8 WWE Returns That Were Much Better Than Expected
You can never go home again. Except when you can.
Shawn Michael's Crown Jewel fiasco proved, as the wrestling business has over and over again, that even the greatest tap out to Father Time eventually.
On Friday in Riyadh, The Heartbreak Kid was more like The Heartbreaking Kid, a pale imitation not just of himself but of Kendall Windham, stumbling through a depressing mess against two similarly depreciated legends. Was a reported $2 million worth it to completely repeal the rare dignity of his wrestling retirement?
For thirty minutes' work, the answer is probably yes.
It was a shame more than a disappointment. If anyone could have another great match after eight years in retreat, it was Shawn. Yet deep down, we all knew it was unlikely. Age might be just a number, but so is 53 - and it's not a small one.
Perhaps the weight of expectation worked against Michaels in the desert. Were it, say, Bryan Clark headlining Crown Jewel, maybe we'd have been wowed by such a sloppy outing. Heck, it would have been one of his best ever matches.
That's the key, really. When you expect nothing, it's easy to be wowed by something. Sometimes, that something is just a wrestler displaying more mobility than a bungalow.
8. Greg Valentine
WWE's Raw Homecoming show in 2005 had two consequences. Firstly, it began the interminable three hour era of the company's flagship show which has ultimately - yet paradoxically - resulted in its lowest ever ratings, but largest ever TV deal.
Secondly, and perhaps less significantly, it set one-time La Résistance member Rob Conway off on an iconoclastic tear. After interrupting the obligatory 'Legends Gathering' on the show, featuring all the usual Jims - Jimmy Snuka, Hillbilly Jim, Jimmy Hart - Conway found himself set upon by the flock of fossils.
In retaliation, he vowed to systematically destroy a series of old-timers. First up Greg Valentine, who at 54 looked just as good (and by extension, just as bad) as he had during his most recent appearance - way back at Royal Rumble '94 - keeping pace with Conway throughout. 'The Hammer' famously needed '20 minutes to warm up' - but managed to get to peak temperature in just seven in the pre-warmed privacy of Heat.
7. Goldberg
It's fair to say that Goldberg's first WWE run was a bit naff. Completely misused in a series of matches which seemed almost designed to expose his weaknesses (specifically, his lack of any real wrestling acumen), Big Bill departed Stamford with his tail between his legs following the drastic WrestleMania XX washout with Brock Lesnar.
The fans in Madison Square Garden vociferously booed both stars that night, au fait with the fact the pair were there for one last pay cheque on their way out of the company. The very idea that the two would raise the roof in a rematch twelve years later was unfathomable.
But that's exactly what they did. The key the second time was keeping it short - very short. At Survivor Series 2016, Goldberg stunned Brock in just 90 seconds. You couldn't ask for more - or, realistically, less - from the match.
6. PCO
If asked to predict which superstar from WWE's 'New Generation' would still be hitting them out the park in 2018, it's unlikely most beyond the smokiest of student dorms would have plumped for former pirate Jean-Pierre Lafitte.
Six years after seemingly bowing out of the industry following defeat at the hands of Nigel McGuinness, Pierre Carl Oullet fished out his aviators in 2016 for one of wrestling's most unlikely comebacks.
Earlier this year, at the ripe old age of 50, PCO shared a spectacular, bruising contest opposite Austrian juggernaut WALTER, as he quickly became the greatest thing you never knew you wanted. His first run has always been underrated - he was a pirate, for crying out loud - but against all logical considerations, his South Asian summer has been, bafflingly, even better.
5. Mr. Perfect
As WCW dwindled into dust, so too did the once fine career of Curt Hennig. As Mr Perfect, Hennig had been one of WWE's most reliable hands during the early '90s, but riddled with back injuries, he opted for the easy life in Atlanta where lifting a finger was an optional part of the job description.
As the company entered tailspin, Hennig left WCW behind in the summer of 2000 - and with it, money for basically nothing. He briefly became a star of the ambitious XWF promotion, but when that inevitably hit the can, he was left in limbo.
Wrestling fans thought they'd seen the last of Hennig in the big leagues, but come entry 25 of Royal Rumble 2002, whose music should surprisingly hit but none other than Mr Perfect's? Curt, effectively auditioning, rolled back the years as he made it to the final three, putting in a performance so impressive that he earned himself a brand new contract. Sadly, the infamous 'plane ride from hell' incident a few months later left his career up in the air once more.
4. Trish Stratus
The women's Royal Rumble notwithstanding, Trish Stratus' tag contest alongside Lita at WWE Evolution was the Hall of Famer's first proper wrestling match in over seven years. As fantastic as her physical fitness unquestionably is, it was fairly reasonable to expect the seven-time Women's champ to be carrying some verdigris after nearly a decade out to pasture.
With two rusty old-timers on one side of the equation, and Alicia Fox subbing for Alexa Bliss on the other - a downgrade if ever there was one - it seemed the task fell to consummate pro Mickie James to keep the whole thing from crumbling.
Not so; with a little helping hand from her long-time rival, you'd be forgiven for thinking Trish had never left. She re-emerged in such fine fettle that the possibility of more matches to come soon surfaced.
3. Brock Lesnar
Brock Lesnar was only 35 when he made his unlikely WWE return in 2012, but after years of punishing toil on his body, both in his public MMA battles and private addiction battles - not to mention a near fatal bout of diverticulitis - it was reasonable to expect the breakout Beast of 2002 would be somewhat defanged.
After decisive defeats in the Octagon, the expectation was that Brock was going to slide into his slippers in Stamford, taking a soft option for hard cash.
He didn't. Lesnar's first match back in WWE for almost a decade was an absolutely rip-roaring affair opposite John Cena. The Beast was back - and better than ever. For a bit, anyway.
2. Finlay
A full 31 years after making his professional debut, Dave Finlay stepped into a WWE ring for the first time at the grand age of 47 - five years since he'd last strapped on the clover-clad singlet.
Unlike PCO's surprise return in 2016 with just an extra year on the clock, the Northern Irishman's SmackDown bow wasn't treated as a nostalgia-fuelled curio - or with any special interest whatsoever, for that matter.
That's probably because his performance entirely belied his age. Going toe-to-toe with relative whippersnapper Matt Hardy, Finlay laid bare his heel credentials and low-key wrestling prowess. It was the springboard for a highly successful second career, which finally came to a close in 2011 - when the evergreen and ever 'Fit' Finlay was forced to hang up his shillelagh at the age of 53.
1. Ricky Steamboat
Mickey Rourke's cold-feet gave rise to one of the most heartwarming comeback stories in wrestling history. After the actor, in the midst of promoting latest film The Wrestler, pulled out of a proposed WrestleMania XXV match with Chris Jericho, plans were hastily altered, and instead of taking aim at the movie's principal star, Y2J set his sights on its major theme - over-the-hill wrestling stars.
Thank goodness he did. A three-on-one handicap between Jericho and a trio of legends promised little, but delivered much. The rickety Roddy Piper and even shakier Jimmy Snuka didn't offer much - despite the latter having last wrestled for WWE just two year prior - but once Ricky Steamboat stepped in the ring with Jericho, things exploded. 'The Dragon', treading the canvas for the first time in fifteen years, didn't look a day older.
Steamboat's exchanges with Y2J were so crisp, that the pair were booked in a singles contest for Backlash - in which he was, somehow, even better.