Exactly How Good Was Taz?

From Human Suplex Machine to Human Meme Machine, the Red Hook native's done it all in wrestling.

Taz AEW
AEW

All Elite Wrestling have established an audience that have remained incredibly plugged into the product since its 2019 launch.

It's a dream situation for an organisation that realistically shouldn't have existed had WWE not blown their near-two decade monopoly. A stabilised total viewership finds Dynamite most Wednesdays, enough of that makes an appointment with Collision and Rampage, and similar numbers can be found across the likes of Twitter, YouTube and Reddit engaging with the action in their own time.

This is even true of commercial breaks, thanks to the company's coverage on Triller (formerly Fite), where literally every second of Dynamite is available to view should the TBS commercials feel as though they're an imposition on the match in question.

Especially if Taz is in the mood to be his best self.

An unexpected and undisputed highlight of the shows on commentary (as he was as the top boss of Team Taz between 2020-2022), the 'Human Suplex Machine' regularly has his best moments ripped and shared online, forcing repeat viewings and inadvertently generating interest in whatever he's particularly enjoying. It's earnest, uninhibited, and typically p*ss funny. This has extended to his excellent and fearless social media game as well as the joyous deification of his son Hook from that same deeply entrenched audience.

"[CM] Punk Fears Hook" was a meme so successful that AEW cameras used to zoom in on signs that fronted it in the building. Not to say Taz is a meme. He'd rip your head off for inferring it and break your arms and legs for thinking it. But he fits into 2024 wrestling in much the same way, because he's yet again found a way to remain relevant.

That's been an unexpected and unlikely pattern in his remarkable career...

CONT'D...


Ricky Starks FTW Champion AEW Fyter Fest Team Taz
AEW.com

Taz was destined to do all of this.

He may not have appeared the most obvious choice to call WrestleManias as he drowned in WWE's political waters, nor put forth the persona of the funniest f*cker in the industry when he was a subhuman maniac with no boots and a painted face, but young Peter Senerchia was leaving ads in wrestling magazines looking for more people to shoot the sh*t about it with.

In that respect, his story isn't different from yours, mine or anybody that's taken a passing interest in pro wrestling at some point in their lives. Why, then, has Taz' journey within the industry been one of the stranger ones?

AEW-era him is, fittingly, Elite Tier Taz. An awesome broadcaster that can scare folk witless with threats (even if they're going to be carried out by other people) who also knows his way around some hilarious patter with his colleagues as long as they stay on his good side.

But at various times across multiple companies, there were questions asked if bookers and bosses were really getting the best of the 'Human Suplex Machine'. At times, he was a man with evidently so much to offer that powerful people seemingly didn't know how to get the best out of him.

Paul Heyman was the first...

CONT'D...


Taz Sabu
WWE.com

The first time Taz picked a headset over a head drop was in ECW. Nursing a broken neck after a 1995 match against Dean Malenko and Too Cold Scorpio, the company's monster-in-waiting used a brief stint in the booth as a way to broaden his horizons in a business known for rewarding the multi-skilled.

Exhibiting the perfect blend of quiet menace and shrewd analysis, the move was vital in ensuring he'd never again go full caveman as The Tasmaniac. He'd only worked five matches in his updated shooter role before the knock, but the move to boots and trunks was made permanent by the virtue of him absolutely not f*cking around when he returned.

Taz' November To Remember 1995 heel turn was the stuff of legend when it occurred. The Red Hook native was a b*stard, but he typically unleashed his bad mood on the bad guys. No longer - the 'Human Suplex Machine' was in the pocket of loathed heel referee Bill Alfonzo, and on a collision course with one of the company's poster boys.

To paraphrase a b*stardised chant, this was awesome.

CONT'D...


Paul Varelans Taz ECW
WWE

Taz Vs Sabu was almost two years in the making, and brilliant in its blinding simplicity.

Taz had linked up with Alfonzo in an act of fury towards ECW management, fans and especially Sabu. Former partners, the 'Human Suplex Machine' was left high and dry by the 'Suicidal, Homicidal, Genocidal Maniac' earlier that year when he took a NJPW date over working a planned triangle tag team match. Paul Heyman fired and buried him on the show he missed, but brought him back as a returning hero later that year.

Understandably, Taz felt spurned by all of this, but making literal his "path of rage" ultimately provided Extreme Championship Wrestling with a headline attraction worthy of the pay-per-view they were chasing.

Between November 1995 and March 1997's Barely Legal, Taz battered his opponents and called out Sabu without reply. At the same time, ECW ran a Raven/Tommy Dreamer storyline revolving around them wrestling constantly provided equal foundation in the exact opposite fashion. Against the backdrop of WWE's New Generation and a pre-nWo WCW, there was suddenly no hotter promotion than the furnace operating out of Philadelphia.

A story that started with a shocking turn ended in one too - at Barely Legal, Alfonzo hatched a plan with Sabu and Rob Van Dam to double cross Taz. This was another tactical masterstroke from Paul Heyman, having seen how popular he'd become during a year's long chase.

He became a talismanic figure for the remainder of the his run, until a rampaging World Wrestling Federation came calling in 1999.

CONT'D...


Tazz Kurt Angle
WWE.com

Taz(z)' WWE debut has been the subject of much conversation in the last few years, and mostly because of the 'Human Suplex Machine's story of how it did him more harm that good.

What still plays to fans as an electrifying greatest hits package at the expense of poor Kurt Angle's bones was in fact too good. Earning one of the biggest pops of the period, this theoretically should have propelled him into the stratosphere right as the company was reaching a commercial and critical apex. Instead, it doomed him to a life on the losing end of every big match he ever had.

The scale of the reaction scared the sh*t out of some of Tazz' new colleagues, who made no secret of their disinterest in selling much for a guy half a foot shorter than them. Four months after Madison Square Garden exploded for him, Triple H was pinning him on SmackDown and only the fools of the hardcore division were taking his suplexes at WrestleMania.

Smartly realising his fate, Tazz used a feud with Jerry Lawler and Jim Ross to return to a former stomping ground. Tolerating Vince McMahon's inner-ear screaming, he seamlessly flitted between part-time wrestler and commentator roles until mounting injuries moved him next to Michael Cole permanently in 2002.

His second life in wrestling had begun.

CONT'D...


Taz Jim Ross Excalibur
AEW

The less said about his time in TNA, the better, though assessing the good and bad is sort of the point here. Seemingly trapped in a constant struggle to give a sh*t about a product that didn't seem to give a sh*t about itself, he was often better in a heel managerial role alongside Samoa Joe and later Aces & Eights than he was at the desk.

What did stick out was just how much authority his voice now brought to a wrestling show. Any wrestling show, even one with energy and stakes as low as mid-2010s Impact. Yet again mastering the stuff that can't be taught, Taz now boasted gravitas as his chief trait. Well, when he wasn't cheerleading for the Knockouts to shake their a*ses about, anyway.

After departing in 2015 right around the time TNA/Impact almost entirely fell out of the regular wrestling conversation forever, he was gone from mainstream televised wrestling almost entirely until seamlessly fitting into AEW as an announcer and eventually leader of Team Taz starting in late-2019. Now a voice of the product, he's as embedded as any of the originals that helped form the company.

It's been an overachievement of a run, but only in terms of how crowded the marketplace was when he arrived. Not because his resumé didn't speak for itself...

CONT'D...


Taz WWE
WWE.com

But how does a run robbed of some prime in-ring years stack up against some of the greats?

Taz' career is one of the trickier to scrutinise, but a deeper dive reveals a tenure that belongs in every wrestling hall of fame.

In ECW, he was so immensely believable that he drove the desire, need and eventual execution of a major stage pro wrestling pay-per-view. He was ahead of his time in spotting the value of blending the aesthetics and athletics of mixed martial arts into his act. He was malleable at every age, twice realising the value of diversifying into the announce booth for a just-in-case plan that eventually manifested as a second life. And in spite of all of this, the gimmick hasn't ever lost its sheen - Taz of 2024 looks more likely to f*cking kill you than the 'Human Suplex Machine' WWE booked so half-heartedly two decades earlier.

Like all the greats, he was at his best when he assumed a level of control over how he was presented. It's no coincidence that he found success everywhere but the one place where that's simply impossible. Equally, it's little shock that the freedom of expression in AEW has suited him just fine.

It absolutely should be highlighted that this piece has covered a near-30 year run too. In an industry as fickle as pro wrestling, that number trumps any figures focussed on title reigns and win/loss records. For a guy that so often didn't want to let people survive, he's mastered art of managing it himself.

'The Human Suplex Machine' rules, and if you disagree, you can tell him yourself.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.