AEW Double Or Nothing: Star Ratings For All 9 Matches

An incredible night for professional wrestling.

DoN Omega
FiteTV

All Elite Wrestling Executive Vice President and Chief Brand Officer Cody and Brandi Rhodes delighted in ramping up already gigantic expectations ahead of Double or Nothing.

"I feel like if you’re not satisfied at the end of Double Or Nothing, you’re not a wrestling fan," said Brandi during the press rounds, in quite the flex.

"On Saturday, there is the chance that you might see the greatest World Championship Title that has ever been created," Cody told Chris Van Vliet of WSVN-TV, in a pointed statement. He booked himself to win the Ten Pounds of Gold at ALL IN. His love of JCP and the NWA borders on the obsessive, and he all but promised a better-looking title than even his precious.

Radiating a level of giddy confidence that exceeded even the promotion's all-out assault of a mission statement - AEW is going to be the best and most meaningful wrestling promotion out there, ran the press release - looking up at cloud nine, some dissenting fans felt looked down at. Cody said, losing himself in his Evening With host duties, that Bayley only pretends to be nice. That "no thought" went into the WWE 24/7 Championship poor Mick Foley had to introduce on Monday's RAW. "What the f*ck was he holding?"

The contrarian mutants of Wrestling Twitter were ready to pounce at the slightest misstep on the night.

If you're going to talk sh*t, you gotta back it up.

9. 21-Man Casino Battle Royale

DoN MJF
FiteTV

A very divisive match, subjectively, this was as entertaining as hell, though ill-advised as an eye-catching mission statement. The undiluted, carefree postmodern approach didn't reflect AEW's apparent real-sports M.O.

Objectively, this probably failed in its dual objectives.

It did not appeal to a curious casual fanbase hovering over the 'Order' button. To a lapsed WWE fan, it seemed to delight in living down to the Independent scene's reputation. Orange Cassidy's casual, limp kicks, the sheer, tiny size of Marko Stunt, and Joey Janela's deranged bumping were consummately Indyrrific. A celebration for the boys but an alienating in-joke to prospective new fans, the onslaught of comedy undermined the stakes. A match in which Tommy Dreamer's face was repeatedly forced into a c*ck and balls will directly inform the lineage of the company's top title. It was tonally at odds with all the hype.

Beyond that, the Kevin Dunn-esque production nightmares, and the confusing and anticlimactic order of entrances, this was MJF's total riot of a debutante ball. The first thing he did was target the guy with no legs and reprimand him for having no feet. Of course he did.

Ultimately, AEW maximised the appeal of a potential superstar in a dazzling coming out party, just babyfaced Hangman Page sufficiently, and created scope for a tantalising midcard programme ahead of AEW's TV debut.

Star Rating: ***1/4


8. Kip Sabian Vs. Sammy Guevara

DoN Kip Sabian
FiteTV

Sammy Guevara impressed here in his brash and vicious heel role - particularly when he aimed a double foot stomp squarely on the back of Kip Sabian's skull before intensifying that onslaught with a barrage of fists.

Intense and wince-inducing for a pre-show match, Guevara stoked the fire in the crowd with his fabulously irritating facial expressions before popping their t*ts off with a high-risk shooting star press to the outside - a spot which probably undermines his heel bit. His arrogance at least informed the finish; he attempted a 630 splash before Sabian caught him with the flash submission win. A decent offering, worked with individual flourishes, this succeeded in its basic aim of ungluing the crowd.

If wins and losses are to matter, in AEW's response to the 50/50 booking malaise, the company will need a 0 to make the top tier look 100. In Sabian, the company has hired a capable and sympathetic babyface to build heat on TV for the likes of MJF - one with a creative and legit enough submission game to not free-fall into geek territory.

Star Rating: ***


7. SoCal Uncensored Vs. Strong Hearts

DoN CIMA
FiteTV

A perfect choice to open the show.

SCU are over as sh*t with this audience because they personify what is so alluring about Independent wrestling. They showed bags of personality in their call-and-response bit before marrying that wonderful d*ckhead charisma with crisp technique and the match layout skills of learned vets who have mastered the game.

It was heartwarming to see CIMA afforded the time and freedom to wrestle at his ageless, timeless best, too. His influence over pro wrestling is vast; his work with the Dragon Gate promotion was proto-everything you see and love now, and this match proved that he hasn't lost his dynamic brilliance. His teammates, largely unfamiliar to the audience, got themselves over with them through stunning, complementary chemistry. T-Hawk's vicious strikes were followed instantly by the lightning-quick timing of El Lindaman's jaw-dropping deadlift power arsenal as this beast sprinted towards a nuts finish.

Regrettably, nobody told Jim Ross that these men were not, in fact, Chinese, which proved distracting and discouraging. In a happy and reassuring development, however, Ross grew in composure throughout the night - as if the wrestling was so good that it sharpened his iron.

Star Rating: ****


6. Britt Baker Vs. Nyla Rose Vs. Kylie Rae Vs. Awesome Kong

DoN Kylie Ray
FiteTV

A not inauspicious start to AEW's Women's division, this was enhanced considerably by the last-minute arrival of Awesome Kong, whose formidable aura carried her contributions to a mostly solid but eye-catching match at various points.

It's a good job Kylie Ray's brand of charisma is infectious, because the act itself is divisive in its cute overkill. The work helps, too; raw but very eager to impress, Ray's battling performance threaded the story of two marketable faces escaping and enduring the daunting physical threats of Kong and spiritual successor Nyla Rose, whose limited but credible skill-set was deployed well enough in this multi-person context - although she mistimed her part in a late multi-woman sequence, undermining the momentum built in no small part by the formula.

The other marketable face, Britt Baker, justified her win and presumed big push. She wrestled smartly enough to mask the lack of proper oomph in her offensive game. Her performance, the match, and the division all felt like a work in progress, albeit one with potential to succeed beyond the remit of a Brandi Rhodes vanity project.

In what became a very astute theme, for AEW's debut show, this match doubled as a building block for a singles clash opposite Ray.

Star Rating: ***


5. Best Friends Vs. Angélico & Jack Evans

DoN Best Friends
Fite TV

A pulsating and inventive if slightly uneven match, this serviced the card effectively enough without threatening to steal it - but that was the aim. It existed to maintain the momentum of the show and showcase the depth, not the leading lights, of AEW's potentially incredible tag team division.

Angélico and Evans drew big reactions throughout with creative and spectacular big-time aerial double-team manoeuvres, but nothing really registered - or was paced quite well enough - to properly maximise the winning babyface appeal of the dorky, loveable Best Friends duo. Ultimately, Double Or Nothing existed as a platform on which to present new characters to a new audience, and as hot and potent as some of the sequences were, this felt a bit interchangeable with much of the wider Indy oeuvre. And that's fine; this was a match on a card designed to be little more than that. Angélico's gear is off-putting CAW stuff - a heckle in the crowd confirmed as much - but his high spots soared in a sugar rush of a match lacking in truly compelling, layered drama.

Entertaining my-turn-your-turn fare performed with admirable, full-on mettle, but nothing that left a lasting impression.

Star Rating: ***1/2


4. Hikaru Shida, Riho Abe & Ryo Mizunami Vs. Aja Kong, Yuka Sakazaki & Emi Sakura

DoN Yuka
FiteTV

A match boasting super range, this also diversified the complexion of the card in itself. Perfectly sequenced and loaded with eclectic genre showcases, this promised much ahead of Kenny Omega's much-touted influence over AEW's Women's division.

Aja Kong kicked so hard that you'd have probably welcomed an old Katsuyori Shibata PK in comparison. Teammate Yuka Sakazaki, Kong's physical and character antithesis, endeared herself to an unfamiliar but receptive crowd in a ridiculously charming cameo in which she belied the Kawaii facade with a spirited and hugely energetic offensive game, where Emi Sakura's Freddie Mercury bit brilliantly unglued a gradually welcoming western audience charmed by the personality and brutal head-dropping action on display.

Ryo Mizunami's explosive late showing added to the escalatory drama of an incredibly well-paced match, the build and commitment of which compensated for the few glitches and lagging issues that slowed down the game (if understandably diminished) Aja Kong.

The timekeeping error was unforgivable, even on a debut show. It detracted from the drama of the finish, and revealed significant teething issues Cody's flexing promotion conditioned us to disregard.

Then again, there was a reason the American Nightmare showed such supreme confidence heading into the weekend...

Star Rating: ****


3. Cody Vs. Dustin Rhodes

DoN Cody
FiteTv

From Cody's entrance, to the outlaw execution, to the disgusting buckets of blood, to the visceral emotion, to the astonishing acknowledgement of pro wrestling's past, to the molten heat, to the sheer authenticity, to the nuanced, multi-dimensional character work, to the at-times unbearable, harrowing drama, this was the preeminent anti-WWE match, promoted by the anti-WWE company - and what a stunning, scarcely believable triumph it was.

The storytelling was absolutely superb - a definitive indictment of WWE's road agent system. Cody, going full-on in his d*ckhead heel role, cartwheeled around his older brother to show off the athleticism that deserted him long ago. Only, it didn't; Dustin Rhodes' awesome somersault senton to the outside awakened something ugly within the younger son, who channelled it by opening a sickening hole in Dustin's head. Dustin broke the motherf*cking Muta scale in a disturbing, anxious match that echoed the old school in both its timeless brilliance and regressive ugliness.

But Rhodes showed enough fire to banish those 2004 memories in an audacious and unforgettable performance, and in delivering, somehow, a Canadian Destroyer, he capped off a superb working performance just as it was felt the match had tumbled down into the deepest waters of the shoot.

An ass-spanking masterpiece of emotion and atonement.

Star Rating: ****1/2


2. The Lucha Brothers Vs. The Young Bucks

DoN Penta
FiteTV

The Young Bucks told an absolutely incredible story here, in which the flips (which are awesome in and of themselves, f*ck you) were wrapped up in an absorbing plot that firmly and very successfully positioned Matt and Nick Jackson as the Aces of AEW's doubles division.

Showing ring rust, purposefully, through several painful miscommunications, this was the richest of psychology. Far more logical than the naysayers - who are naywatchers, so again: f*ck you - would ever credit them for, Matt and Nick emerged from the corporate world to face the most daunting of combat challenges. Penta El Zero M delighted in dropping his stinger offence. His partner, Fénix, performing here in legit Best In The World form, wowed the crowd and mystified his opponents with his staggering reinvention of rope-charming lucha libre.

Apron Canadian Destroyer spots that drew audible shrieks; a cute and dramatically effective Superkick party that pummelled Matt Jackson's face in a spot even Jim Cornette might have enjoyed; the dangerous and furious, über-creative sequences and saves and spots mastered by the Bucks in a match that really earned them: this was as tight as it was awe-inspiring.

Framing this "rusty" vintage of the Bucks as doyens was a very committed push, the conviction behind which should pay off and make the tandem that eventually defeats them.

Long-term storytelling: promise kept.

Star Rating: ****3/4


1. Kenny Omega Vs. Chris Jericho

DoN Omega
FiteTV

Less a subpar Kenny Omega match than a very, very different one, this did not erupt in the trademark cloudburst of counter insanity in the final act.

Instead, this was a gruesome squelcher of lip-pursing physicality perhaps more effective as the opening act of a shared universe extravaganza than a spectacle unto itself. Jericho and Omega wrestled, statically, in a certain gear that ground and ground, portraying incredibly well Omega as a bloody-nosed babyface unable to build his offensive game, and Jericho, in contrast, as a nasty, expert ring general.

That was the intention; AEW went all in on the Alpha as the focal point of the main event scene going forward in a very astute move. Omega excelled in 2018 as the redemptive babyface, a role he is set to emulate - whereas there isn't, if the timing issues that plagued the finishing sequence, a great deal of mileage within this latest, wonderfully acerbic reinvention of the Jericho character.

Ugly by accident more than design by the sudden and anticlimactic finish, it is impossible not to admire the brutality of the storytelling and its awesome, authentic depiction of pure hatred.

The post-match angle, in which Jon Moxley made his debut, was stunning - the way in which Omega avoided the Dirty Deeds by tumbling himself and this disruptor from the ring, instigating a wild brawl, was proper big fight stuff - and crucial. The party is over, and it's just as well: the celebrations were developing a slight air of nausea.

AEW Double Or Nothing was a tremendous, tremendous wrestling show. They are capable of better, too.

Star Rating: ****


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!