Every AEW Title Reign Ranked From Worst To Best
A wrestling champion can't just be booked as a champion.
All Elite Wrestling isn't just a name or a pun.
The idea is to create a perfect pro wrestling promotion. It's the only chance any major promotion has of competing with the promotion so dominant that it's a synonym of professional wrestling.
"What, that WWE stuff?" is the question AEW really wants to change.
It just so happens that this is to be achieved by running through the Don't Do What Donny WWE Does checklist: no f*ck finishes, no scripted promos, no endless rematches, no homogenised in-ring style, no general, stilted weirdness. To become Elite, AEW is attempting to restore that on which pro wrestling was built, leaving no cornerstone unturned.
Key to this - since pro wrestling, reduced, is a star-making business - is that the champions must feel like champions. The idea is to make titles feel like titles, and not props. AEW's entire business model is predicated on everything feeling premium, prestigious, worthy. There are four pay-per-views per year, and the more significant revenue stream of episodic TV functions to sell them.
The big title fight is nothing if the champ is a tentative experiment, an office favourite, or just a plain bust.
So are AEW changing that question?
8. Nyla Rose - Women's Title
A reign absolutely knackered by lockdown, people don't like excuses - particularly when those people are weirdly keen to over-exaggerate every minor flaw on AEW programming - but "literally not able to be physically present you stunningly thick d*ckheads" isn't an excuse.
The Women's division was trending upwards when Rose captured the title from Riho on February 12 in a match so fantastic, and so well-built, that the sight of Riho smashing Rose with a series of snap dragons didn't feel remotely preposterous. The very witty Rose had the potential (and range) to play babyface-leaning tweener in her scheduled mini-programme with Bea Priestley and subsequently pivot to either extreme opposite the fantastically obnoxious Britt Baker and the enchanting Yuka Sakazki. Riho, Hikaru Shida and Kris Statlander formed the rest of a diverse and strong nucleus.
But even before everything changed, and no less than four of the division's key figures were stranded in Japan or seriously injured, it was still apparent that Rose, great in a certain genre, wasn't the Ace needed to elevate all around her. Her ambitious Revolution defence opposite Statlander fell apart completely.
AEW operated with less than half of the roster for no less than five weeks in QT Marshall's training school. Rose, locked down, could not be there.
The reign ended (on a real high) because it was felt, seemingly, that Hikaru Shida - as the far better worker - stood the best chance of playing the rising tide...
7. Hikaru Shida - Women's Title
To what extent can AEW be excused for its hardly committed approach to women's wrestling?
Incredibly, since the recognised global leader in sports entertainment only stopped objectifying women five years ago, there is in the US a dearth of female talent proportionate to the men who were always booked and booked far more prominently. Booked, too, in the inter-gender boom that, irrespective of where one stands on a complex issue, was certainly used by some promoters to shoehorn a man into a women's match. There is much talent in that all but frozen U.S. indy scene, but that talent is not TV ready.
Some adapt quicker than others - the AEW men's undercard is very uneven in that regard - and much of the best and most experienced talents were signed by WWE amid panic of its lax grip on the monopoly.
The division and the discourse surrounding it is not so much a mess as a toxic f*cking dump, at this point; in virtually any field, structures are in place to not overwhelm the inexperienced. Training schemes. Academies. Courses. When AEW does it, in the Deadly Draw or on Dark, it's considered an insult.
Criticised in a vacuum, in the narrower context of the fiction, it's not good enough: Shida gets infinitesimal TV time, and it would be very generous to state that a rivalry with Nyla Rose is "simmering". It's the next big match, but we know this not through a story but by process of elimination.
Shida's title win was great - a gutsy, physical war that made thrilling use of the Double Or Nothing set - as was her only major defence opposite Penelope Ford. That match was creative and snug and crackled with personality and electricity alike.
AEW has had nearly three months to manufacture a rivalry between Shida and a major heel threat - and they are more than capable of overlapping stories, so this could have been achieved while also booking Shida Vs. Ford at Fyter Fest - but they haven't.
6. Riho - Women's Title
This is where the excuses don't much wash.
There was no unprecedented global situation to navigate in 2019. AEW had a heel antagonist for Riho on pay-per-view, in Emi Sakura, who was hugely experienced. The less experienced but very talented Jamie Hayter, a great, nasty heel, was an ideal opponent for a TV mini-series that couldn't materialise as a result of Riho's split schedule.
And yet, Riho's run was, in part, a critical and commercial success: her title win and Full Gear defence were fabulous, emotional struggles, and she was an early ratings hit in the female teenage demographic.
Perhaps with hindsight we should have been nicer to Sakura. In wrestling matches that went as long as the men's matches, a not inconsiderable number of which were lowkey damn good, she gave many critics then what they are asking for now. The Freddie Mercury call-and-response stuff was batsh*t for a heel to do on telly, mind.
Though, given the immense history shared between Sakura and Riho, the same criticism can be levied at AEW itself. This is the big indictment. AEW, not unfairly accused of failing to even try to tell stories in the Women's division, had a very rich, emotional and real story from which to draw at Full Gear. Sakura trained Riho from the age of nine.
This intimate connection and the trajectory of Riho's career informed the awesome velocity of every breathless reversal and the manifested jealousy of those gruesome backbreakers.
No video package.
5. SCU - World Tag Team Title
SCU earned those titles.
Popular enduring vets with a killer act, their crucial, tone-setting openers at Double Or Nothing and All Out were six-man tag bangers that popped the cork on the celebration of the return of mainstream competition. They were the first of many lowkey AEW MVPs.
An early and noble failure at the deft, dovetailing booking with which AEW Dynamite would really start to cook in 2020, Scorpio's Sky foray into the World Title picture removed focus from the Tag Team Titles. And in something of an indictment of what was a sentimental decision to strap SCU, the cracking Young Bucks Vs. Santana and Ortiz feud felt significantly more important. SCU's first big defence, opposite the Lucha Bros. and Private Party at Full Gear, was electric but very uneven - a regression from their tight and emotive work throughout the Tag Team Title tournament.
Otherwise relegated to Dark, SCU entered a superb performance in a tremendous sprint against the Bucks on the December 18 Dynamite overwhelmed entirely by the infamously bad Dark Order initiation angle.
Bookmarked wonderfully by their outstanding title loss to Kenny Omega and Hangman Page on Chris Jericho's Cruise, everything in between articulated that which is felt: the great, early booking didn't launch a great reign.
Champions, simply, must feel like champions. SCU weren't that.
4. Jon Moxley - World Title
Uneven but trending towards brilliance in recent months, Jon Moxley, like Nyla Rose, was unable to make the Georgia block, but had pre-taped an Empty Arena match with Jake Hager.
A bad one; it was attritional, dull, overlong and, in style and atmosphere, antithetical to what AEW stands for. And they still promoted it brilliantly. The failures in AEW - mostly - are very noble.
When Moxley returned, his Double Or Nothing defence was set: Mr. Brodie Lee. It was a curious choice, looking at the rankings, and the set-up was far more functional than AEW's usual big PPV match standard. But the match itself absolutely ruled - a visceral, super-violent head-dropper, they basically killed each other, and the guy who died first lost.
Mox spent yet more time on the shelf, but this only reinforced his babyface awesomeness. He wanted to be with his wife at her time of need, and f*cked everything else off. He's a genuinely rare, good dude, incredibly easy to root for, and his promo game has been incredible since he returned. The same witty badass at his core, he has brought a new level of emotion to put over the Brian Cage and Darby Allin matches. One had an incredible finishing sequence, and the other was just incredible: an emotive war that was far too cool to ever descend into melodrama.
The general bittersweet vibe of "This is really cool, shame there are no f*cking fans here" hasn't helped, obviously, but the numbers don't seem to care: Moxley's last two World Title matches pulled monster ratings.
Nobody, at least in good faith, has ever described the reigning AEW World Champion as "Super Mox". None of this feels oppressive.
It feels, as it should, like the hardest and coolest guy in the industry is its World Champion.
3. Cody - TNT Title
There was, before the unveiling of the new redesign this week, a very rich visual poetry to the unfinished 'Ruby' that came to symbolise the heart and the heft of the run.
Ruby was a piece of tin - almost literally a blank canvas - and it served as a potent metaphor for an organic narrative that has developed itself.
Much like the old title belt, the story arc of the TNT Title was and is shaped by circumstance. Cody initially defended it against Jungle Boy and Marq Quen. In both matches, he developed a new, aggressive demeanour. He wasn't just the magnanimous hero winning quality TV matches in which he sold a bit for the babyfaces; he had to sacrifice the saviour aura he had developed in 2019 for the more noble purpose of making the midcard, the next generation.
The Ricky Starks and Eddie Kingston matches were both fantastic. They were so fantastic that both men painted themselves on the canvas of AEW's format having secured deals on the strength of performances fantasy booked in the more ardent circles of Twitter. The fans wanted Warhorse and they got Warhorse, and he was game, but he didn't quite meet the standard. And you know what?
That's a good thing. There's a rough and unvarnished quality to all this that resonates with far more ambition than failure.
Combined with more polished efforts against Jake Hager (a massive over-delivery) and Scorpio Sky (a really well-told story), the TNT Title run is becoming iconic.
2. Chris Jericho - World Title
Chris Jericho was the inaugural AEW World Champion because he was entrusted to legitimise the title and indeed the company.
He was entrusted to bring a level of match quality consistent with the idea that AEW was the new, premier wrestling brand, not the sports entertainment relic. He was entrusted to make the underneath guys the mainstream had never heard of without compromising himself. He was entrusted to be entertaining, in a new persona removed from his WWE characters, in every and several departments: matches, angles, promos, skits, beat-downs.
He did all of those things in the greatest and most effective entertaining run of his career.
His range was absolutely spectacular; Jericho breezed through so many different modes without diluting any of of them. He was piss funny with his callous comedy schtick and a dangerous, skull-scraping veteran in his classic with Cody at Full Gear. He crafted a great generational styles clash with Darby Allin from which Allin has never looked back. His promo work leading up to November 9 was so phenomenal in that he and Cody made it feel - in wrestling, in 2020 - like a super-fight.
All the while, Jericho brought the ratings and drank a little bit of the bubbly to toast almost constant victory in the Wednesday Night War.
1. Kenny Omega & Hangman Page - World Tag Team Titles
Tag team wrestling matters again, and it is to the enormous credit of Kenny Omega and Hangman Page.
They captured the titles from SCU on Chris Jericho's cruise, and have subsequently led and elevated the greatest tag team division in modern history. Match quality has ranged from merely very good to the greatest tag team match of all time. Dense, intricate, emotionally devastating masterpieces (Young Bucks); jaw-dropping, pulsating lucha sprints (Lucha Brothers); openers with less heralded teams that had no right to be as convincingly dramatic or as high in quality as they were (Private Party, Natural Nightmares, basically every match they've had in recent months): Page and Omega have positioned themselves as true Ace figures as part of an ongoing storyline ludicrously rich in its intrigue.
There is an astonishing level of detail to their work. This beast of a long-form narrative is so well thought-out in these structural masterclasses. Kenny Omega, as the man who pitched the team, plays the workhorse. He takes the body of the match. Page - and sometimes this feels cynical, sometimes noble, it's all so interpretative - is the explosive hot tag who gets the W. It is a twisting, heartfelt drama of masculinity told through the medium of professional wrestling.
What we essentially arrive at is a team you never want to see split up, but can't wait to see split up. A team that is fated to combust, but is perfect, and doubted only by themselves. A team that, ironically for "two singles wrestlers", is far more reliant on one another than most. But, through every grandstanding flex, or every selfish flash of the old megastar teeth, a team that is tragically unaware of it.
The deft plotting of these beats has converged to create the best storyline in wrestling all year, if that's even the correct unit.