Every WCW Halloween Havoc Ranked Worst To Best
Yetis, electrocutions, and Cruiserweight classics: Halloween Havoc was a riot.
Professional wrestling once again dips into the WCW nostalgia well this week as NXT revives Halloween Havoc for its 28 October episode, reviving the spooky old concept for the first time in 20 years.
A year that has already brought us a Bash at the Beach would've likely yielded one of WWE's weird, watered-down Starrcade shows if not for the ongoing global health crisis. AEW's Cody Rhodes, meanwhile, has filed for trademarks on Battlebowl and Bunkhouse Stampede, and is at legal loggerheads with WWE over The Match Beyond and Slamboree. Atlanta's legacy yet lives.
Halloween Havoc has a mixed history. While Eric Bischoff recently claimed it was "one of the more important pay-per-views of the year in WCW," it played host to some of the most maligned moments in company history - and think of the ground that covers. Introduced in 1989 and running until 2000, it was a gaudy, gimmicky holiday special that yielded plenty of decent-to-good wrestling (plus the odd transformative classic) but is mostly remembered for its tweeness and innumerable grand disasters. Don't even try to name a PPV brand with more so-bad-it's-actually-great trainwrecks on its résumé, because there isn't one.
Let's hope WWE plays into Havoc's dumb charm with the NXT revival. Until then, let's relive the, uh... classics.
(In the spirit of Halloween Havoc, pay-per-views will be ranked primarily on how much fun they are to watch, whether "good" or "bad". This is a weird, silly brand, and most of its appeal comes from that, not some opaque standard of "quality".)
12. 1999
This was the first Halloween Havoc to go down on Vince Russo's watch. Appropriately, it stinks.
This was a night of needless swerves, worked shoots, and other such guff. A pay-per-view stuffed with more fake edginess than a RETRIBUTION career retrospective, the closest thing to "good" was Eddie Guerrero vs. Perry Saturn, though even that was sullied by Ric Flair whomping Eddie with a crowbar for the finish. Afterwards, 'The Nature Boy' forced a kiss on Billy Kidman's partner, Torrie Wilson, reminding you this was a gross, gross era.
Sting had a terrible night. First, Hulk Hogan laid down for him after delaying his ring entrance then coming out in street clothes. The match was called even though the opening bell never rang. The World Champion then met United States Champion Goldberg in what was billed as a non-title match. He was crushed in three minutes - and Goldberg was named WCW Champion anyway, because... reasons?
The bad stuff on Halloween Havoc 1999 isn't even funny-bad: it's largely unwatchable, and not worth enduring to get to the paltry "highs".
11. 2000
A hellscape of a show.
Watching the yoked-up Natural Born Thrillers and their Dumb Jock Energy in 2020 is always a riot, so Jindrak and O'Haire's three-way opening with Billy Kidman and Rey Misterio Jr. and the Boogie Knights is worth revisiting. The rest? Ugly, turgid, late-era WCW tripe.
The Many Faces of String bit is a lot less fun than it should be, as the legend faced off with Jeff Jarrett, preceded by a bunch of ringers emerging as Surfer Sting, Wolfpac Sting, and more. It was a weird mess highlighted by Actual Sting yanking 'Double J' out from the hole in the canvas Jarrett had been dragged through by Crow Sting earlier, then finishing the job.
Misfits In Action vs. Perfect Event was so formless that the performers (Lash LeRoux in particular) were a level below even mailing it in. Shane Douglas and Torrie Wilson vs. Konnan and Tigress featured two people who literally didn't know how to wrestle, and came off as such, while David Flair vs. Buff Bagwell revolved around Flair trying to get a sample of Buff's blood after accusing him of impregnating his partner, Miss Hancock, in one of WCW's worst latter-day storylines.
Goldberg buried KroniK in a two-on-one main event. Whatever.
10. 1998
Hulk Hogan vs. Ultimate Warrior from Halloween Havoc 1998 is rightly regarded as one of the worst major-league bouts of all time. Wrestling Observer Newsletter readers named it that year's bout after Dave Meltzer had slapped a -***** rating on it. "One of the worst matches ever held," said Power Slam's Fin Martin.
It was, indeed, a hurricane of urine, but a perverse joy when viewed in 2020. Though a disaster in the moment, watching two legendary egos fap their way through a grim, uncooperative shambles, with neither man wanting to give their opposite number an inch, is kind of hilarious. This is particularly true of the infamous botched finish, in which Hogan tried to burn Warrior with a fireball, only for the flash paper to go up in his own face, singeing his eyebrows and moustache.
What happened with the main event marks Halloween Havoc 1998 as an objective shambles. Goldberg and Diamond Dallas Page worked a strong WCW Title match that was cut off before it could finish. WCW regrettably forgot to inform their providers that the pay-per-view was going to run longer than usual, so they were forced to air the match in full on Nitro the following evening to compensate. A shame, really, as this is a stiff knockdown brawl that somehow got better when Goldberg got concussed, as it forced a complete change of gameplan.
The rest of the PPV is a bloated pile of meh, particularly the 14-minute Scott Hall vs. Kevin Nash countout.
9. 1990
The Network upload of this pay-per-view mercifully cuts three singles matches and the Master Blasters vs. Southern Boys, making it a leaner viewing experience. So-bad-it's-good completionists may wish to find Moondog Rex vs. Junkyard Dog on YouTube, though: how they crammed so much bad into three minutes is almost impressive.
Lowlights include the Fabulous Freebirds vs. Renegade Warriors, as Chris and Mark Youngblood were never any good between the ropes, and a lacklustre main event between Sting and Sid Vicious. The bout itself was nothing special until a finish that took it down a couple more notches, as the Horsemen and a fake Sting interfered, only for the legend to win anyway. Cool!
Highlights are few and far between, though watching the Steiners' dumb jock style meshing with the Nasty Boys' wild brawling is a hoot, even today. The rest of the pay-per-view is flavourless and without notable highs and lows.
8. 1992
This was where the Spin The Wheel, Make The Deal gimmick first came to life, with Sting wrestling Jake 'The Snake' Roberts in the main event. It was a big disappointment. Their Coal Miner's Glove match turned out to be one of the most maligned bouts from this period of WCW, and stands as a bottom-tier On A Pole match without the hilarity of, say, Judy Bagwell on a Forklift. Still, watching Roberts trying to coax a snake that clearly couldn't be arsed into biting him in the face afterwards is worth a laugh.
Most of the good stuff comes in the pay-per-view's first hour. Ricky 'The Dragon' Steamboat vs. Brian Pillman and Steve Austin/Steve Williams vs. Barry Windham/Dusty Rhodes are as strong as you'd expect, even if the latter suffered from overbooking towards the end.
Watch Masa Chono vs. Rick Rude at your peril, though. This was the kind of bout that'll make your soul leave your body. The duo looked like they were wrestling in molasses, working no fire, heat, or story into an utterly boring stallfest of no merit whatsoever. Avoid at all costs.
The rest of the show isn't particularly notable.
7. 1991
Witness the true majesty of a perfect pro-wrestling trainwreck, and one of the all-time-great so-bad-it's-good classics: THE CHAMBER OF HORRORS.
This thing was the best kind of disaster. Ostensibly an enclosed cage match with wacky props like coffins and chainsaws, it stipulated that in order to win, a wrestler had to strap a member of the opposing team into an electric chair and kayfabe fry them on pay-per-view. A literal deathmatch, then. Hilariously, it concluded with Cactus Jack pulling the switch while his own teammate, Abdullah the Butcher, was in the chair - and sparks literally flew.
If televised murder doesn't do it for you, there's a high-effort performance from Ron Simmons to enjoy in the main event, as he faced Lex Luger for the WCW Championship. The rest of Halloween Havoc 1991 is almost boringly competent, though Dustin Rhodes vs. Steve Austin is still genuinely great, and there's also the weird highlight of Kevin Nash wrestling as Oz - and Rick Rude as the WCW Phantom.
6. 1994
We never got to see Hulk Hogan vs. Ric Flair in WWE, though Havoc 1994's steel cage match helped make up for the frustrations of 1992. It was a great piece of pro-wrestling pantomime. There's a lot going on with Mr. T as the referee, multiple interferences, and other tropes, but each was well-played, and it all went down before a fired-up crowd that lapped everything up.
Flair's retirement stipulation didn't last - because of course it didn't - but this was an earnestly great match and a step up from their Clash of the Champions battle. Less exciting was Brother Bruti's reveal as the mysterious masked man who'd been plaguing Hogan, which came after the bout. WCW, in true WCW fashion, found a way to immediately put a dampener on something awesome.
There's not much to the rest of the card. Really, Halloween Havoc 1994 is a one-match show, though the dull resthold-heavy opener between Honky Tonk Man and Johnny B. Badd should be avoided by everyone except those looking for an insomnia cure. Dave Sullivan vs. Kevin Sullivan should tick your so-bad-it's-good box, particularly with Dave's Hulkamania tribute bit in full flow.
5. 1996
The clear highlight of Halloween Havoc 1996, and not just from a workrate nerd's perspective (a perspective your writer has no problem writing from), was Dean Malenko vs. Rey Misterio Jr. As cliché as praising the WCW Cruiserweight division above all else has become, this was clearly the strongest part of the night, with Misterio working as an underdog against Dean's smothering, clinical style. It was a great way to wrap their lengthy series and while it won't pop your eyeballs out like some of Rey's later matches, it holds up.
While Malenko vs. Misterio is the only earnest must-see match on the show, Syxx and Chris Jericho work a decent midcard bout, Harlem Heat and The Outsiders' Tag Team Title clash is solid, and DDP vs. Eddie Guerrero has intensity despite its sloppiness.
Hulk Hogan vs. Randy Savage is bad - and not fun-bad either. It was two veterans who were never going to recover their old magic so far from their prime desperately trying to do so anyway, and it died a death. Marred by stalling aplenty early on, ref bumps, a Giant interfere, and the crooked Nick Patrick storyline, it was followed by a rambling Roddy Piper promo as part of an aimless show-closing angle as the pay-per-view cut off before the segment felt like it was done.
A perfect metaphor for the show as a whole, really.
4. 1989
Subtitled Settling the Score, this was the first Halloween Havoc event and went down towards the end of an excellent year for the NWA/WCW, though the wheels had largely come off by Starrcade a month-and-a-half later.
Still, this is a good, solid wrestling show. While the undercard is largely unspectacular, things pick up considerable as Brian Pillman and Lex Luger contest the United States Title, with the latter in the midst of one of his career's best years. Bouts like this are a reminder of how good the big man was as the '80s rolled to a close. Elsewhere, the Road Warriors vs. Skyscrapers is worth checking out if you're into big beefy boys beefing the beef out of each other.
Halloween Havoc 1989's real highlight, however, is the original ThunderDome. Pitting Ric Flair and Sting against Terry Funk and The Great Muta, it featured more electricity than the myriad Zoom call screens inside the Amway Center at the moment, as parts of the cage were charged up. The stipulation was well-implemented, with Muta getting zapped after scaling the structure alongside Sting, and the whole deal was an effective way to conclude the epic Flair/Funk rivalry. It doesn't quite as strong as the best WarGames matches, but ThunderDome is still a hoot.
Also, Bruno Sammartino was the special guest referee. That's weird.
3. 1993
The first earnestly very good Halloween Havoc show went down in the event's fourth year, with the Spin The Wheel, Make The Deal gimmick redeemed following the Coal Miner's Glove debacle.
Cactus Jack vs. Big Van Vader was left to chance this time. Their stipulation? A Texas Deathmatch. Outstanding. A brutal ripper of a brawl, it felt as unhinged and reckless as any other time these two madmen shared a ring in WCW, and if you've got the stomach for it, it's hard to argue its position alongside the greatest matches in WCW history. Your writer would have it at number two in Halloween Havoc history, at least - behind a bout we'll talk about later on.
There's good stuff elsewhere as Paul Orndorff wrestles Ricky Steamboat, Steve Austin and Dustin Rhodes once again contest the United States Title, and the Nasty Boys face Marcus Bagwell and the perenially underrated 2 Cold Scorpio. Also, The Shockmaster wrestles in the opener, so there's your slice of funny-bad.
Havoc '93's only major disappointment was Rick Rude vs. Ric Flair. A quick glance at the participants suggests a top quality match, though this thing fell way short of expectations, with no connective tissue between the bigger moments.
2. 1995
Forget the serviceable matches had by Johnny B. Badd and DDP, or Sabu and Mr. JL. Forget even the two bad ones wrestled by Randy Savage on this pay-pay-view. Ditch all of that, dear reader, and instead focus on some of the most preposterous sh*t to ever go down on a WCW card, because Halloween Havoc 1995 was a delightful catastrophe.
Ric Flair pulls perhaps the most obvious heel turn of all time while teaming with Sting to face Arn Anderson and Brian Pillman. It's a fun, well-worked match, and Flair is wonderfully over-the-top as he hams it up on the outside, preparing to pull the trigger on his career rival. It's a riot, and essential viewing if you want to know where the "gullible Sting" reputation comes from.
Things only get more preposterous from there.
There's Monster Truck Sumo match on the building's roof that ends with The Giant literally getting thrown off the arena by Hulk Hogan, seemingly plummeting to the ground. Later, the future Big Show literally no-sells death by coming down for his main event with Hogan, which finish on a disqualification when Hulk's manager, Jimmy Hart, hit the referee, somehow costing Hogan the belt.
We can't not mention, The Yeti - sorry, YEH-TAY - though. This was peak Dungeon of Doom bullsh*t as the giant, shambling beast wandered down all bandaged up like an Egyptian mummy, then dry-humped Hogan with The Giant in one of WCW's most infamous moments. The kind of guff WrestleCrap was invented for to cap one of the most perversely entertaining so-bad-it's-great pay-per-views ever.
1. 1997
Rey Misterio Jr. vs Eddie Guerrero is a big part of why Halloween Havoc 1997 was the pay-per-view's best incarnation ever. This is one of the strongest matches either man had throughout their lengthy careers, which says a lot. A state-of-the-art, futuristic battle, it was at least 15 years ahead of its time, and wouldn't feel out of place if it went down on a big event today, with Eddie an incredible heel against the smaller, more electric Rey. Watching him get increasingly agitated by Misterio's fight is a hoot and Rey's offense, of course, is brain-melting, even by modern standards.
It's hard to find a workrate-style match from 23 years ago that still holds up in 2020. This is one of them. A true classic.
Ultimo Dragon and Yuji Nagata worked a ripping opening match and Diamond Dallas Page vs. Randy Savage was a hot brawl. For your so-bad-it's-good content, Steve 'Mongo' McMichael wrestles on this card, feeding into a ridiculously long distraction spot for newcomer Goldberg to come out and do Goldberg things. Jacqulyn vs. Disco Inferno isn't much to watch, though seeing Disco grappling, internally, with the idea of hitting a woman is entertaining.
The bigger names let this show down, however. Ric Flair vs. Curt Hennig didn't come close to living up to either man's reputation while Roddy Piper and Hulk Hogan's cage match is largely a waste of time, with Hogan and Savage uniting to beat up a Sting lookalike afterwards. A strange, strange time, but a good pay-per-view regardless, featuring the best match in the brand's history.