8 Wrestlers Who Didn't "Earn" Their World Title Shots

You think Sting doesn't deserve it? What about these guys?

The decision to run with Sting vs. Seth Rollins for the WWE World championship at Night of Champions has drawn polarized responses from the wrestling fandom. There€™s a segment of the audience who feel that Sting is undeserving of a WWE title shot because he€™s only had one match in the company, which was a high profile loss at WrestleMania to Triple H. Those same people also probably take wrestling a little too seriously, but nevertheless, their point is that in a business that€™s semi-presented as an athletic competition, championship opportunities should earned. The counterpoint to that argument? STING. WWE has spent the better part of the last 20 years reminding us that wrestling isn€™t real, so who are we to argue with them? It€™s too the point now where their own champions are actually using the line €œWins and losses don€™t matter€ on live TV. Why put so much stock into someone €œearning€ a title shot if WWE themselves don€™t? Besides, it isn€™t like there€™s no precedent for this. In fact, some of the most iconic championship bouts in history featured challengers who hadn€™t battled their way into contention. Here€™s 10 Contenders Who didn€™t Earn Their Title Shots.


8. Sting €“ Starrcade 1997

Night of Champions isn€™t even the first time The Man Called Sting has found himself with a championship match that he didn€™t exactly earn. At the time of Starrcade 1997, Sting hadn€™t wrestled an official match in a year and a half. He€™d been working dark matches at house shows here and there to keep the ring rust at bay, but outside of delivering the occasional baseball bat beatdown the viewers hadn€™t seen him in action in quite some time. By that logic, he had no business challenging Hulk Hogan for the WCW world title in what was their biggest pay-per-view of all-time, but that€™s exactly what he did. Wrestling is a business and there was no bigger match that had been built up longer and better than Hogan vs. the brooding, rafter-dwelling anti-hero. It wouldn€™t have made any sense to have Sting come back and start knocking off opponents so he could climb the ladder of contention, proving himself worthy of a title shot. No one wanted to see that. We wanted to see Hollywood eat a Scorpion Death Drop and The Stinger celebrate with the gold.

7. The Giant €“ Halloween Havoc 1995

If you€™re of the opinion that being 0-1 in your WWE run doesn€™t warrant you a title shot, you€™re probably vehemently opposed to the idea of someone who has never had a match in their life, not only challenging for the championship, but actually winning it the very first time they set foot inside the ring. The man fans now know as Big Show made his pro wrestling debut at WCW€™s annual Halloween extravaganza all the way back in 1995. Hulk Hogan saw dollar signs in the gigantic youngster and brought him in as the newest monster for The Hulkster to slay. Not only did the he win the title in his very first match, but he did so by disqualification, conveniently allowing Hogan to drop the belt without being pinned. His reign would only last a week, however as he was soon stripped of the title due to the manner in which he won it being deemed controversial. Besides, if a man can fall of the roof of an arena and then return later on that night to win the championship, who is anyone to say that man didn€™t deserve his title shot?

6. 53 Guys - World War III 1995

World War III was was WCW's attempt to capture the magical chaos of the Royal Rumble, but despite featuring more wrestlers and taking place inside two extra rings, it never lived up to the goal. The inaugural show saw the 60-man three-ring battle royal held to determine the winner of the vacant WCW world championship. Going into the event Hulk Hogan and The Giant were considered the strong favorites, but it was actually Randy "Macho Man" Savage who walked out with the gold thanks to a bit of good old-fashioned wrestling shenanigans. The crazy thing is, out of those sixty guys, only seven of them had a reasonable claim as world title challengers. Besides the three men already mentioned, you had Sting, Lex Luger, Ric Flair and maybe Arn Anderson as legitimate contenders. The rest of the field was populated by elite competitors such as Sgt. Buddy Lee Parker, Mark Starr, Fidel Sierra, Pez Whatley, James Earl Wright and Bobby Walker. WCW could have easily trimmed the fat and made for a much better match, but they preferred the spectacle of the affair. In a kayfabe world where wrestling is real, we could have spent Thanksgiving of 1995 with Big Train Bart as WCW champion.

5. Hulk Hogan - WrestleMania IX

The master politician at work. Much like Sting, no one can argue that Hulk Hogan isn't an icon and one of the biggest stars the business has ever seen. If he was around, he was going to be working at the top of the card because he was smart enough to apply his leverage so that his contracts would guarantee it. Back in 1993, when Hogan made a brief comeback to the company he helped build, he spent his time in a teaming with his best friend, Brutus Beefcake aiding him in his feud vs. Money, Inc. It was a good spot but not one The Hulkster was used to being in. WWE was in the midst of trying out new guys at the top and a lot of work was put into making the current champion, Yokozuna, look like a monster. But at the end of the night, Hogan hit the Samoan sumo with a legdrop and took the belt off of him in a mere 22 seconds. All this despite being gone for nearly a year and wrestling exclusively in tags in the few weeks since his return.

4. Vince Russo - WCW Nitro 2000

There's no way to argue in favor of this one so I'm not even going to try. There are bad decisions, mistakes, and then there's outright incompetence and that's exactly what booking yourself to become the champion of the company when you're neither a wrestler nor a physical specimen of any merit is. The mad scientist that is Russo commonly defends this by saying that he didn't win it fairly but instead picked up the fluke win by accident when Goldberg speared him through the cage. That may be true, but what he fails to realize is that the logic he's using doesn't excuse the booking, it actually makes it worse. The allure to book yourself on top must be incredibly intoxicating because nearly everyone who has had that power put in their hands has done so, from Vince Russo to Eric Bischoff, Kevin Nash, Dusty Rhodes and even Vince McMahon himself. Still, this was inexcusable and just not another in a long line of misfires that took WCW from the top of the world to the TV graveyard in a few short years.

3. David Arquette - WCW Thunder 2000

While we're bashing Russo's creative ideas, let's revisit another one, although he actually credits Tony Schiavone for this gem. The actor was brought into WCW in a bit of cross-promotion for his wrestling-themed movie, Ready To Rumble. He sided with Diamond Dallas Page and Kanyon in their feud with Eric Bischoff and the New Blood. During a match on Thunder, Arquette teamed with DDP to take on Bischoff and Jeff Jarrett under the stipulation that the man who scored the pinfall would become champion. Dewey from Scream pinned the WCW head honcho and surpassed Tommy Rich as the least worthy champion in the lineage of that title. Russo again defends this by pointing out that it got them mainstream media coverage and was covered in USA Today while failing to realize that if that coverage does nothing to increase your ratings or expand your fanbase - and it didn't - those things are all for naught. Especially when you consider what a huge turn-off it was for the remaining diehard WCW fans.

2. 2/3 Of The Entrants - Royal Rumble 1992

Another instance where a world title was decided via a massive battle royal, the 1992 Royal Rumble is remembered quite fondly as an amazing show featuring perhaps the best Rumble match of all-time. Ric Flair was fairly new to the company and cemented his claim as "The Real World's Champion" by entering the match at #3 and going all the way to victory in just over an hour. And while not nearly as filled with detritus as World War III, there were definitely some guys in this match who had no business getting a chance to become champion. Names like Virgil, The Berzerker, and a Knobbs-less Jerry Saggs kicked and punched for their shot at glory, but alas it was not to be. Nevertheless, I prefer to think there's an alternate universe somewhere in which Repo Man ran the gauntlet and reigned over WWE for the next decade.

1. Hulk Hogan - 1984

More than any other instance mentioned, this single entry proves the point that just because someone hasn't "earned" it doesn't mean that awarding them a title shot isn't great for business. When Hulk Hogan returned to the then-WWF in December, 1983 after a successful stint in the AWA, Vince McMahon, Jr. already had him earmarked as the man to lead his revolution toward national expansion. Hulk possessed all the attributes the promoter was looking for in his posterboy, and it wasn't long before he was carrying the company with his 24-inch pythons. But Hulk Hogan didn't "earn" his title shot at all. His matches prior to his bout with The Iron Sheik consisted of squashing two jobbers - some guy named Bill Dixon and Gilbert Guerrero, NOT of the famous Guerrero wrestling family - and a tag match with Bob Backlund vs. Mr. Fuji and Tiger Chung Lee. Should Hulk Hogan have not been put in the match because he hadn't climbed his way up the ladder? History tells us that the idea is absurd, and while there's a big difference between a relatively youngish Hulk Hogan winning his first world title and a 56-year old Sting facing the hottest wrestler in the world, the principle remains the same. Basically the entire point is that Sting is awesome.

Contributor
Contributor

Brad Hamilton is a writer, musician and marketer/social media manager from Atlanta, Georgia. He's an undefeated freestyle rap battle champion, spends too little time being productive and defines himself as the literary version of Brock Lesnar.