Every AEW Wrestler Ranked From Worst To Best - After One Year

Separating the Michael Nakazawas from the Chris Jerichos.

AEW roster ranked
AEW

Double Or Nothing 2020 marked a full calendar year of All Elite Wrestling running shows. Blighted by a spotty, lukewarm build and injuries to Britt Baker, Rey Fenix, and Matt Jackson just three days earlier, it could have been a mess. Instead, it was one of the Empty Arena Era's better shows and a pay-per-view worthy of the DoN brand after the lofty expectations set by last year's event.

Using objective metrics, year one has been a broad success, with Dynamite never dropping beneath TNT's 500,000-a-week expectations and regularly outdrawing WWE NXT, while PPV buyrates keep defying projections. Subjective success is harder to determine. AEW has scratches several itches for fans who'd been yearning for a WWE alternative for two decades but has failed to deliver a consistent women's division, struggled with debuts, and sent the internet spinning with The Dark Order. There's much to be done before they legitimately "change the world."

But what about the wrestlers themselves?

With one year down, let's take a look at how the men and women of AEW have fared so far, with a (present or past) AllEliteWrestling.com roster listing the only qualifying criteria. That means no part-timers like Jeff Cobb or Aja Kong.

Let's dive in...


75. Mel

Mel Hikaru Shida
AEW

Being attached to the disastrous Nightmare Collective project did Mel no favours, though she looked out of her depth in limited in-ring outings for AEW. Not even Hikaru Shida, the women's division vanguard since day one, could guide Mel towards something respectable.

The Collective's dissolution saw Mel vanish into the aether. She hasn't wrestled since January and may well have jettisoned for now, though she is still listed as a roster member on AEW's website. Regardless, there's nothing to suggest his tall, awkward, lumbering powerhouse would bolster her division.

74. Luther

Luther AEW
AEW

Another Nightmare Collective castoff, 'The Original Death Dealer' scored a full-time AEW contract earlier this year. He has been a steady presence on Dark, even since the stable split, and recently indulged in a rivalry with Jimmy Havoc, who defeated the supposed "Japanese deathmatch legend" to put that to rest a few weeks ago.

Luther looks and wrestles like a man out of time. The gimmick is silly and every one of his 51 years show whenever he steps through the ropes, though the Havoc bout demonstrates he's at least capable of a semi-decent plunder brawl. It's hard to imagine a scenario in which he becomes more than a Dark oddity.

73. Leva Bates

Leva Bates
Thomas Tischio AEW

Leva Bates isn't a terrible entertainer though there have been times when she has looked in over her head even with the 'Librarian' jobber shtick, particularly when she's asked to wrestle. The former Blue Pants' chops are almost non-existent.

Having her around as an enhancement talent should work, though Bates has even looked unwieldy when taking a beating. The gimmick is okay for her card position, she gives Peter Avalon somebody to bounce off of. Leva is never going to be a strongly pushed talent anyway, though the performances haven't been good.


72. Michael Nakazawa

Michael Nakazawa
AEW

Being best mates with Kenny Omega paid off for Michael Nakazawa, who may not have made the AEW talent roster if not for his association with the Executive Vice President.

Nakzawa's oil shtick is fun the first few times you see it but quickly wears thin. It's a one-note act with a Dark ceiling despite the odd Dynamite foray, making it hard to see what he offers beyond the odd meme here and there.

71. Alex Reynolds

Alex Reynolds AEW
WWE.com

The Beaver Boys of Alex Reynolds and John Silver barely wrestle as The Dark Order's meat shields, though they have proven themselves a capable enhancement tandem when called upon. Fans of Beyond Wrestling know they can do more than that, of course, but it's unlikely that they'll ever be used higher up the AEW card.

70. John Silver

John Silver
AEW

Though Silver's push and presentation are identical to those of partner Alex Reynolds, this pint-sized powerhouse has stood out more when asked to pull on his boots and dopey gimp mask.

Silver was a highlight in his and Reynolds' recent Dark tag match against the Natural Nightmares. As he did on the indies, the diminutive beefcake stood out for his personality and intensity, laying into his veteran opponents veraciously. It'd be cool to see him get the odd singles match here and there before 2020 is over.


69. Kylie Rae

Kylie Rae
James Musselwhite/AEW

A tough one to rank is Kylie Rae, who worked only a single AEW match before leaving the promotion under mysterious circumstances shortly after Double Or Nothing.

Rae pulled out of the following month's Fyter Fest show and took a brief hiatus from wrestling. She'd eventually return to her old home, Freelance Wrestling, before scoring a regular gig with Impact, where she resides today.

It's a shame, as Kylie would have been a useful building block in the women's division. Having the talented babyface around may have helped the scene avoid many of its early problems, though we'll never know.

68. Anna Jay

AEW Anna Jay
AEW

The newest signing to AEW's women's division had wrestled only seven matches before the promotion brought her in for a jobber spot, then signed her to a full-time deal on the strength of her performance. That's got to feel good for 'The Star of the Show.'

Though we're yet to see Jay outwith anything but enhancement matches, she looks a performer beyond her experience level. Following her progress will be rewarding for anyone paying the closest attention, as she's essentially brand new to this, meaning everyone is in on the ground floor of her career.

67. Bradon Cutler

Brandon Cutler
AEW

'Two Contract Cutler' was unveiled as an AEW signing in an emotional episode of Being The Elite last year. He comes off as one of the most likeable and all-round good guys in the promotion, making it hard to commit to even moderate criticism.

Regardless, the guy is yet to win a single bout here. The "worst wrestler in AEW" storyline with Peter Avalon is fun, though it speaks to both his card position and long-term prospects, as the DnD-inspired wrestler struggles despite his athleticism.


66. Sadie Gibbs

Sadie Gibbs
STARDOM

An ideal world would have seen Sadie Gibbs graft on the indies and in Japan for a few more years before signing with a company like AEW, entering a mainstream American promotion with a more well-rounded skillset.

Scooped up as part of the great 2019 talent grab, Gibbs is an athletic phenom with all the potential in the world but boatloads of rough edges. She may need a busier road schedule than AEW can offer to iron them out completely. A shame, really, and she hasn't wrestled for the promotion since last October.

65. Brandi Rhodes

Brandi Rhodes AEW
Lee South/AEW

The Nightmare Collective was supposedly a Brandi Rhodes creation. Comfortably the worst act the promotion has committed to beyond one or two shows, it (along with lacklustre in-ring performances at Bash at the Beach and Fight for the Fallen) is why she finishes so low here.

Rhodes is better suited to play a more straight-laced manager character. She's doing a decent job with The Natural Nightmares at the moment and was strong by Cody's side before. On top of this, she plays an important role backstage too, serving as AEW's Chief Brand Officer.

64. Billy Gunn

Billy Gunn
AEW

Billy Gunn is fun.

AEW know that they're doing with the player-coach, who rarely laces up and is only ever booked in light-hearted, entertainment-first spots that don't deprive a younger wrestler of a spotlight, while also shepherding his son through American wrestling. It works, and there's no reason to stop using him - despite his age.


63. Austin Gunn

austin Gunn
AEW

Austin Gunn, Professional Fan of Professional Wrestling, has been an Empty Arena Era delight, with his high-energy ringside antics elevating many a Dynamite since the global health crisis kicked in. The guy has been a riot.

It's hard to gauge how much potential Austin has based on his limited in-ring résumé, though he hasn't looked out of his depth and at least has charisma. He, like Sadie Gibbs, could likely benefit from a busier calendar, though he has acquired himself relatively well so far.

62. 10

10 AEW
AEW

Preston '10' Vance is The Dark Order's goober bruiser. He's a slightly elevated enhancement talent capable of getting the job done against part-timers like Lee Johnson and Musa and may score a more significant role later down the line, but he's here to play jobber to the stars for now.

This was apparent on a recent episode of Dynamite, where he had his arm broken by Jon Moxley. He looks a solid all-round wrestler so far and brings something different to the Order's other masked losers.

61. Awesome Kong

Awesome Kong Fight for the Fallen
AEW

A great Double Or Nothing 2019 debut aside, Awesome Kong's AEW run was largely disappointing until she shot off to film the next season of GLOW a few months ago.

Kong has had a long, hard career. She's also 42 years old. Time comes for everybody and sadly, in 2020, it has largely robbed the monster of her believability.

No longer the dominant marauder of old, Kong now requires extreme protection. She is exposed in longer bouts and is likely best suited to quick destruction jobs if she is to return to AEW.


60. Bea Priestley

Bea Priestley
AEW

Still only 24 years old, Bea Priestley is a wrestler who could feature in many a women's 'Best in the World' discussion in time, though she isn't quite there yet The good news is that she's in an ideal place to develop: her home promotion, STARDOM, is one of the world's most efficient talent farms, helping the likes of Io Shirai, Kairi Sane, Mayu Iwatani, and more grow over the past decade.

Priestley has looked a performer above AEW's bottom tiers in her appearances for the promotion. It's clear, however, that the pieces are still coming together, as shown by her accidental injuring of Britt Baker at Fight for the Fallen and lack of standout performances since.

59. Peter Avalon

Peter Avalon
AEW

Peter Avalon has all you could want from a heel jobber. He's a good enough wrestler to take a beating, has an annoying gimmick that makes you want to see him get his *ss kicked, and seemingly has no qualms about being the ladder's bottom rung, hence why he features in the top 60 here.

Lowly card positioning means 'The Librarian' may never rise above this spot, but that's fine. Every promotion needs a jobber or two. Avalon is a good one, and one could argue that he should never win in AEW.

58. Sonny Kiss

Sonny Kiss
AEW

'The Concrete Rose' might be the first AEW wrestlers fans could legitimately call "underused," as Kiss barely shows his face on Dynamite, showing up only for battle royal spots.

This is despite standing out in every Dark performance to date. Kiss is a great athlete with a unique, eye-catching moveset and bags of personality. We'll never know what he's capable of until he's allowed to test himself in a bigger spotlight, so it'd be nice to see this happen before long.

Until then, this is his position.


57. Allie

Allie The Bunny
aew

What's going on with Allie at the moment? While she hasn't wrestled since February 2019, she appeared to have slotted into a decent role as The Butcher and the Blade's manager. This appears to be over now, with all three dropping their death metal aesthetic and Allie going after QT Marshall, whom she courted by, ahem, eating an apple on the latest episode of Dark. Cool.

Whatever the chase, she has rarely been a featured performer as either a wrestler or valet. Here's hoping whatever comes next brings more opportunities.

56. Big Swole

Big Swole
AEW

Swole looked to be levelling up in AEW's women's division prior to the ongoing global health crisis kicking in. She was briefly positioned alongside Nyla Rose and Riho prior to Revolution but fell off the radar thereafter, not re-emerging until a boisterous display as a Double Or Nothing 2020 crowd member.

Solid but unspectacular would be an accurate description here. She was great on Dark's defunct From Undesirable to Undeniable segment and has had a couple of solid matches so far, though she is yet to make a mark.

55. Shanna

Shanna AEW
AEW

Her career likely grounded by travel restrictions relating to the health crisis, Shanna hasn't been seen in months.

It's a shame, really, as her outings thus far suggest she is one of the more well-round wrestlers in the division. She suffers from the same lack of character development as many of her peers but looks slick and polished between the ropes, giving her an advantage over many of her greener, less experienced peers.

Though Shanna's ceiling is likely solid midcard gatekeeper, the scene could really, really use one of those at the moment.


54. Angelico

Angelico AEW
AEW

The Hybrid 2 came to AEW to be jobbers to the stars in the tag division. They aren't here to play a starring role, but to enhance others on their way to do top, so it's hard to throw too much criticism at what they've done so far.

Such a role places a limit on how far they can go on a list like this. Angelico has talent, sure, but this division is loaded with talent. In that context, he's more of a mid-level guy doing lower-level things than an egregiously misused super-worker.

53. Jack Evans

Jack Evans Kenny Omega
AEW

The more dazzling Hybrid 2 member is Jack Evans, who has stood out more than Angelico because he's really, really great playing a sh*thead heel. The guy walks around and mouths off with such an obnoxious swagger that it's hard not to want to see him getting kicked punched in the face, which is the whole point of his character.

Evans, one of the most influential indie high-flyers ever, also has a banger Dark match with Kenny Omega on his résumé. So there's that.

52. CIMA

Kenny Omega CIMA Fight for the Fallen
AEW

That CIMA's #STRONGHEARTS group hasn't been utilised more often is a shame, as the Dragon Gate legend, El Lindaman, and T-Hawk have never disappointed as a hard-hitting all-action trio.

CIMA's AEW run is more distinguished than his freelancing stablemates. He worked Kenny Omega at Fight for the Fallen, Darby Allin on Dynamite, and also associated with SoCal Uncensored in their feud with The Dark Order. He isn't the performer he used to be but the veteran still looks capable of playing a middling role.


51. Jimmy Havoc

Jimmy Havoc
AEW

The black sheep of AEW sometimes stands out for the wrong reasons and lacks the look of a full-time wrestler in a major American promotion, partly explaining why he had largely been consigned to Dark after failing to break through during Dynamite's early days.

Havoc looked good in All Out's Cracker Barrel Clash with Darby Allin and Joey Janela, but he has always done the hardcore stuff well. The real question is whether or not he can fit in as a "serious" AEW wrestler. There have been teething pains, but the tag team with Kip Sabian should at least give him a vehicle to prove he can.

Or cannot. Whatever the case may be.

50. QT Marshall

QT Marshall Cody
AEW

That QT Marshall is rough around the edges is part of his charm. He's easy to root for because you see his flaws every time he wrestles but goddamnit, the guy's just got so much heart. The character likely understands he's never going to be a top guy but that doesn't stop him from trying.

Marshall is likely more important to AEW offscreen than on, as he currently works as one of the promotion's top producers. On top of his, he offered his training school up for Dynamite tapings when the health crisis kicked in, helping AEW through a tough period, further proving his worth.

The Natural Nightmares are a fun midcard pairing, too. They may never be champions but they're never going to mail it in either.

49. Kip Sabian

Kip Sabian Penelope ford
AEW

Working a basic heel gimmick to the point of banality, Kip Sabian is a very okay wrestler who has done a very okay job in AEW thus far.

'Superbad' is a perfectly solid worker but the act needs evolution. Every match pans out the same way, with constant interferences and distractions from Penelope Ford. These things aren't as effective when spammed, so while the Jimmy Havoc tag team could lead to greater things for all involved, they aren't going to be much fun to watch if they don't break the repetitive cycle.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.