9 Ups And 7 Downs From WWE SummerSlam 2015

Premature bells and low blows. Way to ruin a great main event.

WWE took fans on an interesting journey Sunday night. We went to Suplex City, where New Day rocks, Brock Lesnar bleeds, Mick Foley is a joke of a man, the Divas Revolution is a cramped mess and comic books come to life. We saw the Deadman cheat to win, the Green Arrow take flight and John Cena felled by a comedian. We also saw the 83rd match between Sheamus and Randy Orton. SummerSlam was a four-hour affair that on its own put on a perfectly good PPV. But measured against NXT Takeover: Brooklyn, SummerSlam wasn€™t even the best wrestling PPV of the weekend, much less the month or year. Still, either some wrestlers were motivated by NXT€™s show the night before, or they saw Vince McMahon€™s brass ring and reached for it. Either way, WWE put on an above-average PPV with some good matches Sunday night, but it didn€™t exactly blow people away. Having a really popular host turn around and cost a mega-star a world title also didn€™t necessarily hurt or help the overall event. But it happened nonetheless, and we€™ll have to wait to see what the motivation or fallout is. With that said, let€™s find out what made the main event and what go relegated to the pre-show. Let€™s get to it€

Downs...

7. How The Mighty Have Fallen

Remember when Dolph Ziggler cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase in nearby East Rutherford, N.J. in 2013? Remember when Rusev put his undefeated streak and United States Championship up against John Cena at WrestleMania XXXI? Remember when Lana was viewed as a future mega-star because of her looks, promos and acting ability? Remember when Summer Rae inoffensively danced with Fandango? OK, three out of four isn€™t bad. But the point is that Ziggler, Rusev and Lana all have fallen quite far into a stalled, emotionless feud that came to a head at one of WWE€™s biggest PPVs of the year Sunday and ended in a double count-out. A double count-out. WWE couldn€™t even book a simple count-out win for Ziggler or a DQ finish with Rusev using a chair or something other than both men failing to get back into the ring. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ryMcB0cNNWw The match itself wasn€™t bad at all €“ Ziggler and Rusev are both great athletes and rarely have bad matches, so that isn€™t the issue. But look at the emotions surrounding Sasha Banks versus Bayley at NXT Takeover: Brooklyn and compare that to the forced emotions from this slow-moving feud. The saving grace here is that the three mentioned above all are really talented and can salvage this and make it entertaining and captivating, but right now, a DCOR was not what this feud needed.

6. Simply Stunned

It€™s been mentioned before and it deserves to be mentioned again: John Cena needs to stop using his springboard stunner. Period. No questions asked. During what largely was a breathtaking title-for-title match between Cena and Seth Rollins, Cena€™s almost-comical springboard stunner stood out as a horrid move that very nearly was botched. Nearly everything else during the match flowed and was beautiful, which makes this abomination even worse. Please just stop doing it, John. You€™ve been turning out high-quality matches almost weekly, and this move is the one thing (aside from the Five Knuckle Shuffle) that just drags things down each time. It never looks good, and it€™s hard to imagine a time when it will.

5. The Hardcore Comedy Legend

Mick Foley has had a tremendous career that reaches far beyond the squared circle. Besides being a three-time WWF World Champion, he is also a best-selling author and a successful stand-up comedian. Foley is one of the genuinely entertaining performers to come through WWF/E, and anytime he shows up, it should be heralded. But with SummerSlam in his neck of the woods, Foley turned out to trade €œcomic€ riffs with SummerSlam host Jon Stewart. Now, Stewart is hilarious and Foley has been one of the funniest guys in a WWE ring. But when the best €œcomedy€ they can come up with is how Mick misheard €œBrock€ as €œRock€ €“ as in, Stewart wanted Foley to serve as backup while he interviewed Brock Lesnar €“ and that he€™s actually scared of the Beast Incarnate, well, it€™s time to pack it in. Not only was the segment that opened SummerSlam not funny, it portrayed the Hardcore Legend as a fearful man. Yeah, he acknowledged that he€™s been out of the ring for many years, but when was the last time Shawn Michaels played €˜fraidy cat? Maybe if it was funny, you could give it a pass, but not in this instance.

4. An Opportunity Wasted

The Intercontinental Championship triple threat match between Ryback, Big Show and Miz originally was supposed to take place at Battleground, but a staph infection sidelined the champ and delayed the feud for a month. When Ryback returned a couple weeks ago, it looked like we could ramp up and then put this lackluster feud to bed. Not so fast. Although Ryback won Sunday night, he won by pinning Miz after Big Show knocked him out. Any wrestling fan knows that this isn€™t going to fly as an actual conclusion to the feud. Show will likely claim that he deserves a one-on-one title shot, so we€™ll have to endure another confrontation between Ryback and Big Show either on Raw or at Night of Champions next month. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FfEya772YnI It€™s not that Ryback and Big Show are bad together, but they have been squaring off now for more than two months. Despite Ryback being out for a month, the two have faced each other in some form or another five times, and now it looks like it€™ll continue. Ryback should have Shellshocked both Show and Miz, ended this feud and moved on to something new. It feels like an eternity since he faced someone else.

3. 24 Hours Removed From Greatness

Memo to WWE: Go back and watch the Sasha Banks versus Bayley match over and over and over. That was an instant classic between two women, with emotions and a great storyline tied around it. What we got Sunday night at SummerSlam was a mess. Throwing a bunch of spots together and having nine women hit a car crash spot on the outside isn€™t a Divas Revolution. It just shows that despite all the optimism, WWE managed to mangle an easy storyline and what should have been a series of great matches. Instead, we€™ve gotten some good matches, but no clear understanding of what these three-woman teams are fighting for €“ certainly not Nikki Bella€™s Divas Championship, since it hasn€™t been defended in seven weeks. Sunday€™s elimination match started slow, then slammed on the gas with the car crash on the outside. Moments later, Team BAD was quickly and quietly eliminated. The remaining two trios tried to put together a decent little match, but by that point it was a little too late. Perhaps the biggest problem is that Sasha and Bayley tore down the house Saturday. Almost anything after that was going to seem inadequate. It just didn€™t that this felt like one big forced mess. WWE needs to get back to basics fast.

2. SummerSlam Overshadowed By Takeover

After seeing all 10 matches, it€™s pretty obvious that while SummerSlam delivered some really good wrestling, it did not quite stand up to the overall quality of what NXT put on the previous night at Takeover: Brooklyn. It€™s rough to say that WWE€™s developmental territory had a better weekend than the main roster, but watching both PPVs, it€™s pretty clear that NXT had logical conclusions to storylines and really good matches up and down the card. WWE on the other hand did step up its collective game, but still fell a little short. Look at the co-main events each night: Bayley versus Sasha Banks and Finn Balor versus Kevin Owens for NXT and John Cena versus Seth Rollins and Brock Lesnar versus Undertaker. Both sets of matches were extremely good, but there was one noticeable difference: Both WWE main events ended with some shenanigans. Sure, Rollins/Cena only had a ref bump, but still. Lesnar/Taker ended with a series of issues, leaving Taker€™s victory tainted and Brock (through Paul Heyman) claiming victory. The NXT matches, on the other hand, ended strongly and put the champs over. So while SummerSlam was pretty good overall, it just didn€™t measure up to its sister show from Saturday.

1. Premature Bells, Low Blows And Obstructed Views

To say that the SummerSlam main event ended in controversy would be an understatement. To say that it ended in a way that is best for business would not be accurate in any way, shape or form. Let€™s be sure if we have it clear: The rematch billed as €œToo big for WrestleMania€ ended after a referee€™s vision was obstructed so he couldn€™t see Undertaker tapping out in the Kimura Lock, but the timekeeper 30 feet away saw it and rang the bell, leading to mass confusion. Undertaker took advantage and hit a low blow, then made Brock Lesnar pass out for his first win over the Beast in his entire career. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OEnwCdIWhYM What about this is supposed to make you feel good? Undertaker is/has turned heel, but half the audience barely noticed despite the blatant low blow (Taker€™s third in a month on Brock). And instead of milking the whole, €œTaker has never beaten Brock€ as the reason for demanding a career-threatening WrestleMania rematch next year, now it€™s €œTaker tapped behind the ref€™s back and then cheated to win, so we demand a rematch!€ Which version sounds better? Don€™t bother answering that question, it€™ll just show you€™re smarter than a typical WWE writer.

Ups...

9. Too Good To Boo

SummerSlam was in Brooklyn Sunday night, so what better way for a heel act to try to generate some heat than to hate on something local. But rather than making derogatory remarks about the local sports team (a wrestling cliché to be sure), why not mock one of Brooklyn€™s favorite sons, Jay Z? You would think that mocking one of his biggest hits, €œEmpire State of Mind,€ (which also in turn then mocks New York City itself) would do the trick, but New Day was so good at their schtick that they ended up drawing cheers with their pitch pipes, singing and dancing. Unlike the opening segment with Jon Stewart and Mick Foley, this was genuinely funny. When you mock Jay Z in Brooklyn while cutting up a song about New York City and you still get cheered, you know you€™re connecting with the audience.

8. Pin Attempt City

You have to take your hat off to the Miz for playing his role perfectly during the triple threat Intercontinental Championship match against Big Show and champ Ryback. The bout itself was short, quick-paced and inoffensive, with Ryback winning by pinning a downed Miz. Kudos go to Miz though for doing exactly what you€™d expect the undersized guy in this match to do: repeatedly try to steal pinfalls. At one point, Miz hit a Skull-Crushing Finale on Ryback after he had hit Shellshock on Show, then Miz tried pinning each man once, twice and three times to no avail. The crazed scampering between the two downed wrestlers garnered cheers for Miz. The match itself might not have been anything special, but Miz€™s antics definitely helped make it a little more memorable.

7. New Day, New Champs

Maybe Kofi Kingston€™s Icarus shoes telegraphed it a little too much, but you had to believe that New Day was going to leave SummerSlam with the WWE Tag Team Championships in hand. And thanks to the mass confusion that a fatal four-way tag match creates, New Day regained the titles that they arguably should never have lost. The four teams €“ champs Prime Time Players, Los Matadores, Lucha Dragons and New Day €“ kept things moving throughout the match and delivered some pretty fun moments. Kalisto in particular shined in this bout during a flurry against Big E and then Darren Young. Of course, Xavier Woods was gold on the outside, yelling about how Big E was serving €œtriceps meat€ when he hit opponents, and then spiking El Torito to take him out. This isn€™t going to win a Match of the Year nomination, but it was a fun match with the right result: New Day won, the former champs weren€™t pinned, and the most viable team to challenge the new champs (Lucha Dragons) weren€™t pinned either.

6. The Champ Is Here

Wow. OK, did anyone see that one coming? Seriously, if anyone predicted that Jon Stewart would interfere on Seth Rollins€™ behalf and the Architect would leave SummerSlam with both the WWE World Heavyweight and United States Championships in hand, then go buy a lottery ticket. In the Burning Questions column, the question was posed about how WWE would avoid having a dual champ. Out of several scenarios, only one suggested that Rollins win both titles, but it also theorized that he would need help and then would bestow the U.S. Championship to that person. It€™s highly unlikely that Stewart will be handed U.S. gold on Raw. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-kzIjp6hDWA So why? Why did Stewart help Rollins? Why did WWE go this route? And what will Rollins do as a dual singles champ? It€™s tough to categorize this as bad or good because it€™s just so mind-boggling. But since it€™s not a 16th world title reign for Cena and the crowd ate it up with a spoon, then it gets an €œup€ vote here for now.

5. Straight As An Arrow

Right out of the chute, credit has to be given to all four wrestlers in the comic book hero versus villain match. What could have been another disastrous celebrity match that would have made more of a mockery of the wrestling business turned out to be an entertaining €“ albeit safe €“ match between Neville/Stephen Amell and Stardust/King Barrett. Amell, star of television€™s €œGreen Arrow,€ showed that he has some athletic chops during his short spurts in the inoffensive tag match. He kipped up, hit a hiptoss and a leapfrog, nailed an enzuigiri and then dove onto Stardust and Barrett from the top rope to the floor. Amell also took some punishment from both opponents, playing the face in peril (as he should given his lack of ring experience). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jigRNsCV6Xs All of this was very safe stuff (relatively speaking) that allowed Amell to look pretty good in the ring without making Barrett or Stardust look bad. Sure, the cosmic villains lost, but come on, if you ever read a comic book, you€™d know that the heroes win in the end.

4. Win Owens Win

As much as fans love Cesaro right now, the announcers were absolutely right when they said that Kevin Owens really needed a win Sunday night. After losing two straight PPV matches to John Cena and losing the NXT Championship and a rematch, Owens desperately needed to right the ship. The two men laid it all out there with hard-hitting moves inside and outside the ring: somersault plancha, corkscrew plancha, sentons, second-rope gutwrench suplex, Giant Swing into a Sharpshooter, second-rope fisherman€™s buster and of course, a Pop-Up Powerbomb. It was exactly what you hoped for when the match was booked. Both men hit each other hard, and in the end, it was a mistake by Cesaro that cost him. It leaves the door open for a rematch, which most likely will also be fun to watch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kt4w1rZqfDk As mentioned previously, the statute of limitations on the old Booker-Benoit Best of Seven series (both the 1998 WCW original and 2005 WWE version) has passed, so if they can pry the United States or Intercontinental Championship away from Seth Rollins or Ryback, this could be an interesting feud to play out with a title on the line.

3. A Crazy Good Brawl

The memo about trying to match NXT€™s energy levels clearly was received by four of its graduates Sunday night. Dean Ambrose, Roman Reigns, Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper put their collective feet on the gas pedal at SummerSlam and didn€™t let up until the bell rung again. The tag team match between the pairs was a source of great speculation in the lead-up to SummerSlam. Was Sting supposed to join Reigns and Ambrose? Would Wyatt debut a new member of his family to shift the balance of power? Would Ambrose turn on his blood brother? In the end, none of that factored in and Reigns and Ambrose won shockingly clean, pinning Wyatt (also surprising). But the match itself was an awesome display of what you can do if the wrestlers involved are talented and have great timing. They hit a flurry of moves outside the ring that were too fast to call: Ambrose running across three announce tables to dive onto Bray; Reigns leaping over Ambrose to attack; Harper laying out Ambrose so Wyatt can hit a senton; and on and on. Even back in the ring, they kept things moving at a good clip that had fans along for the ride. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zASG5BUowtM The teams have said and the announcers acknowledged that this probably wouldn€™t be the last encounter between the teams, so there€™s still the possibility of new members, turns and whatnot, but this was a fun, energetic brawl.

2. The Clinic Is Open

Springboard stunner aside, John Cena and Seth Rollins went to the limit in what appeared to be a game of €œCan You Top This?€ Sunday night. The two champions hit top rope leaps, dives, power moves and broke out some unconventional offense during their title-for-title match. Cena used a figure-four leglock for what might be the first time in addition to a top rope legdrop and a couple good power moves. Rollins, who must have been watching NXT Takeover: Brooklyn closely Saturday night, decided to pull out all of the stops. The WWE World Heavyweight Champion hit repeated dives, a tope con hilo, a running Shooting Star Press, a Frogsplash, and a superplex floated into a Falcon Arrow. It was quite the display from a guy who also missed an attempt at a Phoenix Splash. In addition to all of these moves, both men really put together a great match. Cena has been on a roll since WrestleMania, having superb matches almost weekly, while Rollins has had a few outstanding ones himself and is perfectly capable of wowing a crowd. The result was something that measured up in terms of quality.

1. A Trip To Suplex City

The ending of the Brock Lesnar versus Undertaker match definitely detracted from the overall evaluation of the main event, but you can€™t deny that up until that point, the two warriors put on a true heavyweight fight. Lesnar delivered a series of suplexes €“ four Germans and a belly-to-belly €“ three F-5s and actually got Taker to tap out. Undertaker hit all his signature spots and looked better than he€™s looked in the ring in some time, maybe since WrestleMania XXIX against CM Punk. But the highlight of the match was the interplay between Brock and Taker, with Brock yelling €œSuplex City, b**ch!€ at his opponent. When Lesnar was busted open, he yelled at UT, €œI€™ll kill you, you son of a b**ch!€ to which Taker replied, €œYou€™re gonna have to!€ before chokeslamming him. After Lesnar kicked out a Tombstone Piledriver, he sat up laughing, followed by Taker, who mock-laughed at him before the started punching the hell out of each other. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9eR9-mk_1BM Even Lesnar€™s defiant gesture while trapped in Hell€™s Gate helped tell the tale of hatred between the two. As far as a main event goes, the bulk of the match really delivered a big fight feel for fans. But that ending€

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.