AEW's Next Big Thing (... Is The Last Thing YOU Want)

AEW could be about to bring in another controversial industry icon. And it could be AWESOME...

MJF Bill Goldberg
AEW/WWE

How do you feel about Bill Goldberg possibly signing for All Elite Wrestling?

Tony Khan's extremely open to it.

He said as much after news broke that the former WCW World Heavyweight and WWE Universal Champion left the market leader after seven years working a part-time schedule for the group. And it makes sense too - Khan's got fingers in the same two pies Goldberg has feasted on during his athletic career. An NFL star between 1990 and 1995, he was forced out of football through injury but the sport's loss was World Championship Wrestling's gain between 1997 and its 2001 closure.

Khan subsequently praised Goldberg's athleticism and personality, and in a manner that implied he'd be a welcome presence in the AEW locker room. The compliments alone instantly transformed empty speculation into one of the bigger stories of the year, and suddenly a theoretically preposterous notion was more of a reality than anybody could have previously imagined.

It has generated as much intrigue as it has fear from fans with the strongest emotional ties to the company. That alone speaks volumes about the potential value of the deal actually going through, but to those on the (in some cases, extremely) negative end of the scale, it has to be asked pragmatically; What exactly is there to be afraid of?

CONT'D...


Sting Jon Moxley Eddie Kingston
AEW

Tony Khan has won the Wrestling Observer Best Booker award every year since 2020.

Your mileage may vary in terms of valuing that recognition, but it is at least democratically decided upon. Readers of the newsletter cast the votes, and those readers in large majorities have named Khan as the best creative force for them for as long as AEW has been a 12-months-a-year television wrestling product.

The level of trust between the President and his core base is at this point extremely assured. Khan brought back trusting the process, brought back actually supporting three letters as much as any individual wrestlers, and stopped "let it play out" being a joke at the market leader's expense.

He's good at this, and even with his time and efforts stretched thinner than ever, he's still working towards maintaining a level way, way beyond the market leader. The weekly match, angle and promo bar in All Elite Wrestling is set substantially higher than WWE's, and that's even counting the version of the company currently simpatico with the needs of its core base.

That includes the treatment of legends. Sting (more on him later) has had a three-year run to rival just about any extended stint in his legendary career, and all following on from age and injuries rendering him previously retired. Khan has always understood AEW's right to steward wrestling history just as much as WWE, and has applied Paul Heyman's accentuate the positives/hide the negatives philosophy to every figure from the industry's past he's been able to get his hands on. It's a safer haven for the old pros than Vince McMahon's erratic mind palace ever was, and even he got a Goldberg right eventually.

CONT'D...


27 Goldberg Brock Lesnar Survivor Series
WWE.com

It took longer than it should have, but Vince McMahon absolutely nailed it with Goldberg.

The 2003 run was a mess, but what in 2003 wasn't? The pathetic Triple H World Heavyweight Title programme wasn't even 'The Game's biggest political crime that year, let alone McMahon's biggest creative screw-up. 2016-2017 with Brock Lesnar was different gravy though, and flashes of brilliance were evident against the likes of Bobby Lashley and Roman Reigns even if battles with The Undertaker, Drew McIntyre and Braun Strowman couldn't live up to the promise of the graphics.

All Elite Wrestling might not have rankings anymore, but it has frameworks in place enough that the likes of Jade Cargill's streak can be protected even when there's little-to-no interest in it. The red-hot version of that with or without the Goldberg numbers of old would make for utterly captivating television over what could stand to be an unforgettable and seminal final run. Massive WCW fan and critically acclaimed booker Tony Khan can keep this simple, stupid. All he needs to do is look at the mammoth roster he's assembled and ask "Who's Next?"

That's key to all of this - Goldberg has to be as All In as the show that helped birth the company. Dynamite and Rampage, every week, in short bursts, building a hype train impossible not to want to hop on. Book him to wrestle approximately 20 of his unimpeachable sub-five minute matches, and luxuriate in how the diverse and immensely talented wrestlers on the roster navigate around it.

Even in short-form, the list of dream matches is as long as Big Bill's original WCW streak. And that's not even the Big Bill that's already on the AEW roster in a match that would also rule! Booking him would be a marathon and a sprint.

CONT'D...


Goldberg WCW Champion
WWE.com

Goldberg's legendary undefeated World Championship Wrestling run is spoken about with such reverence because it was the right booking for the right man at the right time. It was difficult to end and difficult to come back from after the fact, but the former NFL man's remarkable charisma and the lightning-in-a-bottle nature of how he got over made for one of the more captivating snowball pushes in wrestling history.

It worked twofold for WCW too - the squashes were electrifying, but the more of a star Goldberg became, the more his contests with established stars suddenly felt closer to dream matches.

If Tony Khan's been guilty of one thing when it comes to manifesting a range of different (and often unthinkable) combinations, it's that he's inadvertently presented just as many missed opportunities. If CM Punk never wrestles for All Elite Wrestling again, a minimum of two generations of the fanbase will rue that Punk/Kenny Omega and Punk/Cody Rhodes never happened despite there being time to get both done.

The Omega/Vikingo graphic drop for the March 22nd edition Dynamite resulted in a conversational kick-off from the worst Twitter accounts you know, but in reality there should be loads more like this. AEW has reimagined the old model clung to by WWE in the monopoly years, and power to them for it. The gauntlets are old hat now, but they've existed to allow the likes of Nick Gage, Juventud Guerrera, Bandido and others to walk through the front door and make a bit of television magic.

Few wrestlers could be slotted in under those circumstances as well as Bill Goldberg. He'd kick the door down and kick *ss from night one.

CONT'D...


AEW Revolution 2023 MJF
AEW

As a debuting babyface on a one-man mission to win one last top prize, Goldberg has more losers to cut in half than he'd know what to do with.

For a company called All Elite Wrestling, it's been almost too good at lining up wrestlers cast as perennial dweebs. But it does at least create a tier for 'Da Man' to rapidly work through en route to the natural and awesome end destination. After targeting the likes of Tony Nese and The Firm, he can rapidly move on to despatching the likes of Jeff Jarrett and Chris Jericho before answering the arrogant call of an MJF riding yet another high after defeating all Four Pillars and theoretically considering himself indestructible.

Who better to ask "Who's Next?", and who better to answer?

Goldberg spearing the AEW Champion out of his scarf sets up the programme in an instant, especially considering the pace and rate of the former WCW Champion's ascent.

Invoking Triple H's "Reign Of Terror" yet again, Friedman could promise to beat Bill in a fair fight just like his hero 'The Game', then blast and bludgeon the 56-year-old with the Dynamite Diamond Ring as he's mid-Spear. It's a cute bit, a good callback, and a genuinely useful scalp for MJF as he builds the prestige of his reign.

And what of the Challenger afterwards?

Beaten by cheating and unable to get a rematch in a more logical environment, 'Da Man' could snap, leaving absolutely nobody safe...

CONT'D...


Goldberg Sting
WWE.com

The sprint face run becomes a sprint heel climax overnight.

Goldberg could rip through Darby Allin or Jungle Boy in matches that would cast him as a money-grabbing interloper but would be too awesome not to book. Are you suggesting you don't want to see what Goldberg Vs a Rey Fenix, both members of Top Flight or Bandido looks like? Goldberg refusing to take any of Orange Cassidy's sh*t?! Goldberg Vs Danhausen?! Goldberg and two heels vs The Elite to build to an impossibly great Goldberg/Kenny Omega showdown? Off the back of those and others like them, the increasingly infuriated Goldberg could try and be the one to retire Sting amidst a slew of wrestlers and fans that desperately don't want to see the 64-year-old walk away.

As effective as much of his WWE run was, there were times when the former Universal Champion was booked as something of a spirit crusher. Victories over Kevin Owens, Dolph Ziggler and especially The Fiend cast him as a weapon used by Vince McMahon to destroy everybody's hopes and dreams. AEW thankfully doesn't carry that burden with fan-friendly Tony Khan at the helm, but Goldberg the character could easily own it himself. Khan could tweet his regret over signing him, drawing on their old friendship and how 'Da Man' broke a gentleman's agreement by turning on the company's ethos and breaking everybody's hearts.

By losing to Sting, Goldberg could see the error of his ways and use a handshake/hug moment to realise the error and misplaced direction of his anger. From there, he can conclude business with the company losing to either Wardlow or Powerhouse Hobbs in a passing-the-torch exhibition, and ride off into the sunset, arc completed.

Where's the bad on-paper combination? Where's the wasted loss? Where's the net negative? Because the positives are everywhere you look.

CONT'D...


Goldberg is all elite
AEW

Not to drown fun fantasy booking in numbers discussion, but there was a brief spell in 2021 where All Elite Wrestling felt like one star or storyline from competing with Monday Night Raw in viewerships and demographics on a weekly basis. Company cornerstone Chris Jericho was even confident enough to predict it, such was the momentum at the time.

AEW had roared back into life as crowds were let back into buildings, making the best of the fabulous creative from the pandemic and rewarding live audiences with a fully-realised version of a serving-all-masters mainstream pro wrestling show.

CM Punk's iconic debut was incredible before he walked through the First Dance curtain, but even better by the time he'd finished cutting one of the best promos of his career and set up a dream match against Darby Allin. A month later, Bryan Danielson and Adam Cole were on board, and just after that, the company were able to pay off the Kenny Omega/Hangman Page AEW Championship story that had been part of the organisation's DNA from the off.

Unfortunately, the new heights were in fact a ceiling, and it's a ceiling that hasn't been hit since those halcyon days. Goldberg - especially in what should be this relatively short sharp shock of a run - isn't the wrestler to bring about a permanent return to the former highs, but he'd likely be a much-needed spike. If Khan's creative juices are still flowing, he can use that added and unexpected exposure to ensure the passing trade sticks around for the diverse range on offer.

Bill Goldberg's an answer to a question few people have ever asked when it comes to AEW. We are beyond the era where they actively avoid doing anything WWE has ever done, and thankfully the organisation's growing pains appear to have passed too. There's less to fear than what first appears.

"Goldberg Is #AllElite" is reflective of the ever-changing anything-can-happen landscape that established itself in 2022, and if 2023 is to be remembered as the year where the market leader didn't fumble Cody Rhodes, why can't it also be the one known for when the challenger brand made the best of one of the boom period's most legendary Champions?


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.