the match (and sometimes, this column would do the same), but overall, this was a pretty good match, with everyone getting time and opportunities to shine. The crescendo toward the end, with Roman Reigns spearing Finn Balor and Samoa Joe through the timekeeper’s area and Seth Rollins frogsplashing Bray Wyatt through the announce table, was a definite high point, along with the rapid exchanges leading to Joe getting the submission win.

Joe versus Brock Lesnar is a different match, which is certainly a good thing. It’ll be interesting to see how that bout shakes out.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.