9 Most Unintentionally Hilarious "Scary" Wrestler Gimmicks

5. The Boogeyman

Oh, Boogeyman. You had so damn much potential. Remember how creepy those teaser vignettes were? A strange, painted dude with one f**ked up eye crawling out of a child's bedroom closet and whisper-asking, "Do you...know me?". They were pants-sh**tingly chilling. But due to an injury, the character was introduced much later than they intended, and during that time they decided to turn him into the weird kid in elementary school who ate worms to gross people out. Oh! And remember the time he ate that giant mole right off of Jillian Hall's face? That was so stupid and disgusting that it went right full circle into being hilarious, although that's probably not what they had in mind when they scripted it.