How AEW Must Reheat Its Biggest Monster

#JoinDarkOrder.

Brodie Lee TNT
AEW

Monsters get slain in pro wrestling.

It's an abiding truth that the modern pro wrestling fan cannot seem to reconcile at times, likely because the problem is exacerbated across internationally broadcasted episodic television. The inherent plot hole - they should probably win all of the time, given how f*cking massive they are - opens wider every time they don't. Under the old model, this was circumvented. The monster could lick their wounds in another territory, aura automatically restored under the "Look at the sheer size of the c*nt" principle that gets them over in the first place. The new world makes this impossible, and the mad rush to tie every name performer down to a lengthy contract, in the wake of renewed competition, will make that harder still.

Mr. Brodie Lee has vanished since his loss of the AEW TNT Championship. He was protected in the loss as he was strengthened by winning the strap in the first place. He captured it by annihilating Cody in three minutes in a shocking squash made all the more effective by how unprecedented it was. AEW's headline matches are invariably competitive. This wasn't. In an audacious booking manoeuvre penned to write Cody out of storylines, AEW retconned the disaster of December 18 to present the Dark Order as a cackling - and now effective - gang of hard bastards. It was great, as was the final chapter. Cody returned after weeks out to promise vengeance. He delivered it, like a proper babyface, in a gruesome epic of a Dog Collar match that skilfully folded in deranged high spots in a manner that didn't compromise the tone. Lee lost, but it took a monumental effort to uproot the tree.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


Hangman Page Tunnel
AEW

Whether that effort resonated to bad faith actors as - sigh - Cody getting his sh*t in is immaterial. AEW needs to reheat the monster irrespective of how well he was protected because Brodie Lee is awesome in a role that folds in so much of AEW's shared universe and makes stunning use of the win/loss rankings framework and the gravity that resonates from it.

At Full Gear, in what was tremendous booking that serviced the long-term picture, the Elite won, but Hangman Page did not, furthering the idea that he doesn't feel capable of the name. Kenny Omega - who was far quicker to celebrate with the Young Bucks than he was to save them, in the sort of wrinkle at which this company excels - celebrated their title win an emotionally layered scene. Hangman Page emerged from the tunnel, just in frame. He wanted to congratulate his old friends, out of respect, but he didn't respect himself enough to do it because he lost to Kenny Omega. The loss reinforced to him the self-doubt that has plagued him since September 2019. The triumph and tragedy of their respective arcs was blocked so artfully.

On the following Dynamite, Tay Conti defeated Red Velvet in what appeared to be an entirely separate storyline development booked to further build towards the Conti Vs. Anna Jay match and Conti's full babyface singles run.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


Dark Order Tunnel
AEW

Anna Jay attempted to interfere throughout. Conti wasn't receptive to it. At the finish, Stu Grayson and Evil Uno emerged from the tunnel, again, just in frame. As is so often the case, there's something in the symmetry here. On this week's Being The Elite, the Dark Order tried to rally John Silver with their chants of "F*ck Hangman! F*ck Hangman!"

Page, drunk and down, joined in. He told himself to f*ck off in a quietly devastating moment of self-deprecation. Page is the anxious millennial cowboy, and the Dark Order exist in the AEW universe to prey on the anxieties of the weak to bolster their ranks.

For these attentive details and so much else, AEW Dynamite is an exceptional wrestling television programme. If it's missing one quite crucial element, difficult as it is to elicit the old feeling, it's the big heat angle. Entertaining and intriguing as the ongoing Inner Circle mystery is, we're almost left to infer that they're still a dominant group. Eddie Kingston's Family are great, but they seem to exist now to drive storylines within the group itself. The Dark Order, to get the heat back on Mr. Brodie Lee, must resurface as a more serious threat and not indulge John Silver too much, fabulous as he is in the role. The tonal range is important, but there's a more important match to build: Mr. Brodie Lee Vs. Hangman Page.

The cerebral monster versus the man who could elevate the Dark Order to a level beyond.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


Kenny Omega Hangman Page
AEW

To get there, the Dark Order must circle Page at ringside, when he steps back into competition, to explain the varying motivations with a visual cue. This must be handled with more care than the Colt Cabana storyline because Cult is the affable, ageing cult hero. Page is the future Ace of the company.

To sell the anxiety of the turn, he has to show temptation, but he can't play it naively for comedic effect. He's the smarter, more serious babyface. When the Dark Order help him win - and the opponent must be credible, like Eddie Kingston, to strengthen him ahead of the PAC blowoff - he has to notice and he has to rebel. He's a drunk, and he's capable of being manipulated into bad deeds to shake the anxiety. But he's not a bad person, and the looming spectre of the Dark Order is the best way of illuminating that in the interim before he enters the final phase of his quest for redemption.

He is so attentive to detail that he can build the mystery of the recruitment angle in a way that differs to the Cabana deal - perhaps a lower third reading "Has been looking into Scientology and idk". Page uses his aesthetic to tell his stories - it was almost heartbreaking, when he wore the long tights at All Out, in one last bid to connect with Kenny Omega - and he can experiment with a purple trim to deepen the intrigue.

He can't join and will not join the Dark Order.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Cody Dustin Rhodes
AEW

The Dark Order here are symbolic of the self-doubt that has defined this ingenious character arc. They represent Page's inner turmoil, and that they are so large in number allows for weeks' worth of episodic storytelling. It's a neat trick AEW often deploys to prolong/enrich the big matches.

As fun as the Bunkhouse match was on this week's Dynamite, and it was all the more fun for how gratuitous it was, this is why the blade should be preserved. Not one moment of bloodshed has resonated with the same heft as Dustin Rhodes' gusher at Double Or Nothing. There's no going back now, but perhaps the person who bleeds might make all the difference.

AEW has a babyface to build to the top, a monster heel to reheat, and a sense of menace to cut through the frivolity that can, at times, undermine what this is all about. Mr. Brodie Lee needs to make Hangman Page piss blood from his face in a disturbing assault, and he needs to choke the life out of him using the bull rope. The Bucks must be predisposed, Kenny Omega simply apathetic. Page has worked so meticulously to invoke pity. Perhaps, to really shout louder for those in the back, he needs to do something more traditional to broaden the appeal of what is a very nuanced character. With the feud set, he can run through the ranks. Page Vs. John Silver is an awesome prospect of a TV building block in particular.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


Brodie Lee
Lee South/AEW

The big match, the blowoff, should take place at Revolution.

Page needs the prestige of a pay-per-view win to establish him as a headliner, the next next AEW World Champion, after two consecutive Saturday night losses. The slot is so prized that Mr. Brodie Lee reverts to big deal status just be occupying the semi-main position. The match would absolutely f*ck. These are two burly boys who can hit hard and fly harder, but they're also very intelligent. Mr. Brodie Lee has proven himself every bit the layout master Arn Anderson sold him to be, and Hangman Page is one of the top five wrestlers in the world. The depth to his work in 2020 has been outstanding. Hangman Page must win. He is AEW's top babyface project.

Monsters get slain in pro wrestling.

It's an abiding truth that the modern pro wrestling fan cannot seem to reconcile at times, likely because the problem is exacerbated across internationally broadcasted episodic television.

AEW must instead master the cycle, and the cycle must be used to get its biggest project over.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!