Every WWE Wrestler Triple H Has Re-Signed - Ranked From Worst To Best

To call these returned superstars 'a mixed bag' would be an understatement.

Triple H Chelsea Green Bray Wyatt
WWE

Being a WWE superstar is the dream of many wrestlers in this business. Regardless of what critics might think of their brand of “sports entertainment,” the Stamford-based company is still the pinnacle of the industry and a major goal for competitors just getting started and grizzled veterans alike.

However, 2020 through mid-2022 was a tumultuous time to be a WWE superstar, and not just due to the pandemic. During that two-plus-year period, more than 120 wrestlers were released, giving their walking papers amidst uncertain times. Many of them found employment elsewhere, such as AEW or Impact, while others took to the independent scene to carve their own path.

Starting in August 2022, however, WWE reversed that trend under Triple H. The newly minted head of creative began undoing a lot of his father-in-law’s firings, bringing back nearly 20 superstars who were axed in recent years.

Triple H’s rehires were lauded in certain corners of social media as evidence of a resurgent WWE. A popular meme circulated of Hunter as Thanos, wearing an Infinity gauntlet adorned with the heads of returning superstars in place of Infinity stones.

But as we sit here a year later, how do we rate these rehires? Some have fared well, but sadly, most have been far from magic stones powering WWE to greatness and are more cannon fodder troops to fill out the roster. This doesn’t mean rehiring them was a bad idea – just that they aren’t being utilized well.

Let’s get to it…

15. Hit Row

Hit Row WWE 2022
WWE.com

Unfortunately, Triple H’s first rehires that appeared on TV are also arguably in the worst spot.

The quartet Hit Row was unceremoniously released in November 2021, just weeks after debuting on the main roster. It was a body blow to the group, taken out before they even had a chance to fail or succeed on their own. Swerve Strickland would make his way to AEW the following spring, leaving B-Fab, Ashante Thee Adonis and Top Dolla to carry on as a trio.

In August 2022, the group made their unannounced return on SmackDown, picking up a quick win. They would renew hostilities with NXT rivals Legado Del Fantasma and even get a tag title shot in December, but they’ve had only a handful of televised bouts this year, losing all but one of them, both in tag and singles action.

At one point, Top Dolla had an unfortunate botch in trying to dive to the floor, resulting in Michael Cole constantly burying him as Flop Dolla and saying he’s the favourite to win a battle royal because he can’t go over the top rope.

The group went from Triple H’s first return salvo to jobbing jokes, getting beat up by LA Knight in dark segments. It’s always possible they string together a couple of victories, but they seem like the definition of enhancement talent.


14. Emma

Ronda Rousey Emma Tenille Dashwood
WWE.com

Unlike every other name on this list, Emma was not a pandemic-era release. Still, she was someone Triple H brought back upon taking control, and thus, she qualifies.

Emma actually was released in October 2017 and returned nearly five years to the day, unsuccessfully challenging Ronda Rousey for the SmackDown Women’s Championship. Since then, Emma has lost. A lot. She’s lost singles matches, tag matches, mixed tags, the Royal Rumble and tag team turmoil.

It hurts to refer to her as enhancement talent, but she seems to be the walking definition of it, with only one win (a Main Event victory over Roxanne Perez), no major storylines (her angle with real-life partner Madcap Moss vanished from television), and seemingly no clear direction going forward.

Until Emma actually strings together a few wins or has a consistent presence on TV, it’s hard to think otherwise of her.


13. Tegan Nox

Tegan Nox
WWE

Tegan Nox has never really gotten a chance to get out of the starting blocks with WWE. Her injury history during the Mae Young Classic and in NXT was well-documented and stunted her growth in the company.

Still, Nox got a chance on the main roster for a brief period, tagging with Shotzi during the summer of 2021. She would get drafted to Raw that fall, breaking up the team, and then was released without ever appearing on the red brand in November.

Flash forward to December 2022 and Nox made her return, saving Liv Morgan from Damage CTRL. The pairing would last less than a month before Tegan was competing as a singles wrestler, losing to Shayna Baszler in less than 2 minutes in March. Drafted to Raw, she teamed with Dana Brooke in the definition of a makeshift tag team in a tag turmoil match in early July, losing in seconds.

Nox rates only slightly higher than Hit Row and Emma because of her shorter tenure and because she’s simply been barely used. Just 28, if Nox is actually given an opportunity, she could still make an impact.


12. Candice LeRae

Candice LeRae
WWE.com

Noticing a pattern here?

Candice LeRae left WWE on her own terms, allowing her NXT contract to expire in May 2022 while out on maternity leave. She would return to the company that September, just seven months after giving birth. LeRae’s return was another that was hailed as one of great potential, viewed as Triple H adding depth and strength to the women’s division.

The Poison Pixie picked up wins over Nikki ASH, Dakota Kai and even Bayley during her first couple of months, but she also lost to Iyo Sky, Rhea Ripley and Carmella. It would probably be best to describe her return run as “uneven.”

Probably the biggest crime here (and it’s one that has plagued a few of these returns) is that there was little in the way of building up these superstars and (re)introducing them to fans. LeRae never competed on the main roster, so non-NXT fans might not have any idea who she was, and that was born out of the silence that has accompanied several of her matches.

More recently, LeRae has been in limbo as it’s unclear whether WWE will resume The Way, her NXT faction with husband Johnny Gargano, Indi Hartwell and Dexter Lumis (they’ve all been seen together after the draft), or if there will be a DIY reunion with Gargano and Tomasso Ciampa.


11. Dexter Lumis

The Miz Dexter Lumis
WWE.com

Given how he came back into the company, Dexter Lumis seemed poised to be the most unlikely of breakout stars when he returned in August 2022.

Released from NXT just four months earlier, Lumis had been married in storyline to Indi Hartwell, making his departure confusing (as were several releases during this time). When he returned, however, Lumis showed up on the main roster, causing havoc by kidnapping and stalking the Miz for months.

It was a bizarre storyline, with Johnny Gargano having to provide the exposition for the mute Dexter. The wrinkle finally was revealed: Miz had paid Lumis to stage these attacks, but then stiffed the Silent Man, escalating the feud. Lumis would win a WWE contract, but ultimately lose the feud due to a debuting Bronson Reed.

Since then, Lumis has been used almost as much as a second to Indi Hartwell in NXT (twice) than he has on Raw (three matches in 2023). Lumis’ creepiness means he can always be used as comic relief, and if The Way ever gets restarted, Dexter would likely be a part of that.

But after a high-profile return, it’s been a whole lot of nothing for the past seven months.


10. Valhalla (Sarah Logan)

The Viking Raider Valhalla
WWE.com

Superstars who are primarily valets are tough to rate on their own.

Sarah Logan wasn’t exactly tearing things up in WWE at the time of her April 2020 release. She had been part of the now romantically idealized Riott Squad until it disbanded in April 2019. During that following year, she had just five televised matches – all losses.

Logan would step away from wrestling to start a family with husband Erik of the Viking Raiders, giving birth to a son in February 2021. She would make a cameo in the 2022 women’s Royal Rumble match before returning fully to WWE in November as Valhalla, the Raiders’ mystic manager who allegedly speaks to the gods (no, really).

Despite being a trained wrestler, she’s competed in only two matches – a mixed six-person tag against Alpha Academy, as part of the ongoing Raiders/Alphas rivalry, and a singles bout against Maxxine Dupri.

Valhalla has gotten her share of TV time, and she hasn’t been exposed as a loser, so she’s actually positioned better than some of her fellow rehires should she return to the ring. If not, there are worse things than seconding your spouse to the ring.


9. Johnny Gargano

Johnny Gargano JBL
WWE.com

Make no mistake about this placement: Johnny Gargano’s return to WWE has been anything but a success when you consider his talent.

Horribly misused, booked like a geek, jobbed out to Omos, Miz, and Dominik Mysterio, and forced to do bad “comedy” in the Miz/Dexter Lumis feud, there aren’t many good things to say about the guy previously known as the Heart and Soul of NXT.

Johnny Wrestling should have been a can’t-miss babyface returning to WWE in August 2022, eight months after letting his NXT contract expire. A simple video package about his accomplishments and a few dazzling victories would have done the trick, perhaps even elevating him to a United States Championship match against former protégé Austin Theory.

And despite a few wins his first month back, Gargano then racked off four losses the next two months, disappeared from the ring for two months, and then embarrassingly came out to silence at the Royal Rumble. It seemed like he was getting back on track to start 2023, but Johnny was sidelined again and has been off TV for the past couple of months, leaving his stock in question.

Like others, Gargano could right the ship with some solid booking – he’s clearly talented – but if one of Triple H’s favorites couldn’t succeed when Hunter had full control, does anyone want to bet the farm on Johnny Wrestling with Vince back in the fold?


8. Mia Yim (Michin)

The OC AJ Styles Luke Gallows Karl Anderson Mia Yim
WWE.com

What a roller coaster of a ride it’s been for Mia Yim. She toils away in NXT for two years before getting called up to the main roster… as part of RETRIBUTION.

Forced to wear a ridiculous mask (that fell off in her first match), the now-christened Reckoning had two matches as part of that godforsaken stable before it disbanded. Yim got her name back, but never really appeared for WWE before being released in November 2021, alongside her partner (now husband) Keith Lee.

Of the wrestlers Triple H has re-signed, Yim seemed to be one of the best-poised to succeed, as she came back and was immediately inserted into an existing feud, aligning with the OC against the Judgment Day. Billed as the OC’s solution to its “Rhea (Ripley) problem,” Mia evened out the sides when she came back in November 2022. Unfortunately, she was on the losing end of that feud.

From there, Yim (who now is almost exclusively referred to as Michin) tried to help out Becky Lynch in her feud against Damage CTRL, tagged unsuccessfully with Candice LeRae, got mauled by Piper Niven, and lost to Karrion Kross and Scarlett alongside AJ Styles. Her last televised win came in mid-January.

Still, Michin is part of a stable with Styles and the Good Brothers, which at least better positions her than many of the women brought back in the past year.


7. Karrion Kross & Scarlett

Karrion Kross Scarlett
WWE.com

If we were grading these entries on how they’re being booked now compared to when they were previously with the company, Karrion Kross might be near the top of the list.

Fans still use the way the reigning NXT Champion had his entrance watered down and was jobbed out upon making his main roster debut as proof that Vince McMahon had completely lost his touch. He spent less than four months on the main roster getting chopped down before he was released in November 2021, along with his now-wife Scarlett.

Kross and Scarlett were among the first rehires to appear under Triple H, attacking Drew McIntyre in an unannounced return. That seemed like a great first step, but their matches were not well-received critically, and Kross would move on to a feud with Madcap Moss. He had a small feud with Rey Mysterio earlier this year, but Rey moved on to bigger and better things with his son Dominik and the LWO, while Karrion just kind of drifted.

The past two months have seen Kross and Scarlett feud with the OC, though AJ Styles has beaten him three times. Kross is a Triple H favorite, so it’s always possible that he gets a decent midcard push, but for now, it’s best to rate him in the middle.


6. Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson

AJ Styles Good Brothers Luke Gallows Karl Anderson
WWE

Our other duo entry on this list would be none other than the Good Brothers, who manage regularly to find employment despite boasting about putting in minimal effort at times.

Regardless, Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson made quite the splash when they initially debuted as a formidable tag team on the Raw after WrestleMania 32 in 2016. Thoughts of them becoming a dominant force quickly faded as they were relegated to bad comedy segments. They would team up with former Bullet Club leaders AJ Styles and Finn Balor, helping Styles in his unsuccessful effort against Undertaker in the acclaimed Boneyard Match at Mania 36.

A couple of weeks later, the Good Brothers were among the first pandemic releases.

The duo would make their return to WWE in October 2022 in a familiar role – at Styles’ side, re-forming the OC. They would add Mia Yim during their battles with the Judgment Day. Since then, the Good Brothers have hung around in the tag division, beating lesser teams but not sniffing a tag title match either.

The only reason they rank this high is that they haven’t been jobbed out to Hit Row, they’re still at AJ’s side, and they could be reheated at a moment’s notice for a notable program if the situation dictated it. It’s not a terrible role for them at this stage.


5. Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

How do you rank a guy who was responsible for one of the most creative, viral sensations of the year in staging his triumphant return, only for everything to unravel when he got back in the ring?

Bray Wyatt has always been lauded for his imaginative, vivid presentation, including visuals and promos, but it’s never really translated once the bell rings. His release in the summer of 2021 after a perplexing loss at WrestleMania 37 to Randy Orton led to fans campaigning for his return. They’d get their wish a year later.

The “White Rabbit” teasers throughout the fall of 2022 were insanely popular, with fans playing super-sleuth to follow the clues and decipher hidden messages buried in QR codes scattered across Raw and SmackDown. He would finally return at Extreme Rules in October and proceed to cut promos expressing his gratitude, only to be interrupted by a masked figure known as “Uncle Howdy.” (We could probably count Bo Dallas as a co-entry here.)

The less said about the Mtn. Dew Pitch Black match, the better, but suffice it to say, that wasn’t exactly a high point for Wyatt. To date, that’s been his only televised match. A planned – and initiated – feud with Bobby Lashley for WrestleMania 39 was abandoned due to Bray dealing with an undisclosed injury or illness, and he hasn’t been seen since.

Wyatt gets high marks for the sheer success of his return itself and the potential it brought, but it’s tempered by the actual tangibles of his presence on WWE programming after returning.


4. Braun Strowman

Braun Strowman Ricochet
WWE

Braun Strowman’s WWE career has been a lot of “what ifs” and wasted potential (on WWE’s part), along with a fair amount of schadenfreude.

Strowman has garnered the ire of fans online with some of his tirades, including when he mocked independent wrestlers during the height of the pandemic while they were unemployed and struggling. A year later, Braun found himself released from the financial security of WWE and bouncing around independent shows.

He re-signed with WWE in September 2022 and entered a feud with Omos, which he won. But he again pissed off fans with a derisive tweet about high-flyers, calling them “floppy floppers.” A couple weeks later, high-flyer Ricochet defeated Strowman in what had to be a receipt.

Shortly after though, Braun and Ricochet formed a tag team that caught fire and became one of the more entertaining parts of SmackDown. Drafted to Raw this spring, it looked like they were going to be a huge part of Monday nights before Strowman went down with a serious neck injury, requiring surgery.

Just given his past success and track record, it’s safe to say that if he can avoid some of the abysmal booking he faced in 2020-21, Braun will resume his upward trend and be a solid addition to the roster when he returns from injury. But being out of action knocks him down a few pegs.


3. Dakota Kai

WWE SummerSlam 2022 Bayley Io Shirai Dakota Kai
WWE.com

Poor Dakota Kai has had a rough go of it in WWE.

Highly regarded, Kai did not fare well during the NXT 2.0 era, as she was given the gimmick of a “crazy” woman. Amazingly, this didn’t help her connect with fans and she was released in April 2022.

Just three months later, Dakota reappeared on the WWE scene, this time at SummerSlam alongside Bayley and Iyo Sky to form Damage CTRL. The stable had the potential to be a dominant force in the women’s division, and while they got ample TV time, they lost a lot.

Kai and Sky would capture the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship twice and hold the titles for five months, but those reigns would consist of just two successful televised title defenses.

In May, Dakota suffered an ACL injury that has had her sidelined ever since. She returned to TV alongside Bayley and Iyo at SummerSlam and has been around in a managerial role. As one of only two Triple H re-signings to capture gold and a member of a stable that gets tons of TV time, she has to rank high on this list.


2. Bronson Reed

Bronson Reed Chad Gable
WWE.com

By now, it’s clear that most of Triple H’s rehires haven’t really enjoyed sustained success. But some are better positioned to achieve success than others, and Bronson Reed is one of them.

On paper, Reed should be considered a beast – he’s won twice as many televised matches as he’s lost. However, after a series of squashes, Bronson began a three-way feud with Shinsuke Nakamura and Ricochet, then Nak and Tommaso Ciampa. Those matches tended to end in DQs or under dubious circumstances, with each of them interfering in each other’s matches.

Despite being given the nickname “Big” (yes, that’s a thing in 2023) and his Tsunami finisher being treated like a true killshot, Reed lost the feud with Shinsuke before the King of Strong Style moved on to a World Heavyweight Championship feud with Seth Rollins.

Still, there’s every reason to believe Bronson will continue to be a menace in the mid-card for the foreseeable future, so we’ll rate him pretty highly.


1. Chelsea Green

Chelsea Green Sonya Deville
WWE.com

Raise your hand if you thought Chelsea Green was going to be a breakout star for WWE in 2023 after the way she returned at the Royal Rumble this January.

Sit down, you’re lying.

Green returned as little more than a comedy act, playing a “Karen” as WWE tapped into the zeitgeist of 2018. Chelsea has continuously appeared in backstage scenes with Adam Pearce, making demands of him and threatening to call his manager. It took a while to find her footing, but Green has turned the character into a winner through sheer force of will.

All this came after a tumultuous run with WWE that saw plans and pushes sidetracked before she was released in April 2021 before her January 2023 surprise return.

And now, Chelsea managed to finally capture her first WWE gold, the Women’s Tag Team Championship alongside fellow 2015 Tough Enough competitor Sonya Deville in July. Deville’s ACL injury threatened to derail that momentum, but Green proposed holding auditions for a new partner, leading to Piper Niven claiming the other tag title.

Just given their initial interactions, Niven and Green could very quickly become an entertaining staple on WWE programming. And we’ll give Chelsea the top spot on our list based on how quickly she’s become a focal point – even if it’s as comic relief – on Raw and SmackDown. And she’s a champion to boot. What more could you ask?


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.