Every WrestleMania 36 Match Ranked From Worst To Best

A wild and weird weekend of wrestling.

Brock Lesnar Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

A month ago, who could ever have envisioned that WrestleMania 36 would play out quite like this?

This year's version of the annual wrestling extravaganza was unquestionably the strangest and most surreal 'Mania of all time: an inherently awkward, empty arena show that, to its credit, nevertheless served up a fairly entertaining, well-paced platter of 18 matches across two nights.

Was the show undeniably, unavoidably lacking in atmosphere? Absolutely, but it was far from the disastrous trainwreck many fans were expecting or even hoping for, delivering a number of rock solid matches, a handful of very good ones, and at least two envelope-pushing outings nobody will be forgetting any time soon.

Was it a WrestleMania for the ages? Absolutely not, and some of its most exciting moments were undeniably hampered by the empty arena, but given the tight spot WWE was put in, the end result was at least entertainingly weird even when it didn't all work.

Clearly, Night 1 was a hell of a lot more consistent than Night 2, but accepting the dumpster fire potential, WrestleMania 36 made for a (mostly) acceptable weekend of programming...

18. WWE Universal Title: Goldberg (c) Vs. Braun Strowman

Strowman Goldberg
WWE.com

Result: Strowman finally puts Goldberg down after four Running Powerslams, winning the title (2:10).

Rating: What positive can really be said about this apart from WWE letting the right guy win?

Nobody was expecting a classic, but between the actual tedium of the match and Braun's non-existent build per the circumstances, it might be one of the most deflating and underwhelming major title wins in recent WWE history.

It was neat to see Braun finally climb the mountain he clearly should have several years ago, but like this? It was tough to care much, and at the end of the day, Braun's clearly just going to be a transitional champion anyway. 2/10


17. WWE Title: Brock Lesnar (c) Vs. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre Brock Lesnar Claymore Kick
WWE.com

Result: Drew kills Brock with three Claymores to score the win and capture the title (4:35).

Rating: This has to be one of the least-satisfying ways for WWE to render a satisfying result ever.

It was widely reported that Brock wasn't happy about being made to wrestle the match amid current circumstances, which likely explains why it lasted mere minutes and didn't amount to much more than finisher spam.

Drew deserved to have a hard-fought match in front of an adoring crowd, and instead he got a totally flat, dispassionate one to an empty arena.

It's almost bad enough to make one wish they'd given Brock the win and delayed Drew's run until the world was back to normal, especially with the possibility of future TV tapings being limited. 3/10


16. King Corbin Vs. Elias

WWE WrestleMania 36 Elias Baron Corbin
WWE

Result: Elias rolls up Corbin to steal the win (9:00).

Rating: This was definitely a match that happened. Nobody cared about it, it was totally forgettable as you'd expect, and yet for some reason it ran almost 10 minutes rather than just being a quick blow-off match.

Elias winning was genuinely surprising and referee Jessika Carr's trash talk with Corbin was fun, but there was really nothing here that made this befitting of a spot on a WrestleMania card.

On the flip side, a lot of people just realised that Elias has an actual entrance theme. 4/10


15. Last Man Standing: Edge Vs. Randy Orton

Edge Randy orton
WWE.com

Result: Edge finally keeps Orton down for the count with a Conchairto (36:35).

Rating: This was easily the most disappointing and frustrating match of the entire weekend, and it's tough to imagine either man being happy with the end result.

As fun as it was to get a tour of the Performance Center, the molasses-slow pacing really killed this one, especially without a crowd to mask the absolute tedium of the counting sequences.

You also have the question the sense of WWE having one wrestler try to strangle another with gym equipment the week after a prominent Chris Benoit documentary aired, but whatever.

Clearly this needed to be cut down heavily in post-production, because almost 40 minutes made it a soul-sapping slog.

Perhaps a cinematic style would've worked better, because aside from the chainlink fence elbow drop in the PC's main office, there was little creative or even basically interesting on offer here.

At least the brutal ending was decent enough. 4/10


14. Otis Vs. Dolph Ziggler

WWE WrestleMania 36 Otis Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

Result: Otis puts Ziggler down with the Caterpillar (8:15).

Rating: This was a whole lotta nothing wrestling-wise, and a classic case of the storyline, while dumb, being a whole lot more entertaining than the match itself.

The Mandy run-in was hilarious and it was refreshing that she didn't end up turning on Otis, leading to that glorious post-match celebration.

That kiss obviously would've killed in front of a live crowd, but it was still an aptly silly payoff to a daft feud, which is sometimes all you need.

Nothing to write home about from a wrestling perspective, but the right guy won and the storytelling was well-executed. 5/10


13. Natalya Vs. Liv Morgan

Liv Morgan
WWE

Result: Morgan pins Natalya with a roll-up for the win (6:25).

Rating: Hadn't we all had enough of roll-up finishes by this point in the weekend? Still, the right person won and the match was decent enough, if certainly nothing more than a typical kickoff show bout.

To Morgan's credit she does seem to be improving and held her own against Nattie perfectly well here, especially considering the lack of a crowd.

It played out within a sensible time frame and was a totally fine, watchable match. Not much else to say about this one. 5/10


12. Aleister Black Vs. Bobby Lashley

aliester black bobby lashley
WWE.com

Result: Black murders Lashley with the Black Mass for the win (7:20).

Rating: This match ran way too long and clearly should've been a squash, but at least it moved fast enough and wasn't too much of a slog as a result.

It was pretty much just a nothing kickoff show-caliber match for the most part, but at least the right guy won, even if Lashley's selling of the Black Mass was disappointing to say the least.

It got in, got out, and did what it needed to. Certainly nothing more, but also nothing less. 5/10


11. WWE SmackDown Women's Title: Bayley (c) Vs. Lacey Evans Vs. Naomi Vs. Sasha Banks Vs. Tamina

WWE WrestleMania 36 Bayley Lacey Evans
WWE.com

Result: Bayley puts Evans away with the Backstabber to retain the title (19:20).

Rating: This was definitely harmed by being an elimination match, especially as Tamina stuck around for far too long, and it was just a little lacking in energy for a match with five competitors in it.

The commentators sounded bored, the Bayley-Sasha dissension was predictable, and it went on way longer than it needed to.

Bayley and Lacey's back-and-forth in the final stretch was genuinely decent, though, and at least the storyline was clearly moved forward in a meaningful way.

Overall this wasn't bad, but not particularly good either. 5/10


10. WWE Intercontinental Title: Sami Zayn (c) Vs. Daniel Bryan

WWE WrestleMania 36 Sami Zayn Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Result: Zayn takes Bryan down with the Helluva Kick to retain the strap (9:20).

Rating: This was stiff as hell and the additional shenanigans certainly helped liven it up, but we obviously weren't getting the best of Sami here presumably due to his nagging injuries, and it ensured this never got even close to its full potential.

Still, it hit hard and the audible trash talk was fun, yet it also offered up yet another bafflingly flat finish - no doubt unaided by the lack of a crowd - and wasn't nearly the caliber match you'd expect from these two, at WrestleMania no less. 5/10


9. WWE Raw Women's Title: Becky Lynch (c) Vs. Shayna Baszler

Becky Lynch Shayna Baszler
WWE

Result: Becky countered the Kirifuda Clutch into a roll-up to retain the title (8:30).

Rating: Though Becky and Shayna clearly have good chemistry, this match was incredibly underwhelming, between its weird lack of energy, the general in-ring sloppiness, and the terribly anti-climactic ending that's been way overused in Shayna's matches.

It ultimately just made Shayna look like a goof after being built up so effectively. Clearly, this was her time to prevail, so it's tough to see the storytelling logic in having Becky go over.

On the other hand, if Shayna's moment is being saved for later in the year when she'll have an actual crowd to feed off, perhaps it's for the best. Either way, a disappointing match. 5/10


8. Drew Gulak Vs. Cesaro

Cesaro Drew Gulak
WWE.com

Result: Cesaro puts Gulak away with the U.F.O. (4:25).

It was undeniably disappointing how ridiculously short this was, but you can at least appreciate why WWE decided to keep a technical match taking place without a live crowd relatively brief.

Even so, Gulak and Cesaro did well with the little time allotted, and above all else it was great to see Cesaro dust off the U.F.O, even in an empty arena.

However, it pretty much ended just as it was finding its rhythm, and clearly should've gone another 10 minutes or so. Still, it was a solid kickoff show match all the same. 6/10


7. WWE Raw Tag Titles: The Street Profits (c) Vs. Austin Theory & Angel Garza

WWE WrestleMania 36 Street Profits
WWE.com

Result: Ford nails a Frog Splash for the win (6:20).

Rating: This was a fast-paced entertaining sprint that clearly would've benefited from having a few more minutes, but at the same time its brevity also made it a welcome counter to the utterly sluggish Last Man Standing match that preceded it.

The Street Profits did their absolute damnedest to keep the energy levels up despite having no crowd to feed off, and the post-match shenanigans with Bianca Belair were fun too.

Hardly a classic, but a solid cooldown match for sure, and it's easy to imagine how much better a rematch could be with a crowd in the future. 6/10


6. WWE Women's Tag Titles: The Kabuki Warriors (c) Vs. Alexa Bliss & Nikki Cross

WWE WrestleMania 36 Alexa Bliss Kairi Sane
WWE.com

Result: Bliss and Cross capture the titles after Cross nails The Purge on Sane and Bliss hits a Twisted Bliss (15:05).

Rating: It was nice to see this get so long to play out, and it got the show proper off to a fun start with a chaotic demolition derby layout, even if there were some hilariously obvious edits throughout.

The constant, clearly audible screaming took some getting used to, and the non-impact of the final Twisted Bliss gave the match a flat ending which probably should've been re-shot, but it was a solid bout otherwise.

The Kabuki Warriors probably should've kept the titles, though. 6/10


5. No DQ: Kevin Owens Vs. Seth Rollins

WWE WrestleMania 36 Kevin Owens Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Result: Owens puts Rollins away with a Stunner (17:20).

Rating: Let's face it, we all got thoroughly worked with that totally lame DQ finish, so the restart was a nice surprise, and the rest of the match was a gonzo blast.

While nowhere close to the best of what these two are capable of, the physicality was palpable and that elbow drop bump was one of the weekend's most memorable spots.

Rollins' trash talk to Owens was hilarious throughout and they milked the stipulation for all it was worth under the circumstances. Entertaining, even if more was clearly possible. 6/10


4. NXT Women's Title: Rhea Ripley (c) Vs. Charlotte Flair

Rhea Ripley Charlotte Flair
WWE

Result: Flair makes Ripley tap to the Figure-Eight Leglock to win the title (20:30).

Result: This was extremely stiff with some terrific bumps throughout, while Charlotte's psychology with Ripley's knee was rock solid.

It's hard to really be totally on-board with Charlotte winning given that a) she doesn't need it and b) this should've clearly been Ripley's moment, but the match as a whole was undeniably very good, and one of the best women's WrestleMania matches in recent memory.

It probably would've benefited from losing a few minutes in the middle, but you can't really argue with the overall physicality, no matter the disappointing result. 7/10


3. Firefly Fun House Match: John Cena Vs. "The Fiend" Bray Wyatt

John Cena Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

Result: The Fiend puts Cena away with the Mandible Claw (13:00).

Rating: That opening fakeout with Cena's entrance was quite brilliant, and though this didn't have the same element of surprise that the Boneyard match did, it was still a fantastically unique performance piece of a wrestling match.

It's easy to appreciate why some fans might find it too ridiculous, but given how aggressively self-seriously WWE can take itself, it was neat to see them delving into some more creative and boundary-pushing meta areas like this.

To their credit, Wyatt and Cena were clearly fully committed to it, and while it barely counts as an actual wrestling match, were most of us not at least sports entertained? 7/10


2. WWE SmackDown Tag Titles - Ladder Match: John Morrison (c) Vs. Kofi Kingston Vs. Jimmy Uso

WWE WrestleMania 36 Kofi Kingston John Morrison
WWE.com

Result: Morrison grabbed the titles as he fell off the ladder, retaining the straps for himself and The Miz (18:30).

Rating: In terms of actual, somewhat "traditional" wrestling, this was easily the best match of the entire weekend, despite the obvious weirdness of half the expected competitors being missing.

Nevertheless, the three men fought like they actually cared about doing anything but the bare minumum, and Morrison in particular pulled out all the stops to give us a thrilling match despite the total lack of atmosphere.

It was given time to breathe and run long, and though some might see the ending as a little too dumb for its own good, it was at least a creative and unique ladder match finish.

Given the potential for a no-crowd ladder match to be incredibly awkward, this was really, really good. 7/10


1. Boneyard Match: AJ Styles Vs. The Undertaker

WrestleMania Undertaker AJ Styles
WWE Network

Result: The Undertaker "wins" after burying AJ alive (19:00).

Rating: There were a lot of justified concerns that this was going to be nothing more than a glorified No DQ match, so it was great to see WWE giving it the Final Deletion treatment instead.

For starters, the editing was able to cleverly conceal Taker's limited mobility these days, while giving him plenty of opportunity to run his mouth and milk his resurrected American Badass gimmick.

More than anything, it was refreshing to see WWE embrace wrestling's inherent goofiness: between the ridiculous dubbed punching sounds, over-the-top music, and that campy ending sequence, it was exactly what a Taker match needed to be at this point in his career.

If this ends up being his final match, it was an unforgettable banger to go out on. 8/10


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.