AEW Double Or Nothing 2024: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

Tony Khan wrestling on AEW pay-per-view CONFIRMED. No, only joking. Hopefully!

AEW Tony Khan
AEW

AEW Double Or Nothing 2024 will be a long night.

It could be a long night for good reasons, y'know. Fans could come away from the Las Vegas special with beaming smiles and phrases like, 'Tony Khan has cracked it!' or, 'Every match ruled'. Or, perhaps All Elite's loyal fanbase will funeral march their way back to hotel rooms with puzzled faces and cries of, 'CM Punk was right'.

You know the drill by now - positivity is in short supply when looking at all the various nightmares AEW could inflict on the biz this Sunday. As always, our Tony will be hoping his talent-heavy roster comes up with the goods and turns DoN into a show folks remember for good reasons. Sadly, the man's own booking and increasing inability to avoid well-known promoter pitfalls could scupper that.

There are a few matches on the lineup scarily close to the danger zone of audience apathy, and everyone's keen to see whether or not sticking lower-tier belts on some rather expensive signings is a solid plan. Then, there's the threat of a WWE rehash and a swerve so detestable it'd turn fans heel on AEW.

Have fun...

10. Ex-Best Friends Battle Is A Snore

Best Friends Orange Cassidy Trent Beretta Chuck Taylor
AEW

Pictured above: Best Friends during happier times.

On Sunday, Orange Cassidy will seek revenge on behalf of Chuck Taylor by...adhering to countouts, rope breaks and other standard pro wrestling match rules. Wait, what?! It's true. Thus far, AEW hasn't announced that Cassidy vs. Trent Beretta will be 'NO DQ' or anything else of the sort. That could outright murder the bout before it starts.

Orange and Trent can still work around things by making sure their match has some intense spots, but All Elite is asking a hell of a lot of them to make this revenge mission worthwhile under regular match conditions. The knock-on impact of such monotony might kill fan anticipation and make the showdown less-than.

It makes zero sense that the story has included 'Parking Lot Brawls' on free television, but will seemingly peak with a one-on-one singles match on pay-per-view. That's surely the wrong way around on the violence scale! TK should sort this ASAP before bell time.


9. Literally Nobody Cares About This Match

AEW Collision Toni Storm
AEW

Toni Storm performed a cheeky tease angle on TV to both promote Double Or Nothing and mock her rival Serena Deeb's serious wrestling dojo. Unfortunately for 'Timeless', even going chin up, t*ts out may not be enough to save the AEW Women's Title match from being one of Sunday's most yawn-worthy outings.

Few (if any) fans believe Deeb has a shot at taking the belt from Toni, and the story leading into this pay-per-view has hardly been compelling. In fact, it has boiled down to Serena warning Storm to cut the crap, and then Toni upping her histrionics for attention. There's a disconnect though - people aren't all that excited about seeing the pair wrestle.

Yikes.

Storm has one of the most engaging and colourful characters in modern wrestling, so it's a pity she's been relegated to this sort of 'B' feud heading into one of AEW's biggest nights. Toni vs. Deeb belongs on Battle Of The Belts, not Double Or Nothing.


8. Willow Nightingale Gets NOTHING

mercedes mone
All Elite Wrestling

AEW must be praying they see a better return on the sizeable investment Tony Khan made in Mercedes Mone. Thus far, the ex-Sasha Banks hasn't paid dividends for the promotion in terms of television ratings, and it remains to be seen whether she can bring in some pay-per-view dollars. We're about to find out.

Mone is a dead cert to take the TBS Title from Willow Nightingale. It'd be a shock if she lost, but that's not the top worry here. No, it's far more concerning to imagine that all of Willow's hard graft could be rolled up into a ball and tossed away just because Tony has a new action figure to play with.

Willow better get her licks in, and plenty of them.

She deserves better than to lose some sub-10 minute squash that's only on the card to shine a spotlight on all things Mercedes. Nightingale has worked too hard and for too long to become Mone's punching bag in a match that doesn't even reflect Mercedes' key strengths anyway.

Mone will win, but at least let Willow look competitive.


7. Mox Says ’Screw It! I’ll Bleed Too!’

Jon Moxley
AEW

A quick glance at the DoN card reveals all. Both the 'Barbed Wire Steel Cage' and 'Anarchy In The Arena' attractions are likely to feature some blood here or there (more so when the barbed wire gets involved), and that doesn't leave a lot of room for claret elsewhere on the show. Someone write that on a piece of paper and hand it to Jon Moxley.

'PLZ DON'T BLEED, MOX!'.

Now, cast your minds back to Jon's immediate run post-WWE in 2019. He became an old-school brute in New Japan, and brought that style with him to AEW after debuting on the very first Double Or Nothing. Back then, Moxley didn't over-rely on blood to make his matches dramatic. He was the drama.

This weekend's scrap vs. Konosuke Takeshita definitely doesn’t need the red stuff. Moxley should leave that to the cage bout and ‘Anarchy In The Arena’; it's only respectful to know your place on the card and defer to more important matches, after all.


6. Chris Jericho’s Pain Train Rolls On

Chris Jericho Big Bill Renee Paquette
AEW

AEW live crowds have spoken, and (being blunt) they want Chris Jericho to beat it. Any of the support Jericho had when he helped launch the promotion has vanished. He couldn't be further from the guy who worked World Title matches right now, and it's kinda sad to see for longtime fans who have watched him since the WCW days.

Many predict that Hook will win the number one contender situation on Dynamite (which hasn't happened at time of writing), then march on to Double Or Nothing to regain his FTW Title from Chris. In a perfect world, AEW would ditch the unofficial belt completely, but a fair compromise is letting Hook do his own thing with it.

Big Bill is right there as a possible tag-team partner that saves the day for Jericho, so it'd suck to see the former 'Y2J' continue to waste everyone's time in matches few actually want to see. Just let Hook tap him out, then move Jericho into the tag ranks where he'll hopefully be less exposed.

Or, y'know, take him off TV for a spell.


5. Will Ospreay Eats An Unnecessary Loss

Will Ospreay AEW
AEW

ARGH!

No, no this cannot happen. Look, every professional wrestler has to lose eventually, and it's hardly like Will Ospreay is 2,349-0 in terms of a win-loss record throughout his career. He will stare at the ceiling in AEW someday, but it feels too soon and this clash vs. Roderick Strong defo isn't the one, bruv.

Right, that's the final mention of Will's favourite word. Promise. Seriously though, the fact there will be other Undisputed Kingdom members around ringside has this writer fairly worried that Ospreay will flop when going after the International Title then move up the card anyway. That'd spit in the face of structure for his All Elite run.

This is a dude TK will be relying on to headline major stadium shows over in the UK, and it's important that Will looks like one of the best rather than one of the rest. Putting the International Title on him isn't a top plan, but it's too late to back out now.

Or...is it? ARGH!


4. AEW Swerves…Swerve!

Swerve Strickland Ice
AEW

Bloody hell, this sounds awful too.

Samoa Joe was always going to be more of a place-holding AEW World Champ, and that proved to be correct when Swerve Strickland beat him back at Dynasty. Swerve was visibly emotional after that, and rightly so. He's come a long way since tanking as part of Hit Row on SmackDown, and AEW's booking validated his determination to succeed.

Every champion is always one bad decision away from having the rug pulled out from underneath their feet though, and it looks like Strickland has a fight on his hands to even headline upcoming pay-per-views as champ. Other matches at DoN are arguably sexier than his bout vs. Christian Cage, put it that way.

What if AEW decides to book a quick swerve on Swerve by having Christian's entourage help him win the World Title? Or, what if all that whispering in Strickland's ear lately has been about Prince Nana's upcoming betrayal? It wouldn't make sense for Nana to bolt now Swerve is on top, but this is wrestling.


3. House Of Black = Judgment Day Rehash

Adam Copeland
AEW

If Adam Copeland loses on Sunday, then the pre-match stipulation says he has to bow down to House Of Black and effectively become a member by default. Cope has been living the nightmares Malakai Black's group favours over the past while anyway. His face was a picture when he started bleeding from the mouth recently.

It'd be worth someone backstage asking what the plan would be if Adam did have to join HOB. Would he eventually accept his fate and shift back into the same sort of dark character he played right at the start of Judgment Day over in WWE? If so, would that run too close to Edge's final heel bid (which turned out be a bit of a failure)?

Doing this wouldn't help AEW's own identity, 'cause a lot of people would draw comparisons between House Of Black with Copeland and Judgment Day with Edge. On the plus side, Adam and Malakai could be a good team, but they're probs more natural enemies.

AEW shouldn't willingly leech off recent WWE ideas.


2. The Elite Eat Humble Pie

Kazuchika Okada Young Bucks New Elite
AEW

There's a case to be made for The Young Bucks having 'go away heat' in 2024. The team's brand of spot-heavy matches doesn't really suit the characters they've been portraying since turning heel, and the quarter hour breakdowns (if you're into that sort of thing) don't make good reading for the EVP duo at all.

At DoN, they'll team with Elite pals Kazuchika Okada and Jack Perry against Bryan Danielson, FTR and Darby Allin. The latter is subbing in for an injured Eddie Kingston, so it makes sense to believe Darbs will take the fall and let The Elite brag obnoxiously on TV afterwards. Or, AEW could have another plan.

Read: A worse one.

Despite some fans turning off from them, The Bucks, Okada and Perry certainly shouldn't be spoon-fed humble pie just yet, and they also shouldn't lose to a piecemeal team of babyfaces at 'Anarchy In The Arena'. This is the heel group's chance to outsmart their rivals, feed into Claudio Castagnoli's concerns for Bryan and more.

Losing doesn't leave a lot of wriggle room for that story.


1. Tony Khan Gets Physically Involved

Tony Khan
AEW

Rewatch Tony Khan taking a shot to the gut from Jack Perry and a finish from The Bucks last month. Do that, and you'll see why the mere thought of Tony stepping back inside a wrestling ring to get physical is such a nightmare. The guy doesn't have any instincts for selling moves realistically, and he'd only embarrass himself by trying to work a match.

Oh God - nobody give AEW ideas.

There'd be palmed foreheads all around if Khan came out to help make the difference at Double Or Nothing during that 'Anarchy In The Arena' brawl. His revenge on The Elite should come eventually, sure, but it has to come via actual pro wrestlers. Nobody's selling out arenas to see Tony vs. Jack Perry, let's get that straight.

That aforementioned episode of Dynamite in April proved another thing: Tony doesn't suit physicality. Keep him far, far, far away from this 'Anarchy' scenario at DoN, and absolutely don't entertain thoughts of Khan actively setting up a future match.

Which other nightmares could come true at AEW Double Or Nothing 2024? For more wrestling, check out WWE King & Queen Of The Ring 2024: 10 Things That Must Happen and WWE King & Queen Of The Ring 2024: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True! 


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.