8 WWE Superstars Who Are Miscast In Their Current Roles
These characters just aren't clicking.
Most WWE superstars make the most of whatever gimmick they're given, even if it is doomed to flop from the start. It also isn't uncommon for certain stars to be positioned as a babyface or a heel when the individual is clearly more comfortable in the opposite role.
Braun Strowman is a prime example of someone who was booked perfectly as a monster heel yet was in desperate need of a babyface turn when he gradually got over with the audience.
Unfortunately, there are a handful of others on both the Raw and SmackDown Live rosters at the moment who could benefit from a change in character just as much. WWE might be experimenting with something new that just isn't working, or worse yet, they aren't listening to their fans and fail to realize when it's time to switch it up with those wrestlers.
Either way, the bottom line is that these superstars are suffering as a result of the company's questionable decisions, and would really shine if they weren't so miscast in their current characters.
8. Rusev
Rusev was your typical foreign heel when he was called up to the main roster in April 2014, playing the part to perfection as he ran through the roster in the remainder of the year. It wasn't until the following year, however, that he started to incorporate some personality into his promos and it quickly became evident that he was actually hilarious.
It made sense to keep him a heel while he was with Lana, given she was desired to inspire jealousy in a certain part of the audience. The two went their separate ways upon moving over to SmackDown Live in the Superstar Shake-up, raising the question why we're supposed to hate him now when in reality he would make for an amazing babyface.
Rusev's social media and various WWE.com interviews are enough evidence that he is totally likable and has plenty to offer in a comedic role. Anything would be better than having him engage in pointless programs with John Cena and Randy Orton.
A double turn with him and Tye Dillinger was rumored after a recent live event match they had, so maybe a face stint for the Bulgarian brute isn't far off.
7. Jack Gallagher
Unless you've been paying close attention to 205 Live as of late, you likely had no idea Jack Gallagher turned heel and aligned with The Brian Kendrick prior to TLC. He's been more aggressive as a villain thus far than he previously was as a babyface, but he was the one star in the Cruiserweight division fans actually responded to whenever he appeared on Raw. Turning him heel seemed to be a shortsighted decision by WWE.
As a babyface, he was way different than everyone else on the roster, even beyond 205 Live. His colorful tights and playful mannerisms in the ring made him a fan favorite. Changing what works is WWE's forte after all, but Gallagher doesn't just have as big of an upside as a heel. The turn felt like a desperate attempt by WWE to swerve their viewers and nothing more.
Perhaps his partnership with Kendrick will be revealed to be a ploy before long, but if not, WWE is wasting a perfectly fine babyface in Gallagher.
6. Bobby Roode
Stars such as Samoa Joe and Austin Aries started out as babyfaces in NXT before turning heel because officials were aware they would be cheered upon arriving on the brand. Not Bobby Roode. There's no doubt he would have been a popular babyface at first as well, but even more so than Joe and Aries, he is such a natural heel and officials were smart to position him as an antagonist from the start of his run.
Needless to say, it worked out for the better because he went on to amazing success, including a seven month-long reign as NXT champion. His promos were on-point and he was always effective in turning the crowd against him despite his glorious entrance music.
Oddly enough, WWE had him debut as a babyface on SmackDown Live back in August, and one can only assume that was because of his theme song. Fans pop for it, but his character work has left a lot to be desired on the main roster. Now that his rivalry with Dolph Ziggler has wrapped up, it's high time he finds his footing as a heel on the blue brand.
5. Jason Jordan
If it wasn't already evident, Jason Jordan's singles push on Raw hasn't exactly panned out the way officials probably hoped it would.
There is no denying his talent inside the ring, but he lacks charisma, and as a character, we know nothing about him aside from how he's a former tag team champion and Kurt Angle's storyline son. He was revealed to be Kurt's kin nearly four months ago and he hasn't made much progress. In fact, on the nights he isn't being booed, the crowd hardly reacts to him at all.
The easy solution would be to turn him heel. Rocky Maivia suffered from a similar issue in early 1997 when fans took exception to his aggressive push, so WWE went ahead and turned him heel. Upon evolving into The Rock, he became one of the biggest stars the business had ever seen.
Of course, Jordan is no Rock, but he would benefit from following in his footsteps. It might be too early to have him go full-fledged heel on his dad in an attempt to elicit genuine heat, but slowly starting that process soon would at least prove he's worth something if WWE can tweak his character.
4. Charlotte Flair
Similar to her dad, Charlotte Flair is much more comfortable as a heel than as a babyface. That has been the case throughout her entire wrestling career: she was boring as a face in NXT, when she got called up to the main roster in the summer of 2015, and even now.
Fans have come to respect Charlotte and everything she's accomplished up to this point, which is why she gets cheered, but she hasn't cut a memorable promo since signing with SmackDown Live back in April. Compare that to one year ago when, next to The Miz, she was arguably the strongest mic worker in the entire company.
Charlotte had a knack as a heel for dressing down her opponent and playing up how she is essentially wrestling royalty. The robes she wore made her extra detestable and being an elitist just came easy to her.
Granted, SmackDown has their fair share of heels right now, but none of them hold a candle to what Charlotte can do in the role. That might explain why she's been such an afterthought on the blue brand in 2017, but an eventual heel turn would undoubtedly lead her to her first SmackDown Women's Championship.
3. Sasha Banks
Sasha Banks was a fantastic foil for the aforementioned Charlotte Flair during their iconic rivalry in the second half of 2016 over the Raw Women's Championship, but beyond that, she has never made for that great of a babyface on the main roster.
It should be noted that WWE turned her face in the first place because fans were chanting "We want Sasha!" during her absence from programming at the onset of 2016. She moves more merchandise than most of the women and plays the babyface role well, but she has barely scratched the surface in terms of what she's truly capable of.
Look no further than her stint in NXT, where she debuted as a generic face and eventually transformed into 'The Boss'. Every little thing she did was an attempt to generate heat, such as stomping on Bayley's injured hand during their TakeOver: Brooklyn bout or making a little girl in the audience legitimately cry.
We didn't see that side of Sasha when she showed up on the main roster in the summer of 2015 because she was overshadowed by the faction wars happening at the time, but returning to her roots would certainly freshen up her stale persona.
2. Randy Orton
It's no secret that Randy Orton has always preferred to portray a heel and there's a reason for that: he is infinitely more interesting in that role. As a babyface, his matches are just as good, but his character work and promos are the equivalent to watching grass grow.
Orton's latest run as a face showed promise at the beginning when he exited The Authority and was seemingly having more fun by allowing his personality to shine through for a change, but his last year in WWE has been dreadful. From a failed feud with Bray Wyatt to a series of uninspiring matches with Jinder Mahal, fewer stars have had a more disappointing 2017 than him.
It will be difficult for him to escape this rut he's been in unless he turns heel. The simple explanation would be that he's sick of falling short when it matters most and being overshadowed by the up-and-coming talent, such as Shinsuke Nakamura. They have had a soft alliance in recent weeks anyway, and Orton officially turning on him is inevitable.
Babyface Randy Orton is just another body on the roster, but when heel Randy Orton sinks his teeth into something, he's a treat to watch.
1. Roman Reigns
If Vince McMahon wasn't so stubborn and turned Roman Reigns heel following the backlash he received from his Royal Rumble win in 2015, there's a good chance he wouldn't be struggling to solidify his spot as the face of the company today.
His string of stellar matches over the last two years have marked him as one of the company's best performers, and he can be brilliant on the microphone when he wants to be. By and large, though, he comes across like an arrogant jerk through how he carries himself, and oftentimes he embraces the boos.
Fans can compare it the original push John Cena received all they want, but the heat Cena garnered doesn't come close to how hated Reigns is by a majority of the audience. He can be that breakout babyface the company badly wants him to be if they take the heel route first, but they are adamant about getting fans to cheer 'The Big Dog' by keeping him a babyface.
Well, it has been almost three years since Reigns entered singles competition and very little has changed (which might be part of the problem). It isn't as if they haven't had their opportunities to turn him, either, and at this point, it appears they never will.