Every WWE Era Since WrestleMania I - Ranked From Worst To Best

WWE have gone through many a facelift since 1985, but how do they compare?

wwf attitude era
WWE.com

No individual wrestling show has had as profound an impact on the industry's fortunes as WrestleMania I.

Taking place on March 31, 1985, Mania was Vince McMahon Jr.'s first major step towards marrying the worlds of professional wrestling and mainstream celebrity culture. He did it not only by booking some of the biggest wrestlers in the world, but utilising guest stars like Mr. T and Muhammad Ali. After pouring a huge chunk of his personal fortune into the event, McMahon's gamble paid off.

The sport's popularity soared, and WWE were at the forefront of the industry -and popular culture itself. Since then, wrestling has gone through a number of different phases, and WWE have experienced a number of peaks and valleys. Business took a big hit following the Mania-induced Golden Age, recovered through the Attitude Era, then took another decline when McMahon's WCW buyout eliminated competition in America.

WWE have assumed many different identities since 1985, and the product is barely recognisable 32 years later. This time period can be easily split into seven individual eras, with each bringing their own sets of positives and negatives to the table.

Disclaimer: This article focuses primarily the product's all-round quality - but does not altogether neglect business...

7. The New Generation Era (1993-1997)

doink clown raw
WWE.com

As with any other industry, wrestling’s boom periods are typically followed by a considerable bust. Fresh off wrestling’s Golden Age, the New Generation Era is usually held up as the worst period of WWE’s existence, and for good reason.

The first signs of trouble came in 1991, when it was reported that a host of major WWF stars were set to testify that they’d been given steroids by WWE physician George Zahorian. Vince McMahon was indicted as part of these charges two years later, and suddenly found himself staring down the barrel of an eight-year prison sentence.

He was acquitted in July 1994, but the scandal rocked his company’s reputation. Business was sliding. Hulk Hogan left in 1993, and the company never truly replaced him. Bret Hart ascended to the company’s top babyface spot, and the likes of Shawn Michaels and the Undertaker rose around him, but none could match Hogan as a draw, and competition was heating up.

Hogan jumped ship to WCW, and with WWE’s product growing increasingly cartoonish and outdated, fans started switching the channel. For every HBK or Hitman, there was an Isaac Yankem or Friar Ferguson, and ratings took a huge hit when Scott Hall and Kevin Nash left for WCW in 1996.

The New Generation was Vince McMahon Jr.’s lowest ebb as WWE Chairman, and kicked off 84 straight weeks of Nitro crushing Raw in the ratings battle.


6. The PG Era (2008-2011)

john cena punk
WWE.com

The PG Era could technically stretch all the way from 2008 to the present day, given WWE’s enduring television rating. The past five-six years have been defined by other titles, however, and the first few years of PG should be treated as a separate entity.

WWE made the decision to switch their programming to a family-friendly PG rating in July 2008. It prompted a major shift away from the edgier programming of old, with WWE toning back on the explicit violence, sexuality, and all-round crudeness of their product, prompted in part by Linda McMahon’s senate run.

Going PG wasn’t an entirely bad decision; it allowed the company to finally move away from outdated Attitude Era tropes. That being said, the company’s product has been watered down considerably since 2008. Storytelling has become more simplistic than ever before, ratings slid after an initial improvement in 2008, and for a few years, WWE hit the skids.

This was the era of weekly guest hosts, John Cena crushing everyone he stepped inside the ring with, and the brand split’s dying days. It produced highlights like the Shawn Michaels vs. Undertaker WrestleMania match series and the fantastic Cena vs. Edge feud, as well as disasters like the Anonymous Raw General Manager and Michael Cole’s heel turn.

Though never as cringeworthy as the New Generation Era, PG’s first three years didn’t consistently deliver.


5. The Reality Era (2011-2016)

CM Punk's Pipe Bomb
WWE

2011-2016 represented a clear shift in the way fans viewed professional wrestling and what they expected from it.

Gone was patience for the corny, cartoonish tropes of old, supplanted by a desire for more realistic programming. The Reality Era effectively kicked off with CM Punk’s era-defining pipe bomb in 2011, and if it were handled a little differently, it may have gone down as WWE’s greatest period overall.

The Summer of Punk started with a bang, but WWE made a huge mistake in bringing Punk back to television so quickly after “walking out” with the WWE Championship. The movement’s momentum was dealt further damage when Triple H got involved, and like most good things to happen within WWE in the past ten years, it died with a whimper.

The Reality Era saw stars like Zack Ryder and Daniel Bryan get over organically and win the crowd’s support in spite of an apparent lack of push. It brought the Yes! Movement, Bryan’s big night at WrestleMania XXX, and Brock Lesnar’s game-changing return. Conversely, the era also brought with it the wholesale burial of these wrestlers (Lesnar aside) in favour of overexposed guys like Triple H and Cena, and routinely disappointed fans as often as it entertained them.

Furthermore, the Reality Era saw the advent of the WWE Network, which forever changed the way wrestling fans consume the product. It’s one of the biggest advances WWE have ever brought to the industry, and while this period was far from perfect, it was a clear step forward from the previous three-four years - and provided a foundation for today’s product.


4. The New Era (2016-present)

AJ Styles, Roman Reigns
WWE.com

From an in-ring perspective, The New Era is comfortably WWE’s greatest ever period, and it’s not even close. WWE’s roster is stacked at the moment, and while the promotion’s multi-talented rosters are often let down by poor booking, all-round match quality has never been so high. In the likes of AJ Styles, John Cena, Brock Lesnar, and Shinsuke Nakamura, WWE have some of the best wrestlers in the world at their disposal, and barely a pay-per-view or TakeOver live special passes without at least one Match Of The Year candidate.

Kicking-off after WrestleMania 32, what holds the New Era back is that it’s still less than a year old. The matches are great, SmackDown’s current incarnation is one of the best weekly shows in WWE history, and NXT is still soaring, but without the benefit of hindsight and context, it’s impossible to tell how the New Era will stack up historically.

Nonetheless, fans have rarely had it so good. WWE’s product has never been so diverse, and even if Raw and SmackDown aren’t to your taste, there’s still NXT and special events like the Cruiserweight Classic and UK Title Tournament to enjoy. Certain complaints (Roman Reigns’ push, for one) remain constant, but for the most part, modern day WWE is in great shape.

Business is in an interesting position at the moment. WWE announced record revenues last year, but TV ratings are lower than ever, with Raw hitting an all-time low last September. Changing viewer habits mean that such figures aren’t as pertinent as they used to be, but they still make it hard to deem the New Era an outright success.

We’re still in the period’s infancy, however, and WWE have plenty of time to shake these concerns off.


3. The Golden Age (1985-1993)

Hogan Warrior Wrestlemania
WWE.com

Wrestling’s “Golden Age” would sit atop many a wrestling fans’ list of eras, and for good reason. This is when wrestling truly transcended its status as a niche form of entertainment and soared towards mainstream acceptance. Much of this was down to Vince McMahon’s ambition and WrestleMania I’s stunning success. With the industry surging, WWE became an unstoppable juggernaut.

Much of this was down to Hulk Hogan, of course. Hulkamania was instrumental in taking the sport to a new audience, and he absolutely dominated WWF programming. Hogan was at the heart of absolutely everything the company did, and he was the perfect superhero babyface for the time period. Moreover, he was wrestling’s first true mainstream crossover star, and without him, WWE probably wouldn’t even be around today.

While often the Golden Age’s biggest asset, Hogan was also the biggest hindrance. The company’s over-reliance on him forced the likes of Randy Savage and Ultimate Warrior out of the spotlight, and while both had tremendous careers in their own right, they’d have fared even better, had Hogan been a little more giving.

From a wrestling standpoint, this period just doesn’t stack up either. Hulkamania was all about spectacle and showmanship, and while the era produced its fair share of memorable matches, the standard of wrestling was far lower. Most of the era’s work just doesn’t stand up to today’s highly athletic standards.

As a result, it’s impossible to place the Golden Age higher.


2. The Attitude Era (1997-2002)

Austin McMahon
WWE.com

The Attitude Era is often held up as the golden age of WWE programming - particularly by the company themselves. From a business standpoint, it’s incredibly hard to argue with this assessment. WWE have never been as popular as they were in the Attitude Era, and with TV ratings sitting at an average of 6.00 from 1999 to 2000, Raw was absolutely flying.

Attitude is responsible for some of wrestling’s most memorable moments. Effectively kicking off with the Montreal Screwjob and Steve Austin’s rise to prominence, Attitude give us the incredible Austin vs. McMahon feud, Mick Foley’s Hell In A Cell fall, and Mike Tyson. It produced the biggest crossover star in wrestling history (The Rock), WrestleMania X-Seven, the consensus best wrestling PPV ever, and countless great memories.

That said, the Era had plenty of problems, too. The tone was often crude and puerile, wrestling quality was way down, and the company’s women were regularly objectified and pushed on looks above all else. Attitude also escalated onscreen violence to a level that WWE could never hope to top, and as a result, everything that’s taken place since then feels tame by comparison.

But it’s impossible to argue with Attitude’s success. Roster depth was through the roof across the board, and the company’s main event scene has rarely been stacked with as many top-level stars. Even the tag division was flying with teams like Edge & Christian, the Dudley Boyz, and the Hardyz.

Unfortunately, Attitude met a disappointing end through Stone Cold’s botched heel turn and the Invasion angle - but it was the most exciting thing on the planet for a long, long time.


1. Ruthless Aggression (2002-2008)

Edge Rey Mysterio Kurt Angle
www.wwe.com

While the Attitude Era is often wistfully romanticised by a huge portion of WWE’s fanbase, Ruthless Aggression is held to the same esteem by an admittedly smaller section. Some find Attitude hard to overlook, but Ruthless Aggression was the pinnacle of professional wrestling in everything but TV ratings, which remained consistently mediocre throughout.

Nonetheless, from a pure wrestling standpoint, 2002 is one of the best years WWE have ever had. Much of this came from SmackDown, and while Raw bathed in the tiresome sports entertainment tropes of old, the blue brand became an exciting, wrestling-centric island away from the nonsense. The “SmackDown Six” (Kurt Angle, Edge, Chris Benoit, Rey Mysterio, and Eddie & Chavo Guerrero) became centerpieces, and the brand absolute thrived with Paul Heyman as the lead writer.

Ruthless Aggression delivered greatness like Eddie and Benoit’s highly emotional title wins, and the conclusion to The Rock and Austin’s WrestleMania trilogy. It brought the fantastic Shawn Michaels/Triple H feud, the ECW One Night Stand PPVs, and made stars of wrestlers who once looked like they’d be forever consigned to the midcard.

Things weren’t perfect, of course. The product’s overrall quality took a dip from 2006-7, and Triple H was featured far too prominently for many fans’ liking. But hese are minor complaints when compared to the era’s stunning high points.

For the undeniable improvements Ruthless Aggression brought to WWE’s product inside the ring and out, it stands proudly as the company’s strongest era since WrestleMania I.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.