Comparing WWE Survivor Series 2016 To NXT TakeOver: Toronto

Which brand won the weekend?

Asuka Mickie James
WWE.com

A packed weekend of action for Canadian wrestling fans has drawn to a close, incorporating NXT TakeOver: Toronto and the 30th Annual Survivor Series events. Both events had been promoted extensively by the WWE marketing machine, and both promised a full night of excitement for WWE Network subscribers.

Inevitably, both events will be compared with each other. Which delivered the best matches, had the most exciting moments, or told the best stories? Did the so-called developmental show once again outshine the main roster, as they have done on so many similar occasions, or did the superior star power of the top names in the business make Survivor Series more memorable? Which matches lived up to the hype, and which ended with a whimper?

The theme of the weekend was the conflict between Raw and SmackDown Live, so let’s take that concept and give it a twist, pitting NXT against WWE for brand supremacy. Who knows, maybe a future Survivor Series will have the exact same gimmick…

7. Show Openers

NXT Takeover Canada
WWE.com

Both shows opened with the usual elaborate hype videos for their respective events, which were flawlessly produced and presented, as is par for the course for WWE’s top-line production department.

However, a difference that was immediately apparent when the shows went to the live crowd was the energy of those assembled in the Air Canada Centre. While the Survivor Series crowd was excited and cheering for the opening, the NXT assembly, which was actually smaller, were incredibly amped up for the start of the show, and were reacting much more loudly.

A possible contributing factor was the contrasting soundtracks; NXT went with a hard-rock song blasting throughout the arena, the type that would have fitted in perfectly to WWE events around 2000-2001, while SS chose to use a more modern, electronic-sounding track. The former was ideal for pumping up the crowd, while the latter seemed intended to give the opposite effect, as it wasn’t the most energetic song choice for the show.

Winner: NXT


6. Opening Matches

Bobby Roode NXT TakeOver Toronto
WWE.com

Both shows started off with the right choice of entrance, as Survivor Series quickly hit the music for Bayley, while NXT presented a huge, serious-faced choir to serenade Bobby Roode to the ring. Roode’s “Glorious Domination” has quickly become a highlight of NXT events (especially with 10,000-plus singing every word); while Bayley’s popularity is almost unchallenged, particularly amongst pay-per-view live audiences.

However, just as beloved on this night was Roode’s opponent, Tye Dillinger. The Canadian native received the biggest reaction of his career, which had to be incredible for a guy who has been struggling for so long to make it in WWE. He was so over, in fact, that the crowd was making full use of his trademark “10” chant throughout both shows, which hopefully sent a message to management as to the talent they have in The Perfect Ten.

However, the 5-on-5 Women’s Elimination match had a nice surprise of its own, as Natalya was moved into the SmackDown Live team to replace Nikki Bella, who had been mysteriously assaulted backstage. One sure-fire way to get a pop in Canada is to bring out a member of the Hart family, and the reaction for Natalya’s entrance did not disappoint.

Unfortunately for the WWE side, the relative inexperience of some of the competitors showed through at times, and they could not hope to match the excellent opening contest between the almost-tag partners, as Roode and Dillinger put on a fantastic match to start the show on the right note.

Winner: NXT


5. Undercard Matches

WWE Survivor Series 2016 Brian Kendrick Kalisto
WWE.com

I’m going to have to lump the Dusty Classic finals in here against the Cruiserweight and Intercontinental Championship matches, as both served a similar purpose in their respective shows.

Brian Kendrick has been excellent as the wily veteran champion of the Cruiserweight Division, showing he will do anything to hold on to his title against his younger, faster peers. Similarly, The Miz has been fantastic since his wife joined his act, doing some of the best work of his career in being a completely unlikable heel. Kalisto and Sami Zayn were both great choices to challenge for the belts, adding some intrigue as to whether the championships would end up on the opposite show.

However, both bouts suffered due to poor finishes, especially the Cruiserweight championship. Kendrick and Kalisto, along with the division as a whole, did not deserve to be sacrificed in yet another attempt to put over Baron Corbin, who has been lukewarm at best ever since his premature NXT call-up. The finish in the Miz-Zayn match was also weak, although it was at least more creative than relying on Maryse directly interfering with a spray to the eyes, as has been the case in too many Miz matches.

TM-61 and the Authors of Pain had a good tag-team match to finish up the second Dusty Classic tournament, with the Australian duo especially showing off some great high-flying spots as well as displaying their power against the larger AOP. Akam and Rezar have also developed well during this tournament, and at no point looked out of place in a match much longer than their usual squashes. However, despite the finishes leaving a bad taste, the great action from Sami Zayn and The Miz edges the undercard slightly ahead of the Dusty finals.

Winner: WWE


4. Womens Division

asuka mickie james
WWE.com

As previously mentioned, the Women’s 5-on-5 Elimination match suffered slightly due to the inexperience of some of the competitors, leading to some sloppy spots. However, all ten women involved worked hard and put on a fun opener for the WWE event.

One thing I must mention, though, is how Nia Jax was treated for her elimination. She was being (correctly) portrayed as a monster throughout most of the match, dominating the opposite team and single-handedly restoring order when things started to break down. However, she was eliminated by tapping out much too quickly to Becky Lynch’s DisArmHer submission. I don’t think she should have squashed the SmackDown team, but perhaps a better way to protect her aura would have been for one of her team mates to make one too many blind tags, angering her, before Jax snapped and laid waste to every participant she could get her hands on, before walking away from the match, effectively eliminating herself. After all, there was no real reward at stake (a common theme in the elimination matches), so why should she worry about being a team player?

By contrast, the Asuka vs Mickie James match was a great showing for both women, as Mickie was out to prove that they could do far worse than to offer her a permanent spot on any show to round out the Women’s Divisions. It was a different kind of match for Asuka, as we are accustomed to seeing her knocking her opponent around the ring like a rag doll, but the story told was that Mickie’s experience and toughness was a match for the Empress of Tomorrow. As such, we got to see some vulnerability from Asuka, which does not happen too often. A good, physical match all around.

Winner: NXT


3. Tag Division Matches

nxt tag
WWE.com

The Elimination Tag Team match at Survivor Series was really a tale of two matches. The bout started out with an issue that plagues elimination matches, as both The New Day and Breezango were eliminated by things that would not usually end a match in normal competition. Both sides lost another tag team in short order, and the match was in danger of becoming a rushed affair that did nothing for any of the participants.

However, when the match had been whittled down to a 6-on-6 affair, the action suddenly picked up, and the series of big spots brought the crowd to their feet. The match from there was a lot of fast paced fun, showcasing the best of both tag divisions.

Unfortunately, their competition the previous evening was a near-perfect 2-Out-Of-3 Falls Match between The Revival and #DIY. These two teams have fantastic chemistry and pulled out all the stops for NXT’s signature match, giving perfect callbacks to their previous encounters, such as the submission holds focusing on the knee of Johnny Gargano, and some wonderful near falls. When #DIY avoided being hit with their own finisher, then hit Dash and Dawson with a Shatter Machine, every person watching (including myself) thought the match was over.

Unlike the Survivor Series matches, each fall happened with something that could have ended a regular match, so nothing felt cheap. I could heap superlatives on this match all day, but I will have to content myself with simply describing it as a top contender for match of the year. Survivor Series had no chance on this one.

Winner: NXT


2. Men's Division

goldberg lesnar
WWE.com

Clocking in at just less than one hour, the 5-on-5 men’s match at Survivor Series felt like much shorter, it was so much fun. The bout took full advantage of the elimination format, allowing each participant to show themselves at their best, while giving each plenty of time to rest on the outside while there was plenty of action in the ring.

Everybody in the match was presented excellently, with some spectacular moments throughout (barring Shane McMahon’s scary-looking spear bump) and a brief reunion for The Shield meant that the live crowd were on their feet for the duration. The right team got the victory, and for once Bray Wyatt was allowed to look like a dangerous force in the ring.

Over on NXT, the highly-anticipated showdown between Shinsuke Nakamura and Samoa Joe was as physical as would be expected from these two. However, the hard striking style of both men, especially Nakamura, was perhaps too radical of a change for an audience that had witnessed an incredible athletic tag-team contest in the show, meaning that the NXT Championship match suffered slightly by comparison. Nakamura’s character work and aura is absolutely fantastic, but his over-reliance on strikes is not always appreciated by some sections of the audience that are used to hyper-athletic indie-style matches.

The shocking moment provided by the main event squash match on Survivor Series also avoided the crowd being too burnt out, as these two men would have struggled to follow the excellent Elimination match that preceded them. It may have been bad for business long term, but on the night it ended the show with a bang.

Winner: WWE


1. Overall Show Quality

Johnny Gargano Tommaso Ciampa DIY
WWE.com

This category is for everything else that wouldn’t fit into any other section.

The official event durations according to WWE Network were 3:26:02 for Survivor Series, while NXT TakeOver clocked in at 2:24:18. However, NXT packed their shorter show with segments that perfectly encapsulated the phrase “all killer, no filler”, as each match served a distinct purpose and was either a culmination of or an important step in an ongoing storyline.

In contrast, WWE presented their usual plethora of backstage skits, including The Club acting like playground bullies (and fleeing as soon as Mick Foley delivered a non-threatening “knock it off!”), which served little purpose other than to pad out running time. Fortunately, NXT seems to have learned that we watch wrestling shows despite the backstage antics, not because of them. Triple H’s booking has definitely proved that less is more. An extra point is deserved for NXT.

Winner: NXT

So NXT takes 5 of the categories I made up: Show Openers, Opening Matches, Tag Division, Womens Division and Overall Show Quality. WWE gets the win with two: Undercard and Men's Division. Therefore, the overall winner, with 5 points to 2:

NXT TakeOver: Toronto!


Contributor

Purveyor of useless information, mostly concerning gaming, pro wrestling and British sitcoms.