EVERY Wrestler From The Original ALL IN - Where Are They Now?

AEW is set to hit Wembley Stadium for All In soon - but what became of the original cast?

Rey Mysterio All In
ALL IN

The original All In was probably more of a great time than a great show, in retrospect.

The match quality ceiling was very high, even if the show lacked a true classic and was plagued with timing issues. The range compensated for that; All In I was, as pushed, a joyous celebration of an industry beyond the shadow of the monopoly. A big '80s title fight built articulately with a sporting thrust was followed by a demented plunder brawl driven in storylines by a murder mystery premised on the idea that the culprit felt anatomically inadequate. It was all over the shop in the best possible way...

...at the time.

The "vibes" show was lost much of its feel-good us against the world novelty in recent years, too, which has affected its legacy. More than one heavily featured performer was named in the #SpeakingOut movement of 2020. The first All In no longer feels like a celebration, and good. Some of those involved don't deserve your nostalgia.

Tony Khan has adopted the spirit - of pure, defiant ambition - to book the sequel, under the All Elite Wrestling banner, at Wembley Stadium. The exact same thing has happened again: even before the very first match, All In 2 was a resounding, unprecedented success.

But how many stars from the first show are still 'All Elite'...?

43. The Briscoes

The Briscoes
ROH

Tragically, Jay Briscoe passed away in a car crash on January 17, 2023. He was 38 years old. In what was the most scant consolation, the wrestling fandom collectively realised in those brutal hours following the tragedy that - through his credibility, a promo game that was at once intimidating and piss-funny, range, consistency and longevity - they had lost a legitimate all-time great.

Mark Briscoe, currently out with a serious knee injury, arrived in AEW after Tony Khan petitioned for him to do so. He enchanted fans with his hilarious fish out of water on national television persona - who was actually the smartest guy in the room, and the heels were in fact too stupid to get it.


42. SCU

SCU Frankie Kazarian Scorpio Sky
AEW

Their AEW run did not end as anticipated.

Nobody expected them to be serious players in the World Tag Team division for years and years, but they were worthy inaugural champions who just got over the line through fan sentiment in a feel-good storyline that worked with the Inner Circle getting heat at the top of the card. Expected to settle into a lifer babyface role, since they opened the first two AEW PPVs as cult hero babyfaces, the Best Friends took on that mantle. After the weird total burial of his Elite Hunter persona, Frankie Kazarian formally departed for Impact in December '22. Scorpio Sky meanwhile has been pushed time and time again to a level that fans don't buy into.


41. Austin Gunn

Colten Gunn Austin Gunn
AEW

The first of several participants in the 'Over Budget Battle Royal', Austin Gunn has underwent some character arc:

2018: Oh, Billy Gunn has a kid who wrestles. Also what's Billy Gunn doing here?

2020: Genuinely made closed-set Daily's Place a shockingly less bleak place than it had any right to be with his amazing enthusiasm as a planted fan.

2022-23: Evolved into a cracking stooge of a heel able to provide the obnoxiousness - and catharsis - of a wild bumping southern tag practitioner.


40. Billy Gunn

Billy Gunn Anthony Bowens
AEW

In what might be the most shocking story of a transformative change in the wrestling landscape, Billy 'Daddy Ass' Gunn became one of the most over talents in All Elite Wrestling. This is a "played out" post format, but imagine telling people that back in 2018.

He's recently teased retirement, but that feels like a way to add some emotion and heft to a trios run with the Acclaimed that hasn’t picked up the match quality gauntlet thrown down by the Elite, Death Triangle and the House of Black. Still, match quality isn't everything: the Acclaimed's progressive update on the quintessential Attitude Era act is a massive hit with the adoring AEW faithful.


39. Brandon Cutler

Young Bucks Brandon Cutler
AEW

Some people despise Brandon Cutler, who has been cast following Brawl Out as incontrovertible proof that the Elite are "dorks" who should make way for CM Punk and his brand of serious, grown-up wrestling.

But...that's the point. The man plays his character very well, and his character is a massive stooge moron who gets beaten up in violent, ghoulishly cathartic ways or is stupid enough to freeze spray his own eyes. It was a lot more fun in 2021 when he was a heel, granted. In 2023, not so much.


38. Brian Cage

Brian Cage AEW
AEW

After implying that he wasn't too happy throughout his "first" AEW run, in various media interviews and when smashing that 'Like' button on Twitter, following a long hiatus, Brian Cage appears to have embraced his natural role. He is not a headliner, but as far as midcard acts who lose go, there are few better at putting on eight fun minutes that get the crowd going. In 2023, he wrestles far more frequently, is always a dumb fun joy, and may have actually found his ticket to an elusive prominent role through his awesome tag team with Big Bill.


37. Bully Ray

Bubba Ray Dudley Bully Ray Steve Austin Broken Skull Sessions
WWE

Bizarrely, the man most capable of drawing heat in 2023 isn't a draw, and as such hasn't received an offer to sign with AEW or WWE. Instead, he is an idle fantasist on Busted Open Radio whose actual work for Impact Wrestling draws significantly less attention than his braindead takes on a modern scene he himself has no actual influence over.

Is essentially a meme for his love of but inability to draw heat.

"Here's me taunting the fans. They're just out of frame, baying for my blood."

Nathan Fielder
X (@NathanFielder)

36. Cheeseburger

Cheeseburger 1024x683
YouTube

The wonderfully named Cheeseburger continues to be Cheeseburger, working towns as a perennial endearing journeyman loser.

He's not so beloved and sympathetic that anybody gets any more over by defeating him, so the role he plays sporadically in the rebooted ROH isn't pivotal or anything, but he's always good value to get crowds booing and hissing at the heels who kill him . Even if it's in a performative boo/hiss way, he can turn up the volume.


35. Chuck Taylor

Chuck Taylor
AEW

Chuck Taylor is still in the Best Friends, a valuable and popular act beloved by Tony Khan and the super-committed AEW ultras alike. He doesn't wrestle very often, but is always far better, even in a a state of clear physical decline, than you remember him being. Whether he's working with a detailed continuity against Wheeler YUTA or crafting an elegant spot-fest, Taylor is a solid hand without the boring connotations.

Was also instrumental in laying out the situational masterpiece that was the Parking Lot Brawl.


34. Colt Cabana

AEW Colt Cabana
AEW

Colt Cabana has become one of the most notorious wrestlers on the planet without actually doing anything - which might be the point.

Did CM Punk actually tell Tony Khan to get rid of him? Did Khan presume that Punk wanted him gone, gently relegate him to Ring Of Honor, and then hope the locker room furore would die down? Were the AEW roster members who insisted the former was the case right to use Occam's razor without knowing for certain what happened? Or did they know for sure, as some insist?

And why didn't Tony Khan prevent Brawl Out - he must have known something like this was imminent - by booking Colt to do a simple Elevation job with Punk in the building?

...was he allowed?

Whatever happened, Colt - who will always be inextricably linked to all of this as the first reference point of his career - changed the trajectory of AEW forever.

Colt after all this is actually back to producing on Dynamite!


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!