9 Problems With Shane McMahon vs. The Undertaker Match At WrestleMania 32

There are a number of flaws and questions that need addressing...

So it was quite the heart-stopping moment when the cheery opening of "Here Comes the Money" blared at Joe Louis Arena on Monday night, heralding the first WWE on-camera appearance of Shane McMahon since 2009. Detroit received "The Boy Wonder" like the return of a conquering hero, and it was clear that Shane-O-Mac was quite touched by the electric response. While the ooh-and-ahh dialogue between him and his family made for pretty good television, and the match with Undertaker for WrestleMania 32 (with control of Monday Night Raw at stake) is a stunning match announcement, there are plenty of glaring issues with the entire deal. I realize that with a roster gutted by injuries, a desperate move had to made in order to turn heads toward what looked to be a middling show. Since there are no plans to shunt the undesired Roman Reigns down to a midcard match, it's imperative that the rest of the show captivate the lapsed and tired fans. Incorporating Shane McMahon six years after he was last seen? It's an intriguing proposition. But looking closer at what's actually at hand, there are concerns that could easily lead to this match underwhelming, and even confusing, the viewing audience.

9. Why Is The Undertaker A Pawn?

I thought only Theodore Long had the power to enlist Undertaker as his avatar against insubordinates? Instead, Vince McMahon wields the authority to say, "Alright, pal, I choose The Undertaker to represent me in a match with high stakes!" Naturally, it doesn't sound right if you say Undertaker's name without, "Playa" afterward. The problem here is that Undertaker is an omnipotent character, one not bound to the same laws and regulations that 'mortal' wrestlers adhere to. Ever since his 'Streak' expanded to otherworldly levels, Undertaker comes and goes on his own terms, only arriving to accept the challenge of a foolish iconoclast. It diminishes Undertaker to a degree to have him take the match on McMahon's orders.

8. What Is Undertaker's Motivation?

Okay, so Undertaker is Vince's ghoulish avatar for this match. Great. Now what? Unless Vince holds some sort of dark secret over Undertaker's head (you know, one worse than the fact that his brother survived a mortuary fire in their youth), why would WWE's Clint Eastwood take orders from someone he's feuded with a million times? Other than hitting Brock Lesnar in the crotch a few times last summer, Undertaker hasn't done anything treacherous or underhanded since encasing Paul Bearer in concrete on a devilish whim. In other words, why is Undertaker going to attack Shane on Vince's command? For crying out loud, 'Taker and Shane started the Corporate Ministry together! This would be like Lennon being ordered to maim McCartney.

7. In Story, Wouldn't Undertaker Actually Lay Down To Spite Vince?

It seems like if you used nothing but the most obvious logic, Undertaker would do anything to rid Monday Night Raw of Stephanie and Hunter. It's not like his Streak is still up for grabs, so laying down for Shane out of spite wouldn't be entirely out of the question, if you're using logic (a dirty word when McMahons are involved). But what's stopping Undertaker from doing it? Putting it another way, would Undertaker maul Shane into a bloody pulp, pin him to reaffirm his own pride, and leave him laying before 100,000 fans that would rather see Raw minus Stephanie and Triple H? Isn't WrestleMania these days supposed to feature Undertaker as a heroic, albeit dark, figure?

6. Can Shane McMahon, At Age 46, Honestly Take A Crazy Bump?

It's Shane McMahon, whose best matches have seen him leap off of high structures onto hardly-visible crash pads, and perform top-rope plunges through the announcer's desk. The Hell in a Cell cage is a legitimate sixteen feet high. Nostalgic fans who remember Shane at his career apex are going to expect some sort of Foley-esque leap into oblivion. Shane hasn't taken any sort of bumps since about 2009, which is forever not only in wrestling terms, but as the human body creaks into its forties. While nobody would blame Shane for working a more conservative match, the Hell in a Cell stipulation is virtually a guarantee that something crazy is going to happen. Shane will never have to wrestle another match after April 3, but will it be worth it?

5. Can Shane McMahon Still Take Any Bumps At All?

He may not have worked the 300-day road schedules of full-time WWE stars, but he is 46 years old, and hasn't worked a match since his late-thirties. Not everyone can be Shawn Michaels and simply step back into the ring after an extended layoff, working with the same infallible magic that was there throughout your career. The only real way to disguise any issues Shane might have taking bumps is to make the match a standing brawl, with both men throwing punches and swinging weapons. I'm sure Shane will be working out like a madman for the next six weeks to prepare himself for one good stuntshow, but it runs the risk of looking more awkward than we might expect.

4. What's With This Vince 'Messing Up' Story?

Something wasn't fully explained was when Vince and Shane broke the news to Stephanie that Shane never lost his place in the inheritance order. Shane claimed that Vince 'messed up huge' a few years ago, and because of the blunder, Shane negotiated a deal for himself to pursue ventures outside of WWE. At first glance, you could piece the vague clues together and think that maybe Vince did something illegal and Shane was allowed to disassociate himself to avoid any connections should Vince go to jail, but it was said in such a way that it didn't make sense. Or maybe Shane got his father out of some huge debt and negotiated some level of freedom anyway. The story will be forgotten by WrestleMania, but as of Monday night, it was kinda mind-numbing.

3. Would Anyone Actually Believe The Authority Would Go Away?

So the deal is if Shane beats Undertaker, he gets to run Monday Night Raw. That would mean removing Triple H and Stephanie from power, a storyline we saw just as recently as Survivor Series 2014. It lasted exactly six weeks before it was overturned, rendering a well-done main event match completely moot. Let's face it: Stephanie and Triple H enjoy being on camera too much. They take social media photos with every major celebrity that is comped a ticket, because they want to look like savvy and urbane corporate officers, the precise opposite of Vince's poor handling of the media. For Hunter and Stephanie to go away diminishes their profile. Would they really risk that, even if it was as short-lived as the last time an ousting story took place?

2. If Shane Beats Undertaker, Doesn't That Remove Drama From The Main Event?

It's pretty well accepted that Reigns is going to spear Triple H into the Stone Age at WrestleMania, while The Rock and whatever other popular star (probably Shane, too) heads off the Authority interference at the pass. All of this will be done to give Reigns as much rub as possible, because it's sure to stick this time, unlike all those other times. If Shane wins control of Raw, it's pretty much a forgone conclusion that Triple H drops the belt to Reigns, unless the story's going to be that Shane controls the show with Hunter as the champion, and puts him through all sorts of convoluted hell for the amusement of the fans. Actually, if it screws Reigns over, the fans would probably be on board with it. Especially the viewers in Detroit.

1. If Shane Runs Raw, Doesn't He Lose Cred For Endorsing Reigns?

Operating once more under the assumption that Shane somehow becomes the other 'one' in 22 and 2, he becomes the suave and playful overseer of Raw, which will likely have Reigns as its champion. From The Rock to Daniel Bryan to Dean Ambrose to even Paul Heyman, WWE has pulled out every imaginable stop to have well-regarded performers endorse Reigns in their own ways. Face it, Shane would be next. He'd put over Roman as a fighting champion, and give him challenges that would test his mettle, but only out of fairness. Shane came back on Monday night with such momentum that it's a daunting risk to have him put over Roman as his champion for whatever frame of time.

Contributor
Contributor

Justin has been a wrestling fan since 1989, and has been writing about it since 2009. Since 2014, Justin has been a features writer and interviewer for Fighting Spirit Magazine. Justin also writes for History of Wrestling, and is a contributing author to James Dixon's Titan series.