Every AEW Wrestler Ranked From Worst To Best - After One Year
48. Yuka Sakazaki
'The Magical Girl' suffers only for a lack of appearances, as Sakazaki has only worked five matches since debuting at Double Or Nothing 2020. Annoyingly, she looked set to play a bigger role before the global health crisis kicked in and robbed the AEW women of much of its Joshi contingent.
Fleeting showings have shown Sakazaki to be both a charming personality and a strong babyface. The women's division could use both of those things at the moment as even champion Hikaru Shida feels underdeveloped, giving Yuka a clear spot to fill once she's able to return.
47. Brian Cage
Though only part of AEW canon for less than a week, Brian Cage has already made a considerable impact. A well-played Double Or Nothing debut saw him win the Casino Ladder Match and a shot at AEW World Champion Jon Moxley, and the follow-up Dynamite had him crushing jobber Lee Johnson, with manager Taz cutting a bellicose promo to put him over further.
Cage has quietly been under AEW contract since January. He is ready to be shot towards the cards upper echelons as an eyeball-popping, attention-grabbing big man with freak athleticism and a mean manager who can compensate for any spoken shortcomings. Big things are in his immediate future.
46. Shawn Spears
Double Or Nothing's humiliation by Dustin Rhodes' hand is fine, because Shawn Spears is no greater than Tye Dillinger. He's a midcarder. AEW tried to elevate him through the Cody programme, then again in recent weeks, but it hasn't worked. 'The Chairman' didn't convince when the spotlight was shined upon him and will likely slot into a permanent mid-tier role.
Consider this a noble failure: the parties tried, but it just didn't work. This was always going to happen to somebody and it's a shame it had to be with a hard worker like Spears.
An average performer with an average ceiling, perhaps he'll find a character that works for him later down the line. For now, though, he's just a guy.
45. The Butcher
The Butcher and The Blade had it all against them after an ineffective debut angle that saw them rubbing shoulders with Cody immediately, though they were able to overcome this with a strong showing in the following week's tag match. They have demonstrated themselves to be a solid, bruising tandem since then, with the MJF association giving them a rub, though they've barely been featured over the past few months.
The Butcher is a curio. He has an incredible look, a great Lariat, and impressive power, though he is already in his 40s and still green. That he performs above his experience level is unquestionable, though it's impossible to place him higher with such low usage.
44. The Blade
As a far more refined worker than his tag team partner, The Blade finishes one spot higher. Their presentation, however, has been identical.
The former Braxton Sutter is a sleek, well-rounded wrestler who compliments The Butcher well. We just need to see them on television more before assessing how far the team can go.
43. Emi Sakura
With its legitimate pupil/teacher dynamic and smooth chain wrestling, Emi Sakura vs. Riho (Full Gear) is an underrated early gem in AEW's women's division and the key reason Sakura finishes relatively high despite her paucity of appearances since then.
Sakura's character was her main issue in AEW. The Freddie Mercury persona wasn't adequately explained and therefore came off low-rent and amateurish to those unfamiliar with her outside work, despite bringing more than two decades of experience to the table. A shame, really, as this left a talented veteran open to mockery.
42. Penelope Ford
Ford is at a similar developmental stage to Sadie Gibbs in that the bulk of her highlights come from harnessing superior athleticism, though 'The Superbad Girl' is further along her curve.
There's work still to be done here. Penelope isn't complete and rarely wrestles with the same confidence she has in her managerial role, though her springboard moves, dives, and 'ranas give her matches extra sizzle. Coupled with her ability to project personality in her performances, there's a lot to work with.
41. Colt Cabana
After years grafting on the independent scene and with his failed WWE run now a distant memory, it's great to see one of wrestling's good guys working on national television every week. Scott Colton, the man, is hard to root against, and his AEW run has been solid so far.
Cabana's blend of cute comedy and classic, British-style grappling makes him a midcard treasure. His charisma and veteran savvy mean signing him was a no-brainer, though it'd be nice to see him slotted into a medium-to-long-term storyline sooner or later.
40. Kris Statlander
The nose-booping alien gimmick stinks and must go if Statlander is to fulfil her monster potential. There's also a tendency to stretch beyond her capabilities in ways that yield botches and miscommunication between the ropes, though this can be ironed out in time. Why hit a tricky Hurricanrana when a straight punch will do?
When considering Statlander's flaws, it's important to remember that she has only been doing this for two years. As things stand, she is far better than anyone with that experience level has any right to be and can absolutely be a major, major player in this company with development. Her ceiling is astronomical.
39. Stu Grayson
The original Dark Order are a complicated act.
Fans were right to reject the goofy gimmick after a lame Double or Nothing debut, then again when they were thrust back up the card in December 2019. "Dork Order" isn't creative but it is accurate. These guys and their personalities weren't doing it in a purported "real-sport environment" (that barely even exists anymore).
What saves them is their ring work. Grayson and Evil Uno are a sick tag team with years of experience working together, bringing a level of fluidity matched by few others. Those skills have never been in question and Grayson, though not as charismatic as his partner, is the snappier, more impactful wrestler.
38. Evil Uno
Separating Evil Uno and Stu Grayson is almost pointless, but it boiled down to this: Grayson is the better wrestler, Uno is the better promo. As The Dark Order's mouthpiece and focal point until Mr. Brodie Lee showed up, Uno gets the nod.
Let's hope these more to see from the big man. He is great value on social media and comes off as a creative guy, suggesting strengths beyond what his gimmick allows him to show.
37. Isiah Kassidy
Personality and promise define Private Party, who have been typecast as flippydoos and must now work hard to develop their style beyond the giffable - something the duo are no doubt conscious of.
These guys are loaded with potential but sometimes lack the finesse to meet their ambitions. Their matches aren't as clean as they could be and botches are relatively commonplace, though they are extremely exciting when they click into gear. Time will sharpen them up.
36. Marq Quen
Quen is Private Party's cleaner worker, hence why he is positioned above Isiah Kassidy.
The latest episode of Dynamite also featured some excellent selling from the high-flyer. He sold a worked knee injury so convincingly he had internet fans mistaking it for a shoot in the opening six-man tag, showcasing a vital pro-wrestling skill, particularly as he typically takes much of the heat in Private Party's matches.
35. Jake Hager
The Jake Hager experiment faltered when he faced Jon Moxley for the AEW World Championship. It stumbled before that, with Hager's Revolution clash with Dustin Rhodes a certified plodder, though the empty arena brawl was the moment the penny dropped for many. The spirit of Jack Swagger lives on.
Hager's bright spots have come in smaller roles, with his debut on Dynamite's maiden episode a real highlight. He looked like a killer that night and did a good job as Chris Jericho's strong, silent bodyguard, progressing nicely to a monstrous role murdershagging jobbers after the Dustin bout. From there, the wheels came off.
While still a string peripheral figure, 'The Big Hurt' won't become a star here.
34. Wardlow
Speaker of murdershaggers, Wardlow's recent squash matches have been awesome, as MJF's bruiser bulldozed his way through overmatched goobers with impactful throws, bombs, and the best release suplex in the game.
Wardlow also played a perfect role opposite Cody in their pre-Revolution cage match. That bout's structure was designed with highlighting his skills in mind and the big man upheld his end of the bargain, bringing a slow progression of moves culminating in an unlikely Swanton Bomb, prior to his inevitable defeat.
The problem with Wardlow is that we haven't seen enough of him to gauge his ceiling, nor have we heard him cut a promo. He looks good at the moment, though.
33. Joey Janela
The thing about criticising Joey Janela is that the man doesn't give a single f*ck what any internet windbag has to say. His most vociferous haters scream hilariously into the void, gotten to by a wrestler who's going to do his thing regardless of who thinks he's too indie, sloppy, or wreckless to be featured on national television, and that's part of his charm.
That isn't to say there aren't valid criticisms of Janela's AEW work, it's just that most are hysterical over the top.
A creative self-starting individual, Janela's work could stand to be cleaner and he has rarely been a focused figure in AEW, though he has always delivered when asked for a big performance. Matches against Kenny Omega and Cody proved 'The Bad Boy' is more than a mere indie buzz-maker.
32. Christopher Daniels
Christopher Daniels isn't the performer he once was. This is hardly a controversial statement given that he is 50 years old and has knees held together by spit and chewing gum, though it could have been a major issue if the SoCal Uncensored man wasn't such a smart worker.
'The Fallen Angel' has slotted into a role similar to Dustin Rhodes in that he's mostly booked as a sympathetic, broken down babyface who fights valiantly before falling to a rising heel threat. He's good at it, and with Frankie Kazarian and Scorpio Sky carrying the tag team load, this'll like be his job until retirement.
31. Marko Stunt
Marko Stunt is tremendous at getting his ass kicked. That's why he comes close to scratching the top 30.
If 'Mr. Pint Size' was being presented as an unrealistically competitive wrestler against guys like Lance Archer, Brodie Lee, and MJF, that'd be a massive problem. He isn't, though. Stunt gets the sh*t kicked out of him by these guys, mounting only slithers of offense through superior speed and evasiveness before getting put down. He is a job guy on par with WWE's Leon Ruff
Stunt does everything his employers do of him and does it well. The beatings he takes make him together than any witless doughnut to ever crow about him on Twitter, too.
30. Luchasaurus
Jurassic Express' resident big man made a great start to AEW life, highlighting many an early show with his incredible hot tags and ridiculous highlight reel moveset, though his progress was hindered by an untimely hamstring injury. Luchasaurus returned weeks later but looked noticeably slower between the ropes, diminishing his impact at a time when he perhaps should have been moving up the card.
Now back to his best, Luchsaurus is a ridiculously fun midcard/upper-midcard performer who has been protected well by AEW. He'd make for a cool fill-in TNT Championship opponent for Cody.
29. Chuck Taylor
Best Friends doesn't often get the credit they deserve, primarily because they are surrounded by world-class tandems in AEW's industry-best tag division, but they deserve props to rising towards the top of a pile including tandems like the Lucha Brothers, Proud and Powerful, and The Young Bucks.
This is a consequence of booking, of course, but their performances have been strong. Best Friends rule.
Chuck Taylor has been true to himself throughout his AEW run. An underrated brawler with an oddball personality, he'll rarely blow the audience away, but he's always entertaining.
28. Ortiz
That Proud and Powerful could have done more in AEW thus far is a fair assessment. Santana and Ortiz were one of the world's finest tag teams years before inking with Tony Khan's promotion but have yet to emerge as serious contenders here, despite occupying featured spots as members of Chris Jericho's Inner Ciricle. Regardless, the performances have been strong, they had an excellent match with The Young Bucks at Full Gear, and AEW can pull the trigger on them at any moment.
Ortiz is the hooting, hollering, and rope-biting loose cannon of the duo and a fine wrestler to boot. He has cultivated a stronger identity than many others in the promotion.
27. Santana
Santana positions slightly above his Proud and Powerful partner as he had the stronger Jon Moxley singles match prior to Revolution. It's that simple.
That made Santana stand out during that mini-program was a revelatory backstory vignette that put his struggle to the top over huge, particularly when he recontextualised Moxley stabbing his eye by revealing he grew up with a blind father. It was passionate, believable, and emotional, highlighting Satana as one of the promotion's more underrated talkers.
26. Frankie Kazarian
SoCal Uncensored were the tag team in AEW for the promotion's first few months. As a vital cog in that machine, Frankie Kazarian places in the top 30, despite sliding down the rankings since shedding the championships.
Kaz is still a very good worker at 42 years old. His skill, experience, and nous have been vital in holding the division together at times, particularly during the early days, and it'll be interesting to see if he makes another run at the belts in 2020.
25. Mr. Brodie Lee
There's more to unpack with Brodie Lee than this word count will allow, so let's simplify:-
Vince McMahon jabs = bad.
Promo delivery = good.
The Double Or Nothing build = half-baked.
The Jon Moxley match = out-f*cking-standing.
A blowaway DoN performance shot Lee back up after a middling start to life in AEW, proving the old industry heads that call this man a genius of laying out matches were correct in their assessment. That violent, bloody war was a death metal EP come to life and will hopefully provide a springboard to wider acclaim for Lee, who still has much to prove after leaving WWE.
24. Matt Hardy
As daft as his teleporting debut was, Matt Hardy is yet to put a foot wrong in AEW.
Concerns that his Broken brilliance wouldn't track in this environment have been tempered by Hardy switching back and forth between his different personas. He's a weird, creative dude with lots of big ideas that haven't even been tapped into yet, and while his physical troubles are well-known to anyone who followed his WWE career's latter stages, he can still keep it together between the ropes. Hardy remains a competent enough wrestler to survive in this hyper-athletic environment.
Lord knows what the future holds for Hardy, though consider that we haven't even visited his Compound for a Deletion yet.
23. Britt Baker
Pardon the use of personal tone here, but if you can't at least appreciate what Dr. Britt Baker is doing at the moment, chances are I don't trust you as a human being.
Reborn as a delusional heel, Baker's past few months have been excellent. Her 'Role Model' persona has transformed her into one of the company's most compelling acts and she took it to a new level on the most recent episode of Dynamite, calling conspiracy against the entire AEW women's division and, bizarrely, Aubrey Edwards. There isn't a drop of self-awareness to this character - and that's what makes it great.
Why only 23, then? Because of the rank failure that came before. Baker totally flopped as her division's top babyface, delivering months of lacklustre performances before eventually turning heel. It turns out the switch was all she needed to flourish.
22. Trent
Perennially one of the most underrated wrestlers on the planet, the subtle effort AEW has put into positioning Trent as Best Friends' strongest member shows the faith his employers have in him. He has repaid them with typically consistent tag team performances and banger singles bouts with PAC, Kenny Omega, and Jon Moxley, giving him low-key potential as a breakout star.
Trent's kind-of-a-d*ckhead persona hasn't changed much from his NJPW/indie days, but it doesn't need to. Best Friends are over. The former Beretta is a big part of that, and an eventual singles run isn't out of the question at all.
21. Jungle Boy
Jungle Boy's character and physical frame both need fleshing out before he can be considered a prospect on the Sammy Guevara/Darby Allin level, but make no mistake: the 23-year-old is a prospect.
He was one of Double Or Nothing 2020's MVPs thanks to a tremendous defensive performance against MJF. Laid out like an old-school territory era classic, their match saw Jungle Boy bump and sell at a level some 20-year veterans never hit, fighting back with explosive, well-positioned bursts. The kid levelled up - and losing to a counter roll-up is no great shame.
Again, there's still a lot of work to be done, though Jungle Boy's strengths are huge and there is plenty of time for his weaknesses to catch up.
20. Nyla Rose
What prevents Nyla Rose from finishing higher are her performances in her disappointing Revolution clash with Kris Statlander and at Double Or Nothing 2019, where she was anonymous. In fairness, Awesome Kong's debut was always going to overshadow the other monster, though 'The Native Beast' still struggled.
Otherwise, Rose has exceeded all expectations. She found her feet as a monster heel quickly and was a highlight in Fyter Fest's three-way with Riho and Yuka Sakazaki, popping the crowd with brutal offense like her rope-hanging knee drop. This continued throughout her two Women's Title tilts with Riho, both of which rank amongst the division's finest matches, though Nyla hit a new level against the standard-bearing Hikaru Shida at Double Or Nothing 2020, where she lost her strap in only her second defence.
Nyla has also revealed herself to be a capable talker in this time, showing AEW was right to invest in her.
19. Pentagon Jr.
Another one for the "Should Have Been Higher" drawer, here, as while Pentagon Jr. has shone in AEW, he hasn't quite hit the heights expected of him when he signed.
The problem with the Lucha Brothers is that their tag matches tend to fall towards standard spotfest territory when they aren't compelled to flex their creative muscle. This is a particular hindrance to Penta, who isn't as versatile a performer as Rey Fenix, though he is considerably more charismatic.
AEW's terrifying skeleton ninja has nonetheless played a leading role in some of the promotion's more spectacular tag matches since its inception. He's performing at a high level, just not his highest.