9 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (2 Nov)
A NJPW icon AND a controversy magnet on the same show? And Shibata and Colt Cabana were there too?!
What to make of this week's AEW Dynamite?
A card that didn't look exactly the most attractive on paper turned out to be...not exactly the most attractive in practice, and yet very little was actively terrible and so much was so utterly insane that it was difficult not to be charmed by the entire lot.
How much of that emotion was really an accident? All Elite Wrestling has used its on-screen product to quietly recover from the loud and relentless backstage drama that blighted its summer months, with much of the output following All Out 2022 actually rather...good. Full Gear is two Dynamites away and has most major title bouts reasonably well built, all while this episode served as a reminder to never assume everything is exactly as it seems as long as Tony Khan's at the wheel.
To this end, a chaotic night in Baltimore was as brilliant as it was berserk. An all-timer Dynamite, or one of the most confusing shows in company history? Let's light the fuse...
Downs…
3. "TBS" Now Apparently Stands For "This Bull Sh*t"
An okay idea that failed badly in execution, the disrupted Jade Cargill/Marina Shafir match wasn’t exactly made worse by Nyla Rose’s interruptions, but both Champion and Challenger feel like total goofs going into Full Gear.
Belt thief Nyla and Vickie Guerrero attempted to help their Vicious Vixens colleague by chatting sh*t from a distance, but the plan’s profound uselessness meant that the jokes fell flat. Cargill barely sold the noise, and still won easily when she did. An attempt by Keira Hogan to steal the belt back was almost missed by the cameras, but both stables looked like losers when she was flattened by Nyla as she bailed.
This was flimsy, flimsy material that the two simply couldn’t elevate - most of the angle has been - and Rose’s comic charm circles the drain the longer she stays heel too.
2. House Of Black? Alright.
Your mileage may vary on House Of Black or any lore-adjacent acts anyway, but is there not a more salient argument to be made that the spooky nonsense has failed the trio enough that they should perhaps try something else instead?
It was newsworthy that leader Malakai Black will be returning to the fold. Relations between performer and promotion looked to be shaky following All Out 2022, despite Black's later efforts to quell speculation that he'd inadvertently stirred. But the welcome break for the group only facilitating this symbolic rebirth didn't exactly inspire.
Julia Hart buried them so they could rise again or whatever, and though a daft reincarnation as a boyband or something else absurd wasn't the play, a shift away from some of the well-worn goth stuff might have been a little bit more encouraging.
1. A TV Title Match, But Not A TV Main Event
Though it’d be unfair to label Samoa Joe’s TV Title defence as actively terrible, it also didn’t do much to assuage the feeling that the entire episode had slid off the rails in the final half an hour.
The headline contest didn’t go longer than it needed to, but that’s the sort of praise that scans as a burial, and the lack of even one truly memorable moment will consign this to the lower end of Dynamite main events forever. Joe is an icon and a legend, but he’s not Wardlow in 2022. Which, incidentally is why WarJoe is such a cool tag team more than it is a vehicle to splinter the two into blah singles matches like this.
Speaking of the TNT Champion, the post-match beatdown that motivated his appearance was so predictable that fans couldn’t really pop for it. Hobbs got more reaction for beating him down, and this was at least encouraging that homegrown AEW standouts haven’t totally drowned in the ROH sludge.
Ups…
9. If You Can't Go Last, Go First
Satnam Singh is such a beast.pic.twitter.com/OEsMZHGPQk
— Drain Loves The Acclaimed. ✂️ (@DrainBamager) November 3, 2022
A Dynamite card that felt short of a main event turned out to be just that, but Darby Allin and Jay Lethal's tightly-worked opener subsequently earned the sweetest spot on the show. They worked up to the energy of a small-if-lively Baltimore crowd too.
Lethal's limb work was tremendous, as was a repeat of the garage door figure four spot under a guardrail. That all of that was foreshadowing something much bigger all along made it extra sweet in hindsight, especially with speculation mounting about who the heels had in their corner.
Ultimately, the contest will be remembered more for what happened afterwards - more on that later - but the match should at least survive in the memory thanks to Satnam Singh's sensational no-sell of Allin's dive. An awesome big man spot that teased out the potential greatness of this new Sting party match combination, Singh looked more of a danger absorbing such a killer move than he ever has delivering one.
8. Mox & Moriarty Tell A Story, And So Does Ethan Page
A pre-match promo from Jon Moxley was expert in presenting pro wrestling's brilliant basics.
He put Lee Moriarty over as somebody very nearly worthy of a place in his and Bryan Danielson's Blackpool Combat Club, before out-wrestling and out-fighting him in a cagey war that presented the Champion as truthful and informed winner, and The Firm's star as a clear-and-present danger in the years to come.
A good television match never got great, but it maintained all the heat from the opener and crucially served as some moving pictures for Ethan Page's exceptional commentary to soundtrack.
The Canadian star buried MJF following the show-closing beatdown on the 'Salt Of The Earth' and yet again talked his way into sounding like the cast-iron favourite to win the upcoming Championship contenders tournament. Polished and economical, his performance was so good that the attack on Moxley after the fact felt more than just an opportunistic heel picking his spot.
7. A Good Bait-And-Switch
AEW promised and promoted a Renee Paquette sit-down interview between Britt Baker and Saraya on last night’s Dynamite, and though they failed to deliver it, what they did present was knowing of that, and better.
Baker’s choice to not show up was in keeping with her overt arrogance and covert cowardice - things she tried hard to mask in booking herself and Jaime Hayter into a Rampage tag team match later in the show. In the same promo, she dusted off her old “conspiracy” cry as if to angrily remind the newcomer that she’s got more credit in the AEW bank than the former Paige could compete with.
And speaking of her competing - the sit down between friends Renee and Saraya balanced the eventual reveal of that news magnificently. The “one more doctor” line was better than cute, and set the table nicely for everything still to follow before Full Gear.
6. William's Words Of Warning...
...were powerful, but who exactly were they for?
Regal seemed back on his bullsh*t as relates to getting under MJF's skin, noting that he was disappointed to see the 'Salt Of The Earth' taking such a kicking last week. Was this earnest negging from the Blackpool Combat Club cornerstone, was he trying to tease the Number One Contender into brutalising and bloodying him before Full Gear, or was this more possible foreshadowing that he will link up with the 26-year-old on the big night?
The evidence was there if you wanted to find it; Regal referred to Moxley as a "demon" in an extremely cute callback to what AEW's "devil" was needed for in NXT back in 2015, and suggested that the challenger "still had a lot to learn".
Who better to teach him?
5. STILL Running With Scissors
The Acclaimed's Birthday bash for "Daddy *ss" was yet another shining example of how to lean into something as hard as you can when it's over. Especially if there's more to be creamed out of it in merchandise, which, in defence of the indefensible, was a pretty cool way to make the best out of Friday's embarrassing kidnapping Billy Gunn segment.
A sweet moment with a child's sign aside, it all went where it needed to without completely killing the buzz - the original Ass Boys protested about their Father's unity with The Acclaimed, before FTR got a measure of revenge on them for recent grievances and took a long lingering look at Anthony Bowens and Max Caster's tag team titles.
It's a division cooking nicely, even if the title reign of the hottest act feels like it's soon coming to an end.
4. Colt Cabana (Scott Colten) Returns To All Elite Wrestling

Colt Cabana and Chris Jericho had one of those perfectly enjoyable television back-and-forths we're all fed multiple times a week from both major North American promotions, but every time the contest peaked, it did so thanks to the emotion that hung around from Cabana's hugely dramatic entrance.
Jericho had challenged any former Ring Of Honor champion, meaning that a surprise had to be hotter than a person a promotion would hypothetically advertise in advance. "Marcia Colton's baby boy" was absolutely this.
A whispered talking point during CM Punk's run before he became a screamed-about absentee as it imploded, coming back in from the freezing cold looked as vindicating for for Cabana as it was potentially quite vindictive from Tony Khan, Chris Jericho or whomever else orchestrated it.
The match itself sailed by on the scale of the shock experienced by those in-the-know. Which, at this point, was probably most people. Eyes and ears will next turn to the ramifications, should any occur.
3. All Atlantic Is All Action
Sometimes it's just easier not to over-think things too much and enjoy the bullsh*t that's put in front of you.
Your writer doesn't always believe that, but it appears to be the primary messaging of the All Atlantic Championship picture under Orange Cassidy's stewardship, and it's hard to argue against it.
A thrilling three-way defence against Luchasaurus and Rey Fenix didn't take a breath, stole the show, and folded in two major angles before Cassidy eventually retained. Jungle Boy's spectacular surprise attack on his former friend saw both crashing through a table, leaving Fenix to reject the use of Pac's hammer assist and lose as a result.
The future of a Boy & His Dinosaur will surely be decided once and for all at Full Gear and the future of a derailed Death Triangle might be a reckoning with The Elite, but Cassidy's next move was one absolutely nobody could have predicted...
2. SHIBATA?!?!?!?!?!?!
Capping off a night of mind-melting surprise appearances, Katsuyori Shibata returning to AEW to make the save for newfound friend Orange Cassidy was already hotter than the sun before 'The Wrestler' signed the All Atlantic Champion's Dream Opponent contract and agreed to fight him this Friday on Rampage.
Holy f*ckin' sh*t!
Tony Khan recently said on record that he was looking to try and address some fairly obvious issues with Rampage, but moving the show live (or at least away from the post-Dynamite taping schedule) was only half the job. Cards with matches people actually want to watch made up the crucial other half, and this is an almighty step in the right direction.
1. His World
Jeff Jarrett arriving in AEW is as awesome as it is funny as it is shrewd.
‘The King Of The Mountain’ pretty much only had All Elite Wrestling left on his promotional bingo card, and getting his comeuppance in a Full Gear party match tag against Darby Allin and old rival Sting will be a total riot, but the news that he’ll take a Business Development job with the company is even more key to the story than what went on in front of the cameras.
2022 has been an evidently trying year for the company, and Tony Khan’s workload was egotistically enormous enough before he added an entire second company in Ring Of Honor to his slate. If Jarrett alleviates some of that, he’s a benefit. If he offers even a sliver more - as he did here with a classic kabong on one of wrestling’s biggest ever Slapnuts in Allin - he’s a boon.