All In 2: 8 Things We Want To See
Break the walls down (again)...
Well, they did it.
Cody Rhodes, The Young Bucks and friends went All In on a friendly wager with Wrestling Observer chief Dave Meltzer, and they absolutely smashed it. Saturday night's event in Chicago wasn't only a victory for the Bullet Club boys though. It was a win for pro wrestling as a whole.
As the show went off the air, Cody slyly dropped hints to the live crowd inside the Sears Centre that All In 2 was incoming. That raises the question: just how can these guys top what they achieved over the weekend, and what would fans who enjoyed All In like to see from a sequel? More, more, more, is the easy answer, but (funnily enough) there's more to it than that.
The 10,000+ in attendance on Saturday can rightly pat themselves on the back for supporting something special, something that maybe, just maybe might pique WWE's attention enough that their own product becomes better. Competition is something Vince McMahon thrives on, don't forget.
Cody and The Bucks won't be worrying about that for now, not when there's the potential for a greater return at All In 2. This is, hopefully, only the beginning of their combined journey as executive producers. They've proven they have the chops for it...
8. No WWE Disruption
...but WWE still belong in the discussion here, and fans of what Cody and The Young Bucks accomplished will be hoping they don't try to interfere in a sequel's surefire success.
The McMahon family must be looking on with a mixture of amazement and respect for what All In was; this was the first non-WWE or WCW wrestling show in North America to crack 10,000 fans since 1993. That in itself deserves a standing ovation. Cody and pals showed themselves as wonderful self-promoters who, crucially, also put on an excellent product.
Will WWE realistically sit idly by and let this sort of thing continue? It's surely arrogant to suggest they have a say, but this is the most powerful organisation in the industry we're talking about, and they've disrupted nuggets of success before by signing away key talent.
Much of the old TNA roster is on WWE or NXT television in 2018, and that's no happy accident. There's a slight chance WWE will try to undermine talk of All In 2 by offering Cody, The Bucks and Kenny Omega some serious cash before it happens. Fanciful? Perhaps. Out of the question? Not a chance.
7. That 'Over The Budget' Battle Royal Sticks
That 19-person 'Over The Budget' Battle Royal was a riot on All In's pre-show, and it was exactly what any overbooked, over-the-top-rope match should be. There was no po-faced attempts at seriousness to drag things down, or any need from the workers involved to pretend they were the card's main focus.
No, 'Over The Budget' was simple, clean fun.
At All In 2, it should return. In fact, scrap that, this match should become a Zero Hour staple, one fans know will warm them up for the night's action nicely. There's no need to change the formula either, because what happened on Saturday worked. Don't fix what ain't broken and all that.
At 17 minutes, it didn't outstay its welcome, and it should be a blueprint for what Battle Royals become across the entire industry. That's high praise, and yet it's not unwarranted. From comedic name to fun-loving layout, 'Over The Budget' is already a winner.
6. Even More Cameos
The mix of old and new on display at All In tugged at the heart strings. Older fans tuning in to see what all the fuss is about must have smiled their way through cameos from Billy Gunn, Tommy Dreamer, Diamond Dallas Page, Bully Ray and more. On top of that was the sweet spotlight given to NWA traditions.
Seeing former favourites like Road Warrior Animal, Magnum TA and Tully Blanchard in attendance was another nice touch too. The whole evening seemed like a subtle love-letter from Cody to his father Dusty's affinity for the NWA, and it didn't come across as too in-your-face or forced. This, in an industry obsessed with shoving things down fan throats, was lovely to see.
We want more of it.
Seeing even more killer cameos sprinkled throughout the evening would be nice at All In 2. The boys in charge can be trusted to ensure it's not too much and doesn't become ridiculous. There's nothing wrong with celebrating the past whilst forging the future.
5. Even More 'Being The Elite' Immersion
All In did a tremendous job of gratifying those fans who consume every bit of content Cody, The Young Bucks and chums put out online. There were nods to the group's 'Being The Elite' show all over the place, but again, it didn't become overwhelming for those who haven't watched an episode.
To recap, we saw Adam Page's talking boots, some Joey Ryan-related nonsense, Jay Lethal's Randy Savage-inspired alter-ego (along with a neat appearance by Lanny Poffo), and even Marty Scurll breaking some fingers.
Everything worked, and there's no reason why a sequel show can't feature more of this immersion into The Elite's world. The whole night felt like a showcase of why anyone who hasn't should check out some old 'Being The Elite' stuff, and just how clever that is should not be overlooked. Talk about selling one's product to new eyeballs.
The fact fans opened up the show by singing along to the show's theme song proves what kind of connection Cody and The Bucks have forged with their audience. There's genuine appreciation there for what they're doing, and that's something they can exploit next time.
4. A Bigger Venue?
"All In 2! All In 2! All In 2!".
As those chants rang out amidst a clever tease from Cody that a second event was on the cards, attention online started to turn towards exactly where such an event would take place. Even Meltzer chimed in on Wrestling Observer Radio to talk up the chances of upwards of 20,000 in attendance for a sequel.
One thing's for sure: All In 2 will have community buzz long before it happens, and that's something the organisers can capitalise on to make it even bigger than the original. If that's going to be the case, then they must realise they've already outgrown Chicago's Sears Centre (which is an incredible thing to say).
Imagine, for example, if Cody and The Bucks could nail down New York's legendary Madison Square Garden for a repeat showing. ROH have already made history by securing the venue and fending off WWE resistance, so it's not as far-fetched as some might think.
Failing that, there are countless buildings All In 2 could use. The potential is 100% there for a larger gate, whatever The Elite choose to do next. Anyone who supported All In's heartwarming story would be delighted to see it blow up in front of an even larger crowd.
3. A Title Match Main Event
Call this writer an annoying traditionalist, but he would have preferred to see that NWA World Heavyweight Championship bout between Nick Aldis and Cody headline All In. Although The Golden Elite vs. Rey Mysterio, Bandido and Rey Fénix was fun, it didn't quite have the build, pageantry or emotion of Rhodes' win.
That match was a headliner all day long.
At All In 2, it'd be an idea to reformat the card and make sure there's a title match on last. It's arguable, but aside from Kenny Omega vs. Penta El Zero, every subsequent match after Aldis vs. Cody felt like it couldn't follow up; this was especially true of Kazuchika Okada vs. Marty Scurll, which went a bit long and could have done with happening earlier.
Cody looked every bit the main event star and entered a performance that would've made his father proud at All In. On the sequel show, it'd be cool to see that world-class showing vindicated by a main event slot. Forget worries about the booker putting himself on last, because it's deserved here, and it'd give the last match greater weight if it contested a title.
2. More Indy Dream Matches
Omega vs. Penta should open people's eyes to what the Mexican masked man is capable of. Omega (who is undoubtedly one of wrestling's most adaptable workers in 2018) worked hard to make his opponent look like the man, and it made for one of All In's best matches.
There's now a desire from fans to see more indy dream matches like that one on the next All In card.
Setting up some sort of ROH vs. NJPW series (or maybe even drafting in other companies, like Lucha Underground) wouldn't be too difficult for Cody and The Bucks either, and it's something to think about. If they can run a thread of promotional competition throughout All In 2, it'd up the stakes and give some bouts more meaning beyond entertaining exhibition. Food for thought, definitely.
The independent circuit is packed with top talent who rarely get to lock horns. For example, seeing Rey Mysterio go one-on-one with Omega would be a thrill, as would watching Kota Ibushi meet Penta. That'd bring out another side to the Lucha favourite.
1. Alpha Vs. Omega II
Ever since Chris Jericho and Kenny Omega worked their slow-burning classic at January's Wrestle Kingdom 12 show, there's been talk of a rematch between 'Alpha' and Omega. It'd be quite the coup if it happened at All In 2, and it looks like there's a great chance it will.
Jericho's disguised attack on the IWGP Heavyweight Champion after Omega's match against Penta El Zero was All In's best angle by far. It should become the lead-in storyline for a second event. There's no way that All In 2 show can be promoted without 'Alpha vs. Omega II' now, not after what happened in Chicago.
There's a real demand to see Y2J wrestle on the card after his post-match ambush. It must happen.
Again, it'd be great if an NWA Heavyweight Title clash headlined All In 2. If not, then Jericho vs. Omega would more than suffice. It's the sort of grudge match that screams main event attraction anyway, so few would be left disappointed if it went on last.
Go All In (again), maaaaaaaaaaan.
-
What else is on your wish list for All In 2? Let us know down in the comments section below!