HORRIBLE Matches WWE Forced On Fans

WWE honestly should've paid fans to sit through these in-ring disasters.

WWE Extreme Rules 2011 Country Whipping Match Jim Ross Michael Cole Jerry Lawler Jack Swagger
WWE

Nobody asked for any of this.

Sure, there might've been a time when some of the matches featured here had value on paper. One in particular would've even scored in the 'Top 10' for fans dreaming of big inter-promotional wars between the then-WWF and WCW back during the 1990s. The key phrase there is..."back during the 1990s".

Time was not kind to the workers involved, and that led to one of the most depressing exhibitions WWE has ever put on. The horror of what happened is diluted by everything else on the list though. Here, you'll reminisce about ratings-hungry "celebrity" matches, failed experiments, brawls everyone knew would suck going in and much, much more.

All of them have something in common: WWE ignored any doubts or grumbling from the audience and stuck them on the card anyway. A few even happened on traditional pay-per-view too, which means people were asked to pay a one-off lump sum to watch them stink up the place.

It's bad enough to waste one's time on free TV, but paying for these disasters?! That's a whole new level of horrible.

10. “Donald Trump” Vs. “Rosie O’Donnell”

Rosie ODonnell Donald Trump WWE Raw
WWE.com

Let's do what WWE didn't and get this out of the way quickly, shall we?

The 8 January 2007 episode of Raw was blighted by some awful attempted comedy that tried to leech off a real-life feud in the media between Donald Trump and Rosie O'Donnell. WWE wheeled out seriously poor impersonators to play both parties, and the live crowd sat on their hands wondering why they'd bought tickets for this.

Rather predictably, "Trump vs. O'Donnell" flopped hard and ended up being a complete waste of valuable TV time on the flagship. Keep in mind this happened mere weeks before the '07 Royal Rumble. Why build towards that when you can book this tripe, eh? Literally no-one in the audience wanted to see it.

John Cena vs. Umaga was on tap for the Rumble, but WWE elected to gift wrap minutes for a terrible "comedy" segment instead. Sadly, this was only a precursor of things to come once the Raw guest host era got started.


9. Shane McMahon Vs. Dolph Ziggler

Shane McMahon World Cup
WWE.com

This is the first of three entries about Crown Jewel here, which really says everything about WWE's first few forays into Saudi Arabia for supershows they pretended were on par with WrestleMania. The 2018 version was particularly egregious, not least because it ended with a one-two punch of miserable rubbish.

More on the other bout later.

For now, revel in the moment as one Shane McMahon is declared "Best In The World". Yep, Shane-O won WWE's World Cup by replacing an injured Miz in the final vs. Dolph Ziggler. Short erm...babyface comeback later and McMahon was riding high with the trophy as Saudi royalty likely wondered where The Ultimate Warrior was.

In fairness, this did feed into a heel gimmick for Shane, but it was painful to watch play out nonetheless. A pro wrestling World Cup has merit, and tournaments do definitely work, but McMahon's last minute substitution and Hulk Hogan-style comeback failed to satisfy anyone.


8. Bray Wyatt Vs. LA Knight

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Bray Wyatt LA Knight
WWE.com

It feels unkind to bash anything Bray Wyatt following his untimely passing, but it'd also be an outright lie to kid on his match at the 2023 Royal Rumble was special. It really wasn't. In fact, Bray's "Mountain Dew Pitch Black Match" vs. LA Knight showcased everything that was wrong with his 'Fiend' offshoot the first time around.

WWE tried to jazz things up by drenching the scene in neon and introducing a new wrinkle for Wyatt's alter ego. Sadly, it didn't work, and only wrecked any chances these two legitimately excellent workers had of producing the goods. Also, the match clearly only existed so WWE could take in some licensing dollars.

That always works, doesn't it?

Seriously though, eyebrows were raised amongst fans once the Mountain Dew branding started overshadowing everything else during the TV build. The writers relied on Bray's creativity to see them through, but they were asking him to do the impossible.


7. The Entire 1995 Royal Rumble

WWE Royal Rumble 1995
WWE.com

Social media is a hotbed for negativity, so it's no shocker some hit X to blast WWE for the 2024 Royal Rumble matches. Those folks don't know how good they've got it. Some would've been around to see it, but the younger demo who weren't really need to check out the 1995 version via WWE Network/Peacock before that vanishes.

The entire match was a brutal watch.

Vince McMahon and pals were so low on the roster that they dropped gaps between entrants to one minute. The WWF just didn't have the star power to keep an hour long 30-man match interesting, so they wanted to sprint through the thing as soon as possible. That was a shrewd decision.

Shawn Michaels winning was a memorable moment, of course, but the rest of the 38-minute melee was hellish. Entrants like Timothy Well, Steven Dunn, Aldo Montoya, Mantaur and a past-his-prime Dick Murdoch (#27!) made it hard not to realise how paper-thin the WWF's locker room was in January '95.


6. Battle Of The Undertakers

Undertaker Undertaker
WWE.com

WWE has been on/off obsessed with the doppelgänger thing for decades. They tried it with Kane in 2006, but first dabbled with the gimmick for SummerSlam 1994. There, someone had the bright idea of putting The Undertaker vs. Brian Lee in his Halloween costume above Bret vs. Owen Hart in a cage on the card.

Main event, baby.

Worse, The Undertaker vs. "Underfaker" bout was actually supposed to be longer than it turned out. According to legend, Bret and Owen tacked a few more minutes onto their thumping cage war, which meant 'Taker and 'Faker had to shave some time off their headliner. What a shame.

The Undertaker could've justifiably asked the company if they were trolling him by the summer of 1994. He'd already lived through dreadful feuds vs. Kamala, The Giant Gonzalez and Yokozuna. Post-doppelgänger bit, he'd have to contend with King Kong Bundy and Mabel.

Bless those folks in Chicago for sticking around once Bret and Owen hit the showers.


5. Braun Strowman Vs. Tyson Fury

Braun Strowman Tyson Fury
WWE.com

Ready for more Crown Jewel misery?

In 2019, WWE hyped up Tyson Fury's first match as though he was prepping to become the next Bam Bam Bigelow. "Look at the size of him", announcers marvelled. The problem? Despite being very tall and able to punch everyone on the roster's lights out for real, Fury didn't look nearly as imposing as muscle mountain Braun Strowman.

Anyone expecting Bam Bam vs. Lawrence Taylor got Andre The Giant vs. Big John Studd instead. This was a bout so ambling and uncoordinated that even The Great Khali would've been embarrassed. Then, WWE had the cheek to book a countout win for Tyson and act like the dude had just gone 60-minutes with Bret Hart.

Nothing about the match landed. The build was goofy and did a poor job of explaining who was babyface and who was heel, the Saudi Arabian crowd didn't care much for it, and the finish sucked. Also, the less said about Fury performing an Undertaker-like sit up, the better.


4. Ronda Rousey Vs. Shayna Baszler

Ronda Rousey Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

Looking back, despite some highlights here or there, it's fair to say that Ronda Rousey never fell in love with pro wrestling the way WWE claimed. Maybe that's harsh, because she almost-certainly worked hard, but something did feel...off, especially during her latest run in the promotion.

Rousey's "MMA Rules" encounter vs. old pal and former tag partner Shayna Baszler summed it all up. It became obvious just seconds in that the live crowd in Detroit didn't give a toss about some subpar UFC knock off. Both workers visibly froze too, and people were glad to see the back of it by the end.

Their MMA scuffle was the worst match on the SummerSlam 2023 card by a mile, and might actually be one of the weakest SummerSlam bouts ever. Blame for that must go to the UFC-lite approach, and to both women for failing to realise their humdrum action was tanking.

There was a real lack of energy surrounding the whole segment, but it was scheduled for approx 15 minutes curtain to curtain on the format sheets so that's what fans got.


3. The Undertaker Vs. Goldberg

The Undertaker Goldberg
WWE.com

Back to Saudi we go!

As the intro suggests, there was a time period when seeing The Undertaker vs. Goldberg on paper would've caused maximum excitement. That WWF vs. WCW clash would've worked at any point between 1998-maybe 2015, but the sad truth is 'Taker wasn't the 'Deadman' of old by 2019.

This writer will always maintain that the first few minutes of their collision at Super ShowDown looks promising. It was a WWE 2K fantasy battle, but then everything fell apart. Both veterans were spent mere moments in, and that led to some shockingly dangerous spots that could've realistically resulted in serious injury or worse.

It was a frankly terrible decision to give these guys even 10 minutes and the pressure of a main event spot. They needed five mins at most, and should've been squeezed onto the midcard someplace. That's easy to say in hindsight, to be fair, but it wasn't fun to watch two icons of the 90s almost maim one another during a knackered botchfest.

WWE clearly hadn't been paying attention to some of 'Taker's wonky performances beforehand.


2. The “Country Whipping” Disaster

Jim Ross Michael Cole
WWE.com

If anyone needs evidence of how crap WWE's attitude towards women's wrestling was pre-2015 revolution, then take a gander at Extreme Rules 2011. There, a well-built "Loser Leaves Town" match between ex-pals Layla and Michelle McCool was handed a measly five minutes. Meanwhile, this abomination got approx seven.

Curtain to curtain, including entrances, this "Country Whipping" nonsense hoovered up approx 15-20 minutes of pay-per-view time. Yes, yes people were asked to pay for Jim Ross smacking Michael Cole's behind with a leather strap. "Sports Entertainment", pal. We make movies!

JR teamed with Jerry Lawler vs. Cole and Jack Swagger in a tag-team contest so foul it made Lawler vs. Cole from WrestleMania XXVII look like a five-star classic. OK, maybe not, but you get the point. Ross himself has chuckled at WWE's decision-making since, because even he knew he had no business being inside the ring on PPV this long.

Being honest, the iconic announcer had no business being in the ring on PPV at all.


1. DX Vs. The Brothers Of Destruction

WWE Crown Jewel DX Brothers Of Destruction
WWE.com

Somehow, four of the biggest legends in WWE history conspired to go one better than Shane McMahon being dubbed "Best In The World" at Crown Jewel 2018. Mere moments after that horrific announcement, Shawn Michaels returned to the ring for the first time in more than eight years to team with Triple H against The Undertaker and Kane.

Infamously, even these icons of the biz thought their match was the drizzles. 'Taker and Michaels were the most vocal; HBK could be seen on a WWE-produced doc apologising for his performance behind the curtain, and The Undertaker has openly discussed his embarrassment when looking back on the bout.

WWE blatantly only booked the match because Saudi royalty demanded it. Not remotely because it was a good idea or sought after by fans beforehand. If anything, fans wanted to see Shawn come out of retirement to wrestle someone like Daniel Bryan or AJ Styles.

Instead, the company served up a creaking tag that exposed the harsh truths of age.

What other horrible matches did WWE force onto fans? For more wrestling, check out 10 WWE Stars Who BADLY Need New Gimmicks After WrestleMania 40 and WWE 2K24: 10 Things You NEED To Know Before You Buy!


In this post: 
WWE
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.