8 Wrestling Gimmicks That Were Much Darker Outside WWE

From gush-hackers to Bushwhackers.

DOINK WWE ECW
WWE

The Ringmaster. Rocky Maivia. Cowboy Bret Hart. Shorty G. Mason the Mutilator. DDP the stalker. The Viking Raiders. Mighty Mouse. Barry Windham the Stalker. Stardust. Dean Douglas. Deacon Batista.

These are just a handful of the terrible ideas Vince McMahon came up with - and in many cases, stuck with - to either promote new or repackage existing talent. It's fair to say the man has quite the knack for turning the proverbial chicken salad into a sack of chicken sh*t, until, as ever, fate intervenes on his behalf (or quits and forms AEW).

Stardust - Cody Rhodes to everybody besides WWE's spiteful alumni page - is probably the best current example of a wrestler who people could only take seriously once he shed McMahon's horrific creative. But what if he'd stuck with it? Could he have made Stardust legitimate on the indies? Now that would have been a challenge.

And not one without precedent. Several stars, still looking to trade on a name that got them famous, managed to refine the caricature handed to them in Titan Towers into something much more compelling beyond those boundaries. Some did it in advance - only to see all that hard work go to waste once they stepped into Vince's office...

8. Haku

Haku Meng
WWE

Haku was one frightening customer during his time in WWE, a man who, despite wearing no shoes, could easily kick your face in, if not clean bite it off. But, radge though he undoubtedly was, his character never extended to the occult. He was quite content to scare people away with the power of his walnut-hard fists, without any need for the power of the pentagram.

As Colonel Robert Parker's hired muscle in WCW, things broadly remained the same, though he was re-christened Meng and now wore pinstripe suits and cool shades.

That all changed when Meng fell in with the Satanic Kevin Sullivan's Dungeon of Doom lot. The Pacific Islander was no longer just the world's toughest bouncer, but a bona fide killer who'd apparently dispatched enemies on behalf of the Emperor of Japan with his Tongan Death Grip. Perhaps the newly evil Meng's darkest moment came when he was involved in that triple-cage Doomsday Match at Uncensored '96 - a crime against humanity if ever there was one.


7. Goldust

Goldust Seven
WWE

If Dusty Rhodes hadn't been just as entrenched in the industry as his son Dustin, he'd have witheringly lamented his first-born having "gone off the rails" come 1999. The younger Rhodes had spent the previous four years dragging the family name through the mud in a bid to escape its shadow as the increasingly bizarre Goldust, a gimmick which began life as an anthropomorphised Oscar statuette and gradually malformed into one of implied sexual depravity. Still, as embarrassing as that was to the American Dream over awkward Christmas dinners, it was nothing compared to Dustin's WCW stint.

Goldust was a deviant, but at least he wasn't a possible sex offender, as the Atlanta version of the gimmick, Seven, suggested. Vignettes aired on WCW TV showing Rhodes - who now resembled the Strangers from 1998 neo-noir flick Dark City - lurking outside a child's bedroom window, imploring him to get in his van. The implication was supremely icky, even if not necessarily intended.

Turner Standards and Practices agreed, and they forced WCW to drop the character pronto. The next time polka dots were mentioned at a Rhodes' family gathering, Dusty had the perfect riposte: "Well at least I was never... "


6. Kamala

KAMALA WCCW WWE
WWE

In 1983, Skandor Akbar, sick to his back teeth of the Von Erich hegemony in Dallas' WCCW, unleashed his latest addition to his army. By his own admission, the new recruit was far from ready - or rather, North American wrestling wasn't. The Ugandan Giant 'Kimala', waving a sharpened spear and with fiercesomely painted face, was the cruelest African stereotype the industry had ever seen.

That cruelty often got the better of him. Not au fait with the finer points of the sports' rules, the 'untrained beast' would frequently find himself on the end of a disqualification. It rarely mattered; the damage had already been done. Such was the case when he challenged for Harley Race's NWA Championship outside the company in October of that year. Quite why he cared about titles is unclear.

Kimala - or 'Kamala', as he was now known - displayed similar savagery in his first WWE spell, devouring a live chicken before taking on Hulk Hogan for his belt. It was a similar story, as the match went to a double countout.

When Kamala resurfaced from the jungles of Uganda just under ten years later, he was no less savvy about the regulations but significantly less scary. The 1992 version of Kamala who went up against The Undertaker was not just severely out of date but also deeply sympathetic, a terrified man being coerced into battle by his (white) 'handlers'. Far from being the fearless warrior, Kamala turned tail and fled from the stalking Undertaker at SummerSlam '92. Who could blame him in the face of such oppression?


5. Doink

DOINK WWE ECW
WWE

The original incarnation of WWE's Doink expertly and rather horrifically traded on the fears of coulrophobes everywhere. The evil clown was every bit the squared circle Pennywise, from his disarming grin and carnival of the damned theme music, to his stuttering movements and vicious attacks on that idiot Crush.

He was seriously creepy, but probably just a bit too subtle for WWE's early-'90s demographic. After the man under the pancake, Matt Borne, was fired for his recurrent drug issues, Doink was re-tweaked into a fun-loving prankster. With minuscule doppelganger Dink in tow and Ray Apollo playing the role, Doink became horrible for a whole new reason.

Borne reprised the part in ECW, only this time, he wasn't clowning around. Initially, Doink appeared as WWE fans remembered, before Shane Douglas took him under his wing. The Franchise lambasted Vince McMahon for turning wrestlers as gifted as Borne into ridiculous cartoon characters, and promised he could unlock the former Big Josh's true potential.

He only managed half a job. Borne soon began wrestling half as Doink, half as himself, his actions symptomatic of a borderline personality disorder. Wonderfully, he also started referring to himself as 'Borne Again'. And not a miniature tricycle in sight.


4. Sir Mo

Mo Sir Mohammad
WWE

Sir Mo was just about the worst wrestler to ever grace WWE, an ovoid lackey ridiculously made to look small by his behemoth partner, possessing one tenth of his distance running namesake's charisma and only a five-hundredth the stamina. He wasn't even a good rapper.

Though the promotion just about managed to make a virtue of Mabel, with Mo it always remained a case of, "oomph! There he is..." Unsurprisingly, the moment the Lyin' King was let go, the company took the opportunity to jettison 300lbs of flotsam with him.

Back in Memphis, USWA managed to do something WWE couldn't: make Mo marginally relevant. Ditching his courtier's robes for the kufi cap, Mo was recast as 'Sir Mohammad', one of the members of the black supremacist group The Nation of Domination - the forerunner to WWE's own.

Now, it's not as though Mo became an overnight hit, raising the fist alongside such wrestling luminaries as Brakkus, PG-13 and Reggie B. Fine, but it was a damn sight better than his shapeless stint as Men on a Mission's least talented member.


3. The Bushwhackers

Sheepherders Bushwhackers
WWE

One singularly awful match curiously connects a clutch of men on this list, and that's Survivor Series '93's (ignoble) award-winning eight-man tag pitting Men on a Mission & The Bushwhackers against Bam Bam Bigelow, Bastion Booger & The Headshrinkers, which saw the former team all inexplicably donning the get-up of Doink. Either side of that career lowlight, The Bushwhackers also scooped the Meltzer prize for worst tag team of the year, their sardine-eating, head-licking 'comedy' from Down Under a frequent downer.

It's almost impossible to believe then, that before joining WWE, New Zealanders Luke and Butch were amongst the industry's most violent and despised tandems. They'd even shared a five-star classic with The Fantastics in the 1986 Crockett Cup, a feud that'd spill over - with much blood spilled - to a series of barbaric UWF barbed wire matches.

So the story goes, when Vince McMahon clapped eyes on the pair, he decided for no apparent reason they should become light relief, thus ensuring they'd be loathed by a certain section of the audience for an entirely different reason.


2. Raven

RAVEN ECW WWE
WWE

It's fair to say that Raven had mellowed somewhat by the time he returned to WWE in 2000. Some six years after his prior stint in Stamford, whilst not exactly Johnny Polo, he'd been reduced to a generic hardcore wrestler who just happened to wear denim cut-offs and had a flannel shirt wrapped around his waist.

WWE just didn't 'get' Raven - or didn't want to. As far as they were concerned, the gimmick meant a bird squawking over his entrance theme. In a past life, it had been one of the most subversively dark the industry had ever seen.

After leaving New York the first time, Scott Levy arrived in ECW courtesy of Stevie Richards, where he dropped the gilded lifestyle of Johnny Polo, replacing it with a grungy aesthetic straight out of Nirvana's playbook (he even used them for his music). 'Raven' - named for the Edgar Allan Poe poem - was a nihilistic sociopath who immediately set his sights on childhood friend Tommy Dreamer, subjecting the ECW mascot to a saga of psychological torture. Across the next three years, Dreamer fought tooth and nail to dispatch his nemesis, the compelling feud drawing eyes to the rebel promotion in the process.

Another thing we never saw WWE's watered down Raven do was crucify anybody. That, we guess, was reserved for The Undertaker, who no doubt drew inspiration from Raven hitching The Sandman up on a cross years earlier - much to the chagrin of a watching Kurt Angle, who refused to be part of the show on transmission. It's quite something to say it was the most controversial angle in the regularly controversial ECW's history.

Even in WCW, whilst the violence was toned down, Raven continued to be a cerebral presence, surrounded by his Flock of outcasts. So how did Vince McMahon see him when he crossed the divide again? Just some bird, innit.


1. Seth Rollins

Tyler Black Seth Rollins
ROH/WWE

Seth Rollins' 'Monday Night Messiah' mantle is a million times better than the drivel we suffered through during his abortive 2019 babyface run, but the rancour of his Raw ramblings as a leader are meek compared to his time as a lackey in a similar Ring Of Honor group way back in 2007.

The then Tyler Black joined Necro Butcher and Lacey at ROH 161 as part of a new, cult-like stable known as Age of the Fall, under the stewardship of dip-dyed emogoth Jimmy Jacobs. Their very first act was to truss Jay Briscoe up from the belt hook on the lighting rig. Blood dripped from their victim as he hanged from the ceiling like a butchered animal, saturating Jacobs' shirt and at one point trickling into his mouth. So disgusting was the scene that ROH removed the footage from the event PPV.

Though they'd never quite replicate this revolting act, the Age of the Fall continued to terrorise ROH for the next two years, until the breakout star Black, having earned the respect of the crowd with his ring work, turned on his leader. It was his subsequent reign as Ring Of Honor champion that'd ultimately lead the future Rollins to an FCW contract.


Watch Next


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.