8 Worst Ever WWE Survivor Series Eliminations

Why are superstars suddenly so much easier to defeat at this PPV?

The Survivor Series is a pay-per-view concept created in 1987 as Vince McMahon attempted to take advantage of the overwhelming popularity of his promotion while simultaneously cutting into the success of the National Wrestling Alliance and Jim Crockett Promotions' Starrcade event. The event, carrying the tagline "teams of five strive to survive," would feature four 10-Man Tag Team Elimination matches pitting the top Superstars in the world against one another. Some of the top feuds of the time, most notably Hulk Hogan vs. Andre the Giant, would write their latest chapters at the event while a recently-turned-babyface Randy Savage attempted to avenge a guitar shot to the head by leading his team against the Honky Tonk Man and his gallery of rogues. The show was an overwhelming success but fans could not help but be disappointed by some of the eliminations they witnessed. In fact, over the course of its 27 years, Survivor Series has featured a number of head-scratching eliminations that really did nothing good for anyone involved. On November 23, World Wrestling Entertainment will present its annual November pay-per-view extravaganza and at the top of the card will be a traditional Survivor Series elimination tag bout pitting Team Cena against The Authority. With that match receiving all the attention ahead of the huge event, and so many big stars involved, there is sure to be an elimination or two that leaves fans wondering what WWE Creative was thinking. Whether by countout, disqualification or banana peel, WWE Superstars have had their nights ended in some of the most unique, and worst, ways possible. Here, now, is a look back at some of those moments.

8. The Hulkster Gets Counted Out - Survivor Series 1987

The inaugural Survivor Series not only was Vince McMahon's attempt to stick it to Jim Crockett Promotions and the NWA, it was also a showcase for his promotion's wildly successful headline rivalry between Hulk Hogan and Andre the Giant. Thus, when audiences tuned in to the November 26, 1987 pay-per-view, they fully expected to see the Hulkster and the Eighth Wonder of the World do battle on a grand stage for the first time since WrestleMania III. And why wouldn't they? Booking 101 dictated that the match gradually build heat before climaxing with Hogan and Andre waging war for the second straight time on a WWE extravaganza. Instead, McMahon changed things up, taking the opportunity to shine the spotlight on a bright young star and an aging veteran rather than his marquee, pop culture phenomenon. Hogan captained a team of popular midcard stars, including Paul Orndorff, Ken Patera, Don Muraco and newcomer Bam Bam Bigelow, while Andre headed up a team of dastardly villains the likes of Rick Rude, Butch Reed, One Man Gang and King Kong Bundy. Girth met power in the most anticipated match of the night and fans in Richfield, Ohio were hot for the entire contest. The idea of so many recognizable stars battling for supremacy in an event so heavily hyped was incredibly appealing and late in the bout, fans erupted as Hogan entered the contest and hammered away at his king sized rival. Before he could inflict too much damage to the giant, Bundy pulled him out of the ring. In typical Hulkster fashion, he fought back but, in the process, got himself counted out, much to the dismay of the Richfield fans, who could not believe that Hogan would not be around by the end of the contest to vanquish Andre. In his absence, Bigelow turned in a valiant effort but fell short, suffering a butterfly suplex from Andre, who was sole survivor of his team. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_uzUHW63xI The decision to eliminate Hogan prior to the culmination of the match was an incredibly risky one for McMahon. His foray into pay-per-view was still in its infancy and could have been irreparably damaged if his product wasn't as hot as it was. People paid their hard earned-money to see Hogan and Andre square off for the second time in 1987 and were not delivered that, instead treated to Bigelow's breakout performance. Had Bam Bam been able to keep his ego in check and became the next big breakout star for the company, the booking choice would have been forgivable. Since that was not the case, it is difficult to look back on the Hogan elimination as anything but one of the worst in Survivor Series history, especially the early years.

7. Crush Gets...Crushed? - Survivor Series 1996

In 1996, Crush returned to World Wrestling Entertainment following a very real stint in a correctional facility for buying steroids and the illegal possession of a handgun. Rather than shy away from the criminal record like today's image-conscience company would, the WWE of the era played the wrap sheet of the big Hawaiian up, hoping it would give further edge to one of their more recognizable villains. Crush returned to WWE with a new look, sporting dreadlocks, a nose ring and shark teeth tattooed on his forehead and a seemingly nastier, meaner attitude than ever before. He tore through some jobbers and lower card enhancement talent early in his run but soon found himself directionless, as did many of the Superstars involved in the third match of the evening at that November's Survivor Series. Only Marc Mero and Hunter Hearst Helmsley were involved in anything of note, while Rocky Maivia was making a much talked-about debut, leaving Crush as one of the fillers in a match full of them. As disappointing as his use would be heading into the event, his night in historic Madison Square Garden would only go from bad to worse. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xdb044_the-rock-s-wwe-debut-survivor-serie_sport Maivia was the star of the contest, without a doubt. All the hype surrounding his debut and he shined bright, impressing with his considerable athleticism. Crush was one of the heels tasked with playing tackling dummy for Maivia. He bumped around for the mostly basic offensive arsenal of the third-generation star but it was the way that he was eliminated that serves as the biggest disgrace. A guy that brought back and hyped as someone capable of being a top heel for a depleted roster, Crush was pinned by the rookie following a cross body block. You read that correctly, a cross body block. Not the shoulder breaker Maivia used to beat Goldust but a cross body block that even Barry Horowitz himself would have kicked out of. Sure, Crush would recover enough to join the Nation of Domination and feud with Ahmed Johnson but any credibility he had or any shot he once had of starring as a singles force evaporated the minute Maivia dove off the top rope in his direction.

6. The Brain Busters Get Disqualified - Survivor Series 1988

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xz2c3n_survivor-series-88-1-3_sport In 1988, Arn Anderson and Tully Blanchard left Jim Crockett Promotions amid pay disputes and arrived in WWE, many expected them to rocket to the top of the tag team division immediately. They were both head-and-shoulders above the majority of the workers in Vince McMahon's promotions and, with Bobby Heenan guiding them, could enhance the already outstanding tag team division. As was the case with the first Survivor Series, the top tandems in the business would battle in a huge 10-on-10 Tag Team Survivor Series Elimination match. Dubbed "The Brain Busters," the team would partner with the Bolsheviks, the Conquistadors, the Fabulous Rougeaus and Demolition to take on the Hart Foundation, The Rockers, the Young Stallions, the British Bulldogs and the Powers of Pain. Based solely on the lack of quality teams on the heel side, it was all-but a sure thing that Anderson and Blanchard would be one of the last remaining teams. Right? RIGHT? Wrong. Anderson and Blanchard were working Marty Jannetty and Shawn Michaels on the house show circuit and their issues were spilling over onto television. In order to fuel that program, the two teams brawled with each other, ignoring referee instruction and getting themselves disqualified. Suddenly, the heels were left with Demolition and a merry band of misfits, none of which could convincingly defeat any of their babyface opponents.
There were so many other options that could have been explored to continue the rivalry between the Brain Busters and Rockers that did not involve Anderson and Blanchard losing in such an underwhelming manner. Instead, they were sacrificed to further a story that never really did anything for either team but produced several excellent matches for fans. On one hand, the booking protected both teams. On the other, it was a very underwhelming and dissatisfying way to utilize a hot new team.

5. Mabel Gets Counted Out - Survivor Series 1994

The 1994 featured the latest chapter in the story pitting American hero Lex Luger against evil, corrupt businessman "Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase and his Corporation. At SummerSlam three months earlier, Native American Tatanka betrayed his heritage and friend Luger by selling out and joining DiBiase, revealing that money was greater than friendship. With DiBiase having an entire stable at his disposal, Luger set out to find some friends to accompany him into battle at the Survivor Series in a traditional elimination tag bout. Those friends? A who's who of midcard fodder, including Adam Bomb, the Smoking Gunns and Mable. Considering the opposition touted such names as Kama, I.R.S. and an over-the-hill King Kong Bundy, the backup was adequate. Or so he thought. The Corporation turned out to be much more formidable than fans could have imagined, with the babyfaces getting picked off one-by-one, much to the chagrin of the fans in Texas. Even Luger, our supposed hero, fell at the feet of his rivals. Still, there was one man who managed to evade pinfall or submission, a man whose elimination came via countout, thus preserving whatever reputation Vince McMahon and the booking team thought he may have had. That man? Mable. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZCf8BmVvio Yes, nearly eight months before he would turn heel and win the King of the Ring, Mable was protected by bookers more than even Lex freaking Luger. Why? Who knows. It is impossible to think that McMahon would have the wherewithal to know that far in advance that Mable would be the guy he would push to the top of the company with a win in the June 1995 tournament and a main event title shot at that year's SummerSlam, thus opting to protect him nearly an entire year earlier. In fact, given how much of a non-factor the big man was in the Royal Rumble just two months after the 1994 Survivor Series and in the weeks leading into WrestleMania XI, where he did not appear nor did he have a match, the reasoning for protecting him via countout rather than having him pinned or submitted like the rest of his team is that much more boggling. Either way, it happened, leaving no wonder as to why Luger would be so quick to hop on the first train out of WWE.

4. Booker T Rocked And Rolled...Up - Survivor Series 2001

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x25e6hb_team-wwf-vs-team-alliance-full-mathc_sport The Invasion angle that dominated World Wrestling Entertainment throughout the summer and fall of 2001 was a creative catastrophe the likes of which had never been, and may never be, seen again. Odds are you have heard the story before but, in the event that you didn't, all you need to know is that Vince McMahon and his crack creative team bungled the most profitable angle of all-time by failing to allow WCW and ECW stars to look as good as his home grown stars and Survivor Series that November was to be home to the merciful conclusion of the story. The main event would pit Team WWE against Team Alliance (the name for the union of WCW and ECW stars) in a traditional tag team elimination bout. Unlike other Survivor Series tag matches, the stakes would be outrageously high as the losing team would be put out of business. McMahon's company, the babyfaces in the war (naturally) would feature The Rock, Chris Jericho, Kane, Undertaker and Big Show while The Alliance (headed by the bratty Shane and Stephanie McMahon) would head into battle with "Stone Cold" Steve Austin, Rob Van Dam, Shane, Kurt Angle and Booker T holding the fate of the faction in their hands. Of all of the stars on Team Alliance, Booker T was the most interesting. He was incredibly over, was in the prime of his career and demonstrated a knack for entertainment the likes of which WWE coveted. He was an elite performer in front of the camera and a fine competitor between the ropes. But the stench of WCW was all over him and management refused to book him to his fullest potential. Thus, when the Survivor Series main event got underway, the former five-time WCW champion found himself eliminated from the contest well before its climax. In a match with as many Hall of Fame-worthy stars as this one touted, elimination wasn't such a bad thing. It was the way he was eliminated, though, that really proved that Booker was not going to get a fair shake in WWE. At lest at that point, anyway. One of the most decorated and respected stars in WCW history was rolled up by The Rock, eliminated fifth, not important enough to see the fate of the company he carried on his back through. It was incredibly disheartening for fans of the Houston native, who had spent so much time investing themselves emotionally in his journey through the tag ranks, to the world of single competition and, finally, the heavyweight title. To see him eliminated in such a dismissive way crushed the hopes of those anticipating the day that Booker would hold up the top prize in the sports-entertainment under the WWE banner.

3. The Wild Card Dooms Sycho Sid - Survivor Series 1995

In 1995, WWE was suffering from a decided lack of star power. Mabel someone deemed to be a main event heel while main event matches pitting heavyweight champion Diesel against "British Bulldog" Davey Boy Smith had tanked both financially and critically. Meanwhile, floating around the midcard was Sycho Sid, a big man with a strong character and a presence about him that screamed "star." While his devotion to softball left him somewhat unreliable throughout a portion of the year, he was still an incredibly valuable asset to the company. That is why it is all the more interesting that WWE opted to use him as ineffectively as possible late in 1995 as they did. Rather than allowing him to hang around the main event scene, as they would a year later when they realized the star they had, they saddled him in Ted DiBiase's Corporation and stuck him in the mess that was the company's midcard. At the Survivor Series, the company booked the first-ever Wildcard elimination tag match, pairing heels with babyfaces and friends with enemies. It was an intriguing way to freshen up the Survivor Series tag match concept and one that drummed up a great deal of interest from fans. In that match, Sid teamed with Shawn Michaels, Ahmed Johnson and the British Bulldog to take on Dean Douglas, Owen Hart, Yokozuna and Razor Ramon. By the end of the contest, Sid was the only member of the victorious team to have been eliminate, the victim of an errant Sweet Chin Music by Michaels. Sure, he retaliated with a powerbomb but, with that booked into the match already, was it necessary for him to be eliminated at all? Could he not have dropped his rival with the vicious, bone-crushing powerbomb and walked out, being counted out rather than being the only person on his team pinned? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdNX-2XUngc At December's In Your House, Sid would team with the 1-2-3 Kid in a losing effort against Razor Ramon and Marty Jannetty. By the time that outcome was reached, he was of no use to the company for nearly six months. When he returned in the summer of 1996, Vince McMahon and company recognized the error of their ways and pushed Sid as a legitimate main event star,

2. The Legion Of Doom And Demolition Get DQ'd - Survivor Series 1990

The introduction of the Legion of Doom to World Wrestling Entertainment in 1990 set the stage for a dream match featuring the duo formerly known as the Road Warriors and Vince McMahon's BDSM gear-wearing answer to the team, Demolition. Though they were essentially ripoffs of Hawk and Animal, Ax and Smash had earned the reputation of one of wrestling's elite tag teams, thanks to outstanding matches with the likes of the Hart Foundation, the Rockers, the Brain Busters and Strike Force. Still, no matter how good they became or how over they were, they could not escape the constant comparisons to the Road Warriors, who were dominating tag team wrestling in Jim Crockett Promotions and the NWA. By the time Hawk and Animal arrived, though, Ax had undergone health issues that led to him being replaced in the ring by newcomer Crush. Thus, the only chance fans would have of seeing the teams clash on a grand stage was that year's Survivor Series. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iljFbumfsKQ Unfortunately, that much-anticipated clash would last mere moments as Ax was eliminated rather quickly, courtesy of a big splash by WWE champion The Ultimate Warrior. Then, Crush and Smash would brawl with Animal and Hawk, leading to a double-disqualification. With both teams gone, any chance die hard fans of pro wrestling had of seeing them wage war, with a definitive winner and loser, evaporated. Sure, there would be matches all over the country pitting the L.O.D. and the Ultimate Warrior against all three members of Demolition, but those matches were never the hotly anticipated contests that people wanted to see. That Demolition was on its last legs the further out they got from Survivor Series only hurt matters. Thus, the elimination of Demolition and the Legion of Doom by double disqualification at the 1990 event ruined one of the last big money matches the company had for several years.

1. The Headshrinkers - 1993

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x5kvn3_four-doinks-vs-bam-bam-bigelow-head_sport The Headshrinkers arrived in WWE in 1992 and were immediately treated as very real threats to the company's tag team champions. They compiled several victories against babyface tandems and were clearly Vince McMahon's attempt to recreate the Wild Samoans team that had been so very good for both he and his father decades earlier. Fatu and Samu were good enough but suffered from poor booking, the introduction of the Steiner Brothers and the Quebecers and losses to the former. Thus, it would take them nearly two years to accomplish their goal of sporting tag team gold. Still, they at least remained relevant as the 1993 Survivor Series approached. That relevancy, along with their credibility, would be called into question as they took to the ring, teaming with Bam Bam Bigelow and Bastion Booger to battle the mysterious four Doinks. The match ranks as one of the worst matches in the two decade-plus history of the Survivor Series pay-per-view and one of the most blatant examples of sports-entertainment done at its absolute worst. The Bushwhackers and Men on a Mission donned the Doink face paint and systematically picked off each member of the opposing team, beginning with the Headshrinkers' Samu, who bit into a balloon and was stunned enough by the water inside that he was rolled up and eliminated from the bout. Fatu followed shortly thereafter and the future Rikishi's departure from the contest was the worst of all, EVER, as he slipped on a banana peel and was pinned. It was an absolutely absurd, ridiculous and idiotic use of two guys intended to be very real, very serious savage beasts. So awful was their use that night that, by the time the following year's event rolled around, they were babyfaces, their heel heat killed because of stupidity on the part of those booking the shows.

Contributor
Contributor

Erik Beaston is a freelance pro wrestling writer who likes long walks in the park, dandelions and has not quite figured out that this introduction is not for Match.com. He resides in Parts Unknown, where he hosts weekly cookouts with Kane, The Ultimate Warrior, Papa Shango and The Boogeyman. Be jealous.