Crossface: 13 Actors Who Must Be Cast In Chris Benoit's Biopic
Who should star in the just announced movie?

Despite seemingly major obstacles, it looks like there genuinely will be a movie chronicling the rise and tragic end of the Benoit family. Whether it should be called Crossface is a different matter.
Even though it appeared that there was little chance that WWE - and Vince McMahon in particular - would ever allow something so potentially incendiary to exist without severe opposition, the film has basically just been confirmed.
If that is the case, that's great casting, and a statement of intent that this isn't going to end up being a daytime Lifetime movie that ends up being buried away from the silver screen.
So who else should be involved? The opportunity is obviously there to bring some of WWE's most recognisable figures to the screen, and if there was any justice in the world, the following fantasy suggestions would be high up the casting list...
13. Liev Schreiber As Chris Benoit

There's only one man for the job.
Schreiber was linked to the role as early as a few years ago, and more recent reports linked him once again, so it seems someone in the industry is keen to get the talented character actor involved.
He has the right sort of intensity, he's a big guy and he would be believable as Benoit at his most frenetic and his most committed. If this doesn't happen, it will be a travesty.
12. Chris Hemsworth As Triple H

Somewhat helpfully, Triple H himself was strongly rumoured to have been under consideration to play Thor before Hemsworth was cast by Kenneth Branagh. Probably because of the beard and the muscles, or something.
So it makes sense that the man who pipped him to the post for Asgard's most famous son should step in to play him for his key role (apparently already confirmed unofficially by the writer). Obviously, Sean Bean might have a more fitting look (though even his nose is some way away from Hunter's) but Hemsworth is probably the kind of actor HHH would pick himself.
11. Ben Foster As CM Punk

Punk's role in Benoit's story is unlikely to be particularly long, given that the future champ was still in his formative years with WWE when Benoit died, but the pair's paths would have crossed on that fateful last night.
With Benoit set to face Punk at Vengeance: Night of Champions before his no-show there's an opportunity for the film-makers to have the climactic tragedy play out in parallel to the replacement event between Punk and Johnny Nitro. That's probably how it SHOULD be done, anyway.
Foster's appeal for the role lies not only in his similar looks: he's also an incredibly intense actor who skirts the boundary between charismatic and ego-driven (indeed that darkness has made him a great villain at times), which is precisely where Punk operated best.
And of course, the film-makers would be silly not to try and trade on the Punk brand.
10. Michael Chiklis As Kevin Sullivan

With Benoit's relationship with his wife likely to play as big a role in the film as his wrestling career - before the two smash together catastrophically - Nancy's ex Kevin Sullivan surely has to appear. He, after all, was the third wheel of an intriguing romantic entanglement that mirrored the creative direction of the trio's storyline and a necessary component in selling one explosive bookend of the relationship.
It's inevitable that Sullivan will be sold as collateral damage, not only in terms of Benoit stealing his wife, but also in his defection to WWE when Sullivan was promoted controversially to head booker for WCW. With that in mind, the role will require someone who is likeable but gruff and physically imposing, who can play the pantomime villain when Benoit is in hero mode.
That man is former Thing Michael Chiklis, who is due another shot after the first Fantastic Four atrocities ruined his career.
9. Channing Tatum As Johnny Nitro

Alongside Ben Foster's CM Punk, someone has to step into the ring at Vengeance at the climax of the film, and given his previous playing a ridiculously sculpted preening sex-bomb character, Tatum is more than qualified to play stand-in ECW champ Johnny Nitro.
Both have underwear model abs and Hollywood faces, and Tatum would be entirely believable as the conceited, self-aggrandising rookie.
Before he was victim to one of the most unfortunate "image changes" in Hollywood history, a younger Val Kilmer could well have played Nitro, since both used Jim Morrison as an impressive reference point. But that ship has long sailed, and Kilmer now looks like the deeply tragic After photo Bruce Wayne carries around reminding him never, ever to retire.
8. Jon Bernthal As Eddie Guerrero

If Crossface is going to authentically tell the tale of Benoit's wrestling legend, some time will inevitably have to be given over to his time as part of The Radicalz. Their introduction to WWE in 2000 was one of those touchstone moment in his career, and over-looking it would be an oversight to say the least.
Let's be honest, Johnny Depp is a pretty solid doppelganger for the tragically gone superstar, but he's a little on the old side to convincingly play a younger Guerrero. And while there would no doubt be rumbles about a non-Mexican actor taking the role, Jon Bernthal has the double selling points of looking the part and fitting the bill in another way.
Both Guerrero and Bernthal managed to get over despite being villains, and the actor has a certain intangible essence that makes him perfect for anti-hero characters with edge (hence his casting as Punisher). He'd be ideal, especially given his insight into being part of a wrestling family (he's married to Kurt Angle's niece after all).
7. Joe Mangianello As Dean Malenko

With Guerrero, Dean Malenko played an important role in Benoit's rise to the top of the wrestling ladder, so he's a definite requirement in the film. And since both wrestling films and stripper films suit scuplted, hulking actors, another Magic Mike star could be the perfect casting pick.
A few years back, Jeffrey Dean Morgan (or unconfirmed twin Javier Bardem) could have been the right option for Malenko, but too much water has passed under that particular bridge. So the responsibility should fall to Joe Mangianello, who will require make-up and some extensive hair work to stop him being so bloody attractive. He would definitely have the physique though, and he's played cold and calculating well before, which suits Malenko's heel work.
The fourth important pillar of The Radicalz also shouldn't be overlooked, though Perry Saturn is a more difficult prospect for casting. Jason Statham perhaps? His unhinged performance in Mean Machine suggests there's something there that could be channelled, even if he'd need some serious enhancement for the right look.
6. Matt Damon As Kurt Angle

Benoit's wrestling story wouldn't be complete without arguably his greatest foe from one of pro wrestling's finest ever feuds. Having committed some truly memorable moments to memory together, Benoit and Angle's rivalry (and partnership) needs to be explored as part of the former's wrestling peak. Particularly given how the feud got him over with the crowd.
And such a big story element should demand a big name actor.
He might not have the biggest physique in Hollywood, but Damon has proved himself adept at bulking and toning for his Bourne roles and Elysium. And if he could put on the same kind of weight he did for The Informant (and hit the gym at the same time), he could easily fill out enough to convincingly stand in for Angle.
And most importantly, he's the kind of charismatic figure - with traces of that Good Will Hunting attitude - who could capture Angle's personality at the same time.
5. Ed O'Neill As Stu Hart

If Crossface is going to go full biopic (and you have to think there'll be some sort of wrestling "origin" involved - even with a younger actor playing Benoit in the late '80s), Stu Hart surely has to play a key role. The best approach to chronicling Benoit's time training at the Hart dungeon would probably see Stu Hart and Bruce Hart combined into one professional paternal figure (for stream-lining at the very least).
And there's something very compelling about the idea of famous screen patriarch Ed O'Neill playing the notoriously fiery Hart, showing his over-bearing personality, the way he tortured new recruits and pushed his sons to the limit. That side of Hart's mentoring will be important to the film's narrative: after all, there is some suggestion that Benoit's relationship with his own son followed similar lines, and his in-ring persona around 2007 certainly drew something of his experience under Hart.
Clearly, Benoit's story has space for two father figures: as well as Stu Hart as his professional paternal influence, Michael Benoit will no doubt play a key role in the story. JK Simmons should have that role sewn up.
4. Natalie Portman As Stephanie McMahon

Though she'd likely be a more peripheral figure than her father and husband, Stephanie will no doubt be included as a character.
And despite that limited role - as with both CM Punk and Johnny Nitro - having a big, recognisable name to come in for a glorified cameo would be a great idea. So, Natalie Portman - who actually has a look of Stephanie, though without as much muscle to her face - would be the top drawer casting.
She's also proved herself able to straddle the line between adorable and entirely unlikable in past roles, which is pretty much Stephanie's entire brand.
3. Mark Ruffalo As Bret Hart

As much as Stu Hart should be introduced as the big early influence on Schreiber's Benoit in his training days (even if it's no more than a short prologue), Bret Hart has to be the role model figure he was to Benoit in real life.
Again, because of the need to stream-line - something the writer has already referenced in interviews as a challenge - it would make sense to combine both Hart and Tom Billington into one figure, rather than sharing screen time. And as much as a performance of the Dynamite Kid would pop with knowledgable WWE fans, there might be less intrigue from more casual audiences (who will be necessary to bank well at the box office).
Casting big is the right answer once again, and having Mark Ruffalo's screen wrestling experience from Foxcatcher is a nice bonus to his acting skill. Looking the part isn't all that important, even, as Ruffalo has proved himself capable of inhabiting real-life figures and showing the kind of broad range that would make him an intriguing choice.
2. Eric Roberts As Vince McMahon

There can't be any film about WWE without Vince McMahon (which is somewhat ironic, given how unhappy he's definitely going to be with Crossface existing in the first place), and there can only be one man to play him.
Liam Neeson may well have already distanced himself from rumours that he would be playing the WWE supremo, but while he has the physique to convince as Vince, he doesn't quite have the same charm as Eric Roberts. After all, he was never quite charismatic enough to really sell Hannibal in The A-Team, so he's already failed the audition.
Roberts looks the part, can act the part and would be wholly convincing as both sides of McMahon's character, which will be key in not simply presenting him as a pantomime monster.
And for his wife? How about Helen Mirren?
1. Adrianne Palicki As Nancy Benoit

Alongside Schreiber's potential billing as Chris Benoit, the most important part of casting is choosing the right Nancy. At first glance, Adrianne Palicki's CV wouldn't suggest her to be an immediate first choice - particularly as her Rotten Tomatoes scored have been dire, aside from John Wick and Agents Of SHIELD - but she's a great dark horse.
Since taking on the role of Mockingbird in Agents Of SHIELD, she's grown in profile (having also been very watchable in Friday Night Lights), and crucially she wouldn't bring a lot of expectation (or baggage) to the performance, which will be key for the portrayal of Nancy. And if she does it right, it could well be a star-making role, as she will get some seriously weighty material to play with in the Benoits' volatile relationship.
It's likely that the Benoits' son, Daniel, will be played by a newcomer, which is probably the right choice, given his name. And no matter who plays the part, it's not going to be an easy performance to shake.
Who would you cast in Crossface? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.