AEW Double Or Nothing: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

Shots fired.

Double Or Nothing
AEW

AEW's first-ever PPV event got the promotion off to one hell of a strong start, with Double or Nothing proving a hugely crowd-pleasing show for the most part, packed with quality wrestling and terrific storytelling.

Was it perfect? Absolutely not - the production could use some fine-tuning when it comes to editing and camera coverage, but in terms of in-ring action, show pacing and subverting audience expectations, the show was a remarkable success.

With WWE's main product presently residing in the toilet and fan apathy never being stronger, AEW couldn't have come at a better time.

With production values not a million miles away from WWE while boasting wrestling on-par with the best in the business, this show saw AEW throw down the gauntlet to their billion-dollar rival, urging them to do better.

Whether they can ever become a viable alternative to WWE or not, this is an extremely encouraging first PPV. If the teething problems can be ironed out in due course, their August 31st show, All Out, could be even better. Especially if CM Punk shows up, of course...


9. 22-Man Casino Battle Royale

AEW Double Or Nothing Casino Battle Royal
AEW

Result: Adam Page eliminates MJF for the win, and the right to challenge for the AEW World Title (16:00).

Rating: It's always a risk introducing a new match type, especially one with rules this convoluted, and while the concept didn't lend itself that well to live TV, the match was nevertheless a solid riff on the usual Battle Royal formula.

There was a decent mix of athleticism and silly shenanigans (Nakazawa's oil, Joey Janela wearing a lit cigarette and Tommy Dreamer getting his nuts stapled, for instance), not to forget the occasional flash of genuine brutality (that Luchasaurus table spot looked horrific).

It was definitely rough around the edges, though - botches were commonplace and the producer missed crucial coverage of several spots.

Cage's eventual presence ensured a predictable finish, but overall this was a decent showcase for some potential future AEW talent. #SignLuchasaurus. 6/10


8. Fatal-4-Way: Kylie Rae Vs. Nyla Rose Vs. Britt Baker Vs. Awesome Kong

AEW Double Or Nothing Britt Baker Kylie Rae
AEW

Result: Baker kills Rae with the Ushigoroshi for the victory (11:10).

Rating: Just when it seemed like Brandi Rhodes was going to serve up some WWE-style Authority shenanigans, there came the Awesome Kong swerve - and indeed, it was awesome, despite Kong's clearly limited mobility.

Regrettably, however, the usual Fatal-4-Way formula was out in full effect here - two people fighting, two people sleeping - which felt lazy and not the sort of statement you want to make in a new promotion.

Kong spent way too much of the match sleeping after her introduction, and if she really wasn't able to do much, it would've made sense for her to be brutally incapacitated.

Still, the match picked up substantially in the second half as Kong got more involved, and the younger talents all came out of it looking great. 6/10


7. Sammy Guevara Vs. Kip Sabian

AEW Double Or Nothing Kip Sabian Sammy Guevara
AEW

Result: Sabian puts Guevara away with the Deathly Hallows to secure the win (10:00).

Rating: This was fluid and fast-paced throughout, and honestly would've been a fun way to open the main show.

Excessive cutting by the producers definitely harmed the impact of several key moves at home, and it never quite hit the high-gear you might've hoped for, but nevertheless did a great job conveying Kip Sabian's potential as a breakout star.

As a frantic sprint that never let up, though, it delivered the basic goods and then some. 7/10


6. Best Friends Vs. Angélico & Jack Evans

AEW Double Or Nothing Best Friends
AEW

Result: The Best Friends drill Evans with a Dude Buster/Foot Stomp combo for the win (12:35).

Rating: These guys really should've co-ordinated their attire, huh? Too much neon. As for the match itself, all four men went hard, and the results were both savage and hilarious ("Nobody kicks out of the Falcon Arrow!" and the Rainmaker-style hugging).

Evans and Angelico pulled off some incredible teamwork here in a match that unquestionably gave a strong first impression of AEW's tag division.

The post-match beatdown from the Super Smash Brothers was also a fun added wrinkle, though the announcers really should've explained who they were for the sake of the casual crowd.

Presumably they'll be getting a name change moving forward, for legal reasons. 7/10


5. SoCal Uncensored Vs. Strong Hearts

AEW Double Or Nothing SoCal Uncensored
AEW

Result: Kazarian and Daniels kill Lindaman with the Best Meltzer Ever for the win (13:40).

Rating: That SoCal promo sure was rough, huh? Thankfully they proved they've still got it where it counts in the ring, though.

This was a rock solid opener and a brilliantly paced showcase for AEW talent both young and old, and made a very compelling argument for the company going the NJPW route with a trios division in the near-future.

The match also introduced AEW's 10-count rule for non-legal team members - it doesn't really change the ebb and flow of the matches much, but at least makes the ref look like less of a dope.

SCU definitely should've lost, but it's tough to complain when Christopher Daniels and Frankie Kazarian continue to do their thing so damn well. 7/10


4. Kenny Omega Vs. Chris Jericho

AEW Double Or Nothing Chris Jericho Kenny Omega
AEW

Result: Jericho puts Omega away with the Judas Effect (27:00).

Rating: As expected this was a car wreck with a ton of extras, and Omega quite understandably did most of the heavy lifting.

It never really got close to the inspired madness of their NJPW match, and it's clear that Jericho just doesn't have enough gas in the tank for these half-hour matches anymore, but Omega thankfully helped carry him to the finish line splendidly.

If far from a top-tier main event, it was still very good for what it was, even if the ending didn't quite feel earned enough, making Jericho's win come off a tad hollow and rushed.

Following two show-stealing matches it came up a little short, even if by mainstream wrestling standards it was hugely enjoyable. 7/10


3. Aja Kong, Yuka Sakazaki & Emi Sakura Vs. Hikaru Shida, Riho Abe & Ryo Mizunami

AEW Double Or Nothing
AEW

Result: Shida pins Sakura after nailing her with a Running Knee (13:10).

Rating: If you've never seen a Joshi match before, this was one hell of a treat, and everyone got a strong showing here.

The younger wrestlers' breakneck pace was countered perfectly by the sheer high-impact of Aja Kong, who despite slowing down with age absolutely brought the force you'd expect.

Even the premature bell ring botch couldn't derail the momentum here, and actually seemed to accidentally strengthen the authoritry of the ref, while suggesting we won't be getting many screwy finishes in AEW.

Despite a few sloppy spots, this was a great introduction to Joshi for the casual crowd, and an all-round remarkable athletic contest. 8/10


2. Dustin Vs. Cody

AEW Double Or Nothing Cody Dustin
AEW

Result: Cody finally puts his brother away with the Cross Rhodes (22:30).

Rating: Nobody was expecting much of a great wrestling match from these two, but following three intense workrate-focused bouts, it was just the bloody, ugly slug-fest the audience needed, with extremely emotional storytelling to boot.

Dustin earned the "you've still got it" chants in what's surely one of his strongest ever in-ring performances.

The use of blood felt like another statement-of-intent from AEW, and though you can argue it went a little over-the-top, it absolutely added to the drama of the match.

This was more a fun demolition derby than a technical showcase, of course, and exactly what it needed to be - the crowd was red-hot and the desperation in the later stretches was sold terrifically.

Dustin winning would've been a great moment, but the finish made sense and the post-match hug-out was wonderful. 9/10


1. AAA Tag Titles: The Young Bucks (c) Vs. The Lucha Bros

AEW Double Or Nothing Lucha Bros Young Bucks
AEW

Result: The Bucks retain the straps after murdering Fénix with the Meltzer Driver (24:55).

Rating: This was an incredible tag match that nailed a near-perfect balance between "flippy s***" and visceral impact.

Fénix was the easy MVP and earmarked himself as a major asset to AEW - those Double Destroyers from the Bros were absolutely incredible.

You can argue there was perhaps one or two false finishes too many, but for the most part they fed into the desperation, even if the result was fairly predictable.

It's a shame the Bucks didn't lose and then instantly crown themselves the inaugural AEW Tag Team champs, because it would've been the most Bucks things ever.

But everyone knows The Lucha Bros will win the titles back at AAA's Verano de Escándalo PPV in a few weeks, so as far as "holding pattern" bouts go, all four men did a great job making you forget that fact. 9/10


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.